Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Those cool, messy, usually wealthy mums

607 replies

Shessodowntoearth · 18/10/2023 10:19

I want to be one 😅
Does anyone know the type?
Usually quite a few kids, at least two, kids are lovely, but generally quite messy/put together in a kooky way.
Houses are beautiful, but messy/disorganised, beautiful pieces everywhere/decoration but with a lived in/messy vibe. The mums are the same, usually seem quite disorganised but chilled out at the same time, generally away somewhere every school holidays and don’t work.
I know quite a few mums like this near me and wonder what this life is like, mainly the having more money. I’d love to be as laid back if people come around, to not care about the mess as the house is so incredible, to not worry if my kids clothes look scruffy in a cool way and to be comfortable in myself. Is this what happens when you come from money?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
TammyJones · 19/10/2023 12:39

Can I asked the people who are messy/untidy, but clean, don’t you get fed up with lifting up, moving, all your stuff to Hoover / Dust / anti bac?
I get fed up of sliding the microwave over to right 20 inches to wipe underneath once a week.
I hate to have to move piles of cups / homework / letters , etc. as well.

Coffeepot72 · 19/10/2023 12:34

ownedbymydog · 19/10/2023 11:53

This is my favourite thread ever on MN. I grew up like this, without much money though. Bloody hated it and now live in a clean, warm, very small new-build. Lower middle class definitely the life for me!

My parents were fond of ambitious renovation projects and I grew up in a cloud of brick dust. I can't work out if we were working class or middle class, i think we had a foot in both camps. But all the disruption made me hanker after peace and order, and as an adult I'm now living in my third new build. I have a cleaner and the place is spotless (most of the time).

I'm a member of David Lloyd and a big yoga fan, so can I claim to be slightly posh though?! But I also like Spanish all-inclusive holidays (sorry).

caffelattetogo · 19/10/2023 12:26

I think it's more about how you grow up than wealth. My mum and granny both kept a messy house. They were both academics, and neither prioritised housework (my granny used to say it was a feminist issue - why should women be tied to drudgery?). As a result, I think my idea of what's normal is skewed, and piles of papers and dust is ok - I don't really see it. At best it's bohemian, at worst it's pretty chaotic.
Having had two generations of women above me who were paid as well as their male partners and did no more housework than them made that very normal for me.
We have a big old house (mostly paid for pre-kids when I was earning the same as my DH) and maybe that makes it look less squalid. I suspect I chose the style of house because that's how I grew up. But mostly I think it's about what you're used to.

LolaSmiles · 19/10/2023 12:20

whatkatydid2013
You sound like my type of mum.

We also let DC choose what they're wearing and don't care about the odd paint mark or mud stains on the knees. Why would I want to waste money when there's perfectly decent clothes there to play in?
Mine have never left the house in a tutu and odd wellies though, although they've definitely chosen a Christmas jumper in spring once because it was in the clearout pile. Any parent knows that once something is earmarked to leave the house it's the bestest most favouritist, out of the world most amazing item in the universe. 😂

Bookist · 19/10/2023 12:02

DressingRoom · 19/10/2023 11:50

But why do you think the squalor is 'artfully contrived', @Bookist? Our just is. I can assure you no one is 'curating' it to look attractively bohemian.

My only thought is that it's perfectly possible it might appear so to the type of person whose preference is for an entirely empty set of work surfaces in their kitchen, and who lauds the use of boiling water taps because they reduce the 'clutter' of a kettle.

No, I dislike that very austere, operating theatre style of kitchen. We have plenty of stuff out on our kitchen tops but everything is nice and clean.

ownedbymydog · 19/10/2023 11:59

Also, for @DressingRoom , I dream of the day I can have a boiling water tap fitted! Seriously though, that sort of upbringing really doesn’t suit ALL children. Some actually want clean clothes and someone bothering to sign school trip forms. I did, and I saw a good few when working as a teacher.

ownedbymydog · 19/10/2023 11:53

This is my favourite thread ever on MN. I grew up like this, without much money though. Bloody hated it and now live in a clean, warm, very small new-build. Lower middle class definitely the life for me!

DressingRoom · 19/10/2023 11:50

But why do you think the squalor is 'artfully contrived', @Bookist? Our just is. I can assure you no one is 'curating' it to look attractively bohemian.

My only thought is that it's perfectly possible it might appear so to the type of person whose preference is for an entirely empty set of work surfaces in their kitchen, and who lauds the use of boiling water taps because they reduce the 'clutter' of a kettle.

DressingRoom · 19/10/2023 11:47

That seems a perfectly reasonable post, @whatkatydid2013.

I come from the bottom of the working class -- I grew up in a tiny, overcrowded house with no bathroom or indoor loo and illiterate parents, and my father longterm unemployed in the recession of the 80s. We just about had enough to eat (large family, dependent older relatives living with us), but you always knew what day it was by what food there was.

None of this has catapulted me into thinking that worrying about my house's tidiness is a good use of my time. I'm busy.

Bookist · 19/10/2023 11:46

DressingRoom · 19/10/2023 11:34

That's pretty much an encapsulation of the distinction between upper- and lower-middle class, right there.

The widespread obsession with clean and tidy/ 'visitor-ready' houses is one of the reasons I think Mn as a whole skews LMC. While, weirdly, some of the same people seem far less keen on regular showering.

I am WC and definitely have better things to do than cleaning.

I must be an anomaly because on paper I tick many of the posh boxes. I'm privately educated. Live in a large period house. Our DC went to an independent school. We have a cleaner and a gardener. But I still refuse to live in artfully contrived squalor and I wouldn't dream of leaving the house with unbrushed hair and grubby hands.

TheaBrandt · 19/10/2023 11:45

Nancy Mitford has a lot to answer for.

When my granny born in 1920 moved from sprawling house full of books and family heirlooms etc to a small neat east to maintain new build she fretted that she was now “suburban”

Utterbunkum · 19/10/2023 11:45

@MiddleParking I don't have a cleaner, not just because I can't afford it, but if I did, I just know I would clean before they came, which would totally defeat the object of spending the money on a cleaner, lol.

Utterbunkum · 19/10/2023 11:35

I think some of our perception of this is because we know with them it's a choice. It isn't because there's bills to pay and both parents are working all the hours and it's got on top of them.

Their kids aren't dressed in 'old' clothes that are mismatched, etc, because it's whatever the charity shop had available. They aren't dirty because the electric got cut off and nobody wants to wash in cold water.
Oddly, people are less include to make judgements when you live a certain way through choice. It's OK for your kids to wear the Von Trapp curtains if it's just because you think it's shabby chic. If it's because it's all you can afford, and other people know that, it'll be tutting and calls to the social services.

DressingRoom · 19/10/2023 11:34

Bookist · 19/10/2023 11:24

Yes, pretty much. I am more than happy to not be posh if that means I don't have to suffer crusty sheets and mould in the bread bin [shudders]

That's pretty much an encapsulation of the distinction between upper- and lower-middle class, right there.

The widespread obsession with clean and tidy/ 'visitor-ready' houses is one of the reasons I think Mn as a whole skews LMC. While, weirdly, some of the same people seem far less keen on regular showering.

I am WC and definitely have better things to do than cleaning.

Bookist · 19/10/2023 11:24

Coffeepot72 · 19/10/2023 11:15

To summarise:

If you live in a mess you are posh. If you are clean and tidy, you are not posh.

Have I captured everything here?

Yes, pretty much. I am more than happy to not be posh if that means I don't have to suffer crusty sheets and mould in the bread bin [shudders]

Coffeepot72 · 19/10/2023 11:15

To summarise:

If you live in a mess you are posh. If you are clean and tidy, you are not posh.

Have I captured everything here?

BristolBlueGlasses · 19/10/2023 10:56

Apparently we live in a world where people who wear itchy fabrics to shoot fat birds in valleys and have old pubes piling up on their skirting boards are the enviable upper classes.

feralunderclass · 19/10/2023 10:36

And I used to be of the 'I've better things to do than deep cleaning' ilk, until I moved house after ten years. When the furniture was moved I was completely traumitized by the cobwebs and dirt that had fossilised on walls behind wardrobes and bookshelves. I've made an oath to myself that I'll move everything every six months to hoover/clean. I do t want to ever have that shock again!

EachandEveryone · 19/10/2023 10:35

My mum looked after a couple whos house was like that.both published authors. It was so riddled with mice she had to stop going.

feralunderclass · 19/10/2023 10:32

I have this in reverse. Our childhood nanny (or childminder as we called her, but she came to our house) was from a very large and poor Irish family. Very small overcrowded house, but absolutely immaculate. She judged us for so many things (coming downstairs in pyjamas, eating breakfast before "having a wash, " our cleanliness, not having our hair 'done' just to name a few.) Her mum used to send us a bundle of hand me downs for me and our nanny would hand them over to my mum and say" I hope you aren't offended, but... ". The bundle was all neat at meticulously ironed, I used to think this was something very special. She obviously was horrified by the hand me downs I was receiving from cousins 😂.

I only knew one properly old money person growing up, and I thought she was really poor. Very old, dark brown furniture, old pianos, curtains that looked ancient. Their house was so incredibly chaotic, but it was posh chaos. Piles of material that the mother was going to make things from, books EVERYWHERE (titles such as History of Hungarian Folk Dance, A Walk in the Hebrides etc) in piles, tools, and about 100 years worth of photo albums. If you had a cup of tea the teapot was just set on top of the stuff, nothing was cleared away,it seemed to permanently live there.

Coffeepot72 · 19/10/2023 10:25

MrsJellybee · 19/10/2023 09:51

‘Notes on a Scandal’ deals with this brilliantly. The lower-middle class narrator describes cleaning and tidying her tiny flat from top to bottom before anyone comes over. When she visits her upper-middle class colleague’s home, she is shocked at how laissez-faire she is. It isn’t tidy and she finds the children’s socks stuffed down the side of the sofa. The owner jokes that they are slobs. The house is a huge Victorian detached with original fireplace, wine cellar etc. The narrator has bought a new outfit and shoes for the visit. The owner is floating around in some sort of old bohemian frock…

I think I'm quite happy to be described as lower-middle class, and I'll keep my house clean. And I prefer white wine.

MrsJellybee · 19/10/2023 09:51

‘Notes on a Scandal’ deals with this brilliantly. The lower-middle class narrator describes cleaning and tidying her tiny flat from top to bottom before anyone comes over. When she visits her upper-middle class colleague’s home, she is shocked at how laissez-faire she is. It isn’t tidy and she finds the children’s socks stuffed down the side of the sofa. The owner jokes that they are slobs. The house is a huge Victorian detached with original fireplace, wine cellar etc. The narrator has bought a new outfit and shoes for the visit. The owner is floating around in some sort of old bohemian frock…

Sartre · 19/10/2023 09:39

It’s actually always kind of annoyed me how some posh people (as in this description) seem unable to brush their hair and/or teeth and always just look a bit scraggy. Their kids always have matted hair and messy old clothes, it isn’t cool.

ImADevYo · 19/10/2023 09:36

TammyJones · 19/10/2023 03:54

I read this thread and this is an excellent response.
In my home everything has a place and I clean once a week.
It takes me about 2-3 hours
Do I like it? Not particularly.
I do it because I don't want to live in a dust bin, or share my house with crawlies.
Have I got better things to do? Hell yes, but I like to do them in a clean , fresh environment.
My sister is the opposite
But each to their own.
I'm pretty sure most given the choice most people would rather live in a clean environment but unless someone else is cleaning for them they just can't be bothered.

There's a difference between dirt and mess though.
My house is messy with stuff all over but it's certainly not dirty. You won't find crumbs etc all over the place but stuff... Yeah...

WinterDeWinter · 19/10/2023 09:27

MiddleParking · 18/10/2023 19:59

What an odd thing to invent, no I didn’t and nor did anyone else. The poster being derided was pointing to the same stereotype when observed in areas in the north of England as ‘not quite counting’. Which is indeed completely derisible even if there are also some footballers in this half of the country. Literally no one ‘implied’ anything about the ‘Cheshire triangle’ - the only mention of Cheshire as a whole was to point out how laughably unintelligent such a point was.

Gosh. i think you could do with a glass of red 😁

Swipe left for the next trending thread