Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Those cool, messy, usually wealthy mums

607 replies

Shessodowntoearth · 18/10/2023 10:19

I want to be one 😅
Does anyone know the type?
Usually quite a few kids, at least two, kids are lovely, but generally quite messy/put together in a kooky way.
Houses are beautiful, but messy/disorganised, beautiful pieces everywhere/decoration but with a lived in/messy vibe. The mums are the same, usually seem quite disorganised but chilled out at the same time, generally away somewhere every school holidays and don’t work.
I know quite a few mums like this near me and wonder what this life is like, mainly the having more money. I’d love to be as laid back if people come around, to not care about the mess as the house is so incredible, to not worry if my kids clothes look scruffy in a cool way and to be comfortable in myself. Is this what happens when you come from money?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Nina1013 · 20/10/2023 18:54

MrsGalloway · 18/10/2023 12:10

This interesting. I’m from a working lower/middle class background. Both my Mum and my grandmother were absolutely militant about the house being clean and everyone being properly dressed (clean ironed clothes, polished shoes) even though there wasn’t a lot of money. I remember my Nan saying that growing up in the 1930’s in a coal mining town women who hadn’t cleaned their front step by a certain time of day would be judged.

I felt, especially, when my DC were little and I was poorer and more insecure than I am now, under huge pressure to make sure the house was clean, clothes clean and ironed, that they had all the right stuff at school and nursery etc. I agree there is a certain freedom to that kind of coolness especially for women but I can also see the other side of the coin because it is only really socially acceptable if you have money (and possibly are also thin!)

This always interests (in a sad way) me too. My daughter is very carefree - very clever, sporty but lives in her own (wonderful!!) world. Ponies, scruffy, loves life, loves the outdoors. She is very scatty, loses things like there’s no tomorrow and regularly rips her leggings etc.

Obviously she gets clean and she has clean clothes, but it doesn’t bother me if she’s walking around with a hole in her leggings despite being told 500 times to bin them and wear some new ones, or if her trainers are muddy etc. I have nothing to prove, and don’t worry that anyone would judge us for it.

However my mum (her gran) grew up in extreme poverty, going to school with holes in her shoes etc (nice life now, comfortably off) - she will get in the car and drive to a shop to buy new stuff for her rather than let her walk around like she is if she happens to pick her up from an activity where she has left in such a state. Neither of us disagree about it (although obviously I tell her it’s completely unnecessary), but I am acutely aware that it’s to do with exactly what you say - she feels like she has something to prove because she was so looked down on for things out of her control as a child. She won’t allow my daughter to walk around in anything other than clean and tidy clothes because she doesn’t want her to feel ashamed the way she did as a child, and the thought of my mum feeling like that breaks my heart. It’s obviously scarred her deeply.

Utterbunkum · 20/10/2023 16:29

@girlswillbegirls I have seen those types of things and I find it a little depressing. It's great it works for you, but for some of us, our homes are who we are. I don't want to hide everything away in neat storage, or de-clutter to the extent my house looks like a holiday home. We live here. I would hate our house looking as though we didn't. Years ago, when my husband and I moved into our first house, I remember my father visiting and saying, 'this first thing that strikes me about this house is music and books' and I loved that. We lived in a mid terraced. I had about 400 books, my husband the equivalent in CDs and vinyl. We had shelves and racks, but also piles. I had a stack by the bath (loved reading in the bath). Piles of CDs in the kitchen as a selection to play when washing up. We loved it. We moved to start a new life in a remote corner of the British isles where we couldn't afford to buy so we rented our terrace out and rented a tiny apartment for ourselves. DH stored his records, etc in our terrace loft, and took minimal CDs. I was limited to one box of books, and most others went to charity. I was heartbroken. Every book had been read. I often re-read them. We didn't have room in the loft, so I said goodbye to some old friends and got a kindle, but I missed seeing the about the house. Now back on the mainland, DH reunited with the music and I am working on the books. I don't want to hide them. I am not embarrassed by them, trashy novels included. They are who I am. I couldn't bear to hide it all away just to do what? Pretend we don't live there? I don't get it, it's not for me, but I do appreciate for some people, the bare minimum is relaxing. I have only been in one house like that and found it the opposite. I felt I was cluttering a space that wasn't intended to be sat in, to be honest. And the person who lived there still spent more time cleaning it because she dusted every surface every single day.

Shraree · 20/10/2023 15:51

I agree it's largely about confidence (which often comes from upbringing).
I've been seeing reels about mums showing a sped up video of their days cleaning and tidying their houses before they pick up their kids from school.
This probably sounds awful but I automatically think how boring their lives seem. Why not get a job and hire someone else to to that? Or if I wasn't working, I wouldn't be spending my entire day cleaning, I'd end up starting a load of hobbies.
I'm aware this makes me sound entitled - and i probably am. But I genuinely couldn't think of a worse way to spend my time.
(Please note - I realise some people love cleaning. And would probably find the things I do in my life boring. Im just giving my honest perspective).
There is a definite snobby reaction I have to seeing such reels. I'm trying to be less judgemental but the feeling is there

picturethispatsy · 20/10/2023 15:42

i have a friend like this.

she comes from very old money, parents are British but have a home in Africa too.

she’s absolutely lovely, very intelligent and so kind and unpretentious despite the poshest accent.

her house is not something I could live in though. The first time I visited I was sort of shocked ha. It had a decades old layer of dust on all the old vintage solid wood furniture. It was cluttered beyond imagination. There was stuff everywhere, crafting stuff everywhere, every wall was covered with bookshelves full of old books and antiques or plastered with portraits of family going back generations (not photos actual paintings people had sat for). The kitchen was cleanish but hadn’t been updated since the 1950s. You get the picture.

she doesn’t work but she home educates her 3 children (as do I) so not lazy at all and her kids all have long unbrushed hair (one of them their hair was turning into dreads) and live in mismatched scruffy old clothes. They are such lovely kids though, full of fun, kind and very clever and creative like she is.

WinterDeWinter · 20/10/2023 15:36

i think the class politics aspect is interesting. There are the posher ones and then the academic ones, and I’ve known a few of both (am myself ‘creative’ and messy but v cash poor). Both are annoying in different ways. The thing that infuriates me about the posher kind is the disjunct between their performative ‘activism’ and their Tory voting habits. They’re keen not to be seen as county types, but all their liberalism is social (ie doesn’t cost them anything ) rather than economic. They are individualists, so they do their own cool thing and vote for their own kind, like they always have.

LadyFlumpalot · 20/10/2023 14:46

Ohhh I know one of these. Beautiful house in the countryside, lives completely off grid, has horses, dogs, cats and chickens. As likely to show up on the school run on horseback (but not dressage style) as in her muddy vintage Landrover. Kids run wild and free with the animals and when my DD goes for a play date she comes back muddy, exhausted, covered in horse hair and as happy as can be.

She's very old school wealthy, very very lovely and kind, very put together in a messy way. She honestly lives my dream life.

Stokey · 20/10/2023 14:39

@restingbitchface30 who or what is Ms Rachel?

@1990thatsme every MN thread ends up in competitive cleaning! I never thought I was particularly slobby till I came on here and saw the pearl grasping about things like suitcases on beds.

@girlswillbegirls not sure how you do minimalist with kids. My house is definitely clean (I have a cleaner but also work) but cluttered. They clean the main bits and leave the clutter in tidier piles.

LolaSmiles · 20/10/2023 14:39

girlswillbegirls
Baskets and bins.
I'm not messy a la wealthy rich family with curated boho aesthetic. I'm going for the 'it isn't terrible and there's other things I enjoy more than dusting bookshelves' look.

Put a basket where the clutter dump areas are, lift it up to clean, return, sort when full.
Toy bins for DC toys downstairs. At the end of the day, they all go in a toy bin or basket out the way and I can sweep the floors.

girlswillbegirls · 20/10/2023 14:27

I do like this thread too. It's very interesting.

I hope I don't offend anyone with this question: for people here saying they have a cluttered house but clean. How are you able to clean if everything is messy?

I genuinely like to know. I'm reducing the amount of stuff in mine since watching the minimalists documentary in netflix a year ago. I do think having very little around is the way to go. My house is pretty minimalistic now and so easy to tidy/clean.
For everyone who claim having a messy house so they can enjoy life, it's actually so much easier not having the mess around. So you just switch on the Robvac if the floors are all clear. They key is having little but useful/nice quality. Cleaning itself is very quick then. And seing my home always decluttered and clean affects really positively my MH. And so much more time to enjoy life too.

EatDiamondsForBreakfast · 20/10/2023 14:17

I’ve loved reading this thread. So interesting!! I’ve been trying to think if we have these kinds of mums in Australia 😂 none that I know but it’s been such an interesting read.

Meniscus · 20/10/2023 14:01

feralunderclass · 19/10/2023 10:32

I have this in reverse. Our childhood nanny (or childminder as we called her, but she came to our house) was from a very large and poor Irish family. Very small overcrowded house, but absolutely immaculate. She judged us for so many things (coming downstairs in pyjamas, eating breakfast before "having a wash, " our cleanliness, not having our hair 'done' just to name a few.) Her mum used to send us a bundle of hand me downs for me and our nanny would hand them over to my mum and say" I hope you aren't offended, but... ". The bundle was all neat at meticulously ironed, I used to think this was something very special. She obviously was horrified by the hand me downs I was receiving from cousins 😂.

I only knew one properly old money person growing up, and I thought she was really poor. Very old, dark brown furniture, old pianos, curtains that looked ancient. Their house was so incredibly chaotic, but it was posh chaos. Piles of material that the mother was going to make things from, books EVERYWHERE (titles such as History of Hungarian Folk Dance, A Walk in the Hebrides etc) in piles, tools, and about 100 years worth of photo albums. If you had a cup of tea the teapot was just set on top of the stuff, nothing was cleared away,it seemed to permanently live there.

I am from a very large and poor Irish family - outdoor loo, three to a bed, adults not sufficiently literate to help with homework, just about enough food.

I now live in bookish chaos a crumbling Victorian pile with a long haired scruffbucket child. It’s not wealth, confidence, expecting someone else to do it or upbringing (my upbringing script was ‘fit in at all costs and expect nothing — nice things and university are only for rich people’), it’s that time is finite, and tidying the house comes a distant last to all the other things I want to do with my time. If people, by which I mean women, have internalised the idea that housework is ‘their’ job because they have a vagina, or they equate a clean house with morality, more fool them.

Intriguedbythis · 20/10/2023 13:57

@TravellingT i have a friend exactly the same. Kids all dressed beautiful in that old fashioned style Caramel baby brand, very barefoot family though.

Utterbunkum · 20/10/2023 13:19

@TravellingT 'There's a distinction to be made between messy and neglect though. Matted hair, worn out clothes and dirt is not the vibe'.
I agree

TravellingT · 20/10/2023 12:58

I'm a lady who lunches and botox girly but my closest friend lives in a naice red brick in Notting Hill and she's a barefoot, kids with curly hair in dungarees, where's expensive but made to look old clothes etc. She's fab, her husband is too.

There's a distinction to be made between messy and neglect though. Matted hair, worn out clothes and dirt is not the vibe

Utterbunkum · 20/10/2023 12:40

justjeansandanicetop · 20/10/2023 12:11

This is a different slant on the the topic but I wholly agree with it.

I hate todays throwaway society. I have a friend who redecorates her sitting room EVERY YEAR. She keeps the same couch because it cost a fortune (DFS, overpriced), but once a year she strips the wallpaper, puts more up, paints all the bits not wallpapered, buys new curtains, coffee table, side tables and tv stand, new rug, new lamps and ornaments.

She did it twice in one year a while back because she changed her mind and "couldn't stand" it for another 6 months.

In saying that, I guess some of it maybe comes down to the old "buy cheap, buy twice" and the Terry Pratchett (I think?) story of poor guy having to buy boots at £10 and replace them every year. Total cost over 10 years, £100. Rich guy spending £50 on boots that lasted 10 years, total cost £50.

But I digress; there's been a lot of good points made on here and I do agree that a lot of it is secret code for "I'm rich, so I can be as scruffy as I want etc etc and it doesn't matter." Agree that working class families would be hauled over the coals for some of the things that these affluent families get away with.

Also agree that some of this may be natural / unintentional, but some is horribly contrived.

Yes, the Vines 'boots' theory is very true. Something else Pratchett' said was that the very rich can afford to be poor and stomp around wearing old clothes. As you, and many others say, they don't get the same level of judgement.

I do think a lot of the bohemian thing is contrived to give the 'earth mother' effect, and frankly I wonder if their houses are infested with mice and fleas as well. But the other 'old money's side of childcare is being too posh to look after your own kids, packing them off to boarding school and Nannies in the holidays. Reminds me of that Downton Abbey episode where one character says to Dowager Violet Crawley, ' I thought you would be the sort who saw your children washed and dressed for an hour every evening' and she replied, 'yes, dear, but that hour was exhausting!'

Utterbunkum · 20/10/2023 12:18

@MatildaonMain that's true. We were lucky in that places round here deliver. And I get it doesn't suit all houses, we live in an Edwardian semi with dark wood floors (not anything like as posh as it sounds, but we love it) which is lucky as it does suit, but to be honest, we would probably have bought it anyway as buying new would be very expensive. Beds are a different matter, though. Old beds are too heavy to get upstairs, but Argos do decent cheap beds. Good job the wardrobes were built in, though, as I wouldn't have fancied lugging a wardrobe upstairs to be fair. And there is the worry of floors supporting heavy furniture.

justjeansandanicetop · 20/10/2023 12:11

Utterbunkum · 20/10/2023 10:50

@Evilwitchwhoroams I agree. We recently moved out of furnished rental, and I could never have afforded to furnish from IKEA in total, plus I don't like it much. So we trawled the charity shops. Turns out people don't want old brown furniture, so we god a large solid wood extendable dining table with 4 chairs for £30, a 60s Welsh dresser for £50....I could go on, but you get the gist. I was shocked at the cost of simply things like beside tables if bought new. £100 each for flimsy MDF crap painted in white. Nothing matches, but it's all good quality.
I grew up in a sterile environment where everything was pristine. My folks weren't in any way well off, so a lot of it was looking after things. We had the same 3 piece suite for 20 years. My mother still has kitchenware I remember from 40-odd years ago. These days, it's so throwaway, and I do wonder at these people with more money than sense buying cheap, painted tat at hugely inflated prices when there's all this stunning wood furniture being practically given away.

I also wonder at people not looking after what they have. Cleaning and maintaining things does increase their life. My mother goes a bit far, by getting all the removable bits out of the washing machine and cleaning down after every wash, but it works. She has probably extended its life by about 5 years. I am not the pristine sort, but I keep that ethos of making things last. That's the real, old fashioned working class way. You got the best you could afford when you could afford and looked after it. You had grandma's old side cabinet even if it didn't 'go' with anything because it was good quality and people with little money don't throw away useable stuff because it's not the 'right' colour. Your eldest child was expected to look after their clothes because they would be handed down to the next one.
These boho parents might no be as clean as they should be, but they don't appear to be anything like as wasteful as the aspiring middle classes. And that is how they keep hold of their money. Their kids don't have new clothes every fortnight. They don't throw out old wood furniture because it isn't fashionable.

This is a different slant on the the topic but I wholly agree with it.

I hate todays throwaway society. I have a friend who redecorates her sitting room EVERY YEAR. She keeps the same couch because it cost a fortune (DFS, overpriced), but once a year she strips the wallpaper, puts more up, paints all the bits not wallpapered, buys new curtains, coffee table, side tables and tv stand, new rug, new lamps and ornaments.

She did it twice in one year a while back because she changed her mind and "couldn't stand" it for another 6 months.

In saying that, I guess some of it maybe comes down to the old "buy cheap, buy twice" and the Terry Pratchett (I think?) story of poor guy having to buy boots at £10 and replace them every year. Total cost over 10 years, £100. Rich guy spending £50 on boots that lasted 10 years, total cost £50.

But I digress; there's been a lot of good points made on here and I do agree that a lot of it is secret code for "I'm rich, so I can be as scruffy as I want etc etc and it doesn't matter." Agree that working class families would be hauled over the coals for some of the things that these affluent families get away with.

Also agree that some of this may be natural / unintentional, but some is horribly contrived.

MatildaonMain · 20/10/2023 11:57

Brown furniture is so unfashionable now you can pick up really beautiful and good quality pieces for peanuts in charity shops and auctions. Transporting it can be a faff though, and it doesn’t suit every house.

Utterbunkum · 20/10/2023 10:50

@Evilwitchwhoroams I agree. We recently moved out of furnished rental, and I could never have afforded to furnish from IKEA in total, plus I don't like it much. So we trawled the charity shops. Turns out people don't want old brown furniture, so we god a large solid wood extendable dining table with 4 chairs for £30, a 60s Welsh dresser for £50....I could go on, but you get the gist. I was shocked at the cost of simply things like beside tables if bought new. £100 each for flimsy MDF crap painted in white. Nothing matches, but it's all good quality.
I grew up in a sterile environment where everything was pristine. My folks weren't in any way well off, so a lot of it was looking after things. We had the same 3 piece suite for 20 years. My mother still has kitchenware I remember from 40-odd years ago. These days, it's so throwaway, and I do wonder at these people with more money than sense buying cheap, painted tat at hugely inflated prices when there's all this stunning wood furniture being practically given away.

I also wonder at people not looking after what they have. Cleaning and maintaining things does increase their life. My mother goes a bit far, by getting all the removable bits out of the washing machine and cleaning down after every wash, but it works. She has probably extended its life by about 5 years. I am not the pristine sort, but I keep that ethos of making things last. That's the real, old fashioned working class way. You got the best you could afford when you could afford and looked after it. You had grandma's old side cabinet even if it didn't 'go' with anything because it was good quality and people with little money don't throw away useable stuff because it's not the 'right' colour. Your eldest child was expected to look after their clothes because they would be handed down to the next one.
These boho parents might no be as clean as they should be, but they don't appear to be anything like as wasteful as the aspiring middle classes. And that is how they keep hold of their money. Their kids don't have new clothes every fortnight. They don't throw out old wood furniture because it isn't fashionable.

purplehair1 · 20/10/2023 10:41

Ghost dresses they can’t be bothered to iron, little girls with tangled hair…

Intriguedbythis · 20/10/2023 10:00

@Tatslookawful So true, very contrived.

Evilwitchwhoroams · 20/10/2023 09:58

I don't think it's a status thing, it's purely confidence. I despair of my friends who constantly worry what people think of them. Why? You just need to be happy in yourself. The last couple of generations of my family have been poor so it's not money.
I grew up with, and still have, passed down furniture which is much more beautiful than IKEA crap, I have five kids (quite accidentally) but I have never claimed benefits and they all pass down clothes because I would rather buy a classic than a brand name which is outdated within months. My house is a tip but I like to think it's clean although messy....and I am happier that way. I cook meals from scratch (creatively because I never have everything in a recipe ) which is much cheaper than buying chilled ready meals. I WFH unlike many of my friends who seem to assume I don't really work. What I don't do is scour social media to see what is fashionable this month and rush out to buy it, I don't change my furniture/ wallpaper/paint colour every year. My children are not dressed in the latest Nike trainers or MK ( I am actually not even sure what is the latest thing! ) And they don't all carry iPhones/earbuds and go to nail bars. ..oooh and I drive an ancient landcruiser as opposed to leasing this year's model. Believe me, it's a far more comfortable relaxed lifestyle than having to afford everything new and shiny all the time, which we call 'the Essex lifestyle'..which in turn makes for a happier, more laid back personality. I can afford to welcome friends anytime to my messy house because I'm not ashamed of it. Some people might feel sorry for me because I don't have the trappings of 'Essex'..but I really don't care. 😁 ..and as a BTW I think I am more comfortable financially purely because of this lifestyle.

joanne2020 · 20/10/2023 08:46

Yeah maybe it’s not being so cool but just not feeling responsible ALL the time

LillyOfTheValley2020 · 20/10/2023 07:55

OMG I so know what you mean 😃!!! I most envy their laid back attitude and gorgeous house! I hVe this daydream right now that when we move our house will be newly done up therefor cleaning will be so much easier … I doubt I will ever achieve the laidback-ness though no matter how much cashmere I would own 🤣. My mum always says it’s the work pressure that stresses me out. I’m thinking it may be generics.
I love to be friends with these mums though. I feel all relaxed around them. A new perspective I suppose…

justjeansandanicetop · 20/10/2023 07:31

"I get a new car once about every 6 years and I drive it into the ground"

Jesus Christ @SerafinasGoose, I'm not sure what point you're trying to make with this, but please don't do this. Cars should live much, much longer than 6 years. Learn and proper servicing and maintenance and you won't destroy a car in 6 years.