Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What does religion matter when people, children, are dying?

38 replies

Chiwahwah · 18/10/2023 08:51

I'm an atheist so struggle to understand but even if I was religious I feel that sanctity of life would be of the upmost importance?
How can anyone allow such atrocities in the name of religion?
Doesn't it go against the fabric of what religion should be?
I just don't understand at all. I feel so broken that this is happening, we're all just human.

Why aren't we capable of doing of living peacefully? :(

All over the world people are hurting each other.

Sometimes I feel like humans are just monsters.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SoIRejoined · 18/10/2023 16:37

The Dawkins quote is a non starter as it's obvious that the same people do both good and bad things, and it's quite hard to identify who the "good" people are, especially in a war.

TrashedSofa · 18/10/2023 11:04

Syrupyslop · 18/10/2023 10:58

Ok, I was responding to a post where you were quoting and agreeing with someone who said it’s not about religion as wars happen where there is no religion.

I was responding to that, not the Dawkins quote.

What I wrote was about Dawkins being wrong on that point.

Syrupyslop · 18/10/2023 10:58

TrashedSofa · 18/10/2023 10:50

No.

Dawkins said;

"Without religion you have good people doing good things and bad doing bad. It's only with religion that you have good people doing evil things"

This is indeed saying that only with the presence of religion will certain awful things happen. Your first paragraph indicates that you haven't understood, because refuting this has nothing to do with what you wrote there.

Ok, I was responding to a post where you were quoting and agreeing with someone who said it’s not about religion as wars happen where there is no religion.

I was responding to that, not the Dawkins quote.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 10:58

WandaWonder · 18/10/2023 10:51

It's not religion doing it people are doing it

I am not religious

Religions, being abstract sets of ideas, can't kill people, this is true. That's not what we're discussing though. That would be a very short and boring discussion.

CoffeeCantata · 18/10/2023 10:56

Religion vs tribalism is a false dichotomy. Beliefs about politics, history, the morality of revenge, what God wants - those all shape people's behaviours, just as most of them shape yours on a daily basis.

You have no idea if they're following the tenets of their religion or not because you don't know anything about their religions. You simply assume, because you've been taught to, that the central point of all religions is morality, and that they all agree on something like love your neighbour or the Golden Rule as the highest value. It's completely false.

Wow, Polly!

That's a LOT of assumptions, and some bizarre ones.

Full marks for confidence, though.

Syrupyslop · 18/10/2023 10:53

None of these people are really following the tenets of their religion if they are prepared to slaughter others to achieve their aims

You are clearly not familiar with religious texts if you think this!

WandaWonder · 18/10/2023 10:51

It's not religion doing it people are doing it

I am not religious

TrashedSofa · 18/10/2023 10:50

Syrupyslop · 18/10/2023 10:38

This isn’t good logic. Saying ‘religion causes conflict’. Is not saying ‘ all conflict is caused by religion’

Your ( false) argument is also trying to separate religion out as a stand-alone. And it’s not. It’s intertwined with all the other things humans care about. Religion will be acting in combination with other factors where it contributes to conflict.

No.

Dawkins said;

"Without religion you have good people doing good things and bad doing bad. It's only with religion that you have good people doing evil things"

This is indeed saying that only with the presence of religion will certain awful things happen. Your first paragraph indicates that you haven't understood, because refuting this has nothing to do with what you wrote there.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 10:47

CoffeeCantata · 18/10/2023 10:43

But it's never really religion, is it? It's tribal - about politics and history and revenge for wrongs of the past, on both sides.

Religion is just a banner or an excuse people do these things under. If it wasn't that, it would be something else. It's not religion which makes Islamic/IRA etc terrorists do what they do - it's hatred and resentment and a wish for revenge from people who perceive themselves as oppressed minorities, either fairly or not. None of these people are really following the tenets of their religion if they are prepared to slaughter others to achieve their aims.

Religion vs tribalism is a false dichotomy. Beliefs about politics, history, the morality of revenge, what God wants - those all shape people's behaviours, just as most of them shape yours on a daily basis.

You have no idea if they're following the tenets of their religion or not because you don't know anything about their religions. You simply assume, because you've been taught to, that the central point of all religions is morality, and that they all agree on something like love your neighbour or the Golden Rule as the highest value. It's completely false.

CoffeeCantata · 18/10/2023 10:43

But it's never really religion, is it? It's tribal - about politics and history and revenge for wrongs of the past, on both sides.

Religion is just a banner or an excuse people do these things under. If it wasn't that, it would be something else. It's not religion which makes Islamic/IRA etc terrorists do what they do - it's hatred and resentment and a wish for revenge from people who perceive themselves as oppressed minorities, either fairly or not. None of these people are really following the tenets of their religion if they are prepared to slaughter others to achieve their aims.

RudsyFarmer · 18/10/2023 10:42

It’s cultural not just religious. It’s wrapped up in every fibre of the people and their daily lives. If you are atheist or a non practising/lapsed Christian for example we just don’t understand. We are not surrounded by a society where the expectation is you act in a certain
way or you are in essence expelled from the community. If you lived in these communities you would also be acting in exactly the same way.

Syrupyslop · 18/10/2023 10:38

TrashedSofa · 18/10/2023 10:33

Yep.

Dawkins is full of shit, as evidenced by what the Russians have done to the Ukrainians. Its just a completely stupid take.

This isn’t good logic. Saying ‘religion causes conflict’. Is not saying ‘ all conflict is caused by religion’

Your ( false) argument is also trying to separate religion out as a stand-alone. And it’s not. It’s intertwined with all the other things humans care about. Religion will be acting in combination with other factors where it contributes to conflict.

ChickenNugget6 · 18/10/2023 10:37

It's so very shameful what is happening. I don't know what people can starve and bomb children. It's an awful situation and it needs to stop.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 10:36

@Syrupyslop Well said. The same people who deny religious beliefs can cause wars generally have no problem believing that, say, nationalist beliefs, or racial supremacist beliefs, can cause wars.

Syrupyslop · 18/10/2023 10:33

Some people on this thread are making really simplistic divisions between ‘religion’ and ‘everything else people do’.

People live their lives through the narratives they tell themselves ( or others tell them) and the beliefs and values in those narratives. Religion is a key narrative that gives people a framework through which they understand the world, other people and what relationship they should have with other people.

Our evolved human instincts ( for status, for connection with others, for tribalism, for security of food and shelter, for pair bonding, for nurturing children etc) , all these are intimately intertwined with religious beliefs.

You can’t separate them out and say, oh religion doesn’t lead to war! Of course it does! And religion is intimately intertwined with issues of power, and territory and dominance and all those other human traits, as religion IS humanity. It’s how we live out our human lives.

TrashedSofa · 18/10/2023 10:33

koalaknickers · 18/10/2023 09:30

As pp have said, this isn't about religion.

Sad to say, but millions upon millions of people including children have died under regimes where there was no religion.

It's just man's inhumanity to man.

Yep.

Dawkins is full of shit, as evidenced by what the Russians have done to the Ukrainians. Its just a completely stupid take.

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 18/10/2023 10:23

draw lines in the SAND, not stand. Sorry.

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 18/10/2023 10:23

The great Israeli writer and intellectual Amos Oz described the ongoing wars/conflicts and tensions between Gaza and Israel as a real estate dispute, above all else.
When couples divorce, the biggest fight, sometimes bigger than the one over the children, is over property. Humans crave ownership, on a micro and macro scale. We're hardwired to draw lines in the stand and stick flags in the earth. We are not, by nature, good at sharing/agreeing.

You could split hairs over what Amos Oz stated and I have no doubt he'd agree that traditions, cultures, genetics, and religion play huge roles in the ongoing conflict. But at its heart, the conflict is about land, stolen land according to some, land owed according to others. Pick your side of the fence. I think God and religion actually have very little to do with it. It's, very generally and simply speaking, about feeling owed, on both sides.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 10:19

NoSquirrels · 18/10/2023 10:08

I’m not quite following - I don’t ‘believe’ that all religions are only about ‘lurve’ - I’m just pointing out the fact that nearly all well-established religions share common themes. And that wars are never about ‘religion’ per se but about power. Do you disagree?

I’m also not unaware of the ways in which humans can be brutal and invent non-religious regimes to oppress and gain/maintain power.

I was paraphrasing the dogma. 'Love your neighbour' is not a central tenet of all religions, not by a very long margin. Nor are all religions even fundamentally about central tenets/moral codes anyway.

Of course I disagree that wars are solely about power. Tell me this, are you solely motivated by a desire for power? Of course not. You believe you're motivated by many different things, including your beliefs and values. Even what you define as 'power' is shaped by your culture/religion/worldview.

Everyone who claims wars are only about wealth and power will insist that they themselves are not solely motivated by such base things. Oh but other people are of course - men, capitalists, imperialists, take your pick. On the other hand terrorists are claimed to be motivated by an almost robotic reaction to their environment as they're deemed to be victims and therefore can't be oppressors.

NoSquirrels · 18/10/2023 10:08

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 09:45

You believe this because you live in a post-Christian, post-liberation theology society in which religion has been reduced to a set of moral rules, in which Christianity has been reduced to 'Lurve', and ecumenism and politics dictates that all other religions are similarly dumbed down for public consumption. You also believe it because despite killing vast numbers of people in the last century, left wing dogmas remain mindlessly embedded in western European culture particularly.

I’m not quite following - I don’t ‘believe’ that all religions are only about ‘lurve’ - I’m just pointing out the fact that nearly all well-established religions share common themes. And that wars are never about ‘religion’ per se but about power. Do you disagree?

I’m also not unaware of the ways in which humans can be brutal and invent non-religious regimes to oppress and gain/maintain power.

Dotjones · 18/10/2023 09:56

In many religions people who are not of that faith are not seen as worthy of life. Killing in the name of religion is not an issue. Think about it, if you believe your religion is the real, correct one, and you believe that those who are faithful to it will have eternal paradise in the afterlife, and those who don't believe will be condemned to eternal torture, there is no reason not to kill.

Kill a believer, you've done them a favour by sending them to eternal paradise.

Kill a non-believer, it doesn't matter, they were not worthy of life and deserve the eternal damnation that is due to them.

If someone believes these things - things which are written in well-known religious texts and are seen as fact by many - killing is not problematic.

Killing is only really an issue for people who are not convinced of a happier afterlife.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 09:45

NoSquirrels · 18/10/2023 09:40

Throughout human history, violence has been done and wars have been fought in the name of ‘religion’.

Yet every established religion has a variation of ‘love your neighbours’ as a central tenet.

It’s not about who believes in what flavour of god. It’s about power.

Edited

You believe this because you live in a post-Christian, post-liberation theology society in which religion has been reduced to a set of moral rules, in which Christianity has been reduced to 'Lurve', and ecumenism and politics dictates that all other religions are similarly dumbed down for public consumption. You also believe it because despite killing vast numbers of people in the last century, left wing dogmas remain mindlessly embedded in western European culture particularly.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 09:43

Hoardasurass · 18/10/2023 09:27

@Chiwahwah Richard Dawkins got it right when he said
"Without religion you have good people doing good things and bad doing bad. It's only with religion that you have good people doing evil things"

Ironically, it's hard to see how without some conception of a fundamental soul, a person who does evil things is actually a good person. Even his binary of good people vs bad people is essentially Christian. God vs Devil.

NoSquirrels · 18/10/2023 09:40

Throughout human history, violence has been done and wars have been fought in the name of ‘religion’.

Yet every established religion has a variation of ‘love your neighbours’ as a central tenet.

It’s not about who believes in what flavour of god. It’s about power.

KitchenSinkLlama · 18/10/2023 09:35

Hoardasurass · 18/10/2023 09:27

@Chiwahwah Richard Dawkins got it right when he said
"Without religion you have good people doing good things and bad doing bad. It's only with religion that you have good people doing evil things"

He is absolutely right.