Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jury Duty

222 replies

Chickenkeev · 18/10/2023 08:48

Has anyone ever done it? I've never been called (thank fk!) but i'm curious as to what it's like. In one way it could be really interesting, and in another way it could be really traumatising. And, in the traumatising cases, is there any aftercare?

OP posts:
MotherEarthisaTerf · 18/10/2023 09:55

olderbutwiser · 18/10/2023 09:03

I did a longish case - 6 weeks, fraud. It was a bit gruelling, before selection they told us that there would be a lot of data and information and if we weren’t comfortable with that we could withdraw. They also excused several parents of young children given it was a long case and they needed us all there every day.

I really enjoyed it. The most surprising thing about it was how inept some of the defendants were and how detectable the crime was.

Thank you .- I was wondering about whether you would have the opportunity to serve on JD but opt out of cases if you were unable to handle them. Eg I could sit many cases of criminality but mental health complications would mean a difficult emotional case would not be appropriate.

I would hate to opt out of civic duty by saying I was incapable of any trials but some of them could make me quite unwell.

SapphosRock · 18/10/2023 09:51

Yes I've done it. It was a shooting and quite traumatic, it gave me anxiety. No after care!

It was an interesting experience but I didn't enjoy it. I can remember the 11 other jurors really well. It's a weird, intense relationship you develop very quickly.

I've been called again but DC was newborn so got out of it.

StrawberryWater · 18/10/2023 09:51

I’ve been called up but I wasn’t used. Kind of sat around all day doing nothing but I met some nice people who I’m still friends with.

Nobody in my social circle or family has been called up.

Stephisaur · 18/10/2023 09:49

I did it a few years ago and found it really dull!

I was only called on 2 short cases. The first took half a day, there was no doubt that he was guilty.

The second was on my very last day. Sounded a lot more interesting but the defendant did a runner so we all got sent home.

I got a lot of reading done over the 2 weeks I was there 😂

My neighbour was there at the same time as me and he got a very distressing case. He did about 6 weeks and was then given a special exemption notice for the next 10 years.

You get a nominal amount of money. We were encouraged to claim travel/food expenses even if we didn't actually need them. It was definitely less than my daily rate at work, but thankfully work still paid me for those weeks too.

ruffler45 · 18/10/2023 09:48

Did it first time about 4 years ago, more than enough turn up, you sit in a room and wait to be selected for a jury. Everything will be explained by the court ushers as a lot of people are new to the process. It does not mean you will actually be needed so maybe a lot of waiting around. Just have to sit there and listen to the evidence then go to a room and decide between you. you will be surprised how your thoughts/opinion varies as the evidence is presented.
You may feel be a bit wary walking to and from the courthouse ( I was a bit) but dont be. Tampering with a jury is consider a very serious offence and is dealt with according.

Hoardasurass · 18/10/2023 09:46

@Iheartpizza they randomly pull names off the electoral register using a metaphorical hat. It's completely random.
They called 40 for my last trial, and then excused anyone over 70, 7+ months pregnant,anyone who was in the military, police or crt system and then anyone who knew about the case independently from the trial or knew anyone in the trial.
After that the 23 of us who were left literally had our names put in a hat 1st 15 out were jurors next 5 substitutes, the rest got to leave. Then we were told the full charge list and anyone who couldn't do it due to trauma etc were let go the substitutes took there places and were swarn in then the remaining substitutes were released and the trial started with the 15 jurors. Not sure what would have happened if we needed more than 5 substitutes.

nonevernotever · 18/10/2023 09:45

And I've been told by people working in the court service here that they need to call 100 people in order to be sure of getting one jury of 15.

nonevernotever · 18/10/2023 09:44

Also in Scotland. I've been called a dozen times and selected to serve on the jury three times. The first was a murder. The second was historic child sexual assaults, including rape, within an extended family and the third was a rape case. All were traumatic for different reasons, though I think we came to the right verdict each time. The legal side of it is interesting, but there's a lot of sitting around, the food was poor and you can't avoid the knowledge that this is impacting on so many people's lives. Ultimately I can't remember the names involved in any of the three cases, but I can absolutely remember the faces and the details of the evidence.

Mirandawrongs · 18/10/2023 09:44

I did it earlier this year. Stabbing.

the case lasted exactly two weeks.
week one was all evidence/defence and week two we deliberated.
got the right result thought, it was unanimous.

you claim expenses.
they pay fixed amount for wages, you are at a loss
they pay travel, provide tickets or mileage
you get a fixed amount for lunch, doesn’t even cover at the court canteen.

however, I’m glad I did it!

Chickenkeev · 18/10/2023 09:43

DilemmaDelilah · 18/10/2023 09:41

I've done it twice. Once in Crown Court for a murder case, when I was just 22. The second was more recently and was for an inquest.
The murder was of a local woman I had frequently seen around the city centre, but did not know (she was quite eccentric so easy to recognise)
The inquest was for the death of a young soldier who was run over by his own lorry. Very very sad.
You will get reimbursed for lost wages and your employer has to release you, plus you will get an allowance for lunch. There is a lot of waiting around and of course you can't contact anyone outside during the day, or speak to anyone at all about it until after it is all over, if at all.
People in certain categories or in certain circumstances do not have to do just duty, but you would need to look up what those are as I can't remember.

How does that work practically though? I can't imagine in all honesty coming home to H and saying absolutely nothing. I really don't think i'd be able to do that.

OP posts:
Wonkasworld · 18/10/2023 09:43

Ahfeckingfeckit · 18/10/2023 09:38

I would love to do it, I think it something that we should do as citizens if asked, though I wouldn’t want a case that threatened the secure of my family - as with the one my mum did- or anything to do with child abuse.

Most people think they'd love to do it, until their time comes!

NewLeafAgain · 18/10/2023 09:42

Selected to start 2 weeks after baby was due so was excused. Id love to do it. Know someone who did it but got counselling after (arranged by the courthouse for all jury members).

Ahfeckingfeckit · 18/10/2023 09:41

‘I would love to do it, I think it something that we should do as citizens if asked, though I wouldn’t want a case that threatened the secure of my family - as with the one my mum did- or anything to do with child abuse.
That hadn't even occurred to me tbh 😬’

terrorism or gangster stuff can mean people threatening jurors or their families…

Barney60 · 18/10/2023 09:41

Ive never been called but a close friend of mine has, said had to be at court for a certain time each morning, said it was boring just sitting about, case was cancelled once so wasted day. He got travelling expenses and lunch money.

DilemmaDelilah · 18/10/2023 09:41

I've done it twice. Once in Crown Court for a murder case, when I was just 22. The second was more recently and was for an inquest.
The murder was of a local woman I had frequently seen around the city centre, but did not know (she was quite eccentric so easy to recognise)
The inquest was for the death of a young soldier who was run over by his own lorry. Very very sad.
You will get reimbursed for lost wages and your employer has to release you, plus you will get an allowance for lunch. There is a lot of waiting around and of course you can't contact anyone outside during the day, or speak to anyone at all about it until after it is all over, if at all.
People in certain categories or in certain circumstances do not have to do just duty, but you would need to look up what those are as I can't remember.

Ahfeckingfeckit · 18/10/2023 09:40

‘You get paid a nominal amount
It is often less than your employer would pay’

depends on your employer - ours pays as usual and claims whatever the allowance is from the system, which isn’t anywhere near my normal salary but they see it as civic duty and cover it regardless of length of the service.

TenderDandelions · 18/10/2023 09:40

I've never done it myself, but I'd like to. If they could wait until I retire though, it would be good - it would cause chaos with work!

I know two people that have done it that have shared some stories.

One was a basic trial about a man that had conned a little old lady out of her savings for roof work that she didn't need. As part of his evidence he was asked "you were seen getting in to a blue Ford Mondeo - do you deny this?" and he replied "I do deny it - I don't have a blue Ford Mondeo".

At the lunch break, my friend went out to have a smoke and saw the defendant walking over to the car park and getting in a blue Mondeo! He spoke to one of the court personnel when he went back in who told him that of course it was totally inadmissible and he should disregard what he'd seen and not tell anyone else on the jury. The rest of the evidence was overwhelming though apparently and they found him guilty.

I also know someone that served on the jury for the Dennis Nilsen trial. When they released the David Tennant drama about him, my friend watched it and said he could see the person in his position in the jury box and could see that they'd tried to recreate his clothing from the court drawings of the time.

spidermonkeys · 18/10/2023 09:39

My friend did it a few years back. Horrific case. She never really got over it tbh.

Chickenkeev · 18/10/2023 09:39

Ahfeckingfeckit · 18/10/2023 09:38

I would love to do it, I think it something that we should do as citizens if asked, though I wouldn’t want a case that threatened the secure of my family - as with the one my mum did- or anything to do with child abuse.

That hadn't even occurred to me tbh 😬

OP posts:
AWellReadWoman · 18/10/2023 09:38

I've been called up twice. As soon as I turned 18 and then again about five years ago. I was petrified of doing it the first time but luckily it was quite a straight forward case and I found it all very interesting. Thankfully neither of the cases were traumatising in anyway. I'm really not sure how I'd have coped if they had been especially as a very naive 18 year old.

Thatladdo · 18/10/2023 09:38

Seems it varies wildly depending on your court. Mine was reasonably modern, free bottled water and hot drinks on tap, snack machines were full, great court staff, expenses took 2 days to be paid into my bank, and cases were run really well it seemed.
If I was to give negatives, be prepared for the posibility of leaving the courthouse or using public transport allongside the defendants.

Ahfeckingfeckit · 18/10/2023 09:38

I would love to do it, I think it something that we should do as citizens if asked, though I wouldn’t want a case that threatened the secure of my family - as with the one my mum did- or anything to do with child abuse.

Wonkasworld · 18/10/2023 09:38

Oh and from my time, jurors aren't accompanied outside when they leave the court. You have to be on your guard if you're sworn in.

GoFaster83 · 18/10/2023 09:37

I read an entire book waiting for the potential jury to be called and then selected. Only for one witness to announce his previous crimes and the trial to be stalled and eventually cancelled. Wasted 2 days of my life on that. Very frustrating but also very interesting. We got 5 years off being called again.

AgaMM · 18/10/2023 09:36

No where near the same but I used to work with the lawyers of Christian charity, and every now and then they had claims of child sex abuse made against them. Reading the details of what happened was horrifying and it’s never really left me, so I can imagine having to sit through a lengthy trial that involves abuse would be extremely traumatic for the juror. Anyone who has been through that has my sympathies.

Side point - their first response was to argue and prove it never happened, rather than provide any emotional support for the victims. Made me realise I could never ever work in that area.