Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask these questions about Palestine

272 replies

Workplacenoob · 18/10/2023 07:29

Why did the Palestinians vote hamas in?

Why don't they topple their government?

Why haven't the rich countries in the ME been pouring money into Palestine over the past few years? Don't they consider that area holy land/aren't they interested in protecting it?

Just as Europe opened its borders to the refugees of Ukraine, why hasn't the ME done the same for Palestine?

I understand Iran funds Hamas. But why?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Coughingdodger · 19/10/2023 08:35

Meshigenus · 19/10/2023 07:14

@Desertrose2023
Maybe they are busy with the women and girls affected by conflict in Syria, Sudan, Yemen, Myanmar, Ethopia and Afghanistan who don't have access to clean water, medicines or electricity?

None of these wars are being perpetrated by the West.

Coughingdodger · 19/10/2023 08:33

Meshigenus · 19/10/2023 03:22

You mean in 1948, Jews may have felt a tad unsafe in the world? A little bit traumatized as a nation? Why, what on earth may have caused such a paranoid and unreasonable assumption?

Firstly, I didn’t write the piece.
Also, it’s not 1948 any more. Most people who were adults in 1948 are dead.

Meshigenus · 19/10/2023 08:30

@Desertrose2023
They did? So israel was supplying gaza with all these essential items? Interestinf when people on this site claim its the same as the warsaw ghetto or bergen belsen. Not forgetting gaza has had 20 years to arrange its own water and electricity or get it from Egypt rather than the hated israel.
Hamas clearly still has fuel to fire missiles to israel so perhaps they can give it to the generators.
I don't think israel should have cut the water as I don't think you should do that to a civillian population. But I can also understand why you don't want to supply water and power to people who have just declared war on you, butchered babies, mowed down young people at a festival, executed families, raped women and paraded their naked bodies and taken 200 people hostage.

Teddleshon · 19/10/2023 08:26

How do you account for the state of a country like Liberia ( never colonised) if colonisation is the defining evil?

Pollyputhekettleon · 19/10/2023 08:20

MigraineOfSalt · 19/10/2023 08:11

Your style is so intensely patronising.

To people who deserve it, yes, absolutely. Dishonestly accuse me of supporting ethnic cleansing and you can suck up getting patronized in response. They should be grateful I didn't get them deleted for a personal attack, which I could do, anytime. I happen to support free speech, which is why I rarely do that.

MigraineOfSalt · 19/10/2023 08:11

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 12:20

It's not my fault if you have difficulty reading. There are lots of adult literacy courses available that can help.

Your style is so intensely patronising.

Desertrose2023 · 19/10/2023 07:49

Meshigenus · 19/10/2023 07:14

@Desertrose2023
Maybe they are busy with the women and girls affected by conflict in Syria, Sudan, Yemen, Myanmar, Ethopia and Afghanistan who don't have access to clean water, medicines or electricity?

Those women are also deserving of outrage.

what makes Gaza’s women different is that they had access to all those things and it’s now being INTENTIONALLY WITHHELD as a form of illegal collective punishment 🙄

Meshigenus · 19/10/2023 07:14

@Desertrose2023
Maybe they are busy with the women and girls affected by conflict in Syria, Sudan, Yemen, Myanmar, Ethopia and Afghanistan who don't have access to clean water, medicines or electricity?

Desertrose2023 · 19/10/2023 06:53

where is the feminist outrage for the women and girls of Gaza? 50,000 currently pregnant according to the UN who currently have no access to clean water, electricity, medicines blocked and whose homes are being carpet bombed as we speak.

I thought Mumsnet was a site set up as a place to support women and mothers ? Clearly the sisterhood is dead.

https://abcnews.go.com/amp/Health/pregnant-women-new-mothers-risk-amid-israel-hamas/story?id=104006519

Pregnant women, new mothers are at risk amid Israel-Hamas conflict: Experts

Thousands of pregnant women and new mothers are trapped amid the Israel-Hamas conflict, putting their health and their lives at risk, experts said,

https://abcnews.go.com/amp/Health/pregnant-women-new-mothers-risk-amid-israel-hamas/story?id=104006519

ForeverScout · 19/10/2023 06:29

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 09:51

The separation of Burma was peaceful.

Cyprus presumably didn't participate in the population transfer, leaving the two populations continuing to live side by side. That kind of proves my point that sometimes population transfer work, you know.

The US, Australia, New Zealand, Canada and dozens of other places did just fine after independence. They certainly did not need any continuous hard work. Because of course they're fundamentally completely different places, with totally different cultural and religious values to, say, Afghanistan.

This blaming of the colonizer is ignoring the entire history of these countries prior to colonization. It even manages to ignore the awkward fact that the British weren't the first people to colonize those areas! The British are not some all-powerful gods who created conflict out of some Garden of Eden. Again this is nothing more than leftist anti-imperialist dogma.

FFS those countries you mention - US, NZ, Australia, Canada - did not do "just fine" after independence. Race relations in each of these countries are fucked up, STILL, which shows how deeply colonisation fucks things up in general. It fucks them up for centuries after the fact. It fucks them up for every generation that comes after, whether we bomb each other or 'just' incarcerate, violate, segregate, steal children, steal land, withhold resources, beat up and beat down. The colonised peoples in each of these countries are still struggling, are still coping with generational trauma, shame and fear, they are underrepresented in positive statistics and overrepresented in negative statistics, and they STILL have to fight for their place at the table to be heard and valued and their many losses even acknowledged let alone restitution made. So please don't use us as a prop in your racist characterisation of Arabs / Muslims being less civilised or humane or indeed any more barbaric than any other people group. It is patently and demonstratively untrue.

I actually came on here to see if I misread the tone of your posts on the previous thread. I can see I did not - more than a touch of Great Replacement conspiracy theory here.

Meshigenus · 19/10/2023 03:22

Coughingdodger · 18/10/2023 12:51

Yes indeed.
Just read a piece by a journalist called Gideon Rachman in the Financial Times. He says that Israel was founded on the premise that Jews aren’t safe anywhere due to global anti-semitism and no one will help them. Many Israelis truly believe this. And currently they’re traumatised and frightened and lashing out because they feel alone. US policy is to tread softly, avoid harsh denunciations, try to persuade them that they’re not alone. So that they will then calm down and listen when people ask them to moderate their response. The US in this way has already brokered safe routes during certain times and a partial restoration of the water supply. Long term - who knows how this impasse can be managed but hopefully in the short term emotions on both sides can be brought down.

You mean in 1948, Jews may have felt a tad unsafe in the world? A little bit traumatized as a nation? Why, what on earth may have caused such a paranoid and unreasonable assumption?

Reallifelurker · 18/10/2023 21:46

Lol

bobaloo · 18/10/2023 20:41

@Pollyputhekettleon👏 thank you. Your depth and breadth of knowledge in this area is clear. If only those engaging with you were as thorough in their examination of history, politics and religion.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 19:12

Chaiandkaafee · 18/10/2023 17:42

Wow @Pollyputhekettleon you've been on here all day arguing with people! I’ve gone and come back from work and you are here pushing your agenda!

Thank you for the compliment, but there's no need to go all stalker on me you know. Like wow.

Chaiandkaafee · 18/10/2023 17:42

Wow @Pollyputhekettleon you've been on here all day arguing with people! I’ve gone and come back from work and you are here pushing your agenda!

Reallifelurker · 18/10/2023 17:18

t's not my fault if you have difficulty reading. There are lots of adult literacy courses available that can help.

Grow up.

Valerianandfoxglovesoup · 18/10/2023 17:08

It's so odd sitting here in the Middle East reading what people not here think we think and do. Honestly, do you really think Palestine is not supported? Palestinians and Syrians have a huge presence as refugees and permanent residents. Its not our first rodeo, many of us have friends and colleagues who are inconstant danger and lose family nenbers all the time. Just just in the last week but day in day out, year after year. I don't profess to know what the UK is all about these days because I've been away so long so I try not to base my assumptions on stereotypical examples.

Meshigenus · 18/10/2023 16:51

LemonyTicket · 18/10/2023 15:18

Why did the Palestinians vote hamas in?

There was about equal votes for Hamas vs Fatah. I guess voting for them indicated the mood and priorities of the population at the time.

Why don't they topple their government?

Every poll I've ever seen shows a high level of support for them. And even if it didn't, they're immensely powerful and would probably kill someone for even saying something like that.

Why haven't the rich countries in the ME been pouring money into Palestine over the past few years?

a) They kind of have
b) They are generally not humanitarian in these ways (look at other countries in perpetual conflict)
c) A lot are prejudiced against Palestinians

Just as Europe opened its borders to the refugees of Ukraine, why hasn't the ME done the same for Palestine?

They have kind of. There's millions in Jordan. Problem is that they keep them in refugee camps and won't let them become citizens.

I understand Iran funds Hamas. But why?

Common enemy (Jews, America, Democracy, The West)

Actually Jordan, uniquely among ME counties, did grant Palestinians citizenship. However, Palestinians, even if granted citizenship of another country, remain refugees in perpetuity.
Every other refugee in the world ceases to be a refugee (ie in need of international protectio) when they take citizenship of their country of asylum. Only Palestinians remain refugees forever.
Palestinians are also barred from taking part in any refugee resettlement programme.
The ONLY durable solution available to Palestinians is return whlle other refugees have the solutions of local integration and resettlement. Except return isn't an option (return where? To what?). So they are refugees in perpetuity, from generation to generation.

Why are Palestine refugees unique among the world's refugees? How does this be efkt them?

ProvincialLady1 · 18/10/2023 15:47

Desertrose2023 · 18/10/2023 14:50

@ProvincialLady1 while Im sure they appreciate the sympathy you’ve got for them from the safety of your home thousands of miles away, what they really need is your outrage and for you to speak out about what’s happening to them. It’s a genocide in real time. That’s the reality of the situation, simplistic or not, anyone with an ounce of humanity and critical thought who’s done their research can see that. Take a even a cursory look at the accounts of UNRWA, MSF, Mohamed Al Kurd, Shaun King and many others to see for yourself what the mainstream media don’t show you.

maybe a longer term solution can consider the hundreds of years of history of the region that the pro-Israel apologists keep referring too so that we keep navel gazing and are distracted from the atrocities that are happening as we speak.

To be clear, I'm talking about sympathising in general, not about the current situation, which is horrific. But you were taking about root causes, which obviously are important - and the subject of the thread.

LemonyTicket · 18/10/2023 15:18

Why did the Palestinians vote hamas in?

There was about equal votes for Hamas vs Fatah. I guess voting for them indicated the mood and priorities of the population at the time.

Why don't they topple their government?

Every poll I've ever seen shows a high level of support for them. And even if it didn't, they're immensely powerful and would probably kill someone for even saying something like that.

Why haven't the rich countries in the ME been pouring money into Palestine over the past few years?

a) They kind of have
b) They are generally not humanitarian in these ways (look at other countries in perpetual conflict)
c) A lot are prejudiced against Palestinians

Just as Europe opened its borders to the refugees of Ukraine, why hasn't the ME done the same for Palestine?

They have kind of. There's millions in Jordan. Problem is that they keep them in refugee camps and won't let them become citizens.

I understand Iran funds Hamas. But why?

Common enemy (Jews, America, Democracy, The West)

NotTerfNorCis · 18/10/2023 15:02

It seems Israeli missiles had already hit the hospital. This from the Guardian:

We received the two missiles that hit the hospital. We could see and tell that they are from an Israeli strike at the hospital. And then we received the warnings,” he said.
Staff told refugees who crowded into its courtyard about those warnings, but they apparently judged the hospital safer than other options in a city under attack. In the afternoon before hundreds were killed and maimed, they had been singing peace songs to keep up their spirits, Naoum said.

Desertrose2023 · 18/10/2023 14:50

@ProvincialLady1 while Im sure they appreciate the sympathy you’ve got for them from the safety of your home thousands of miles away, what they really need is your outrage and for you to speak out about what’s happening to them. It’s a genocide in real time. That’s the reality of the situation, simplistic or not, anyone with an ounce of humanity and critical thought who’s done their research can see that. Take a even a cursory look at the accounts of UNRWA, MSF, Mohamed Al Kurd, Shaun King and many others to see for yourself what the mainstream media don’t show you.

maybe a longer term solution can consider the hundreds of years of history of the region that the pro-Israel apologists keep referring too so that we keep navel gazing and are distracted from the atrocities that are happening as we speak.

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 18/10/2023 14:49

@ProvincialLady1 if you don't like the use of the term apartheid, you need to take that up with:

The United Nations
https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2022/03/israels-55-year-occupation-palestinian-territory-apartheid-un-human-rights

Human Rights Watch
https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/threshold-crossed/israeli-authorities-and-crimes-apartheid-and-persecution

Global Centre for the Responsibility to Protect
https://www.globalr2p.org/countries/israel-and-the-occupied-palestinian-territory/

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 14:46

@ProvincialLady1 They have to restrict the conversation about root causes to the last few decades, or at least post-1948, because things become a little awkward for them once you go back further than that.

ProvincialLady1 · 18/10/2023 14:38

Desertrose2023 · 18/10/2023 12:24

Just more obfuscation in your reply - exactly the same as I posted before. It’s always the same with the apologists for Israel’s crimes “but Hamas”, “but the Arabs”, but this, but that, but….

never a response to the actual present day issue which is the root cause, the appalling treatment of the Palestinian people who have been living under military occupation and inhumane treatment for decades. People whose water, electricity and internet are currently turned off. Who are being starved as collective punishment. There’s nothing that you can say to justify this so you just don’t address it.

and to the poster who asked “what apartheid even means?”, shame on you. You might want to start with some light reading, I’d suggest human rights watch report on Israel’s apartheid as a good place to start:

https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/threshold-crossed/israeli-authorities-and-crimes-apartheid-and-persecution

But this is exactly the point, you can't just look at the present day issues as the 'root cause'. I have a lot of sympathy with the situation facing people in Gaza and the West Bank but it's also massively important to look at the full history and the ideology, otherwise you're just offering unworkable solutions and condemnation of the Israelis across the board. They have absolutely done things wrong, but it's also not fair to describe them in these simplistic terms like coloniser, apartheid etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread