Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people think so little of care home staff?

95 replies

AMAcarer · 17/10/2023 23:28

NC for this one

I'm a Senior Care Assistant in a Nursing home, I also previously worked in domiciliary care and support work. I'm extremely experienced, kind and compassionate, I know I excel in my role and I mentor my team to high standards BUT I'm at breaking point.

I could write paragraph after paragraph about how we are treated often by residents' family members, and how their expectations just simply don't match up to reality, and they never ever will unless by some miracle my 40 bed unit has at least 2-1 staffing ratios! So many of my colleagues are in tears during their shifts, being told their best isn't good enough (and many other nasty jibes) by family members or friends of residents.

Now, I know many have bad experiences with Care and Nursing homes, they don't always get it right. People are living longer including those with severe disabilities and impairments, than we didn't see reach these ages in the past. We are so short staffed, and cannot attract new staff due to the poor pay for the demanding role we do.

If Care staff are so utterly useless then why are we trusted with some of the most vulnerable people to look after? Why can residents' loved ones not see the bigger picture we face in the home? Why do they not trust what we communicate to them in terms of what their loved one needs? Why are we not deemed as being skilled workers or valued the same as others in health and social care?

What can be done to make us valued, and respected and our role recognised?

I know many people DO understand and we have many kind visitors to the home, but the overwhelming majority just seem to berate us at any given opportunity. We can't go on like this,

OP posts:
hellohellothere · 18/10/2023 07:54

Hufflypuffly123 · 18/10/2023 07:50

I think everyone wants their family member to receive the lindividualised oving care they would, in an ideal world, receive from loved ones at home.

But that isn't possible. Everyone deep down wants their loved one to be a priority and when there's a dozen or more other residents to consider, that can't happen.

And some family members have unrealistic expectations and wants.

I don't think it's unrealistic to expect the person in care to be clean and taken to the toilet regularly.

givemeasunnyday · 18/10/2023 07:54

I have the greatest respect for anyone who works in care, as I know I couldn't do it, and I think they should be paid more than what they are. I'm not in the UK, but I was more than happy with the care given to my late DM in two different rest homes. The first one closed due to a lack of residents, and the staff were so caring and upset for the people in their care having to move. My late DF lived in his own apartment within a rest home complex, and needed care in the last month of his life, and once again he received excellent care. However, I do know people who moan and groan, and make demands of the staff who are doing a good job anyway, but can't be expected to be everywhere at the same time, and it angers me. I haven't seen anyone who is just doing the work because they need to do something and care work is easy to get into.

Zingy123 · 18/10/2023 07:53

My Nan was sent to a care home for rehabilitation. She was neglected even though we were visiting every day. She had an undiagnosed water infection. It eventually killed her as it turned to pneumonia. She wasn't being given fluids either unless we gave them to her. She went from a fit 96 year old to being unrecognisable.

Hufflypuffly123 · 18/10/2023 07:50

I think everyone wants their family member to receive the lindividualised oving care they would, in an ideal world, receive from loved ones at home.

But that isn't possible. Everyone deep down wants their loved one to be a priority and when there's a dozen or more other residents to consider, that can't happen.

And some family members have unrealistic expectations and wants.

PixiePirate · 18/10/2023 07:49

I think manners and etiquette are failing in general and a growing number of people are just awful to everyone tbh. This post could be applied to various other jobs and activities such as nurseries, schools, retail, call centres and road users. It’s shit and unacceptable behaviour, but I don’t think it’s ‘about’ care home staff as such. It’s unacceptable though and must be incredibly hard to deal with day in, day out.

SpidersAreShitheads · 18/10/2023 07:45

@TheLightSideOfTheMoon - that is really shocking, and genuinely heartbreaking.

SpidersAreShitheads · 18/10/2023 07:41

MillieVonPinkle · 18/10/2023 07:17

A central register for care staff might help, with wages in line with NHS staff who are much better paid for the same work

Agree with this.

The 'problem' is that pretty much anyone can get a job as a carer and people know this - and there are some people who will therefore treat you like shit because they consider you beneath them.

Care roles don't align with any other roles in health and social care. You couldn't walk into a job as a nurse or in social work without some qualifications but you can in care which seems bonkers.

^^all of this.

There are many answers to your questions OP.

There are great carers and great care homes but there also many shitty care homes with awful care workers. There are unfortunately a lot of bad apples in your industry and this colours public perception.

As PP said, carers are low paid, often unqualified and frequently attract unenthusiastic, disinterested individuals and this translates into the poor quality care that they provide.

There’s little incentive for intelligent, skilled workers to stay in care - especially when the work is so gruelling.

This means that families know many care workers are either a) not knowledgeable or b) not really interested - and sometimes both. This can make it very difficult to trust the judgement of the care worker especially if they’re communicating difficult news.

You asked why families use care homes if they’re so poorly thought of - sometimes it’s the only choice a family has. It doesn’t mean they trust you, it’s just that they can’t look after the family member at home.

And on that note, care workers are so used to the daily grind of the job, there’s often scant communication with the family about expectations. I understand that’s partially due to time pressures but you’re asking what contributes to the frustration of families, and this is part of it.

OP, earlier in this thread you casually mentioned that of COURSE the patients in your unit couldn’t have a shower every day although they could have a strip down wash. This is the kind of thing that families might struggle with as it’s a pretty basic request. My beloved dad never missed a daily shower, even when he was battling severe cognitive decline with Huntingtons Disease. He’d have been deeply distressed not to be able to shower daily. I would say that being able to shower daily (if desired) is a very basic care need but you mentioned so casually that it wouldn’t be possible, as if that should be obvious…. And this is where the understaffing is going to clash with family expectations. Because it would seem to suggest that no matter how caring you are, patients at your facility are a very long way from getting their basic needs met. That’s not your fault but for family members who have trusted the care home with the well-being of their relative, of course they’re going to be unhappy. You think these family members are unreasonable because you’re working hard and doing your best - but from the family’s perspective, their loved one isn’t getting the basic care they need. It’s an awful situation all round.

Prob worth mentioning that I was also a care worker when I was younger, so I’ve seen it from both sides.

A radical shake up is needed for all of the above reasons but it’s vanishingly unlikely because the Tories don’t really care about the elderly, and Labour don’t seem interested either.

Tumbleweed101 · 18/10/2023 07:40

No care role is paid well enough or valued and respected enough whether that is childcare or adult care. I’ve done both.

It really frustrates me that someone sitting behind a desk is paid more and valued more than those caring for our most vulnerable in a physically hard and sometimes emotionally hard
role.

We would have relatives visit once a year and do nothing but complain about the care and yet they weren’t willing to do anything to change their lives to offer the person support.

On the whole people I know who have needed carers for end of life loved ones recently have had nothing but relieved praise.

hellohellothere · 18/10/2023 07:28

It's such a hard job and people are overstretched as no one one wants to do it. I just hope I have the strength to end it myself if I ever have to go into a care home. It sounds awful.

LlynTegid · 18/10/2023 07:28

Probably the same people in many cases who are rude to retail workers.

piscofrisco · 18/10/2023 07:25

Because people equate what you get paid with what you are worth.
Care staff are some of the lowest paid workers, doing a job that is often complex (often now tasks that used to be reserved for nurses),physically and emotionally gruelling and always under resourced. People often aren't aware of that, or if they are they choose not to be.
I was a care home manager for 24 years. Of course there are bad staff. But the majority of them are doing an amazing job in circumstances other people wouldn't consider getting out of bed for.
The nurses and drs going on strike for better t's and c's and pay wouldn't last a week in a care job. And get social care props up the NHS. Without it hospitals woods be overrun in days. The way social care is viewed, prioritised and remunerated makes me seethe!!

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 18/10/2023 07:23

I left a job in a care home yesterday. My job wasn’t actually care, but I worked closely with carers.

I three months I’ve seen:

People being told there’s not enough staff for them to use the toilet and to ‘do it in your pad’. This was said in a busy room with other residents and left the person in question in tears trying to hold it in.

Watched a resident being dragged by a carer screaming, ‘let me go’ repeatedly.

In three months I didn’t see a single person have a bath. I was told the baths didn’t work and haven’t got years.

Found a massive knife in one of the bathrooms (one of the residents liked to collect cutlery and crockery and wash it up). When I queried it I was told it was the gardeners, but left unattended in reach of people with dementia.

A man repeatedly telling staff he was cold and being ignored. He was visibly shivering.

Lots more, they’ll come to me.

It made me depressed.

And this was a large chain of homes that pride themselves on ‘premium’ service.

NeedToChangeName · 18/10/2023 07:21

OP asked why are carers not respected?

I'd say it's because -

Misogyny (most caring roles undertaken by women)

Low pay

Few qualifications involved

No career path

So, if eg, working as a carer was part of nedical training to be a Dr, people might view it differently

To clarify, I think it's a difficult role that, when performed well, is incredibly valuable

MillieVonPinkle · 18/10/2023 07:17

A central register for care staff might help, with wages in line with NHS staff who are much better paid for the same work

Agree with this.

The 'problem' is that pretty much anyone can get a job as a carer and people know this - and there are some people who will therefore treat you like shit because they consider you beneath them.

Care roles don't align with any other roles in health and social care. You couldn't walk into a job as a nurse or in social work without some qualifications but you can in care which seems bonkers.

DivergentTris · 18/10/2023 07:07

jlpth · 17/10/2023 23:41

Many people are just horrible. So a lot of residents will have horrible family members. Just like working in retail - lots of the public are just horrible.

This sounds awful and cynical, but unfortunately, it's true. I had a career break from an emergency service, where I expected to see people at their worst, but that's why I was called out, to help, so you are prepared to deal with all sorts thrown at you. However, on my career break, I worked in retail for a bit, and a lot of the public I dealt with were rude and entitled. I was not expecting this in an environment where people were simply going about their everyday lives doing the mundane. It was inexcusable.
I wasn't actually planning on going back to the emergency service, but if I was going to be dealing with this side of human nature I at least wanted to be in an environment where I could at least empathise with where it was coming from so went back. People can be awful at times and take it out on retail/care staff for no reason at all (most of what I experienced, there was no actual reason for it).
OP, I do think your environment will be similar, I feel for you. I think you should all have more recognition for the profession you're in.

Minxyjinx · 18/10/2023 07:07

X

Conkersinautumn · 18/10/2023 07:05

Definitely, it really shows the respect that people have for those in need and the vulnerable when the people charged with supporting them, improving their daily life and monitoring their wellbeing are paid less than refuse collectors.

Redlocks30 · 18/10/2023 07:03

If Care staff are so utterly useless then why are we trusted with some of the most vulnerable people to look after?

I felt the same working in schools (particularly over Covid) where the government and the media were tripping over themselves to paint teachers as lazy, leftie or inept, yet still want children in earlier doing breakfast clubs, longer days, shorter holidays and want more and more added to the curriculum because a minority of parents aren’t doing it at home. If we are that dreadful, why do you want us to have your children even more?!

RachelSTG · 18/10/2023 07:02

I really relate to your post op. I worked in care for 15 years; in-patient units, care in the community, supported living and nursing homes. You get no respect and I accumulated debt over that time as I was paid a pittance despite doing every training course going. I left the sector this year for a mon-fri 9-5. I wish I left years ago. I wasted so many years languishing. People just think of you as a 'bum-wiper' even though care is a profession. The whole sector needs overhauled. I can't believe I ordered medication, administered medication - prescribed and controlled, attended social work meetings, wrote detailed reports and care plans, risk assessed etc for £10 an hour! What a joke.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 18/10/2023 07:00

Many homes are now owned by private equity firms who are not in the business of providing care they are simply interested in asset stripping and profit. Sadly the residents who are paying eye watering costs are not getting value for money which angers family members. The homes are often badly run, short staffed and badly paid. Of course there are some fantastic homes and great people but they are becoming increasingly rare.

theduchessofspork · 18/10/2023 06:57

I’ve found a lot of carers to be great, some to be average and a significant minority poor (I used to work in the industry). There care homes that are generally poor - and people have heard about those and cab be suspicious when their relatives are so vulnerable. Plus the fact, as you say, most people want loved relatives to have a level of personal attention that just isn’t realistic.

I think the PP that said we aren’t good at managing family expectations is right. I would talk to the nursing and management staff about this, and what could he done to provide info when a paitient joins and info about progressive conditions like dementia .
Things like the fact that the person no longer likes X, but seem to be enjoying Y need to be communicated like you would in a nursery. It shouldn’t be that difficult to do a very quick monthly report.

I’d talk to your management about a new system for all this, as part of telling the rellies about this, they could remind them that the care team works hard and any concerns should be brought to the nursing staff.

Pennyplant19 · 18/10/2023 06:51

Oh my goodness, my Mum is in a Dementia unit in a residential home and her carers are absolutely wonderful - I couldn't wish for kinder, more tolerant caring people to be looking after my Mum. I make sure I tell them this too.

Conkersinautumn · 18/10/2023 06:48

I loved working in care, but only for the clients and hope to go back into it (I can't at the moment because I can't work nights and my agency insisted on at least two a week, so I didn't get any hours) unfortunately a lot of families are dealing with carers that are burnt out. My agency would hound me on holidays, scheduled non availability, and I even received a call about covering someone when I was at a funeral for a previous long term client. Unfortunately the senior staff, the schedulers and managers seem to treat staff as robots, the families pick up on the that and the role is socially viewed as lower than mice.

porridgecake · 18/10/2023 06:44

Cheshiresun · 18/10/2023 00:07

One of the problems in our area is that all of the council owned homes have gone, as the councils didn't want to run them anymore. The social workers recommended a few homes, but they were all council run and on contacting them when looking for a care home for my Great Aunt, they said they were all closing and not taking any new residents.

So now they are obviously all private. I'm not saying council run were better than private or the other way around, but obviously profit must be a big factor in privately owned homes.

Care homes are mostly privately run now, with a mix of self funding and state funded residents. They have to be because the self funders subsidise the state funded residents. Self funders pay around £1500 per week, the LA pay around £500. The care staff are paid very badly, but there must be so many other costs involved in just paying all the bills.

Soontobe60 · 18/10/2023 06:44

ShellySarah · 17/10/2023 23:32

The first day my mum was in a care home she deteriorated rapidly and was vomiting badly. I rang the call bell and both times the carer said we can't do anything switched the bell off and walked away.

It wasn't until the night nurse turned up that I demanded she do something and she called an out of hours GP. Mum was admitted to hospital within 3 days due to severe dehydration due to their neglect.

Sorry but the "care" I've seen leaves a lot to be desired. They were sitting around in the corridor whilst my mum was like that.

Why didn’t the GP have her admitted to hospital straight away? If you were there with her, why didn’t you take her yourself???

Swipe left for the next trending thread