Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Called aside in the office today...

530 replies

whatty · 17/10/2023 23:11

I work in London in a hub office (many businesses under common ownership using the same space) in a senior role (I am female in my 40s). It is a hot desking set up- sit where you like when you come in. Some areas in the office have music playing & some don't (some context!).

At the end of my day today, a senior male colleague (50s) from another business asked to have a word with me. I have met him a few times at sessions where the businesses have been collaborating/ doing leadership workshops. He didn't remember me, so introduced himself.

He then proceeded to tell me that as I had been on calls all day (11.30-6.30 with a short lunch break) that I had been distracting people around me, and "many" people (from his area of the business) had reached out to him mention that they had found me distracting. For info- I had a headset on, and was working with colleagues on budget documentation & talking to my team re: work they were tackling.

He recommended that I use a pod/ room in future if I was going to be on lots of calls. I questioned whether there was a policy re: working in silence/ being a silent space- and he admitted that it was just different approaches to working, and that the team he works in tends to avoid being on calls in the open plan. He then said he hoped that this conversation would be taken in the way in which it was intended. I was confused to be honest- so I said it wasn't clear how it was meant. But that I'd consider his feedback.

When we left the room where we had his conversation, it was clear that those from his business around me were all aware that I was being "pulled aside".

I was livid if I'm being honest- and upset too. I am really busy at work, have been doing long hours, and felt that he had no right to tell me what to do in a shared office space. I accept that I am tired and emotional though, so perhaps should just leave it and move on. However- I also feel like he wouldn't have had that conversation with me if I was male. And that I wouldn't be unreasonable to pull him aside/ talk to him when I next encounter him with some measured feedback of my own.

What do you think? Would I be unreasonable to stew on this- and think up some direct home truths? Or should I keep quiet in the office and on the feedback front. TIA for any guidance you can offer!

OP posts:
AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 10:10

I completely, and fundamentaly, disagree with you.

Perhaps you havent worked in a male dominated profession for 25 years like I have (IT) and this was a power move by a self important male middle manager (as described) which I used to witness on a weekly or even daily basis. Thankfully, most workplaces are becoming a bit more egalitarian nowadays and nobody I know would publicly pull aside a colleague, of either sex, for anything where I work. In fact, they'd be in trouble with HR if they were witnessed doing it by an even more senior manager.

I accept things are probably still very different in the NHS.

bohemianmullet · 18/10/2023 10:10

Ah apologies, I think I misunderstood the set-up. You say both he's from another business and also that he's a colleague. I'm afraid I don't quite understand how that works, so I'm not sure of the situation at all, or how the hub environment therefore works. So ignore my suggestions which was more for a hub with a lot of different businesses using the same space.

Coffeerum · 18/10/2023 10:06

@Alainlechat So it's okay to tell someone to keep it down out in the open space, in front of everyone else, and it is okay to send a passive agressive email asking people who do loud teams calls to use a pod, but it isn't okay to step aside with someone for a slightly more private chat to let them know multiple people have complained and would they mind altering their behaviour in future?

DrMarshaFieldstone · 18/10/2023 10:05

AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 09:56

I didn't say she wasn't being unreasonable. I said theres no way he would have publicly pulled her into a room and given her a dressing down about it if she'd been a male. This is emphatically true, at least where I work (a wework type office). At most, another manager from an aligned/related team would maybe have said, in passing, to a young junior male, 'can you keep it down a bit mate' or something similar. Absolutely no way would he have pulled him into a room. If it was a manager from a completely separate business they would say nothing directly. They would complain to the workspace management team who would have then put signs up, if they agreed, about which were designated quiet areas etc. They might also have sent an email to everyone saying please use a pod in such and such shared workspace area if you need a meeting space.

And how do I think he should have handled the fact that memeners of his team were (allegedly) complaining about teb noicse she was making on calls? Exactly as above. He should have raised it with the shared work space management, in private, or, at a push, with her manager, again in private. He has no jurisdiction over her and it is absolutely not acceptable to pull her up in public to humiliate and embarass her, which was absolutely a deliberate power move because HE was annoyed by her behaviour.

He asked to speak to her in another room. This conversation was therefore private but his team would have known the content because he was addressing their complaints.

I will accept that the request to go into the room will have had to be delivered publicly. There would have been no way around this and it does not constitute a ‘public dressing-down’.

I am absolutely fascinated that you would have preferred he go over her head to her manager. I think most people would be far more justifiably angered by this. He approached her as a peer and in my view this shows far more respect than lodging a complaint.

bohemianmullet · 18/10/2023 10:05

What makes this a bit complex is that this guy is from another business. Perhaps the way he asked for a word felt like he was managing you or something, and he wasn't careful enough in the way he handled it to make it clear it was a request, business to business, rather than directing or telling you. He's nothing to do with you so he could have handled it more in terms of asking you if you'd mind using the pods more if having a lot of calls, rather than directing you to always use pods. It's difficult if you have a mix of businesses with different ways of doing things and I can also see that you maybe feel why should you be directed or limited in what you do by another business and their working style, when it is not their actual space but a hub. Presumably another business that has to have calls all the time would have a different working style. What are the norms for the hub space? Are there rules or general etiquette that people adhere too across all the businesses (not just his one?).

What I think is unreasonable is you are asking if you should dream up some problems to give this guy some home truths. That just sounds over-sensitive and unfair. It probably wasn't a particularly easy conversation for him to have and he probably was the one dealing with a lot of people saying they couldn't concentrate, so he was left to try and speak to you.

I agree with @LuluKentGirl that one person on calls can be massively distracting if everyone else quiet, whereas if the atmosphere is more that everyone is on calls then it might be easier to tune out. I also agree with the person who points out the worry about confidentiality if you are discussing budgets etc in front of other businesses.

If it was me i might be tempted to have a conversation where I thanked him for bringing it to my attention and say as a courtesey I would try to use pods etc more if i had a very call-filled day, however there needs to be an understanding that there are different companies working there and being in a hub means there needs to be a certain amount of tolerance and give and take including occasional calls for which you wouldn't always be able to book a room in advance. I wouldn't do that to be pissy but more as a gracious acknowledgement that you want to be helpful whilst reminding gently that your work is separate from him and his.

Brefugee · 18/10/2023 10:04

PestoQueen · 18/10/2023 09:49

Hmmm, having worked in a cramped open plan office in The NHS for many years where many of us had hours of client telephone appointments, meetings with students in one corner of office, office conversations etc all the time, I find this "requiring a pod" a bit OTT to be honest!! We always managed fine! However I guess if there are discreet places to sit away from main office than fair enough but I almost laughed at what I see as a non issue really and do get why you felt a bit annoyed!

When everyone is doing it - that's the office culture. Where only one does it - and it disturbs the majority? Then, as OP acknowledged, it's not that office culture and has to stop

ilovemydogmore · 18/10/2023 10:04

He did the right thing, let you get on with your day and then politely explained to you directly and discretely. Your anger comes from embarrasment.

I work in an office like this. Pods are for calls, or stay home. Open plan spaces are for quiet, individual work.

Everanewbie · 18/10/2023 10:01

PestoQueen · 18/10/2023 09:49

Hmmm, having worked in a cramped open plan office in The NHS for many years where many of us had hours of client telephone appointments, meetings with students in one corner of office, office conversations etc all the time, I find this "requiring a pod" a bit OTT to be honest!! We always managed fine! However I guess if there are discreet places to sit away from main office than fair enough but I almost laughed at what I see as a non issue really and do get why you felt a bit annoyed!

Yes, but your first two lines are the key point. Most workers in your environment spent a high proportion of their day on the phone. So being surrounded by people doing the same didn't bother you. But in OPs case, everyone else's job has vanishingly little phone time and work away quietly. So OP is the only one, in a quiet office who spends most of the day on the phone. The odd phone call is part and parcel of shared office space, but not 6-7 hours of constant calls.

orangegato · 18/10/2023 10:00

This is why home working is the future. Don’t have listen to other people’s gobs all day.

FannyBawz · 18/10/2023 09:59

He’s right. Suck it up.

AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 09:56

DrMarshaFieldstone · 18/10/2023 09:39

OP was being unreasonable in her use of the workspace. I am genuinely interested in what you think would have been the correct way for the manager to deal with this, given that his team were directing their complaints to him.

I didn't say she wasn't being unreasonable. I said theres no way he would have publicly pulled her into a room and given her a dressing down about it if she'd been a male. This is emphatically true, at least where I work (a wework type office). At most, another manager from an aligned/related team would maybe have said, in passing, to a young junior male, 'can you keep it down a bit mate' or something similar. Absolutely no way would he have pulled him into a room. If it was a manager from a completely separate business they would say nothing directly. They would complain to the workspace management team who would have then put signs up, if they agreed, about which were designated quiet areas etc. They might also have sent an email to everyone saying please use a pod in such and such shared workspace area if you need a meeting space.

And how do I think he should have handled the fact that memeners of his team were (allegedly) complaining about teb noicse she was making on calls? Exactly as above. He should have raised it with the shared work space management, in private, or, at a push, with her manager, again in private. He has no jurisdiction over her and it is absolutely not acceptable to pull her up in public to humiliate and embarass her, which was absolutely a deliberate power move because HE was annoyed by her behaviour.

DitheringBlidiot · 18/10/2023 09:54

PestoQueen · 18/10/2023 09:49

Hmmm, having worked in a cramped open plan office in The NHS for many years where many of us had hours of client telephone appointments, meetings with students in one corner of office, office conversations etc all the time, I find this "requiring a pod" a bit OTT to be honest!! We always managed fine! However I guess if there are discreet places to sit away from main office than fair enough but I almost laughed at what I see as a non issue really and do get why you felt a bit annoyed!

But the two can't be compared. One was a noisy, busy office with nowhere else to go and one is an open plan hub with designated areas to conduct meetings.

Frasers · 18/10/2023 09:53

AIstolemylunch · 18/10/2023 09:34

I think he does, as described, and that is how I would have interpreted it OP. And there is no way he'd have pulled a bloke into a room wher I work.

Then you need to look for a new job if open sexual inequality is in place.

in my place of work, like others, gender wouldn’t be relevant.

we have all worked with the ops type. Man or woman. The one who comes into the office and does a days worth of calls loudly. Trying to show how important they are, it’s why she tells us what she was discussing when it’s irrelevant and why she thinks she’s in a position to give feedback to a senior manager.

the thing is no one is impressed. It’s the opposite, everyone hates it and feels disdain for the person performance working.

so the manager did right in pulling her aside and asking her to take calls in a pod to e sure she didn’t disrupt everyone else. So unless some back story here if a man was being just as much of a twat then he’d also get told.

MsMarch · 18/10/2023 09:53

whatty · 18/10/2023 09:10

Thanks for all the feedback. I was clearly in the wrong. Just one point of clarification- I didn't book a pod for the day, as I needed multiple screens, rather than just my laptop for the calls I was on... Either way- I should have booked an office and will do in future. Seems a bit miserable to come into the hub to see people around the office and have some meetings in person- but spend the majority of the day in a cupboard. But times have obviously changed, and I need to get on board.

Thanks again for the your comments

This is why I think hot-desking is ridiculous. Because you're coming into the office to be able to engage with colleagues etc... but half the time you're not even sitting with your team or people you know or will benefit from engaging with.

Brefugee · 18/10/2023 09:53

Setyoufree · 18/10/2023 06:56

This is a weird post COVID thing IMO. Previously if you worked with international colleagues you'd have been on the phone to them all day. Now it's unacceptable and you have to get a pod, apparently. Which makes the "you must come into an office so you can sit in a cupboard on your own all day" mandate absolutely ridiculous

Meh. It was unacceptable and distracting before. I've had discussions with people walking around making calls and stopping behind my desk. At ties when I'm working on budgets in 3 spreadsheets on 2 monitors it is unbearable.

And I have always told them to go away.

Nowadays hopefully people understand how to work in shared offices

GingerIsBest · 18/10/2023 09:52

I used to work in a large open plan office. Everyone was on the phone all the time - as there were lots of people, it was just a sort of low level general buzz. I couldn't work out why, when I moved to working in a remote working location, the noise of other people's phone calls was so annoying and, I assumed, so were my calls.

A friend, who works in building management told me it's all to do with dividers. In permanent offices, they have those dividers between desks. Apparently, at the bank she worked at, they'd actually invested in research regarding the ideal height of these - high enough to stop sound being annoying, low enough to still encourage collaboration!

It's a long way round of saying that I suspect you were being very annoying, without meaning to be, and it was totally reasonable too uggest you go work somewhere else or take calls somewhere else.

ThanksItHasPockets · 18/10/2023 09:51

Colourfulponderings · 18/10/2023 09:48

Pre covid would have been normal but now most people are used to being somewhere not overheard and retreat to pods ime.

Pre-Covid it was normal to undertake nearly seven hours of conference calls in an open-plan office? My professional life has been spent in the education sector rather than business so I can’t claim any expertise but I do question this assertion.

PestoQueen · 18/10/2023 09:49

Hmmm, having worked in a cramped open plan office in The NHS for many years where many of us had hours of client telephone appointments, meetings with students in one corner of office, office conversations etc all the time, I find this "requiring a pod" a bit OTT to be honest!! We always managed fine! However I guess if there are discreet places to sit away from main office than fair enough but I almost laughed at what I see as a non issue really and do get why you felt a bit annoyed!

Colourfulponderings · 18/10/2023 09:48

Pre covid would have been normal but now most people are used to being somewhere not overheard and retreat to pods ime.

BretonBlue · 18/10/2023 09:45

DrMarshaFieldstone · 18/10/2023 09:39

OP was being unreasonable in her use of the workspace. I am genuinely interested in what you think would have been the correct way for the manager to deal with this, given that his team were directing their complaints to him.

I’d be interested to know this, too.

Coffeerum · 18/10/2023 09:45

@Platypuslover Well most people on here are utterly wrong!

If you go around thinking everyone but you is wrong...it probably is you!

DitheringBlidiot · 18/10/2023 09:44

Platypuslover · 18/10/2023 09:40

There could also be a case made for the music being played not being legal if they didn’t have a business license to do so. Just saying.

Oh for goodness' sake!

saraclara · 18/10/2023 09:43

The way he approached the op was a chauvinistic power move!

In that case, I'll have to let my boss know that when SHE had to pull out a colleague to have exactly the same chat, she was being chauvinistic.

Seriously, you're being ridiculous.

SweetPetrichor · 18/10/2023 09:43

The office/pod sounds like a good idea. It can be intensely irritating listening to half a conversation for hours and hours. He handled it professionally, politely, it’s just part of sharing space.

Platypuslover · 18/10/2023 09:40

There could also be a case made for the music being played not being legal if they didn’t have a business license to do so. Just saying.