Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my university lectures were... well, lectures

267 replies

reallyyyy · 17/10/2023 22:18

I started a new course a few weeks ago, it's my second degree and it's a healthcare degree so that might be why. But our lectures are so interactive and filled with so many activities that feel like a waste of time. I had a 2 hour lecture today and 40 minutes of it was spent making posters of different topics to put on the board at the front, with the vision that we would be learning from each other. Only, we couldn't read the posters as they were too small and far away and it didn't teach us anything. There are also lots of 'discuss in pairs X, Y and Z' and it's not helpful or useful. It was nice in the first week as a bit of an icebreaker but now it just feels annoying.

I'm finding it frustrating sitting in a 2 hour lecture and being taught 1 hour of content. I'm not sure if it's because I studied a different degree before but lectures were 2 hours of information and I learnt a lot from them.

We have seminars too so it's not like I'm not enjoying the interaction, just not in a lecture.

I know IABU but I think I'm just overly tired from getting up at 5:30am to commute in for a lecture just to spend half the time making posters or colouring in diagrams.

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 18/10/2023 12:09

Are these group discussions and activities taking place in traditional lecture theatres with potentially 200+ students? How would noise levels be managed? Getting stressed just thinking about it.

The seminars I remember we're more like 20 at most and in smaller rooms

lauraloulou1 · 18/10/2023 12:05

YABU
Lecturers would love to lecture for 2 hrs too as its much easier than managing classes and encouraging peer to peer learning but you wouldn't learn as much. The old school standing in a lecture room doesn't work for most students and is generally a sign of a lazy lecturer not up to date with the latest approaches. that is why your lecturers are interactive and a mix of both. Particularly post covid. The other issue lecturers are facing is that covid kids have no social skills - covid teens who are in college now have no social skills and employers expect them. So we are having to add this element into our teaching so that our students have a vague hope of getting and keeping a job. So yeah. Maybe you are finding the social element more challenging than you are admitting and that's translating into anger? Perhaps have a look at that. And make sure you do all your reading ahead of class so you can participate fully.

reallyyyy · 18/10/2023 12:03

I'm glad a lot of you agree with me, I thought I was BU. I'm definitely going to mention it in the feedback forms. It's extra frustrating as this particular module is particularly difficult, and it feels like the lecturer whizzes through the complicated slides to then waste time on lots of activities that aren't helpful.

Interesting that a few of you mentioned autism/neurodiversity as I've been wondering about whether I'm potentially neurodiverse lately. My first degree was a heavy scientific degree and I would skip nearly all of my lectures and go through the content at home which worked really well for me and I graduated top of my cohort. I'd love to skip these lectures but attendance in person is monitored and mandatory due to it being an NHS course.

OP posts:
FucksSakeSusan · 18/10/2023 11:47

Talking at someone for an hour is now considered bad practice so a range of learning strategies being used is actually a good thing. However, poster making doesn't sound like it's teaching them anything and should be done in students' own time as a consolidation task.

FWIW lecturers' teaching skills vary greatly and some are just shit. Many places make them do an HE teaching qualification which can help, but some are employed on the strength of their research/grants they can bring in rather than their teaching ability. This is not helpful for the students but the university has the REF to think about...

WhatNoRaisins · 18/10/2023 11:22

I really enjoyed having a mix of seminars with group work and straight lectures where you took notes. Wouldn't have enjoyed only having one sort.

While I can believe that teaching what you have learnt to others can consolidate learning it's a bit convenient isn't it. The students aren't being paid to teach others and a lot of people will just be coasting.

Lagoonablue · 18/10/2023 10:57

The point is no one size fits all so there will be some activities others like but you don’t. The key is to gave a range of activities.

and comparing children’s learning with adults is pointless.

re ND. There is no contravention of the Equality Act. Students usually have personal learning plans where reasonable adjustments can be made.

Irishwitchsocks · 18/10/2023 10:16

Sounds very woolly

TheOutlaws · 18/10/2023 10:14

@DangerousDora

I would be inclined to argue that your DS’s uni are contravening the Equality Act. One of the reasons schools now use direct instruction/retrieval practice/silent completion of tasks is because it is proven to benefit ND students (including ADHD, who already have an unmanageable cognitive load without faffing around ‘co-creating’). Universities who do mad co-teaching nonsense are MASSIVELY behind the research curve on this one.

NB I’ve just completed an MSc remotely so I have experienced it from the other side. We were remote, so we learned by online lectures and reading, not ‘co-creating’.

SaffronSpice · 18/10/2023 09:46

I see a few people have said this is a very noughties style of learning. I wonder if this reflects the time those implementing this were themselves trained?

I had lectures, never two hours though - 50 minute ones so if two in a row had travel time/break. We also had tutorials and 3 hour practicals. In my final year we had some seminar types where groups were set different topics to prepare talks on and present. I hated those as there were always students who couldn’t be bothered. But the real problem came with the exam and your exam question (3 x 1 hour essays) was on a topic another group had presented. So they had done the in depth reading on that topic rather than you and didn’t share their material and what they presented was not up to scratch. Yes you could have read up but by that stage we were beyond the ‘neatly and concisely present in textbooks’ stage of knowledge so researching all the topics from scratch was impossible (hence being given a topic per group in the first place).

DangerousDora · 18/10/2023 09:37

@Alaimo That’s a good point actually and possibly borne out by ds getting top marks in his first lot of assessments, apparently significantly ahead of the majority of the group.

Thank you. I will pass that on to him, it may help him see things a bit more positively.

Alaimo · 18/10/2023 09:05

@DangerousDora Ds is genuinely passionate about his subject, so does a lot of self-directed learning at home, but he feels like he is then having to effectively teach that knowledge to the coaster students during these sessions.

I sympathise with your DS and other neurodivergent students who find this type of education stressful. But what you describe in your quote here, can actually work to your son's advantage. As the expression goes, the best way to understand a concept is to teach it to others. It might feel unfair to your son, but by explaining it to others he is further developing his own understanding of the topic. If asked 2 weeks later what they remember, I'd expect your son to have a reasonably good retention of what he learned (and better than if he had only studied independently at home), whereas the students who had it explained to them by your son will most likely have forgotten most of it.

mugboat · 18/10/2023 08:53

Perhaps it depends on the subject, I did History and Politics. No lab work. I got more out of the seminars for which I and to prepare in advance and then discuss with a small group.

I can literally remember nothing from the lectures. Except having wrist ache from trying to keep up with a lecturer.

shockeditellyou · 18/10/2023 08:47

mugboat · 18/10/2023 08:03

When I was an undergraduate 1999-2002 ALL of my lectures were delivered in this didactic fashion. I learnt practically nothing in them.

Unless you have a dynamic lecturer, they will stand and talk at you for 1-2 hours and you need to try to keep up with them and take notes. No normal undergraduate can write as fast as a person talks.

When you spend 1-2 hours trying to write what someone is saying, you're essentially focusing on transcription rather than actually learning anything.

Just because you write something down, doesn't mean you will remember it later let alone understand it.

Lectures like this are very frustrating... and I'd argue, lazy teaching.

I found the complete opposite. I was at Uni at the same time and the vast majority of my labs were chalk and talk. They were generally excellent - well structured, and delivered using overhead projectors, with lecturers doing worked examples as necessary. Having to take notes forces you to engage with the subject very effectively. Yes, there were some crap lecturers but we were at Uni, FFS, and perfectly capable of helping ourselves via textbooks. We also had supplementary tutorials and extensive lab work.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 18/10/2023 08:06

RosaGallica · 18/10/2023 06:23

Yanbu, op, they think we’re all 5 nowadays. The sad thing is that if you took someone trained in this system and put them in a lecture they would not be able to focus for long or assimilate the information, and then they would feel that it was the lecturer at fault too. And then they wonder why older people think the country is dumbed down and qualifications can’t be trusted.

Following this with interest, although it’s many years since I taught at University.

It just occurred to me that I go to quite a few ‘societies’ at local levels (gardening, local history, art, general ‘interest’ groups). At all of them, people sit in a darkened room listening to a lecturer speaking with the aid of slides for about 45 minutes. The questions at the end seem to demonstrate that most attendees have listened, understood and thought about the presentation…..

mugboat · 18/10/2023 08:03

When I was an undergraduate 1999-2002 ALL of my lectures were delivered in this didactic fashion. I learnt practically nothing in them.

Unless you have a dynamic lecturer, they will stand and talk at you for 1-2 hours and you need to try to keep up with them and take notes. No normal undergraduate can write as fast as a person talks.

When you spend 1-2 hours trying to write what someone is saying, you're essentially focusing on transcription rather than actually learning anything.

Just because you write something down, doesn't mean you will remember it later let alone understand it.

Lectures like this are very frustrating... and I'd argue, lazy teaching.

DangerousDora · 18/10/2023 08:02

Tatumm · 18/10/2023 00:16

I had no idea this was normal. How do neurodivergent students find this style?

Ds (ASD) has just started uni a couple of years after his peer group and coincidentally, was complaining about this last night.

He’s doing a computing subject and has relatively high contact hours compared to some subjects. One day a week he is in for 8 hours of lectures, so four two hour sessions. Last week he spent half the day - in his words - “playing with lego” and another two hours on a similar type of ‘interactive group activity’.

He finds the forced social aspect of this type of learning stressful and exhausting and is also getting increasingly frustrated by the seemingly large numbers of ‘coasters’ in these sessions who just sit back and let the rest of the group do the work, then it’s submitted as collaborative. (Although that did show up in their first round of assessments recently.) Ds is genuinely passionate about his subject, so does a lot of self-directed learning at home, but he feels like he is then having to effectively teach that knowledge to the coaster students during these sessions.

The career he is aiming for and would be expected from this particular course after uni will require minimal teamwork, so the teaching style of the course is effectively at odds with the subject/prospects.

When he had his DSA assessment they set him up with tech to support him with recording and note taking in lectures. Now, at two months in, he hasn’t been able to use it yet.

RaisinsOfMildAnnoyance · 18/10/2023 07:54

Yep, I know of a masters course where a lecturer passed around sparkly stickers to use as part of their poster work. 🙄

Badbadbunny · 18/10/2023 07:54

Unwisebutnotillegal · 18/10/2023 06:37

Yep I’ve just started a masters and feel like I’m in primary school not university. One of the lecturers commented to me that it’s not about education anymore just the piece of paper at the end.

Nail on the head there! It's the result of the commoditisation of uni degrees. Thanks Blair!

TheGoogleMum · 18/10/2023 07:53

I went for a lecturer job interview recently and was asked to prepare an interactive teaching session- they don't want to hire people who just stand and talk! So I'd say it probably comes from the university than the lecturers

Hellofromtheotherslide · 18/10/2023 07:40

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 17/10/2023 22:23

Are you supposed to be doing additional reading before it? There’s a technique called flipped classroom which means that people do reading / preparation then come into a seminar based session to consolidate their learning.

Also, if it’s a healthcare course, they might also be looking at you developing softer skills which can’t be learned from being ‘taught’ or assessed.

This is the method that's being used in the degree I'm on at the moment and can't say I'm enjoying it either. Reading all of the materials etc is interesting and useful, but the actual classes I attend to 'discuss' the topics are often pointless with no real application of anything learnt and frustrates many of us. However, I believe the point of it is to develop soft skills alongside the actual primary skill/knowledge but it's too much when it is every single subject.

Hufflypuffly123 · 18/10/2023 07:37

They can't suit everyone. I prefer lectures but many people find it difficult to absorb information that way.

And even though I prefer lectures I always uses to think what was the point in attending one when you'd be given hand outs or a copy of the slideshow anyway.

donquixotedelamancha · 18/10/2023 07:32

SisterMichaelsHabit · 17/10/2023 22:33

This is how teaching has gone.

It's to do with educational theory.

Lectures come from the "old" way of teaching, where we (apparently) believed learners were empty vessels who needed filling with knowledge.

Now things are supposed to be taught with a minimum of teacher talking time, teachers are supposed to facilitate while students learn by doing activities and guessing at what they're actually learning (deductive learning, in educational jargon). It's implemented to varying degrees of success and things like your posters are supposed to show that learning is taking place where this wasn't really assessed when people just did lectures.

There's some value to this approach, but they've gone overboard with it and need to reign it in and remember educators actually do have more knowledge that's why they're teaching a bloody class and maybe it's not a bad thing for them to just share that knowledge with the learners and save us all hours of listening to rooms full of confused people scribbling with felt tip pens who won't remember what they covered today by next week because they weren't allowed to just listen and make some notes occasionally.

Edited

In schools we are swinging back the other way because research still shows that direct instruction is the most efficient way to learn a completely new topic.

Making a poster is a very, very low impact way for adults to learn.

Zodfa · 18/10/2023 07:30

Small group discussion should work, probably better than from-the-front delivery, when students have a reasonable chance of figuring out the answers (but the answers are not super-obvious things they probably knew already) and are guided appropriately by the lecturer - making the parameters of the task clear from the start, helping people who get stuck, bringing it all back together at the end.

Other stuff (e.g. facts the students could not be expected to come up with themselves) is best taught entirely from the front.

Unfortunately it sounds like some people have gone overboard and think small group discussion is always better no matter in what context or how it is moderated.

A solution for ND and other students who may not feel comfortable with the discussion element is to let them think over the problems privately during the group times. ("Get into groups of between 1 and 5 and try to work out ...")

VisaWoes · 18/10/2023 07:27

I’m a university lecturer and when I did my pg cert this was very much promoted as good pedagogical practice. Lots of talk about active learning, that the evidence shows it promotes better understanding than traditional didactic methods. Lots of talk of different activities and chunking.

I prefer to teach more traditionally but will pose questions in my slides without the answers to try and get discussion going. Chuck in a few videos and maybe a short quiz at the end. 🤷‍♀️

Saschka · 18/10/2023 07:23

totallyteutonic · 18/10/2023 00:06

So funny that universities are going this direction whilst schools are going back to more trad methods. I’m doing an MA and all the teaching is like this, it’s really annoying. I just don’t care about my classmates inexpert experiences and opinions. It all feels very dumbed down compared to my undergrad.

MAs are meant to be about independent learning though - I’ve done both an MA in education and an MSc in epidemiology, and DH did an MSc in urban studies, and all of our seminars were like that - you were meant to do all the reading beforehand. The aim of the seminars was to work with other people to put your reading into practice. There weren’t any lectures.

I do agree that undergraduates need a bit more handholding.