Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my university lectures were... well, lectures

267 replies

reallyyyy · 17/10/2023 22:18

I started a new course a few weeks ago, it's my second degree and it's a healthcare degree so that might be why. But our lectures are so interactive and filled with so many activities that feel like a waste of time. I had a 2 hour lecture today and 40 minutes of it was spent making posters of different topics to put on the board at the front, with the vision that we would be learning from each other. Only, we couldn't read the posters as they were too small and far away and it didn't teach us anything. There are also lots of 'discuss in pairs X, Y and Z' and it's not helpful or useful. It was nice in the first week as a bit of an icebreaker but now it just feels annoying.

I'm finding it frustrating sitting in a 2 hour lecture and being taught 1 hour of content. I'm not sure if it's because I studied a different degree before but lectures were 2 hours of information and I learnt a lot from them.

We have seminars too so it's not like I'm not enjoying the interaction, just not in a lecture.

I know IABU but I think I'm just overly tired from getting up at 5:30am to commute in for a lecture just to spend half the time making posters or colouring in diagrams.

OP posts:
BurbageBrook · 19/10/2023 07:42

@totallyteutonic makes a great point. I'm a lecturer and I get great feedback on my teaching (whether lectures or more interactive seminars) but I used to be a secondary school teacher so I have the natural inclination for teaching as well as the training. Some of my colleagues have had barely any training and actively dislike the teaching requirement part of their roles.

OneMoreStepAlongTheRoadIGo · 19/10/2023 07:42

We'd be slated in adult ed for just talking... !

BurbageBrook · 19/10/2023 07:39

Schools have finally accepted that, actually, it's helpful just to TELL people things sometimes and direct instruction is all the rage. Unfortunately at university level, pedagogy is about twenty years behind so they expect lecturers to do all the interactive stuff. It's silly -- both types of teaching are valid but too much of any one method isn't great. Ideally there would be a balance between lecturing and interaction IMO.

totallyteutonic · 19/10/2023 07:35

@SerafinasGoose

Much too sweeping.

I didn’t say all lecturers I said the lecturers on my course

Darhon · 19/10/2023 06:11

Tatumm · 18/10/2023 00:16

I had no idea this was normal. How do neurodivergent students find this style?

Work in HE with disabled students, on a high content hours course with a lot of didactic delivery of teaching. On balance, neurodivergent students mostly (it’s not uniform), dislike traditionally delivered lectures. However, this is often around sensory issues of being in crowds, the noise of other students and auditory processing issues.

However, let’s not romanticise didactic lectures. They have been poorly attended on he for decades and if you stand at the back of them now, lots of students are browsing and internet shopping.

You really need a mix of methods for leaning and understanding.

user1846385927482658 · 18/10/2023 22:48

Hm it's tough managing the weight and impact of socio-cultural factors students arrive with about what learning looks like and how it happens. I think it needs more of a place in preparing students.

VisaWoes · 18/10/2023 22:16

fishfingersandtoes · 18/10/2023 16:22

I had the opposite experience. Did a masters and was really impressed with the flipped classroom model that the lecturers used. It meant that after doing two really quite difficult and long readings, I could compare my understanding and interpretations to that of others in the class and test it out in class discussions with the lecturer, who was an expert in both the subject and guiding the discussion. I'd have been fine with taking notes in a lecture too (like my undergraduate days) but this was far far better for me.
IMO learning is a social activity. Why bother to come to the classroom if all you are doing is listening? You could just watch the recording or do the readings on your own.

We’ve tried doing this on the course I teach on and I’ve come to the conclusion that students will never be satisfied, at least not the whole cohort.

so the first year we taught a module quite traditionally, mainly PowerPoint lectures broken up with some videos, quizes, case studies, etc. the students said they were fed up with the PowerPoints and they could read a PowerPoint at home.

so the next year we did a flipped classroom with the new cohort and they hated it. They got the PowerPoints to read before the session at home, they a scenario and case study based classroom session. Lots of complaints about how they were teaching themselves the content, they didn’t understand it, etc.

It’s so difficult. Nothing seems right.

SerafinasGoose · 18/10/2023 21:47

I think the main reason they don’t work is the fact the academics aren’t good teachers.

Much too sweeping.

The academics who taught me were in the main fine, inspiring teachers. Their knowledge and passion for their research field was infectious. And they knew their stuff.

I can't judge my own teaching. I know I have the subject knowledge in spades, and this tends to communicate itself in your style of delivery. All I have to go on is my students' feedback, and my modules consistently register extremely high satisfaction scores in MEQs. These days that isn't necessarily easily done and other variables are of course at work: UCU data indicates women from Profs down to ALs are usually rated lower than men.

University lecturers today are also expected to have QTS. Ironically, that's probably exactly where most of this 'interactive' stuff is coming from - as well as management directives to keep teaching as cheap as possible. They then invariably hold lecturers responsible when this invariably looks like what it often is: an attempt to shove square pegs into round holes. And students are not fools. They know, and can spot a cheap compromise for exactly what it is.

To add to our woes, hybrid online/on campus teaching is almost certainly coming as a standard model. I abhor the very idea.

totallyteutonic · 18/10/2023 21:32

*trad seminar format

totallyteutonic · 18/10/2023 21:31

Having experienced yet another terrible ‘interactive’ masters session this evening I think the main reason they don’t work is the fact the academics aren’t good teachers. I am a teacher and it takes a lot to effectively manage discussion, plan activities that further understanding etc. and these guys just can’t do it! Stick to lecturing and read seminar format unless you are actually a good teacher I say!

Someone up thread replied to me saying undergrads need their hands held and masters students need to be more independent. This is total opposite of my experience (both at top 10 unis, study a social science). Undergrad was actually HARD, e.g. lecture, then read classic text and expect to be able to participate in a deep conversation about it. This MA is total Mickey Mouse stuff! Obviously can’t say if it’s representative but seems to foreground people’s experiences and thoughts rather than knowledge and intellectual debate.

SerafinasGoose · 18/10/2023 21:16

The problem as I see it is this. Universities used to prefer the lecture method because it was a cheap, quick cerebral dump of a lot of information to a lot of people. Lecture theatres can hold scores, even hundreds of students. There's no expectation of interaction. As an undergradate myself I rated my lecturers, many of whom were undoubtedly knowledgeable and produced outstanding research. But the lectures were of pretty poor quality: I quickly realised I could glean the same information as I could get in the introduction to most of the books we were studying. I also got the sense they'd probably been delivering the same stuff for about 20 years.

I keep mine current, put time into researching them, and review them annually to make sure I'm using the most recent, and relevant, research. I don't want to get up there and just spout the same old tired, uninspiring stuff year after year. But a further issue is that now there's a trend toward 'whole group' teaching rather than lectures. And one thing the research does undoubtedly show is that talking 'at' people for ages at a stretch is unproductive: they will switch off. My undergradute lectures only lasted 40 minutes. That's ample.

So my lectures (around two hours) have around 30-40 minutes of delivered content, then an activity/guided discussion. Then the remainder of the guided content is delivered and, time permitting, we have another discussion building on the first, which then sets up lines of thinking for the smaller seminar sessions.

The problem is that for a lot of teachers, lectures and seminars now look pretty much identical. I try to keep a distinct style and feel to my 'whole group' sessions, seminars and workshops, but it would be easy to fall into delivering the same sort of thing every time. Then the students get bored with the same dull routine, and stop attending. In summary, all this is down to cost-cutting. The days of the cosy chat about books with your lecturer in a tutorial of about 10 students are gone. Lecturers are not lecturers anymore. We're teachers. There is a difference.

I agree with the points upthread that spending valuable teaching contact time making pretty posters and playing with glittery post-it stickers is of use to no-one, and that would never happen in my sessions. I have seen a poster used as actual assessment for one module; likewise, there's an emphasis on variation away from 'traditional' assessment methods. This is one particular form of assessment I'd never choose under any pretext. The word-count of most essays is also shorter. I'd have hated this. I loved my good, beefy 4000-word Level 6 essays where I could really get stuck into my subject.

I feel people's frustration. £9K is a lot of money to spend on tuition per year. Students deserve value for money, but IMO management are going about this in the wrong way. There's too much emphasis put on students as 'customers' (they're not) and on what they want from their education (as opposed to what they might not think they want but actually need). They're paying for our expertise, whilst at the same time being actively encouraged to discount it.

It's a frustrating time to be a lecturer. And don't even get me started on study skills, which are currently the bane of my life.

WhatNoRaisins · 18/10/2023 17:37

It's tricky if they call that format a lecture given that it's not what the average person would expect from the term lecture.

Oakbeam · 18/10/2023 17:16

Badbadbunny · 18/10/2023 16:53

Surely it's all about the Uni being upfront as to how each course/module is being delivered. That way students can choose a Uni/course/module that suits their preferences as to how they prefer to learn.

They might not know what works best for them until they have experienced a variety of different university teaching methods.

Badbadbunny · 18/10/2023 16:53

Surely it's all about the Uni being upfront as to how each course/module is being delivered. That way students can choose a Uni/course/module that suits their preferences as to how they prefer to learn.

mugboat · 18/10/2023 16:49

fishfingersandtoes · 18/10/2023 16:22

I had the opposite experience. Did a masters and was really impressed with the flipped classroom model that the lecturers used. It meant that after doing two really quite difficult and long readings, I could compare my understanding and interpretations to that of others in the class and test it out in class discussions with the lecturer, who was an expert in both the subject and guiding the discussion. I'd have been fine with taking notes in a lecture too (like my undergraduate days) but this was far far better for me.
IMO learning is a social activity. Why bother to come to the classroom if all you are doing is listening? You could just watch the recording or do the readings on your own.

Totally agree. I'd rather read an article and take notes at my own pace than hurriedly take inadequate notes at my lecturer's pace...
if you prepare before class by doing the reading, you can consolidate your knowledge during the lecture time.

fishfingersandtoes · 18/10/2023 16:22

I had the opposite experience. Did a masters and was really impressed with the flipped classroom model that the lecturers used. It meant that after doing two really quite difficult and long readings, I could compare my understanding and interpretations to that of others in the class and test it out in class discussions with the lecturer, who was an expert in both the subject and guiding the discussion. I'd have been fine with taking notes in a lecture too (like my undergraduate days) but this was far far better for me.
IMO learning is a social activity. Why bother to come to the classroom if all you are doing is listening? You could just watch the recording or do the readings on your own.

Lollygaggle · 18/10/2023 14:06

When I give careers advice I often tell students to find out what style of teaching ie problem based learning, evidence based learning is used and how much contact time they have and how this might influence their choice of university.

I have a suspicion that this style of teaching has gained traction in clinical subjects such as my own (dentistry) because clinical subjects are notoriously expensive to provide and teaching staff have been cut to the bone.

Most of us who have been post graduate trainers have noted how much more we have to teach clinically and in theory as the years have gone by . It is also distressing that non conventional ways of gaining information such as you tube have gained traction without the critical analysis that a tutor/lecturer would have provided.

It has its positives in as much as when I qualified it wasn't until a couple of years later I learned that what I was taught as dogmatically right was not necessarily so. These days students have a wider experience of differing views. However they have not necessarily been well grounded in basics to allow them to critically review sources of information.

However especially in clinical subjects there is a lot of knowledge that you just have to force into your brain , retain and be able to use. Chalk and talk absolutely gave you those basics without which you are not safe to practice. Indeed part of the student experience was learning the skills to assimilate the huge body of knowledge you need , and to continue to need these skills throughout your practicing life. You might need different skills ,according to your learning style , to retain information given in a lecture but there is little to beat the concentrated power burst of knowledge in a lecture that forms the basis of your study . In any lecture it's a good one if you remember two things from it , but it's your notes that form the start of your study.

There are times when moving bits of post it notes around has been quite interesting (this technique was used quite a lot on dental educators course , however these are for people who have the knowledge but had to think about the different ways of presenting it to different styles of learners). But in terms of the hard graft of learning a really challenging clinical subject to a safe standard lectures are the bedrock .

DangerousDora · 18/10/2023 13:25

@lauraloulou1 the thing is, my son has settled in and adjusted to student life beautifully, far better than we could ever have hoped. Probably because he delayed going until he was ready, worked for a while in between - so he is used to woking in a team - and is living at home rather than in halls.

He understand the need for a mix of learning and they have different sessions that are supposed to accommodate that, but over 5 hours of it back to back on one day, timetabled as ‘lectures’, is too much. They have seminars and group sessions on other days, which I (and he) would expect to be more interactive and team based.

CoffeeWithCheese · 18/10/2023 12:45

It's early days and they tend to get a bit less whizzy and interactive as the course goes on in my experience.

As for how ND students cope - I just did, the same way most of us did - do the task in 3 minutes and spend another 10 chatting about crap... however after a year of it shifted online, the words "I'm just going to pop you in randomly allocated breakout rooms" still bring me out in a cold sweat because face-to-face you're generally sat next to people you get on with, but that yawning abyss as the screen goes black and you wait to see who you're going to be making awkward small talk with for the next 10 minutes seems like a decade.

justjeansandanicetop · 18/10/2023 12:36

YANBU, I like a good old fashioned lecture, too.

EveryKneeShallBow · 18/10/2023 12:31

lesserspotted · 17/10/2023 22:24

YANBU stupid faddy rubbish - complain, and complain loud and long!

Agree. A lecture is a lecture, or should be.

Oakbeam · 18/10/2023 12:28

Unless you have a dynamic lecturer, they will stand and talk at you for 1-2 hours and you need to try to keep up with them and take notes. No normal undergraduate can write as fast as a person talks

The sensible ones listen to the lecture, engage with the lecturer, and write up their notes later while watching the recording of the lecture.

HappyMarriage · 18/10/2023 12:20

Ugh I hate this kind of thing where the majority of the ‘content’ from the expert is just them asking the class to share their thoughts/ideas/experiences. No I don’t want to hear a bunch of random people share their thoughts I want to hear what you the so called experienced expert has to say about this topic which is why I’ve signed up to this training in the first place

lauraloulou1 · 18/10/2023 12:16

Also in terms of feedback: I wouldn't overdo the feedback regarding you thinking you know how best to create a lecture that works for most students. Your lecturer would have to have some level of training to have their position and poster making as a one-off would be encouraged as a group creative learning response. The comments here and the rush to agree with you seem to be more from those who studied a long time ago or whose kids aren't adjusting to college. And the reason for this is that these kids have spent way way too much time alone with computer screens doing "self directed study" (which has a very poor impact on mental health long term) or who are used to poor levels of secondard school didactic teaching. Self directed study has its place but most jobs require high levels of interaction, particularly NHS jobs, and part of what is being assessed for you is what the NHS call "working well with others" which will be on your job spec for the next 30 years if you want a career there. So perhaps focusing on why you don't enjoy this would serve you best.

DonnaGiovanna · 18/10/2023 12:13

This is one reason autistic dd has opted for OU. That style of teaching is completely inaccessible to her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread