Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my university lectures were... well, lectures

267 replies

reallyyyy · 17/10/2023 22:18

I started a new course a few weeks ago, it's my second degree and it's a healthcare degree so that might be why. But our lectures are so interactive and filled with so many activities that feel like a waste of time. I had a 2 hour lecture today and 40 minutes of it was spent making posters of different topics to put on the board at the front, with the vision that we would be learning from each other. Only, we couldn't read the posters as they were too small and far away and it didn't teach us anything. There are also lots of 'discuss in pairs X, Y and Z' and it's not helpful or useful. It was nice in the first week as a bit of an icebreaker but now it just feels annoying.

I'm finding it frustrating sitting in a 2 hour lecture and being taught 1 hour of content. I'm not sure if it's because I studied a different degree before but lectures were 2 hours of information and I learnt a lot from them.

We have seminars too so it's not like I'm not enjoying the interaction, just not in a lecture.

I know IABU but I think I'm just overly tired from getting up at 5:30am to commute in for a lecture just to spend half the time making posters or colouring in diagrams.

OP posts:
CornishClott · 19/10/2023 11:12

I did an art course many years ago and looking back the course had been padded out . It could have been condensed down to two years .

IcedPurple · 19/10/2023 11:00

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 10:56

And how does a train driver manage to be in control of his train for a couple of hours or more between station stops? Airline pilots? Lorry drivers?

In the workplace, people have to concentrate for hours at a time and can't indulge themselves in taking a bit of a break to draw a poster!

Perhaps having to sit through lectures and force themselves to pay attention etc would be a really good test of aptitude and good practice for the world of work!

Exactly.

Surgeons have to stay focussed in operations sometimes lasting 5 hours or more. If attention spans were as short as this 'research' supposedly shows, who'd risk having an operation?

IcedPurple · 19/10/2023 10:58

mugboat · 19/10/2023 10:55

can't compare a film with multiple characters talking, scene switching, action scenes etc with 1 person standing talking

Bit of goal post shifting going on!

Lots of films and TV programmes have pretty complex plots requiring focussed attention. Yet millions of people manage to sit through 2 hour films quite easily without the need for poster making breaks.

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 10:56

IcedPurple · 19/10/2023 10:49

I'd be interested to see that 'research'.

How does anyone manage to sit through a 2 hour film without taking a break to make posters if that's true?

And how does a train driver manage to be in control of his train for a couple of hours or more between station stops? Airline pilots? Lorry drivers?

In the workplace, people have to concentrate for hours at a time and can't indulge themselves in taking a bit of a break to draw a poster!

Perhaps having to sit through lectures and force themselves to pay attention etc would be a really good test of aptitude and good practice for the world of work!

mugboat · 19/10/2023 10:55

IcedPurple · 19/10/2023 10:49

I'd be interested to see that 'research'.

How does anyone manage to sit through a 2 hour film without taking a break to make posters if that's true?

can't compare a film with multiple characters talking, scene switching, action scenes etc with 1 person standing talking

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 10:53

mugboat · 19/10/2023 10:41

Research shows that adults' attention span is 20 mins max. The assumption that it's ineffective teaching to talk at a room of people for 1-2 hours is based research not on assumptions.

That will be average.

It doesn't take into account that lots of students will be more than capable of an attention span lasting more than 20 minutes!

Choice is needed so students can choose the type of course they want to do based upon prior knowledge of teaching styles etc.

If someone genuinely has an attention span of under 20 minutes, they're going to be pretty useless in a lot of workplaces!

IcedPurple · 19/10/2023 10:49

mugboat · 19/10/2023 10:41

Research shows that adults' attention span is 20 mins max. The assumption that it's ineffective teaching to talk at a room of people for 1-2 hours is based research not on assumptions.

I'd be interested to see that 'research'.

How does anyone manage to sit through a 2 hour film without taking a break to make posters if that's true?

Gettingbysomehow · 19/10/2023 10:43

I did a health care degree in my 40's and it was all of this. I felt like a three year old at pre-school.
If I never see a flip chart again it will be too soon.

mugboat · 19/10/2023 10:41

IcedPurple · 19/10/2023 09:54

I think it's really patronising to students. It's assuming that they're not capable of listening to an expert for 50 minutes or so unless they make posters or 'discuss in pairs'.

The same ideas are also present in the workplace. Instead of discussing important issues, you have to sit around writing your 'ideas' on coloured paper and chatting in groups. Complete waste of time.

Research shows that adults' attention span is 20 mins max. The assumption that it's ineffective teaching to talk at a room of people for 1-2 hours is based research not on assumptions.

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 10:41

@Lollygaggle

My personal opinion ,as someone who has been involved in post grad education for clinicians , is that we do not allow our young people to fail. I learned my study skills because I thought cleverness was enough to get me through exams. I cruised through until I got to first year uni when after failing an exam I finally got the message about hard work and study. Ultimately each of us has to learn how to learn. The problem is it is now unacceptable to fail at any stage in the education system because of targets and so people are not free to fail and learn from it in a positive way.

I fully agree. But inevitable really with pushing more and more school leavers to go to Uni, as a large proportion of students aren't really up to it, hence why Unis have to fall over themselves to "help" weaker students. Made even worse with the price hike of tuition fees to £9k!

Personally, rather than converting the Polys into Unis, I think we should have kept and developed them as a more practical alternative form of higher education for the less academic students. We've now got a two tier system where degrees from different types of Uni and degrees in different subjects are claimed to be of equivalent standing, but it's like the Emperors new clothes, we all know they're not the same at all, not to mention the disastrous lack of training young people into the more practical trades and skills.

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 10:36

@Darhon

You really need a mix of methods for leaning and understanding.

Yes, but not dumbing down so far as to spend what should be quality time on making posters! That kind of thing should have been left behind at primary school. It can't be a good use of lecturer time to sit around whilst the students fart around with making posters!

Lollygaggle · 19/10/2023 10:14

I utterly agree with the poster about cpd. In my profession you have to do quite a lot each year and pay for it.
Typically a whole day will be three lecturers who will chalk and talk or a practical course with a mix of lectures and then putting what you've learned into action.
Everyone wants and is engaged in a fact packed lecture, but then we have been trained over decades to assimilate information in this way.
My personal opinion ,as someone who has been involved in post grad education for clinicians , is that we do not allow our young people to fail. I learned my study skills because I thought cleverness was enough to get me through exams. I cruised through until I got to first year uni when after failing an exam I finally got the message about hard work and study. Ultimately each of us has to learn how to learn. The problem is it is now unacceptable to fail at any stage in the education system because of targets and so people are not free to fail and learn from it in a positive way.

IcedPurple · 19/10/2023 09:54

spiderlight · 19/10/2023 09:38

My DH is a senior lecturer and he hates this. It has been foisted on him from on high. He has nearly 30 years' experience of giving fun, engaging lectures, with overwhelming positive feedback and students regularly contacting him years later to thank him for inspiring them, but now his university has deemed that they have to use a completely different format, which he and the students find much less effective, and he has no choice in the matter.

I think it's really patronising to students. It's assuming that they're not capable of listening to an expert for 50 minutes or so unless they make posters or 'discuss in pairs'.

The same ideas are also present in the workplace. Instead of discussing important issues, you have to sit around writing your 'ideas' on coloured paper and chatting in groups. Complete waste of time.

SerafinasGoose · 19/10/2023 09:47

Sartre · 19/10/2023 09:31

Also a lecturer and I can confirm this. I lecture within humanities and our department was entirely depleted over summer (thanks Tories) so now we’re down to 5 lecturers from 12. Our workload effectively doubled so now we all have to teach extra modules we never touched before. On top of this they’re trying to encourage us to take a more interactive approach with students and get them to partake in weird activities like making posters as you mentioned.

I don’t like it, it isn’t my style. I prefer just sitting discussing literature with my students and bouncing off each other. Universities are changing rapidly, you can thank our wonderful government for that.

We're in the same position. We are haemorrhaging staff. The department you describe above could very easily be mine.

Humanities are in serious trouble across the board. Very sad.

(No student will ever sit making posters in any seminar of mine).

IcedPurple · 19/10/2023 09:44

I was last in full time education over 15 years ago, but this trend had already started then. So much of our time was spent in 'group work' or watching 'presentations' from our colleagues. Which is fine up to a point, but some of the academic staff were very well known experts in their field, and I'd have loved to hear more from them.

Old-fashioned lectures can still be a valuable learning tool. Problem is, they're "unfashionable". The current belief is that talking 'at' people is wrong, even when students are paying a lot of money for expertise. I don't think listening is a passive experience either. Taking notes, thinking about the material, maybe asking questions at the end, is very engaging. At least it is for me. I still remember lectures from my bacherlor's degree back in the mists of time!

spiderlight · 19/10/2023 09:38

My DH is a senior lecturer and he hates this. It has been foisted on him from on high. He has nearly 30 years' experience of giving fun, engaging lectures, with overwhelming positive feedback and students regularly contacting him years later to thank him for inspiring them, but now his university has deemed that they have to use a completely different format, which he and the students find much less effective, and he has no choice in the matter.

Sartre · 19/10/2023 09:33

SerafinasGoose · 19/10/2023 09:12

Apologies, I misread.

To reply ad hoc to a couple of other points made upthread: some students complain if students perceive their 'lectures' are being read directly from PowerPoint slides (whether or not that perception is accurate). We see a lot of complaints to that tune in our various modules in MMR and MEQs.

I deliberately design my slides as 'cue cards' so they're a mere skeleton of what I intend to say, with 'pauses' to account for in-built tasks (we just use another slide as a 'whiteboard' for exercises so students can consult them afterwards). The idea here is that they know a PPTX deck is no substitute for the 'live' experience so will be more likely to attend. Now I'm being told to record every session with talk-based content, so the strategy is moot anyway!

As to students complaining no matter what we do: they are continually subject to surveys NSS, MEQ on every module as it's mandatory, 'You said, we did' (a particular bugbear of mine). When you invite people to complain (and surveys are invariably negatively worded in a way that encourages this), they often will.

Still on the point of complaints, a perennial one from my students, no matter how much assessment guidance they get, is that it's never enough. They get so much stuff I never received: inbuilt library research sessions, a pause in the schedule so they can complete formative work building up to their assessed submission, a template of what kind of evidence they could include (talk about spoon-feeding, I never got that!) and for the non-standard assessment tasks they get a piece of work structured to every text, every single weekly seminar, which feeds into that task. They also get a screencast on the VLE that walks them through every step of the work.

I still get complaints that they don't get enough guidance. Invariably, these complaints are coming from serial non-attendees. I don't see what more I can do short of writing the thing for them.

On a further (related) point, universities seem to be losing the aim of turning out autonomous, independent learners. They are reading for a degree - the onus is on them to do the work - with a few contact points each week. On my degree this was typically six hours. Our students demand more time from us, as they want their money's worth. We allot it - they then don't turn up. So here's another obstacle, what students are telling us what they want isn't actually what they do want as things work out.

There's also the stuff on employability: a big deal in the national organisations working in my individual subject group. We are not employment training factories, but we are expected to deliver this as well.

No wonder quality is going down - and I'm not under any illusion that it's not. Somewhere along the way, universities (or those governing them) have forgotten what they're actually for.

Also agree with this.

I teach literature and you’d be amazed (or perhaps not) by how many students don’t read the set texts. They then turn up pointlessly to seminars having not touched the book and therefore can’t partake at all. They pay 9k a year and can’t even be arsed reading a book.

Sartre · 19/10/2023 09:31

Sushilover14 · 17/10/2023 23:17

Lecturers are encourage to design classes in this manner as of late - to do with the whole students as producers idea. As a lecturer, I don’t like it at all. I prefer the system of lectures where a lecture occurs and separate seminars allowing for student activity and discussion.

Also a lecturer and I can confirm this. I lecture within humanities and our department was entirely depleted over summer (thanks Tories) so now we’re down to 5 lecturers from 12. Our workload effectively doubled so now we all have to teach extra modules we never touched before. On top of this they’re trying to encourage us to take a more interactive approach with students and get them to partake in weird activities like making posters as you mentioned.

I don’t like it, it isn’t my style. I prefer just sitting discussing literature with my students and bouncing off each other. Universities are changing rapidly, you can thank our wonderful government for that.

DumboHimalayan · 19/10/2023 09:26

fishfingersandtoes · 19/10/2023 08:42

I think complaints are often just from those who are disgruntled with their marks and have little to do with quality of teaching.
I am a teacher and I really believe it's a craft, there is no one size fits all. Neither for students or for teachers. At university the onus is or should be on the students to learn.

To be fair, you could manoeuvre yourself into a no-lose situation that way.

Student complains about teaching style.

A. Student has poor grades. Obviously disgruntled with marks and looking for excuses. Ignore.

B. Student has good grades. Well, the teaching style obviously didn't affect them that badly, then — sounds like they only thought they learnt worse with it, when they actually learnt better. Ignore.

Grin
SerafinasGoose · 19/10/2023 09:12

totallyteutonic · 19/10/2023 07:35

@SerafinasGoose

Much too sweeping.

I didn’t say all lecturers I said the lecturers on my course

Apologies, I misread.

To reply ad hoc to a couple of other points made upthread: some students complain if students perceive their 'lectures' are being read directly from PowerPoint slides (whether or not that perception is accurate). We see a lot of complaints to that tune in our various modules in MMR and MEQs.

I deliberately design my slides as 'cue cards' so they're a mere skeleton of what I intend to say, with 'pauses' to account for in-built tasks (we just use another slide as a 'whiteboard' for exercises so students can consult them afterwards). The idea here is that they know a PPTX deck is no substitute for the 'live' experience so will be more likely to attend. Now I'm being told to record every session with talk-based content, so the strategy is moot anyway!

As to students complaining no matter what we do: they are continually subject to surveys NSS, MEQ on every module as it's mandatory, 'You said, we did' (a particular bugbear of mine). When you invite people to complain (and surveys are invariably negatively worded in a way that encourages this), they often will.

Still on the point of complaints, a perennial one from my students, no matter how much assessment guidance they get, is that it's never enough. They get so much stuff I never received: inbuilt library research sessions, a pause in the schedule so they can complete formative work building up to their assessed submission, a template of what kind of evidence they could include (talk about spoon-feeding, I never got that!) and for the non-standard assessment tasks they get a piece of work structured to every text, every single weekly seminar, which feeds into that task. They also get a screencast on the VLE that walks them through every step of the work.

I still get complaints that they don't get enough guidance. Invariably, these complaints are coming from serial non-attendees. I don't see what more I can do short of writing the thing for them.

On a further (related) point, universities seem to be losing the aim of turning out autonomous, independent learners. They are reading for a degree - the onus is on them to do the work - with a few contact points each week. On my degree this was typically six hours. Our students demand more time from us, as they want their money's worth. We allot it - they then don't turn up. So here's another obstacle, what students are telling us what they want isn't actually what they do want as things work out.

There's also the stuff on employability: a big deal in the national organisations working in my individual subject group. We are not employment training factories, but we are expected to deliver this as well.

No wonder quality is going down - and I'm not under any illusion that it's not. Somewhere along the way, universities (or those governing them) have forgotten what they're actually for.

DavesSpareDeckChair · 19/10/2023 09:00

Clafoutie · 17/10/2023 23:01

Oops, wrong thread!

😆
I was trying to work out if this was some sort of comment on the "woolly" or "warm and fuzzy" style of teaching!

Pancakeorcrepe · 19/10/2023 08:48

I would absolutely hate this

fishfingersandtoes · 19/10/2023 08:42

VisaWoes · 18/10/2023 22:16

We’ve tried doing this on the course I teach on and I’ve come to the conclusion that students will never be satisfied, at least not the whole cohort.

so the first year we taught a module quite traditionally, mainly PowerPoint lectures broken up with some videos, quizes, case studies, etc. the students said they were fed up with the PowerPoints and they could read a PowerPoint at home.

so the next year we did a flipped classroom with the new cohort and they hated it. They got the PowerPoints to read before the session at home, they a scenario and case study based classroom session. Lots of complaints about how they were teaching themselves the content, they didn’t understand it, etc.

It’s so difficult. Nothing seems right.

I think complaints are often just from those who are disgruntled with their marks and have little to do with quality of teaching.
I am a teacher and I really believe it's a craft, there is no one size fits all. Neither for students or for teachers. At university the onus is or should be on the students to learn.

Badbadbunny · 19/10/2023 08:24

I'm long past schools/university etc. But a requirement of my professional body (as it's common) is many hours of yearly CPD. Luckily, these days being self employed, I can choose my own. I am never a repeat customer of any training provider firms who indulge in the time wasting "gimmicks"- I want pretty formal talks/lectures and the training providers who do that will get my repeat custom. Funny thing is, the firms who provide what others would probably call "boring" seem to be the ones who have more attendees and last longer. The ones using trendy/modern methods don't seem to last long and seem to have fewer customers! Then again, I'm in the traditionally boring profession of accountancy!

It's nothing new for me. I hated the "group work" type of lessons way back in my school days. I always did better in the lessons where the teacher did the teaching, and the classroom was set out in rows rather than clusters. My end of year test marks proved the point. I always dropped grades when in "trendy" classes with teachers do let the class "discover" things for themselves rather than teach them!

I think we have to accept that different people have different preferences as to how they learn. And, yes, the providers, whether teachers, lecturers or whoever need to lose the arrogance that they know best, and give students the choice, the choice to choose the uni, subject, module according to their personal learning preferences.

At least with private CPD providing firms, the person buying the course has the choice of their learning style, but for some reason, universtities don't want to give that informed choice to their students.

desikated · 19/10/2023 08:03

This thread is so interesting.

I'm a lecturer at a Russell Group Uni. We had to do the equiv of some kind of 'teacher training' for lecturing but at much less intensity.

In this we are explicitly told multiple times that

1/ didactic teaching (eg talking directly for an hour or two) is not good teaching, that students don't like it and it doesn't help learning
2/ that all teaching should be interactive especially lectures
3/ that lectures are not an effective way for students to learn (insert references to evidence here)

I do get your frustration OP and others. But, lecturers are being explicitly told to do this and that lectures in their pure form are not 'good' teaching.

Do feedback (gently!) it is useful to know and certainly given me food for thought about my lectures.

Swipe left for the next trending thread