Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my university lectures were... well, lectures

267 replies

reallyyyy · 17/10/2023 22:18

I started a new course a few weeks ago, it's my second degree and it's a healthcare degree so that might be why. But our lectures are so interactive and filled with so many activities that feel like a waste of time. I had a 2 hour lecture today and 40 minutes of it was spent making posters of different topics to put on the board at the front, with the vision that we would be learning from each other. Only, we couldn't read the posters as they were too small and far away and it didn't teach us anything. There are also lots of 'discuss in pairs X, Y and Z' and it's not helpful or useful. It was nice in the first week as a bit of an icebreaker but now it just feels annoying.

I'm finding it frustrating sitting in a 2 hour lecture and being taught 1 hour of content. I'm not sure if it's because I studied a different degree before but lectures were 2 hours of information and I learnt a lot from them.

We have seminars too so it's not like I'm not enjoying the interaction, just not in a lecture.

I know IABU but I think I'm just overly tired from getting up at 5:30am to commute in for a lecture just to spend half the time making posters or colouring in diagrams.

OP posts:
JustAMinutePleass · 19/10/2023 15:49

Online degrees are even worse: recently withdrew from York because they expected me to pay £10,000 so a lecturer could paraphase a text book for 10s. The UK is so behind in education it’s unreal.

CoffeeCantata · 19/10/2023 15:47

Also - I remember when working in a very pressured teaching job we were informed that, instead of our weekly mid-week staff meeting, the Head had booked us all to attend a special presentation by some kind of inspirational speaker 35 miles up a busy motorway at rush-hour. It was a vile wet and windy evening - I will never forget how angry I felt!

We got there to find a huge hall full of teachers, and the speaker started his performance with a demonstration of his juggling skills. And it went on like that. He was a cross between a children's entertainer and an evangelical American preacher. I was expecting to take notes but came away with practically nothing to show for this utter waste of time, money and energy.

Surely any intelligent person feels insulted and patronised by this kind of approach? I cannot for the life of me remember anything he said or even the theme or point of his presentation.

CoffeeCantata · 19/10/2023 15:39

HappyMarriage · Yesterday 12:20

Ugh I hate this kind of thing where the majority of the ‘content’ from the expert is just them asking the class to share their thoughts/ideas/experiences. No I don’t want to hear a bunch of random people share their thoughts I want to hear what you the so called experienced expert has to say about this topic which is why I’ve signed up to this training in the first place

Totally agree. Gosh, this thread has depressed me - I'm a retired teacher and definitely Team Traditional Lecture. I would be bored out of my mind by 'games' group activities, role play and writing rubbish on post-it notes.

It's all rooted in the Post-modern de-bunking of authority/expert figures, including authors and academics. We are all supposed to be 'experts' now. Yawn.

It's pervaded museum culture too (I worked in museum education for many years). I visited a well-loved museum after a huge renovation project to find the informative labels in the art galleries replaced by 'reactions and comments from the public'. Things like 'I like this painting because it reminds me of my Gran's house. She always cooks a cake for us and it all looks so cosy' (genuine label!). Like HappyMarriage, I'm afraid I have zero interest in the thoughts of random visitors - I can do that bit for myself, thanks. I want to know about the history and context of the painting from someone who's made a life study of the subject. I find the new approach utterly alienating and alarming in its devaluing of the expert.

Perhaps university education isn't for everyone??? Isn't this the real answer, as many people have been saying since Blair's reforms. It's a special kind of intellectual challenge and used to put the emphasis on Socratic discussion and a lot of personal research/reading etc, and the ability to think and construct arguments effectively.

Sure, there are subjects/vocations which need a different approach but what on earth is happening to standards if this kind of dumbing down is going on in universities??

CasperGutman · 19/10/2023 14:37

I'm doing a postgraduate course at the moment, not in health but something more like law. On our course we have lectures, which are recorded so we can consume them in our own time during the week, and live in-person sessions which are more interactive. Some of the other students refer to these as "lectures", but I would call them "classes" or something like that (others might say "tutorials" but my own background leads me to think of a tutorial as involving no more than a small handful of students, and these involve about a dozen to a dozen-and-a-half).

So, I think the sessions you have an issue with have a place but agree they're not really "lectures", which would by definition involve less doing and more listening.

LolaSmiles · 19/10/2023 14:33

This sounds like the sort of thing that was ever so fashionable in UK secondary schools a decade ago.

We've since moved away from that because the evidence generally says it's not effective teaching.

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 14:31

SaffronSpice · 19/10/2023 14:11

A large chunk of the change in expectations of universities occurred when polytechnics became universities. Prior to that Universities were about research and ‘pure’ subjects. They were not expected to be applied, the research was that fundamental sort to establish principles underlining the subject. Polytechnics, on the other hand, trained for specific industries. Their courses were designed to meet industry demand, for technicians (in the broad sense), health services etc and what little research there was was applied.

Yep, that was the start of the demise, then came Blair's 50% and tuition fees! Enough said!

SerafinasGoose · 19/10/2023 14:24

Desecratedcoconut · 19/10/2023 14:12

Has anyone else noticed that the phrase 'reading' a particular degree subject has mostly disappeared

Tbf, I remember I lecturer having a rant about this in 1997.

😂

The year tuition fees came in. I suspect that's not a coincidence.

SawX · 19/10/2023 14:18

I'm doing my second master's and very glad they're still doing actual lectures. What I don't get from lecturers I get from reading papers and books by other experts, not fellow students.

Desecratedcoconut · 19/10/2023 14:12

Has anyone else noticed that the phrase 'reading' a particular degree subject has mostly disappeared

Tbf, I remember I lecturer having a rant about this in 1997.

SaffronSpice · 19/10/2023 14:11

SerafinasGoose · 19/10/2023 13:58

Has anyone else noticed that the phrase 'reading' a particular degree subject has mostly disappeared. Ie 'I'm reading literature' has become 'I'm studying literature'. That tells us everything we need to know, I think, and suggests universities have moved away from the function they were originally conceived to fulfil. The clue was in the title 'Academia'.

Work in the Humanities at degree level (less so physical sciences which have always had more contact time) has always been mostly independent. But lecturing staff are now having to justify every minute of contact time because students are paying handsomely for it.

In doing so we've moved further and further from what actual undergraduate study should deliver.

On my own syllabuses, gods forbid (according to my department) I overload them with subject-specific context (which as a PP above points out, they won't bother to read). Half my energy goes into study skills workshops that a robot could stand up there and teach. It's hardly taxing stuff. But this is what they demand (otherwise known as spoon-feeding). As a student, I got 12 weeks of content-heavy material and I far preferred this. All the other stuff was extraneous. I had to find out how to conduct research, find library materials, use referencing systems and polish up my writing and stucturing skills all by myself. It was simply assumed students would do this. And I valued this a lot more.

One small thing I can do is to ensure the contexts I teach are robustly challenging. And a lot of the students do appreciate it. They are smart young people who are capable of critical thinking and some still want (and deserve) to be pushed in their learning. But we're expected to employ differentiation, just as is any school teacher.

University teaching has changed beyond recognition. A lot more is demanded now, and we are still expected to be world class researchers. Something's got to give.

Edited

A large chunk of the change in expectations of universities occurred when polytechnics became universities. Prior to that Universities were about research and ‘pure’ subjects. They were not expected to be applied, the research was that fundamental sort to establish principles underlining the subject. Polytechnics, on the other hand, trained for specific industries. Their courses were designed to meet industry demand, for technicians (in the broad sense), health services etc and what little research there was was applied.

OrlandointheWilderness · 19/10/2023 14:05

Ah@Toddlerteaplease unfortunately I'll be an adult nurse... 😂

OrlandointheWilderness · 19/10/2023 14:05

Actually I'm being harsh about my uni there. They try really hard to give us a good mix - some of the content is very heavy. We tend to do seminars and lectures, the lectures are fairly content heavy but involve a lot of discussion which can be very useful.

Toddlerteaplease · 19/10/2023 14:05

OrlandointheWilderness · 19/10/2023 14:00

Sounds awfully like my nursing degree...! 😂
We spent an afternoon the other week constructing a swing for a golf ball in teams. We're 3rd years. We all feel like this it time we really could spend better with so much to do.

I mean it might come handy in paediatrics, although in 20 years I haven't needed that particular skill. I can't see how it's relevant to nursing!

OrlandointheWilderness · 19/10/2023 14:01

Toddlerteaplease · 17/10/2023 23:00

Please tell me that it's not Leadership and innovation in Nursing. I'm starting it it march and dreading it. As I have absolutely no interest in it whatsoever!

Ohhh that's the modules we are on! Actually leadership hasn't been too bad, but yes the golf ball swing was one of those sessions 😂.

OrlandointheWilderness · 19/10/2023 14:00

Sounds awfully like my nursing degree...! 😂
We spent an afternoon the other week constructing a swing for a golf ball in teams. We're 3rd years. We all feel like this it time we really could spend better with so much to do.

SerafinasGoose · 19/10/2023 13:58

Has anyone else noticed that the phrase 'reading' a particular degree subject has mostly disappeared. Ie 'I'm reading literature' has become 'I'm studying literature'. That tells us everything we need to know, I think, and suggests universities have moved away from the function they were originally conceived to fulfil. The clue was in the title 'Academia'.

Work in the Humanities at degree level (less so physical sciences which have always had more contact time) has always been mostly independent. But lecturing staff are now having to justify every minute of contact time because students are paying handsomely for it.

In doing so we've moved further and further from what actual undergraduate study should deliver.

On my own syllabuses, gods forbid (according to my department) I overload them with subject-specific context (which as a PP above points out, they won't bother to read). Half my energy goes into study skills workshops that a robot could stand up there and teach. It's hardly taxing stuff. But this is what they demand (otherwise known as spoon-feeding). As a student, I got 12 weeks of content-heavy material and I far preferred this. All the other stuff was extraneous. I had to find out how to conduct research, find library materials, use referencing systems and polish up my writing and stucturing skills all by myself. It was simply assumed students would do this. And I valued this a lot more.

One small thing I can do is to ensure the contexts I teach are robustly challenging. And a lot of the students do appreciate it. They are smart young people who are capable of critical thinking and some still want (and deserve) to be pushed in their learning. But we're expected to employ differentiation, just as is any school teacher.

University teaching has changed beyond recognition. A lot more is demanded now, and we are still expected to be world class researchers. Something's got to give.

WhatPostDoc · 19/10/2023 13:54

Its the way we're expected to teach now. It's actually what most students want. They want less content, more consolidation, and unis are so student survey driven they do it. They want interactivity - mid lecture check ins, questions in groups, worked examples.

It's also to do with the change in assessment formats after covid. Now many places are favouring the longer open exams, so students have access to their notes, internet and AI. You can't ask factual recall questions anymore to assess learning. Its all application based - which is what those interactive activities are geared towards. Its bloody hard to ask questions they can't just ask AI to solve for them.

Superscientist · 19/10/2023 13:47

On my degree which I admit is a few years ago we had 1h lectures with 50m of prof talking and 10m for questions and switch over
Workshops in groups of 30 which were 2h and what you described would fall into this category.
Tutorials groups of 4-5 and 1h. We had work to do in advance for this

SerafinasGoose · 19/10/2023 13:43

user1846385927482658 · 19/10/2023 13:15

We are not employment training factories

Maybe they should be if the reason the majority of students attend is as a career gateway.

That's not what a degree does. There are postgradate training schemes and courses for precisely that reason. As to the employability model currently being embedded across the Humanities (universities all across the sector, inlcuding some Russell Group) - students usually detest project modules designed to enhance employability elements. They will say: 'but I wanted to do a degree in literature/history/film!' And that's where the compromises come in. Square pegs, round holes: literature somehow being 'bent' to fit a corporate context and vice versa. The expectation that they'll produce some work (usually a half-patched together blog) for an external partner. Students can see those compromises for exactly what they are.

English students are already eminently employable. The Humanties teach us something about the human condition, hence the name. They are taught independent thinking and to be autonomous workers and learners; they are taught sharp critical thinking skills and learn to be thorough and analytical. They're also drilled in the rudiments of good research and writing. They're already suited for all kinds of occupations: teaching, the cultural and creative industries, publishing and printing, museum curatorship, archival work, and, more generally, public-facing roles.

This is what happens when you tell a generation of young people the humanities are worthless and STEM are the only subjects worth studying.

As to the post-92 sector, these institutions are already well on their way back to the original tech-college model. My anticipation is the humanities will all-but die out at places like this, unless they can be dressed up as an integral part of media, digital or AI/tech degrees. If the Tories stay in power this is all but a given; if they don't, it's probably inevitable anyway.

It's very sad to see academia as we knew it distilled in this way. When Blair brought in the tuition fees it was obvious this was going nowhere good, but even I couldn't have ancitipated the degree and extent to which the whole system would disintegrate, and I certainly never suspected degrees like English would be the areas to suffer. Sociology, Gender Studies etc., yes, but not English and History. Weirdly enough Media Studies/Gender Studies were the degrees non-grata 20 years or so ago; now that's shifted to all Humanities subjects (which is where Labour tried to direct the bums onto seats in their drive to increase the numbers going through university). Widening participation turns into mass participation when students are attending university when there's no discernible benefit to them. There have been a lot of these.

Desecratedcoconut · 19/10/2023 13:31

The very best thing about uni was sitting in a lecture hall and being led through a body of work at breakneck speed and watching all the threads of the required reading being pulled together with the skill of somebody who knows more than they teach.

Posters? 🤮

user1846385927482658 · 19/10/2023 13:18

IcedPurple · 19/10/2023 10:58

Bit of goal post shifting going on!

Lots of films and TV programmes have pretty complex plots requiring focussed attention. Yet millions of people manage to sit through 2 hour films quite easily without the need for poster making breaks.

That's a straw man argument. There are more ways to refocus attention than "poster making breaks" anyway.

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 13:17

SaffronSpice · 19/10/2023 13:02

So you are saying because someone doing joint honours does less of one subject there is no need for those doing single honours to do so much if that subject either?

Depends on what it is, obviously. But it does seem as if some single degrees do unnecessary stuff just to pad out the year. In my Physics example, if the first years' lab experiments were essential to the degree and for years 2 & 3, then they'd have to be done by the joint subject students too!

I just believe that the "one size fits all" fixed term 3 year degrees isn't necessary and that some courses could be condensed into 2 years, subject to the course. By the same token, I can't help thinking that some of the more intense subjects may benefit from being longer.

Just think how much money would be saved by having an accelerated 2 year course where possible. Students only borrowing 2 years of tuition fees and student accommodation for a start. Students into the workplace sooner, thus earning money and paying taxes etc.

I just think things need to be more flexible when possible and where not detrimental.

user1846385927482658 · 19/10/2023 13:15

We are not employment training factories

Maybe they should be if the reason the majority of students attend is as a career gateway.

SaffronSpice · 19/10/2023 13:02

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 11:40

To be blunt, I think the vast majority of Uni courses are padded out and could be done in two years. Obviously not the ones that require a lot of technical, lab work, etc., or medical degrees with extensive work placements etc.

When we went around open days, we went on a tour of the Physics labs and the guy taking us around, who was a lecturer, explained that those doing a full Physics degree would have a couple of modules in year 1 which were lab based doing practicals, which they'd set out in the lab we were shown - they appeared to be mostly the practicals that DS had already done for his A level physics. The lecturer then said that those doing split degrees (i.e. Physics with Maths etc) wouldn't have the practical modules as they'd be doing their other subject modules instead so wouldn't set foot in the labs in the first year. So, basically, they weren't actually necessary! Probably one of those "nice to have, but not essential" kinds of thing. Sounded more like it was just a matter of "padding" in the first year. Not disputing they'd probably have been useful for students to do (in most cases, again), but clearly not essential.

I think a lot of the first year is like that really, in the name of getting all students up to the same standard to move into year 2. Surely there are better ways, especially for those who've done things before and don't need to go over the same material a second time.

A bit like, say, economics, where someone who's done A level economics could probably go straight into year 2 at Uni as year 1 seems to be mostly very similar to A level content, because it's one of those subjects that doesn't require prior knowledge!

After all, for most courses, the marks in year 1 don't count towards the final degree classification, you just need to "pass" the modules and exams, so for many, won't have really been of any use.

So you are saying because someone doing joint honours does less of one subject there is no need for those doing single honours to do so much if that subject either?

user1497207191 · 19/10/2023 11:40

CornishClott · 19/10/2023 11:12

I did an art course many years ago and looking back the course had been padded out . It could have been condensed down to two years .

To be blunt, I think the vast majority of Uni courses are padded out and could be done in two years. Obviously not the ones that require a lot of technical, lab work, etc., or medical degrees with extensive work placements etc.

When we went around open days, we went on a tour of the Physics labs and the guy taking us around, who was a lecturer, explained that those doing a full Physics degree would have a couple of modules in year 1 which were lab based doing practicals, which they'd set out in the lab we were shown - they appeared to be mostly the practicals that DS had already done for his A level physics. The lecturer then said that those doing split degrees (i.e. Physics with Maths etc) wouldn't have the practical modules as they'd be doing their other subject modules instead so wouldn't set foot in the labs in the first year. So, basically, they weren't actually necessary! Probably one of those "nice to have, but not essential" kinds of thing. Sounded more like it was just a matter of "padding" in the first year. Not disputing they'd probably have been useful for students to do (in most cases, again), but clearly not essential.

I think a lot of the first year is like that really, in the name of getting all students up to the same standard to move into year 2. Surely there are better ways, especially for those who've done things before and don't need to go over the same material a second time.

A bit like, say, economics, where someone who's done A level economics could probably go straight into year 2 at Uni as year 1 seems to be mostly very similar to A level content, because it's one of those subjects that doesn't require prior knowledge!

After all, for most courses, the marks in year 1 don't count towards the final degree classification, you just need to "pass" the modules and exams, so for many, won't have really been of any use.