Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my university lectures were... well, lectures

267 replies

reallyyyy · 17/10/2023 22:18

I started a new course a few weeks ago, it's my second degree and it's a healthcare degree so that might be why. But our lectures are so interactive and filled with so many activities that feel like a waste of time. I had a 2 hour lecture today and 40 minutes of it was spent making posters of different topics to put on the board at the front, with the vision that we would be learning from each other. Only, we couldn't read the posters as they were too small and far away and it didn't teach us anything. There are also lots of 'discuss in pairs X, Y and Z' and it's not helpful or useful. It was nice in the first week as a bit of an icebreaker but now it just feels annoying.

I'm finding it frustrating sitting in a 2 hour lecture and being taught 1 hour of content. I'm not sure if it's because I studied a different degree before but lectures were 2 hours of information and I learnt a lot from them.

We have seminars too so it's not like I'm not enjoying the interaction, just not in a lecture.

I know IABU but I think I'm just overly tired from getting up at 5:30am to commute in for a lecture just to spend half the time making posters or colouring in diagrams.

OP posts:
cardibach · 23/10/2023 13:19

mugboat · 23/10/2023 12:00

No, lecturers have changed because this style of lecture has proven to be inefficient.

The changes are based in academic research into pedagogy. You do chalk and talk teaching and most of your class won't follow. Esp if you are literally standing talking at people.

No. Even in schools the research now says that ‘chalk and talk’ with regular testing is more efficient than group work etc. And even at undergrad level we are talking about adults who are interested in the subject being taught, so I imagine it goes even more so for them.

mugboat · 23/10/2023 12:04

cardibach · 23/10/2023 11:17

Reading off a PowerPoint isn’t a lecture. It’s just bad teaching. That’s not what a proper lecture is - but lecturers upthread have said they’ve been told to put everything on the slides because of students who don’t want to do the work themselves. Listen. Make note of key points. Go away and read, draw, discuss. Whatever works.

Edited

I agree it's bad teaching and yet many lecturers still do it... this is why they are given guidance about teaching.

Lecturing and public speaking is a skill and it's one that academics do not necessarily have.

mugboat · 23/10/2023 12:02

SaffronSpice · 23/10/2023 11:26

I could equally argue that group discussions, posters, presentations etc. are a starting point to read around the published literature.

Where is the role for expertise in this? Why must the wheel always be reinvented?

because we are learning and improving all the time in all areas...
and it's not reinventing the wheel... it's building and improving upon what we already know

mugboat · 23/10/2023 12:00

cardibach · 22/10/2023 20:05

But the lecture is supposed to be the first step, point in gout the main areas and summarising things a bit! You are supposed to learn by talking that and reading a round it, discussing it in seminars and tutorials (and in the bar) and when you plan and write your essays.
If you use notes and abbreviations it’s not at all impossible to keep up with the headlines.
Have lecturers been forced to change because so many undergraduates don’t understand what their part in learning is supposed to be?

No, lecturers have changed because this style of lecture has proven to be inefficient.

The changes are based in academic research into pedagogy. You do chalk and talk teaching and most of your class won't follow. Esp if you are literally standing talking at people.

Sickofatrocity · 23/10/2023 11:46

I also went back and did an online degree 25 years after my first, and it was like that, too. I think it is to cater or Gen Z's apparent need to be engaged all of the time in the content.

SaffronSpice · 23/10/2023 11:26

I could equally argue that group discussions, posters, presentations etc. are a starting point to read around the published literature.

Where is the role for expertise in this? Why must the wheel always be reinvented?

borntobequiet · 23/10/2023 11:23

The course I teach has a one-hour lecture of the traditional type followed by a two-hour seminar with follow on activities. It’s surprising how little of the lecture content sticks, so the seminar time is valuable.

cardibach · 23/10/2023 11:17

Umph · 23/10/2023 10:46

I’m fairly intelligent (high IQ, good grades, can bash out an essay on a subject I know nothing about and still achieve a 1st etc.) however, I have slow auditory processing, am easily distracted, and find being ‘talked at’ frustrating and miserable. Lecture notes do not further my understanding.

I could equally argue that group discussions, posters, presentations etc. are a starting point to read around the published literature. I don’t really understand why you think that lectures are the only way that this is possible.

To me, watching someone read off a PowerPoint for two hours is a pointless exercise. I could have been in bed doing that myself!

Reading off a PowerPoint isn’t a lecture. It’s just bad teaching. That’s not what a proper lecture is - but lecturers upthread have said they’ve been told to put everything on the slides because of students who don’t want to do the work themselves. Listen. Make note of key points. Go away and read, draw, discuss. Whatever works.

cardibach · 23/10/2023 11:15

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 23/10/2023 05:53

Do you really not understand? Or is it just that you learn differently?

I’m a teacher, so I fully understand people prefer different activities to learn. I also know that ‘learning styles’ as absolutes is nonsense - the research doesn’t say what you think it does. What I’m saying is, nobody retains enough information (ie ‘learns’) from a lecture - sure, some people will remember more than others but everyone needs to do the independent work themselves. Do the posters if that helps. Read more. Make more notes. Discuss with others. The lecture is a starting point. It always has been. Degree level study is independent. So I don’t understand someone who expects a lecture to teach them everything. Genuinely. I don’t get how you would go to university and expect everything to be handed to you via lectures (or seminars or tutorials). These all contribute. But you have to do the extra work yourself.

Umph · 23/10/2023 10:46

cardibach · 22/10/2023 19:59

I don’t understand…you listen and make notes. Then you read them back and read around the published literature. You do some revision work to aid retention. You aren’t supposed to know it all after one lecture.

I’m fairly intelligent (high IQ, good grades, can bash out an essay on a subject I know nothing about and still achieve a 1st etc.) however, I have slow auditory processing, am easily distracted, and find being ‘talked at’ frustrating and miserable. Lecture notes do not further my understanding.

I could equally argue that group discussions, posters, presentations etc. are a starting point to read around the published literature. I don’t really understand why you think that lectures are the only way that this is possible.

To me, watching someone read off a PowerPoint for two hours is a pointless exercise. I could have been in bed doing that myself!

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 23/10/2023 05:53

cardibach · 22/10/2023 19:59

I don’t understand…you listen and make notes. Then you read them back and read around the published literature. You do some revision work to aid retention. You aren’t supposed to know it all after one lecture.

Do you really not understand? Or is it just that you learn differently?

Oakbeam · 22/10/2023 21:13

Did a humanities PhD in the late 1990s, I assure you we were all presenting off papers we had written

You still present papers you have written. Your poster complements your paper and is there displayed when you aren’t. Generating interest. Hopefully.

XenoBitch · 22/10/2023 21:05

Years ago, I tried and failed uni. I did not understand the lecture format at all. You just get talked at, and then how to go off and do what?

Later on, I went back to uni for a healthcare course. The units are set out by the professional body, and most lectures were interactive, or had points you did group work. I found this so much easier to get to grips with.

But then, I failed that too. I can't do independent learning at all, and even the times we had to go off during a lecture and make a poster or whatever... my mind just has a block and I can't do it.

Ramalangadingdong · 22/10/2023 20:51

cardibach · 22/10/2023 20:39

Lectures are not spoon feeding for goodness sake! They are more a signpost to what reading and discussion to do afterwards. The people really excited by learning are the ones who want to do this.

I agree with you, but I also think that there are so many different approaches to teaching and interactive lectures are a way of trying to keep things fresh. I stand by the idea of trusting the teachers’ expertise however - unless op detects incompetence or inexperience that is having a negative impact on the classes in which case op should go through the proper channels to get this sorted.

cardibach · 22/10/2023 20:39

Ramalangadingdong · 21/10/2023 02:52

There seems to be one in every class: that student who thinks they know better than the tutor how to teach the class. They usually want to be spoon fed information because they are not that excited by learning per se and just see education as a means to an end (getting a job) when it can be very rewarding. In its own right.

Lectures are not spoon feeding for goodness sake! They are more a signpost to what reading and discussion to do afterwards. The people really excited by learning are the ones who want to do this.

cardibach · 22/10/2023 20:37

Ramalangadingdong · 21/10/2023 02:40

Perhaps you want the lecturers to do all the work for you? Listening to a lecture is passive learning. You retain more information through active learning. Trust your teacher’s knowledge and experience.

You are supposed to go away and do more active learning independently to add to what the expert has told you. They’ve used the lecture to guide you as to the main areas of interest/relevance so you can learn efficiently by reading appropriately afterwards.

SaffronSpice · 22/10/2023 20:21

AI is potentially a real issue for universities. I know one lecturer who talks of having to return to traditional exams - something they had been moving away from.

VisaWoes · 22/10/2023 20:17

Unless you have a dynamic lecturer, they will stand and talk at you for 1-2 hours and you need to try to keep up with them and take notes. No normal undergraduate can write as fast as a person talks.

you can use AI to take notes in lectures for you now! 😆. I saw some tiktok videos on it the other day.

VisaWoes · 22/10/2023 20:16

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 22/10/2023 19:18

I’m doing my nursing degree through the OU and they do a thing called enquiry based learning where the tutor doesn’t actually teach you anything but you are given a case study to go and research a set question through articles etc and present your findings, I really don’t like it

My second degree (also healthcare) was entirely PRoblem based learning. Not a single lecture or seminar in three years! 🙈😂

cardibach · 22/10/2023 20:12

fishfingersandtoes · 18/10/2023 16:22

I had the opposite experience. Did a masters and was really impressed with the flipped classroom model that the lecturers used. It meant that after doing two really quite difficult and long readings, I could compare my understanding and interpretations to that of others in the class and test it out in class discussions with the lecturer, who was an expert in both the subject and guiding the discussion. I'd have been fine with taking notes in a lecture too (like my undergraduate days) but this was far far better for me.
IMO learning is a social activity. Why bother to come to the classroom if all you are doing is listening? You could just watch the recording or do the readings on your own.

In my degree we did both. Traditional lectures and then seminars and tutorials where we discussed both the knowledge from lectures and from wider reading advised in them.

cardibach · 22/10/2023 20:05

mugboat · 18/10/2023 08:03

When I was an undergraduate 1999-2002 ALL of my lectures were delivered in this didactic fashion. I learnt practically nothing in them.

Unless you have a dynamic lecturer, they will stand and talk at you for 1-2 hours and you need to try to keep up with them and take notes. No normal undergraduate can write as fast as a person talks.

When you spend 1-2 hours trying to write what someone is saying, you're essentially focusing on transcription rather than actually learning anything.

Just because you write something down, doesn't mean you will remember it later let alone understand it.

Lectures like this are very frustrating... and I'd argue, lazy teaching.

But the lecture is supposed to be the first step, point in gout the main areas and summarising things a bit! You are supposed to learn by talking that and reading a round it, discussing it in seminars and tutorials (and in the bar) and when you plan and write your essays.
If you use notes and abbreviations it’s not at all impossible to keep up with the headlines.
Have lecturers been forced to change because so many undergraduates don’t understand what their part in learning is supposed to be?

cardibach · 22/10/2023 19:59

Umph · 18/10/2023 07:12

I don’t learn from lectures. I can’t retain the information. Not everyone has the same learning style.

I don’t understand…you listen and make notes. Then you read them back and read around the published literature. You do some revision work to aid retention. You aren’t supposed to know it all after one lecture.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 22/10/2023 19:18

I’m doing my nursing degree through the OU and they do a thing called enquiry based learning where the tutor doesn’t actually teach you anything but you are given a case study to go and research a set question through articles etc and present your findings, I really don’t like it

VisaWoes · 22/10/2023 19:09

My first degree we could still hand write essays. My housemates in my first year went halves on an electronic typewriter which was very fancy. Then in Year 2 I bought an ancient secondhand 386 PC for about £300 which was a fortune in the early 90s. I was probably ripped off. It got stolen within a year as well!

SaffronSpice · 22/10/2023 14:31

Saschka · 22/10/2023 13:15

We regularly had to do them in med school (ie undergrad) in the late 90s.

It was a massive pain! Having to send your PowerPoint to the library A0 plotter two weeks in advance. I also remember having to do end-of-project presentations on an OHP, and having to print out your PowerPoint slides onto transparencies and hoping you didn’t feed them in wrong and melt them into the printer 🤣

PowerPoint?! In my day we had to print them out in pieces on normal A4 paper and back them with card.

I remember having to finish my undergrad project two weeks before deadline to have time to send it to get printed out on the laser printer (you picked up your printing a few days later from a pigeon hole in the computing department) then get soft-bound at the library. I had a picture in mine - a black and white line drawing - which took the printer 15 minutes to think about before printing so people kept thinking the printer had crashed and cancelled my print job.

Then again, my father had to pay a typist to type up his handwritten PhD on a manual typewriter,,.

Swipe left for the next trending thread