Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers should wear body cams

296 replies

Ffs555 · 17/10/2023 21:19

Rail staff are wearing them, Wetherspoons staff had them on when I went in, it's becoming more common luckily.
I know it isn't a foolproof solution but I think it would stop so many behavioural incidents.
There are signs up in many public facing workplaces saying abuse won't be tolerated, yet it seems teachers/support staff are expected to put up with it 'because they're just kids'.
I used to be a teacher, was threatened by a pupil, he got half a day in internal exclusion and that was it. I had a year 11 pupil make death threats about another teacher in front of me.
I've had another year 11 male pupil walk up to me and grab the mouse out of my hand when I was on the pc.
However have got off lightly compared to many teachers. Still, we're sworn at constantly and verbally abused.
I have left teaching unfortunately due to the behaviour, my new role is much less stressful.
You practically have to bring a weapon into a school to get permanently excluded, schools don't like to permanently exclude due to costs and reputation.
We used to have a very difficult pupil who brought in a fake weapon one day. The headteacher himself said unfortunately it wasn't a real one, otherwise we could have excluded him permanently.
Anyway, I don't know what the solution is, all this restorative conversation stuff doesn't work. Kids don't care about a detention or even a day's exclusion in a lot of cases.

OP posts:
Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 20:34

@Lavender14

The goal of the general public, if anyone bothered to educate them about this, would not be to 'identify the root of the behaviour'. It would be to prioritize the safety of the other children and teachers, by exclusion wherever needed.

Abbimae · 18/10/2023 20:32

As a teacher I would love this. You don’t believe little Johnny is a knob head, watch and see.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 20:31

@ThrallsWife

Exposing the violence to the public consistently would work. It's something you'd expect a union to do, but they're not doing it. And apparently no one in teaching is standing up to whoever it is that's enforcing the nicey nice discipline policies.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 20:28

RMNofTikTok · 18/10/2023 20:19

@Pollyputhekettleon

Someone claimed earlier that all key stage 2 children are spitting on staff and calling them paedos and slags earlier 😂 are you telling me you believe that?

If it's not alleged that teachers are not being attacked en mass, then why are so many crying for BWC after reading the thread?

I worked in a school on an estate that had council cctv and the buses had been rerouted due to the danger. There were not daily attacks on staff.

Absolutely nobody claimed 'that all key stage 2 children are spitting on staff and calling them paedos and slags'. I don't even need to to find me the quote to know that's, to put it politely, false. Why are you persistently saying things that you know are not true?

Also, again, why do you keep talking about your personal experience as if it's evidence that everyone else is lying?

Lavender14 · 18/10/2023 20:27

I work in an alternative education setting with very high risk young people. We don't have cctv and I'd never wear a body cam. I have been threatened with a knife on one occasion so I know what it feels like to deal with weapons in our setting.

Ultimately schools need better resourcing. Teachers need better training and more support in and outside of the classroom and schools need more resources for pupils with educational needs, sen and otherwise.

The vast majority of young people I work with have been put out of schools for asb due to significant trauma. The vast majority don't have any incidents of aggressive behaviour in our setting because our approach is very different, the setting itself is very different and groups are never more than 18 in a class. In fact I can only think of 2 incidents in the last 8 years.

Being completely honest, I think a lot of times it's easy to blame the pupil but oftentimes, the other adults in the room could have deescalated quicker/ more appropriately/ recognised behaviours faster etc. But without appropriate training they won't know that at the time. Teachers are often so overworked etc that they don't have the time nor the threshold to provide that support so more children are now falling out of mainstream education and more teachers are choosing to leave. I have a lot of support for myself in my job, that helps me sustain high threshold working.

It's not good enough and at the crux of it there are children who deserve an education who are being failed by the education system. Cctv won't fix a thing, it'll just make it easier to blame the pupil and have them expelled/ suspended which doesn't help identify the root of the behaviour. The majority of pupils lashing out in this way are to an extent vulnerable. The only thing that will help is better targeted support in schools. I also offer this to mainstream education and it always amazes me how few schools actually take us up on it considering it's a free service. In fact I've been really disgusted at the attitudes I get from teachers when I've done training with them around dv and other important topics.

ThrallsWife · 18/10/2023 20:23

CCTV has its merits. I used to work in a school with one of the highest numbers of CCTV cameras around many years ago. It helped us find thieves, prove who damaged equipment, find evidence of assaults and I witnessed 2 people's careers being saved by them, because CCTV proved that they had been falsely accused of inappropriate behaviour towards a child.

But times have changed a lot since then. Body cameras would only work in exposing the daily disrespect and indeed violence on a larger scale to an audience, much like it very briefly did for the journalist who'd gone undercover as a supply teacher many years back. The problem is, no one cared for long enough.

Do the parents of the young man who threatened me today to get the fuck out of his way or else care? They didn't the many times he jumped the school fence, used a chair to try and smash in a window or any one of the many detentions he got for other types of antisocial behaviour.

I am broken today by the behaviour I have had to endure over this week. Body cams, however, won't help. Smaller classes, more SLT presence, more money for alternative provision, more mental health support, more in-class support and more actual exclusions allowed would help. We don't need more evidence - we have plenty of that. We need more actual help.

RMNofTikTok · 18/10/2023 20:19

@Pollyputhekettleon

Someone claimed earlier that all key stage 2 children are spitting on staff and calling them paedos and slags earlier 😂 are you telling me you believe that?

If it's not alleged that teachers are not being attacked en mass, then why are so many crying for BWC after reading the thread?

I worked in a school on an estate that had council cctv and the buses had been rerouted due to the danger. There were not daily attacks on staff.

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 20:19

RMNofTikTok · 18/10/2023 20:01

@FrippEnos

The police will readily arrest children when a crime has been committed.

This seems like a cultural issue within schools. The only way to change culture is to take a stand. Teachers cannot teach children whom have bail conditions to stay away from them.

Again, I highly doubt secondary schools on the whole are as bad as are claimed here, given I worked in one in one of the most deprived areas in the country. And this was... 2019 (agency on top of my 30h a week prison contract before anyone questions it!) So very much sounds like folk devil and moral panic. Yes there are fights, but teachers being mass assaulted on a daily basis? Absolutely not.

I have seen teachers being forced to teach the child that have assaulted them the day before and seen teachers forced out because they went to the police.

Teachers cannot teach children whom have bail conditions to stay away from them.
As I haven't seen this I don't know if it would be possible to enforce. but it is different from a pupil being arrested and charged to getting bail.

No one has said that teachers are being assaulted on a daily basis, just that sweet FA is being done about it.

And I have had HTs saying that pupil X shouldn't be left allow with female members of staff because they are known to sexually assault them in their previous school and similar to the whole staff as the pupil is know to be generally violent towards staff members. ,

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 20:15

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 19:56

We apparently have different goals. My goal is that children and teachers should be safe in school. It's not to prevent violence in society. If you shuffle the problem out of schools then there is no more problem for children in schools, which is all I care about. I'm not trying to solve some kind of broader social problem of violence and antisocial behaviour. In a sane society everyone would agree that that's not the role of the education system.

Sorry I missed that they get shuffled to other mainstream schools and become their problem.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 20:03

RMNofTikTok · 18/10/2023 20:01

@FrippEnos

The police will readily arrest children when a crime has been committed.

This seems like a cultural issue within schools. The only way to change culture is to take a stand. Teachers cannot teach children whom have bail conditions to stay away from them.

Again, I highly doubt secondary schools on the whole are as bad as are claimed here, given I worked in one in one of the most deprived areas in the country. And this was... 2019 (agency on top of my 30h a week prison contract before anyone questions it!) So very much sounds like folk devil and moral panic. Yes there are fights, but teachers being mass assaulted on a daily basis? Absolutely not.

Why would your individual personal experience cause you to doubt what I've seen probably dozens of teachers on here say? And, by the way, absolutely no one claimed teachers were 'being mass assaulted on a daily basis'. As of course you're well aware.

RMNofTikTok · 18/10/2023 20:01

@FrippEnos

The police will readily arrest children when a crime has been committed.

This seems like a cultural issue within schools. The only way to change culture is to take a stand. Teachers cannot teach children whom have bail conditions to stay away from them.

Again, I highly doubt secondary schools on the whole are as bad as are claimed here, given I worked in one in one of the most deprived areas in the country. And this was... 2019 (agency on top of my 30h a week prison contract before anyone questions it!) So very much sounds like folk devil and moral panic. Yes there are fights, but teachers being mass assaulted on a daily basis? Absolutely not.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 19:59

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 18/10/2023 19:57

Have you ever tried getting the police involved in a school incident?

My nephew had a knife pulled on him at the school gate and nothing was done until his Mum got a local journalist involved. The police were adamant it was a school issue. School said outside the gates isn’t their problem.

The police will do anything generally to avoid getting involved when under 18's commit crime. Any excuse. I'm sure they feel it's a pointless waste of time unless it's a really serious crime, because it is.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 18/10/2023 19:57

RMNofTikTok · 18/10/2023 19:40

If schools are as violent as people are claiming, why aren't there thousands of arrests every day?

Have you ever tried getting the police involved in a school incident?

My nephew had a knife pulled on him at the school gate and nothing was done until his Mum got a local journalist involved. The police were adamant it was a school issue. School said outside the gates isn’t their problem.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 19:56

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 19:50

But that doesn't stop them from being violent, that just shuffles the problem along.

We apparently have different goals. My goal is that children and teachers should be safe in school. It's not to prevent violence in society. If you shuffle the problem out of schools then there is no more problem for children in schools, which is all I care about. I'm not trying to solve some kind of broader social problem of violence and antisocial behaviour. In a sane society everyone would agree that that's not the role of the education system.

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 19:55

Noname99 · 18/10/2023 18:57

Pollyputhekettleon
blackbird77

Parents are 100% behind schools and teachers dealing with behaviour right up until it’s their child. When it’s their child it’s either “they only did it because they are being bullied” or they suddenly develop up a SEND need and it’s the school’s fault for not meeting need or the teachers fault for not intervening correctly for their specific ‘sensory’ need which means it’s the teachers fault for having the shit kicked out of them or the other child. It’s NEVER EVER their child’s fault. And body cams and cctv would help but as I said in my original post, parents still find an excuse.

To add to this often there are other parents that will back up the pupils parent as they have something against the education system as well.

A friend of mine will tell you how badly bullied he was at school by the teachers, they do this all the time until I remind them of what an absolute horror they were at school.

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 19:52

RMNofTikTok · 18/10/2023 19:40

If schools are as violent as people are claiming, why aren't there thousands of arrests every day?

Because schools don't like to report to the police, the police don't like arresting school children as they see it as the schools problem.
And teachers that go to the police often get no support from the school, end up teaching the pupils that have assaulted them and are forced either out of the profession or at very least out of the school.

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 19:50

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 18:55

You stop them from being violent in school by kicking them out of school of course. I'm pretty sure most posters on those threads could have answered that. Very simple and very effective. Punishing the non-violent students, even unintentionally, in order to allow the violent ones to remain in school, is wrong. Yes it's the school's fault, primarily for refusing to oppose what appears to be disciplinary policies being imposed by Ofsted or the government.

But that doesn't stop them from being violent, that just shuffles the problem along.

RMNofTikTok · 18/10/2023 19:40

If schools are as violent as people are claiming, why aren't there thousands of arrests every day?

MrsHamlet · 18/10/2023 19:07

TeaKitten · 18/10/2023 06:53

I didn’t say it would stop it. I said why can’t a teacher give a detention. It’s a consequence.

We can. We do. Doesn't stop them doing it - whatever it is - again.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 19:02

Noname99 · 18/10/2023 18:57

Pollyputhekettleon
blackbird77

Parents are 100% behind schools and teachers dealing with behaviour right up until it’s their child. When it’s their child it’s either “they only did it because they are being bullied” or they suddenly develop up a SEND need and it’s the school’s fault for not meeting need or the teachers fault for not intervening correctly for their specific ‘sensory’ need which means it’s the teachers fault for having the shit kicked out of them or the other child. It’s NEVER EVER their child’s fault. And body cams and cctv would help but as I said in my original post, parents still find an excuse.

None of that would matter if schools weren't under farcical obligations to avoid excluding children, and those polices aren't coming from parents. They appear to be coming from Ofsted and/or the government, with zero opposition from teacher's unions. If that policy were changed then, as happened years ago, the parents could say what they liked but the child would be out and that would be the end of it. In an ideal world of course they could then go to some kind of special school that is capable of educating them, or at least containing them, without risk to any other children or normal teachers.

Noname99 · 18/10/2023 18:57

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 16:05

@blackbird77

Yes I think if teachers and head teachers stood together they could stop this. Oftsed only have power because they're allowed to. I absolutely agree the majority of the public would be on the teacher's side if they were aware of what's been happening. They have no idea. The unions give the impression that it's all about pay and maybe working hours.

Hopefully you're right and that it will soon become an unavoidable issue for governments. But I do think that only action by teachers themselves can turn it around. Their unions are supposed to serve them, not their own ideological agenda.

Pollyputhekettleon
blackbird77

Parents are 100% behind schools and teachers dealing with behaviour right up until it’s their child. When it’s their child it’s either “they only did it because they are being bullied” or they suddenly develop up a SEND need and it’s the school’s fault for not meeting need or the teachers fault for not intervening correctly for their specific ‘sensory’ need which means it’s the teachers fault for having the shit kicked out of them or the other child. It’s NEVER EVER their child’s fault. And body cams and cctv would help but as I said in my original post, parents still find an excuse.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 18:55

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 18:48

@Pollyputhekettleon

On a recent thread (two really) about toilets being locked in schools.
There were some hardcore posters that kept blaming the schools. At no point did they cover how to stop the pupils from destroying the toilets, it was the schools fault for not controlling the kids and the schools fault for punishing the rest.

This is exactly the same thing.
How do you stop those pupils from being violent?

You stop them from being violent in school by kicking them out of school of course. I'm pretty sure most posters on those threads could have answered that. Very simple and very effective. Punishing the non-violent students, even unintentionally, in order to allow the violent ones to remain in school, is wrong. Yes it's the school's fault, primarily for refusing to oppose what appears to be disciplinary policies being imposed by Ofsted or the government.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 18:52

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 18:39

Your questions are part of the problem.

Surely you should be asking were the boys arrested and are the police going to charge them with assault?

That would be a strange thing to ask! From everything I've read schools pretty much never report such assaults to police. It would be futile anyway because the criminal justice system operates according to the same ideology as the education system.

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 18:50

Just a quick thought on this.

How long do posters think it would be before the usual suspects started to say 'you are filming me so I am going to film you' and acting upon it with the usual crowd on here saying that its only fair as their kids are being filmed?

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 18:48

@Pollyputhekettleon

On a recent thread (two really) about toilets being locked in schools.
There were some hardcore posters that kept blaming the schools. At no point did they cover how to stop the pupils from destroying the toilets, it was the schools fault for not controlling the kids and the schools fault for punishing the rest.

This is exactly the same thing.
How do you stop those pupils from being violent?

Swipe left for the next trending thread