Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers should wear body cams

296 replies

Ffs555 · 17/10/2023 21:19

Rail staff are wearing them, Wetherspoons staff had them on when I went in, it's becoming more common luckily.
I know it isn't a foolproof solution but I think it would stop so many behavioural incidents.
There are signs up in many public facing workplaces saying abuse won't be tolerated, yet it seems teachers/support staff are expected to put up with it 'because they're just kids'.
I used to be a teacher, was threatened by a pupil, he got half a day in internal exclusion and that was it. I had a year 11 pupil make death threats about another teacher in front of me.
I've had another year 11 male pupil walk up to me and grab the mouse out of my hand when I was on the pc.
However have got off lightly compared to many teachers. Still, we're sworn at constantly and verbally abused.
I have left teaching unfortunately due to the behaviour, my new role is much less stressful.
You practically have to bring a weapon into a school to get permanently excluded, schools don't like to permanently exclude due to costs and reputation.
We used to have a very difficult pupil who brought in a fake weapon one day. The headteacher himself said unfortunately it wasn't a real one, otherwise we could have excluded him permanently.
Anyway, I don't know what the solution is, all this restorative conversation stuff doesn't work. Kids don't care about a detention or even a day's exclusion in a lot of cases.

OP posts:
RubyRubyRubyRubay · 18/10/2023 22:52

Children behaving in a disturbing manner should be flagged up and tracked onto some professional intervention - long term, possibly throughout secondary.
This isn't an intervention that should be carried out by, or funded by, individual schools. It need a government funded, properly trained child psychotherapy response in every major town to break the chain and stop this.

I often work alongside a very poorly funded, understaffed, education intervention scheme. The 15 year olds coming through have been in lockdown from 11-13, and it shows. The one's coming through to 15 now are much worse in ability to engage than any teens I've worked with in 15 years. They have horrific communication skills (many non verbal / won't even say their name as a PP said), no motivation, no discipline. I believe that this particular lot lost any guidance that they might have had during the first two years at secondary due to lockdown and as it has made the behavioural problem a whole lot worse in recent years.

They shouldn't be in school as they are nowhere near 'ready to learn'. It is pointless them being there. They need professional help in a different setting to address whatever is creating this behaviour and sort it out. I also believe a very positive, adult male influence on many of these young people is severely lacking and needs to be put in place. They may have dads around but they aren't good role models. The chain needs to be broken.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/10/2023 22:10

@Lavender14 are you a teacher and if so, when did you last work in mainstream under the pressures teachers are currently experiencing?

Sherrystrull · 18/10/2023 22:07

MrsHamlet · 18/10/2023 21:54

I don't see schools doing that in the same way where they could be and that is a problem.

I have classes of 32. There is simply no time to get to the root of Bob's problem whilst also trying to teach the 31 other students in the room.

I am sympathetic up to the point where Bob is fucking up everyone else's opportunities as well as his own.

Absolutely this. The argument that it works in specialist provision is preaching to the converted. Teachers know children with significant needs would be much better off in a specialist provision with a tiny class.

The expectation that a teacher with a class of 32 and a basic classroom with no resources should achieve the same is insulting to say the least.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 22:07

Wishingwell57 · 18/10/2023 22:05

I just feel that the frustration should be directed more at the current system and the government for the lack of funding than at the pupils themselves which is how it comes across at times through this thread.

No, it's not lack of funding in schools. You could throw all the money you like at the problem, and pupils will still be aggressive and violent. (Not all of them, obviously).

The fault is in current attitudes towards child upbringing, which is perpetuated from one generation to the next.

'Gentle' parenting, trying to keep calm in all situations, even when little Johnny is trashing the house. It has a knock on effect at school.

God yes I've seen this gentle parenting thing in practice and the results are horrible at the margins (obviously many children will turn out fine regardless). Although I suspect parental social media addition is feeding into it as well.

Lavender14 · 18/10/2023 22:05

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/10/2023 21:56

@Lavender14 yes, you and your colleagues are doing an amazing jobs and mainstream teachers are rude, uncaring failures..
Perhaps this is because they're trying to you know 'teach' and youve got amazing resources like 18 in a class and the ability to offer 2-1 classroom support?

I didn't say that teachers were rude uncaring failures. I said they were burnt out and overworked and under resourced. You're twisting what I did say. We do teach. I work in a team of 2. So when it's 2-1 that is literally all that we can offer and we need to put other things on hold to do it. When there's sickness we don't have the resource to cover it, I run things alone. And again every single one of the young people I work with are extremely high risk. So it's very full on and I do understand the pressure that goes with that. The differences I think is the support I personally receive that isn't available to teachers in mainstream and that's not right.

Your resourcing is the issue not the pupil is my point. And I agree with @Pollyputhekettleon that unions need to do more to promote the requirements and needs of their members and other bodies need to step up to the plate.

I didn't include parents because the children I work with don't have parents who engage with us at all or aren't well enough to be remotely helpful when they do. So essentially they're a moot point in the context of my role.

Wishingwell57 · 18/10/2023 22:05

I just feel that the frustration should be directed more at the current system and the government for the lack of funding than at the pupils themselves which is how it comes across at times through this thread.

No, it's not lack of funding in schools. You could throw all the money you like at the problem, and pupils will still be aggressive and violent. (Not all of them, obviously).

The fault is in current attitudes towards child upbringing, which is perpetuated from one generation to the next.

'Gentle' parenting, trying to keep calm in all situations, even when little Johnny is trashing the house. It has a knock on effect at school.

MrsHamlet · 18/10/2023 22:03

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/10/2023 22:00

I'm not a teacher though am assuming the above, @MrsHamlet (apologies for tag!) Does your school have the staff to provide 2:1 staff to pupils?

Does it hell!!!!!

We have a student who has an EHCP specifying 2:1. 2 days before the end of half term and it's not happened yet.

And before I get shouted down for our failure to meet his needs, the magic TA tree is dead. Deader than a door nail.

StarDolphins · 18/10/2023 22:01

I would be absolutely fine with this & fine for my child’s class/school to have CCTV. Not that I think anything would be done about all the feral & wild kids though.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/10/2023 22:00

I'm not a teacher though am assuming the above, @MrsHamlet (apologies for tag!) Does your school have the staff to provide 2:1 staff to pupils?

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/10/2023 21:56

@Lavender14 yes, you and your colleagues are doing an amazing jobs and mainstream teachers are rude, uncaring failures..
Perhaps this is because they're trying to you know 'teach' and youve got amazing resources like 18 in a class and the ability to offer 2-1 classroom support?

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 21:55

@Lavender14

I see this every time this comes up for discussion - the claim that people are simply blaming the poor children on the one hand, and the claim that more funding will solve the problem on the other.

The people actually taking most of the blame are the parents, headteachers and Ofsted, from what I can see. Yet you don't mention them at all? I've also been blaming the system, the government and the teacher's unions. You don't mention the unions at all either, yet they're doing nothing to protect their members.

This is not simply a funding problem, far from it. It's a policy built on an ideology that's also rampant in the criminal justice system. It views perpetrators as victims and places their rights above those of their actual victims. That policy of not allowing exclusions, and forcing schools to take pupils excluded from other schools, is the fundamental problem.

As to the safeguarding training, it's again just part of turning teachers into social workers and an education system into an extension of social work/containment. I perfectly understand why they might be pissed off about it. Except of course they're not allowed to say that because they'll be accused of lacking compassion.

MrsHamlet · 18/10/2023 21:54

I don't see schools doing that in the same way where they could be and that is a problem.

I have classes of 32. There is simply no time to get to the root of Bob's problem whilst also trying to teach the 31 other students in the room.

I am sympathetic up to the point where Bob is fucking up everyone else's opportunities as well as his own.

Lavender14 · 18/10/2023 21:44

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 21:32

@Lavender14

I didn't say they shouldn't be 'safeguarded', although that's a ridiculous word. In the real world we live in, where funding is limited and behavioural problems are increasing all the time, there's a conflict between the rights of children and teachers to be safe from violence at school vs the rights of violent children to be in school. It shouldn't be controversial that the right to safety trumps the right to 'education' (in quotes because most of the antisocial/violent ones are getting no education to speak of anyway).

I imagine that the teachers you train are pretty pissed off at the attitude that it should be part of their job to deal with antisocial behaviour and violence. And rightly so.

The training I do is safeguarding based predominantly, so it's absolutely part of their job.

I totally agree with your point that there's a conflict there but I just feel that the frustration should be directed more at the current system and the government for the lack of funding than at the pupils themselves which is how it comes across at times through this thread.

@MyGooseisTotallyLoose of course there needs to be a balance, as I said I work with a very high threshold so I'm weighing that up daily. But I've only ever once got to the point where I've had to move a young person to 2-1 working because we've been able to get to the root of the problem and that's often involved using other professionals in the process. I don't see schools doing that in the same way where they could be and that is a problem. As part of my assessment for new students coming on to our program I need to find out what support hasn't been trialled in school to help them sustain and some really basic things aren't even being attempted. It shouldn't really get to the point where nothing is being attempted and its left to the level I work at before things are tried. But again that's a systemic problem and in part due to class size. But again, I think that's a failing on the education system and government for lack of budgeting than it is the fault of a pupil who isn't coping with the status quo.

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 21:43

@Lavender14
The problem with "there are reasons" for the behaviour is that the reasons are very rarely sorted and there is a point at which the "reasons" excuse stops being an excuse and they go into wider society and are violent there.

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 21:32

@Lavender14

I didn't say they shouldn't be 'safeguarded', although that's a ridiculous word. In the real world we live in, where funding is limited and behavioural problems are increasing all the time, there's a conflict between the rights of children and teachers to be safe from violence at school vs the rights of violent children to be in school. It shouldn't be controversial that the right to safety trumps the right to 'education' (in quotes because most of the antisocial/violent ones are getting no education to speak of anyway).

I imagine that the teachers you train are pretty pissed off at the attitude that it should be part of their job to deal with antisocial behaviour and violence. And rightly so.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/10/2023 21:27

@Lavender14 you still seem to be saying 'oh but reasons' for what is generally violent, abusive behaviours and expect teachers and other pupils to accept all the horrors they are being put through and have the floopy, 'oh I really need to accept why Timmy, is threatening me and other kids with a knife and why he's called me a fucking slag and destroyed the classroom'? Who cares about the 29 other kids and their disrupted education? As long as Timmy stays in school!'

bombastix · 18/10/2023 21:24

No. Depressing

MrsHamlet · 18/10/2023 21:18

bombastix · 18/10/2023 21:16

Sounds like Bob has a bully dad

There are multiple ACEs. I get it. Doesn't make any of his actions acceptable though.

bombastix · 18/10/2023 21:16

Sounds like Bob has a bully dad

MrsHamlet · 18/10/2023 21:14

@bombastix Bob has been like this since primary but he's bigger and more dangerous now.

He's very good with his hands and can be perfectly pleasant when he is getting his own way. I like him. His behaviour is appalling though.

bombastix · 18/10/2023 21:12

@MrsHamlet - is it likely that Bob is going to be a useful member of society?

Less flippantly, I will ask another stupid question. Children arrive from primary schools. Do they arrive with these problems in regulation or do they develop them in secondary?

RMNofTikTok · 18/10/2023 21:06

Conkersinautumn · 18/10/2023 07:39

I'm amused by the othering on here as well. This isn't 'just' children where the parents are as described here (absent, criminal, misogynistic). I can list on one hand the children in year 5 that haven't engaged in attacking others, staff teaching and particularly non teaching, they are the exception. The chances are if your child is in primary school and in KS2 they are regularly calling staff bitches/ whores/ pedo/ freaks. Teaching staff not so much, definitely cleaners, lunch staff, caretakers etc. We don't even bother reporting because there's no consequences.

@Pollyputhekettleon I think you'll find it was here at around 07:00 this morning

Lavender14 · 18/10/2023 20:59

Pollyputhekettleon · 18/10/2023 20:34

@Lavender14

The goal of the general public, if anyone bothered to educate them about this, would not be to 'identify the root of the behaviour'. It would be to prioritize the safety of the other children and teachers, by exclusion wherever needed.

@Pollyputhekettleon and @MyGooseisTotallyLoose why shouldn't those children also be safeguarded though? When 1/4 homes in the UK have domestic violence for example, you think all those kids are going into school and behaving just as the other 3/4 are? With better resourcing it's possible to do both. Just because children are "difficult" or "challenging" doesn't make them any less entitled to support, safeguarding and an education. In fact id argue they're the ones who actually need it the most. There should be an period of trying to work through challenges and understand behaviours. For a lot of children school is the only place problems at home are picked up so I'd say it's an essential part of being a teacher. And if it's not realistic for the teacher to do it, then my question is why the schools are blocking free services like ours who can go in and do that to take the load off the teachers? I find the young people I work with are generally pretty logical (even if the logic is flawed), understand why they're acting a certain way and you can usually intercept it and the behaviour isn't needed any more, behaviour is a reaction. For me it's too easy for schools to just wash their hands off those kids and no I don't think it's good enough. I'm not saying it's a teacher specific problem, it's a problem with the education system overall. Although honestly the attitude I get from teachers I train is really disheartening. Obviously some are there because they genuinely want to support their pupils and care but a lot are so openly unbothered it's just rude and i can't think of any other profession where you could bring that attitude to training and have people think it's acceptable. Giving them the benefit of the doubt, I'd say they're probably burnt out and feel under resourced and under supported in the current system, but if the attitude and opinions they bring to my training is what they bring to their classroom then I'm not surprised some children are maybe lashing out at them because it's like a red flag to a bull. Accountability works both ways.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/10/2023 20:45

Lavender14 · 18/10/2023 20:27

I work in an alternative education setting with very high risk young people. We don't have cctv and I'd never wear a body cam. I have been threatened with a knife on one occasion so I know what it feels like to deal with weapons in our setting.

Ultimately schools need better resourcing. Teachers need better training and more support in and outside of the classroom and schools need more resources for pupils with educational needs, sen and otherwise.

The vast majority of young people I work with have been put out of schools for asb due to significant trauma. The vast majority don't have any incidents of aggressive behaviour in our setting because our approach is very different, the setting itself is very different and groups are never more than 18 in a class. In fact I can only think of 2 incidents in the last 8 years.

Being completely honest, I think a lot of times it's easy to blame the pupil but oftentimes, the other adults in the room could have deescalated quicker/ more appropriately/ recognised behaviours faster etc. But without appropriate training they won't know that at the time. Teachers are often so overworked etc that they don't have the time nor the threshold to provide that support so more children are now falling out of mainstream education and more teachers are choosing to leave. I have a lot of support for myself in my job, that helps me sustain high threshold working.

It's not good enough and at the crux of it there are children who deserve an education who are being failed by the education system. Cctv won't fix a thing, it'll just make it easier to blame the pupil and have them expelled/ suspended which doesn't help identify the root of the behaviour. The majority of pupils lashing out in this way are to an extent vulnerable. The only thing that will help is better targeted support in schools. I also offer this to mainstream education and it always amazes me how few schools actually take us up on it considering it's a free service. In fact I've been really disgusted at the attitudes I get from teachers when I've done training with them around dv and other important topics.

So it's everyone else's fault and they're just misunderstood?

MrsHamlet · 18/10/2023 20:38

I totally understand the root of Bob's behaviour. However, it doesn't mean it is acceptable for him to assault a peer, or to call a member of staff who tries to intervene a "fucking pedo cunt"

Swipe left for the next trending thread