Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private school vs private anything educational

771 replies

stopitstopitnooow · 17/10/2023 20:38

If you have an issue with private schools, why? Do you have an issue with:

Buying houses in expensive catchment areas
Extracurricular activities such as music lessons, swimming, sports coaching
Tutors; language, 11+, GCSE

(Also, private healthcare, dentists, opticians)

I honestly don't understand the angst when it comes to private schools. Let people spend their money however they see fit.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Alo3Vera · 17/10/2023 22:19

Understated32

Crack on the top unis and jobs will start to see a fairer distribution.

missylissy9 · 17/10/2023 22:19

I agree that all children should have an equal education but eliminating private schools is not going to solve the issue. State schools in the UK do not provide the same level of education as private schools. That's why I choose to send my children to a private school. The only way this will change is if the government steps up to improve state schools which is not likely to happen. That is why my kids are privately educated, if state schools were all to magically improve overnight then, no my kids would not be in a private school.

Highandlows · 17/10/2023 22:18

If there were not private schools here I would move abroad where frankly the fees are much lower anyway for international schools.

Tiredalwaystired · 17/10/2023 22:18

I’ve seen posters on Mumsnet who have openly said that their very academically average family members have used the old boys network from their private school and now earn six figure sums. It’s that sort of inequality that I most have a problem with. Nothing about quality of education or learning new skills (for example out of school piano lessons) which also takes hard graft.

it’s the money can buy you the “right” connections that I have the biggest issue with.

I also understand why smaller class sizes are the appeal for children who may need more help to thrive though and I do t have a problem with that.

Alo3Vera · 17/10/2023 22:18

Bloodsweatntears

it’s not just tiny classes and resources but connections too. You’re asking the impossible. Most schools are doing an excellent job. Aside from the connections the type of education and provision the top tiny percentage of the wealthiest get that gives the advantage just isn’t possible to give to the majority.

Understated32 · 17/10/2023 22:17

Alo3Vera · 17/10/2023 22:15

EmpressoftheMundane

No I can’t read it and it’s the Spectator with an article written by somebody privately educated anyway.

The fact remains only 7% of the country are privately educated and only 67% of Oxbridge places go to state educated kids. Most of those places( state and private) go to a few schools in the London area.

That needs looking at too.

And what percentage APPLY to Oxbridge?

Understated32 · 17/10/2023 22:16

CatamaranViper · 17/10/2023 21:10

Every child should be entitled to a fair and good education.

Unfortunately the people with the most influence tend to be the ones with the most money. If their kids were in state schools, state schools would be much better.

It's hard enough in life without taking opportunities away from children and giving them to ones whose parents earn that extra zero.

Wrong. A large number of people who put their children in private schools have lots of other options available to them besides ‘joining the local state school.’

If this is country chooses to cut its nose of to spite its face and remove private schools I’ll move to a country for which I have dual citizenship with and put them in private there. I know plenty of others who would do the same.

What happened to ambition and drive?! My parents couldn’t go to a private - my grandparents couldn’t have dreamed of it but it didn’t stop my parents pushing for it at every turn in life so they could achieve it for their own.

Highandlows · 17/10/2023 22:16

@WillowCraft Yes, but are you calling for abolishing the schools? I am saving £100k to the state by sending my child privately educated. The reason schools are not in good shape it is because the government do not prioritise education. Not because 7 percent go to private school.

DdraigGoch · 17/10/2023 22:15

The proven way to reduce inequality in education is to improve state provision. You might call it "levelling up". If state schools were good enough, few people would pay considerable amounts of money on private education. Threats of taxation are a distraction.

Alo3Vera · 17/10/2023 22:15

EmpressoftheMundane

No I can’t read it and it’s the Spectator with an article written by somebody privately educated anyway.

The fact remains only 7% of the country are privately educated and only 67% of Oxbridge places go to state educated kids. Most of those places( state and private) go to a few schools in the London area.

That needs looking at too.

Oasis1975 · 17/10/2023 22:15

State schools do pay VAT but it is then reimbursed by the local authority (and then government) as state schools have VAT exempt status in UK

Bloodsweatntears · 17/10/2023 22:14

Alo3Vera · 17/10/2023 21:39

Any kid who is bright enough should have the same chance of getting into Oxbridge or medical school end of. Instead we have an unfair private education system that hardly anybody can afford deciding who is more likely to get those places. It’s not music lessons or the better comprehensives, it’s private schools

It’s 2023 and needs to stop.

I can’t believe these threads.

Posters arguing that private schools are too good at educating children, so they should be banned.

Surely the argument should be that state schools must be brought up to the same level? So all DCs have access to an excellent education.

Private schools aren’t causing lack of social mobility. It is poorly performing and underfunded state education that is the issue.

Any anger should be directed at the government for years of under funding and failing to prioritise education.

ABCXYZ17 · 17/10/2023 22:13

EmpressoftheMundane · 17/10/2023 22:09

I don’t agree that education should be a leveller. Education should be to develop each child’s intellect as far as possible. Not to hold some back to stay at the level of the main group.

I don’t believe that the state owns my children, and don’t accept that I should be forced into state education that I don’t agree with.

Among the crowd that wants to eliminate private schools there is a strong streak of authoritarian control. We know what is best for your children. We will force you to hand them over 30 hours per week, and we will teach them what we think they ought to know and no more.

No thanks

You’re not forced into it, you have the option to home educate. The only legal requirement is that you provide an education for your child.

ToadOnTheHill · 17/10/2023 22:13

Yeah yeah @Understated32 lifes is unfair. You work harder. Not fair on little kids though, is it. Shame they have lazy parents like us working full time and still not able to get them into a good school. If only there was money and resources for all schools to be good schools. For all kids to be supported. For kids with SEN to have the provisions they need to develop and live life to their potential.

Be honest. Part of why you like private school is that your kids dont have to deal with disruptive children in classes of 30 and a lack of resources. Why shouldn't my child be entitled to that too? It's not a race to the bottom.

WillowCraft · 17/10/2023 22:12

Surely it's pretty obvious why private education is different to buying a porsche.

All children should have the right to an excellent education. It is not fair that the children of rich people have a lifelong advantage over the children of poor people. It entrenches disadvantage.

In my opinion all exam grades should be weighted by school and postcode

The additional problem is that if people can just opt out of state services there's no incentive for politicians to improve them, given that politicians are almost all in the top earners bracket (that goes for healthcare to an extent although not many are rich enough to avoid the NHS for emergency care)

Highandlows · 17/10/2023 22:09

I see this is the only democratic country in the world where this ridiculous divide and issue exists. People work, pay taxes and can choose to do wherever they want with their money. I went to private school abroad and for me it was natural to send my kids to private school. Even thought the state choices abroad were not abysmal like some you find here.

EmpressoftheMundane · 17/10/2023 22:09

I don’t agree that education should be a leveller. Education should be to develop each child’s intellect as far as possible. Not to hold some back to stay at the level of the main group.

I don’t believe that the state owns my children, and don’t accept that I should be forced into state education that I don’t agree with.

Among the crowd that wants to eliminate private schools there is a strong streak of authoritarian control. We know what is best for your children. We will force you to hand them over 30 hours per week, and we will teach them what we think they ought to know and no more.

No thanks

NashvilleQueen · 17/10/2023 22:08

So much 'life is unfair' on here but no desire to try and change it. Best to look after your own and tough tits to those that lose out.

MidnightOnceMore · 17/10/2023 22:04

tiktokontheclock · 17/10/2023 21:34

It loses a lot of votes. Dd is privately educated and even those parents I know who may have voted for them won't if they continue to push this.

It won't lose as many votes as it gains. The policy is broadly popular.

Only c.7% of children go to private schools. 93% of children go to state school.

Of those who send their children to private, more than half already vote Tory. Then there are those who support the policy despite it affecting them - plenty of wealthier left wingers agree with higher taxation for their income bracket. So you're left with a small percentage of potential Labour-voting private school parents who will make this a deciding factor.

Fizbosshoes · 17/10/2023 22:04

stopitstopitnooow · 17/10/2023 20:57

Should you pay VAT on uni fees then? Swimming lessons? Football coaching?

My DC each do one extra curricular sport/activity. There is VAT on both

Lovelyjubleee · 17/10/2023 22:02

stopitstopitnooow · 17/10/2023 21:37

They haven't passed the law yet, or even been elected and you're moving your son?

Madness

Sorry that you find it hard to understand stopitstopitnooow.

But my DS is in Y6. He has one shot at grammar school, and only in this academic year.

If I don’t move him at the start of Y7, I can’t.

Frustrating that we can’t adopt a wait and see approach; if my DS was in a lower year we could.

I trust my explanation convinces you of my sanity! 🙄

Understated32 · 17/10/2023 22:02

ToadOnTheHill · 17/10/2023 20:57

I think it's unfair you can buy your way out of a failing school and I cant. I work hard too. I'm a good mum. I was bought up without money and I did the best my parents could offer me and I'm doing my best for my children. But it will never be as much as you cam do for yours. My child is lovely. Kind, thoughtful, hard working. And she will never get those opportunities.

Life is unfair. You can’t have equality across everything. There are people who think your life in unfair.

I’ve put mine in private school - I’ve spent 5 years at university (which I funded myself by working alongside it) and have worked in professional services with an average work week of 60-80 hours to be able to do it (for over 10 years)

Everyone’s definition of working hard is different as is everyone’s definition of what a fair life looks like.

ABCXYZ17 · 17/10/2023 21:59

You need to understand that education should be a leveller. The issue with private schools is that parents who care and are engaged enough to spend money on private schools fail to contribute to their local school. If these families went to the local school it would benefit all. A greater number of parents invested, more pupils in that school who come from supportive backgrounds benefits everyone.
You also need to understand that there is a disproportionate advantage in going to private school compared to state schools when it comes to university places and job opportunities. Interestingly pupils who went to state school with the same A level grades as a pupil who went to private school go on to get better degrees. Yet they are still disadvantaged in the jobs market. Education should enable our society to be a true meritocracy but the private school system prevents this. That is why I have a problem with it.

EmpressoftheMundane · 17/10/2023 21:59

Alo3Vera · 17/10/2023 21:29

EmpressoftheMundane

Errr they really aren't.

Just 7% of children attend private schools. Yet privately educated young people make up almost one in three undergraduates at the country’s most selective universities. In the jobs market, the figures are even worse: two-thirds of the senior judiciary were privately educated as were six out of 10 civil service permanent secretaries, more than half of diplomats and more than four in 10 senior media editors. This is not a product simply of their raw ability, but also of the vast resources that go into their education, the social connections and favours it opens up and the other forms of cultural capital it endows.

Hoards of kids at grammars don’t get into Oxbridge, on medicine course etc even though theoretically they should be. Stands to reason the teaching is no better and it’s the same massively underfunded state education with huge classes and no social connections. Often taught by tired teachers trained in the same training colleges who can’t hack diverse comprehensives.

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-truth-about-getting-into-oxbridge/

If you cannot get through the paywall:

The grammar school figure for the acceptance of students educated in the UK is, in fact, 4.1 per cent higher than the independent school figure (20.7 percent).

The truth about getting into Oxbridge

Liz Truss suggests that all students who score straight A*s at A-level should be interviewed by Oxford or Cambridge. They, and their parents, might well wonder why they would not be summoned for an interview if they can achieve such impressive results....

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-truth-about-getting-into-oxbridge/

Alo3Vera · 17/10/2023 21:57

Mammyofonlyone · Today 21:53

Of course it delivers top results it only has the top most motivated percentage attending. Bright kids have the capability to do well anywhere.

It’s far more impressive to see schools with a mixed intake producing results that show massive progress and achievement at all levels and starting points.