Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private school vs private anything educational

771 replies

stopitstopitnooow · 17/10/2023 20:38

If you have an issue with private schools, why? Do you have an issue with:

Buying houses in expensive catchment areas
Extracurricular activities such as music lessons, swimming, sports coaching
Tutors; language, 11+, GCSE

(Also, private healthcare, dentists, opticians)

I honestly don't understand the angst when it comes to private schools. Let people spend their money however they see fit.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
MasterBeth · 22/10/2023 19:12

Baconisdelicious · 22/10/2023 19:02

Don't be so dramatic @Baconisdelicious- you phrase it as if ALL 7% will bail out

the underlying theme of this thread is that if we charge vat on schools fees, somehow education will be improved in state schools. So my (repeated) question is how? Whether it's all 7% or a small minority of those who are currently independently educated, how will their shifting to the state system improve the state system and/or somehow even up the playing field in the private schools?

Actually, I don't think anyone is arguing this ^^.

The argument is that the state should not be subsidising privilege through the offering of tax breaks to private schools. And that the (admittedly less than sector-changing) extra revenue raised through putting VAT on private schools will be better spent on state schools.

The broader argument is that the UK elite (politicians, newspaper columnists, academia, and government - especially Conservative government) - doesn't prioritise state education because it is unfairly drawn from private education.

YoureALizardHarry11 · 22/10/2023 19:11

Stormyseasallround · 22/10/2023 18:58

You think that it’s fair that you can afford private school and others can’t - it’s their hard luck, your advantage and they should just suck it up.

I can afford to privately educate my children even after their charitable status ends and I have to pay massively increased fees. If you can’t, then I think that’s hard luck and you should just suck it up, or get a better job. I’m richer than you, and the disadvantage to your children seems absolutely fine to me.

Still sit well with you?

This is a really good point! I was actually thinking this, people are fine with inequality until it affects them!

Baconisdelicious · 22/10/2023 19:02

Don't be so dramatic @Baconisdelicious- you phrase it as if ALL 7% will bail out

the underlying theme of this thread is that if we charge vat on schools fees, somehow education will be improved in state schools. So my (repeated) question is how? Whether it's all 7% or a small minority of those who are currently independently educated, how will their shifting to the state system improve the state system and/or somehow even up the playing field in the private schools?

Stormyseasallround · 22/10/2023 18:58

You think that it’s fair that you can afford private school and others can’t - it’s their hard luck, your advantage and they should just suck it up.

I can afford to privately educate my children even after their charitable status ends and I have to pay massively increased fees. If you can’t, then I think that’s hard luck and you should just suck it up, or get a better job. I’m richer than you, and the disadvantage to your children seems absolutely fine to me.

Still sit well with you?

sistermichaelseyeroll · 22/10/2023 18:50

GreenAppleCrumble · 22/10/2023 12:42

@sistermichaelseyeroll I take your point. I’m interested in your experience tbh. Did you go to boarding school? Your words remind me of some other people’s experience at that sort of school.

I know many private schools now are a million miles away from that though - they are day schools where the main differences from state schools are smaller classes, greater parental support (and criticism!), more extra-curricular opportunities and better classroom behaviour.

I went to a day school.

Baconisdelicious · 22/10/2023 18:46

Not getting the secondary education being in crisis claim. Only 10% of schools are rated as unsatisfactory and they then have Ofsted crawling all over them. Parents primarily choose private education due to snobbery and the unfair advantage it buys

Hmm....I work in an independent in an area that is broadly very deprived. Our school is thriving, more so post-covid and the current economic crisis. There are some excellent schools locally, some not so good, but what is clear from friends in the state sector is that it is deteriorating....and fast, even in the good schools. I don't think our parents, for the most part, are choosing private out of snobbery. Rather, there is a significant number who are boarderline when it comes to affording it, are looking at both state and private, and are scraping together the fees for the independent where as 5 years ago, they;d have risked the state schools.

As for 'unfair advantage', the majority of our children do stuff - art, music, drama, sports - outside of school which is paid for. They do stuff inside school - art, music, drama, sports - which is also paid extra for. All they're buying is small class sizes and a cohort of kids who think it's cool to acheive. The rest they'd be paying for regardless.

MasterBeth · 22/10/2023 18:32

GreenAppleCrumble · 22/10/2023 17:02

@MasterBeth I’m not disagreeing with your ideology exactly. But can you see that for many parents, choosing a school is very much a pragmatic exercise?

Secondary education especially is in absolute crisis. Do you really judge the parent who scrapes together the money to avoid a dire school?

To be totally transparent, yes I send my kids to private school. I don’t do it to ‘buy advantage’ and all those oxbridge statistics are irrelevant to me at this point. I do it to dodge the dreadful experience my kids would have at our local comp. I do it for the ‘now’ not the future.

You didn’t mention (or I missed it) whether you are against people paying to opt out of dire healthcare by going private?

Yes, I understand that it's a personal decision for many people who will prioritise their individual child's benefit, rather than wider society's. If there is unfairness baked into society, it's not surprising that people will go along with it.

But that's why it's incumbent on governments to try and put policies into place that will try and make things fairer for the majority. And, yes, that absolutely goes for healthcare as well.

inapropertyquandry · 22/10/2023 18:30

Don't be so dramatic @Baconisdelicious - you phrase it as if ALL 7% will bail out.

Baconisdelicious · 22/10/2023 18:26

Without a decent education it affects someone’s whole future, and they are more likely to stay impoverished throughout life

I'll ask again. How do you think tipping the 7% of kids in education out of the private sector into the state sector is going to improve the life of the most disadvantaged?

Baconisdelicious · 22/10/2023 18:22

Do the private sector educate teachers? No.Itis funded, at least in the first instance by the government

most private schoool offer placements to PGCE students. Why do you think they wouldn't?

curaçao · 22/10/2023 18:10

Do the private sector educate teachers? No.It is funded, at least in the first instance by the government

YoureALizardHarry11 · 22/10/2023 18:08

The point I was trying to make is houses are the same as cars, no one needs a posh car, they need something functional they can get about in. Same as houses, no one needs a big posh house, they need something that meets basic requirements and that’s safe.

Education isn’t the same and should be more equal for the reasons I said.

YoureALizardHarry11 · 22/10/2023 18:04

GreenAppleCrumble · 22/10/2023 18:01

and that’s fine, as long as every house is safe, warm and functional.

I assume you’re joking?

Why? A lot of people are living in shit houses full of mould, not well insulated etc. They should be improved, but not everyone needs a 4 bed detached, as long as it’s safe and comfortable etc. if someone can afford a bigger house that’s ok.

GreenAppleCrumble · 22/10/2023 18:01

and that’s fine, as long as every house is safe, warm and functional.

I assume you’re joking?

Mia85 · 22/10/2023 18:01

jamimmi · 17/10/2023 20:59

I'm not sure why your concerned op. I belive the labour plan is to stop charitable status and make private schools pay tax. State schools already have to pay tax on all equipment, resources etc. Its not picking on private schools it making taxation equal..Personally I'd prefer it if they make state schools tax exempt like the private ones though and even it up that way.

I realise this was a few days ago but I couldn't see that anyone had responded to this. This is a misunderstanding of the situation.
(1) Labour are no longer seeking to remove charitable status from private schools and no-one who knew anything about the law thought it was ever likely that they would. (2) Private schools currently pay VAT. Whereas state schools can reclaim VAT they pay suppliers, private schools cannot. So the current situation on VAT is advantageous to state schools NOT to private schools (3) The plan is to make parents pay VAT, not the school (though Keir Starmer has fudged this when talking about it) - by putting VAT on educational services the policy would require VAT to be added to parents' bills (4) If this happens then the schools will then be able to offset the VAT that they pay (see point 2).

YoureALizardHarry11 · 22/10/2023 17:57

Education is a basic necessity, like housing, food, water, warmth. Some people have ‘’better’’ bigger houses in nicer areas with better fixtures and fittings etc, and that’s fine, as long as every house is safe, warm and functional.

However, I believe everyone is entitled to at least a high quality of education as standard, as well educated children are our future and the vast majority don’t have access to a good education, so this makes the privileged at an advantage for good jobs (a relatively small minority).

Without a decent education it affects someone’s whole future, and they are more likely to stay impoverished throughout life.

Whether or not someone can afford private tuition outside school is irrelevant really, but the universal standard needs increasing so you can’t buy yourself into jobs.

GreenAppleCrumble · 22/10/2023 17:56

Alo3Vera · 22/10/2023 17:49

Last I heard MN threads didn’t define school quality. State schools may be massively underfunded but are not “very often total disaster zones”.How offensive to the scores of hardworking staff who are providing good and outstanding education in 90% of the country’s schools.

Please don’t try to justify the unfair privileges that private education buys by denigrating the education everyone else gets.

https://www.schoolbus.co.uk/news/featured-article/number-of-teachers-leaving-the-profession-hits-record-high/9649

This is one of many sources that will, effectively, inform you that teaching in the UK is up shit creek.

Not denigrating the work of teachers FFS. They do an amazing job in a fucking awful situation. Inadequate funding, dickheads from OFSTED driving them to suicide, unbelievably poor behaviour from pupils, lack of parental support for sanctions.

But sure, keep telling yourself state education is just fine and dandy 🙄

https://www.schoolbus.co.uk/news/featured-article/number-of-teachers-leaving-the-profession-hits-record-high/9649

Alo3Vera · 22/10/2023 17:49

Last I heard MN threads didn’t define school quality. State schools may be massively underfunded but are not “very often total disaster zones”.How offensive to the scores of hardworking staff who are providing good and outstanding education in 90% of the country’s schools.

Please don’t try to justify the unfair privileges that private education buys by denigrating the education everyone else gets.

GreenAppleCrumble · 22/10/2023 17:42

@Alo3Vera

Not getting the secondary education being in crisis claim

Really?! Have you not seen the figures on teachers leaving the profession? The threads on behaviour in schools? Or on the way kids can’t even safely go to the toilet at school? There’s another thread about appalling classroom behaviour. There was one a while back about the fact that kids have to stand in the rain to eat their lunch. Schools are very often total disaster zones.

If you have a chance not to subject your children to that (and you don’t live in a highly affluent area where there are fantastic state schools), many people take that chance even if it slowly bankrupts them!

Alo3Vera · 22/10/2023 17:39

Because SEN will make up a tiny percentage of private school pupils, many private schools are also worse for SEN provision.

Children of equal ability have an unfair advantage when they attend private schools.

Everybody knows it. Own it.

writteninthewater · 22/10/2023 17:39

I think it's good for children (and just everyone in general to be honest) to mix with people from a wide range of backgrounds, it's nothing to do with them not being fair for me. I couldn't care less about any of your examples apart from the paying for a good catchment area.

Also many parents will do private school plus pay for everything in your examples, it's not one or the other.

AmongstTheCosmos · 22/10/2023 17:35

You've been given lots of examples of parents who haven't opted for private education for reasons of snobbery. Why is it that you don't believe them? My DD is also at a private school because of her SEN being utterly unsupported at her state primary. It has precisely the sum total of fuck all to do with snobbery.

Alo3Vera · 22/10/2023 17:25

GreenAppleCrumble

Not getting the secondary education being in crisis claim. Only 10% of schools are rated as unsatisfactory and they then have Ofsted crawling all over them.

Parents primarily choose private education due to snobbery and the unfair advantage it buys.

Alo3Vera · 22/10/2023 17:20

You’re still part of a privileged tiny minority SEN or not. I too have a child with SEN, like most we can’t afford private.

jeaux90 · 22/10/2023 17:03

Legendairy · 22/10/2023 15:24

The only way my DS with SEN gets an equal education is by him going to a private school with a learning support unit that caters to his needs. He will now come out with distinctly average GCSEs which he would not achieved in the state sector. I fail to see how that is unfair to anyone TBH.

Until the state sector can provide a good standard of education across the country then I think the arguements people have against private schools are complete nonsense. It isn't a fair system within state schools. it really depends on the area and the quality of the schools. My DS would have ended up in a school that has much lower than average results who wouldn't have been able to get the support he needed and most likely would have been bullied as it is rife there.

The only people who argue against them live in areas with good/outstanding schools or live in grammar school areas (how are they any different to private schools in principle).

I would much prefer to have sent by DS to the local state school, we are skint as due to cost of living the fees have risen 10% this last 2 years compared to the usual 2 % and now looks like DH will lose his job by xmas so we'll struggle to get DS through the rest of Y11 but for his future it will be worth it as he'll hopefully get 5 x 4s and get onto the course he wants.

Every word of this.
My DD14 has ASD and ADHD and the local provision at state school is shocking.

I'm a lone parent so the school fees are a big burden but it's worth every penny to see her flourish in a small nurturing all girls school with small classes and support she needs.

She too will come out with average grades.

Swipe left for the next trending thread