Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private school vs private anything educational

771 replies

stopitstopitnooow · 17/10/2023 20:38

If you have an issue with private schools, why? Do you have an issue with:

Buying houses in expensive catchment areas
Extracurricular activities such as music lessons, swimming, sports coaching
Tutors; language, 11+, GCSE

(Also, private healthcare, dentists, opticians)

I honestly don't understand the angst when it comes to private schools. Let people spend their money however they see fit.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Bornonsunday · 23/10/2023 10:26

My son has emailed the Head of sixth form to ask about applying for oxbridge next year, in his average/Good state comprehensive.

He hasn't heard anything back. They have no extra classes/help and no interest in helping him. Privilege isn't just about academics, it's about expectations, attitudes and prejudice.

He probably won't be able to apply without support as I've no idea how to help him with the extra exams etc.

GreenAppleCrumble · 23/10/2023 10:23

SoTiredOfIt · 23/10/2023 09:53

Imagine all the private schools were turned into state schools.

But why bother imagining that? It’s so far from the reality of what might happen.

inapropertyquandry · 23/10/2023 10:21

@JustAMinutePleass the 2023 report is skewed by the results of the pandemic, where schools bought in extra tuition. The 2019 report paints a different picture.

sep135 · 23/10/2023 10:12

Imagine all the private schools were turned into state schools.

Except most won't be in reality. Our school is owned by a separate worshipful company, not the school itself. It's also 285 acres of prime property land near to London which would be probably be worth well over 100 million.

I suspect few state schools could fund the maintenance of the listed buildings and a fraction of the land given current funding constraints. Even if the owner was forced/encouraged to sell with a residential/school deal with the LA.

My state school education has served me well and improving standards should be the objective. But pushing private pupils into a stretched state system by adding VAT isn't the answer.

SoTiredOfIt · 23/10/2023 09:53

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 23/10/2023 08:25

I find the idea that you can improve a taxpayer-funded service by deliberately increasing demand on it really perverse.

Imagine all the private schools were turned into state schools.

SoTiredOfIt · 23/10/2023 09:51

@Another76543 yes there's more inequality that needs addressing.

Tackling the disparities between rich & poor affects many things.

SoTiredOfIt · 23/10/2023 09:49

Sigmama · 17/10/2023 20:52

I think all children have a right to an equal education, how you can compare that go fancy cars is beyond me

Not in some people's narrow minded self interest to see it 🤷🏻‍♀️

SoTiredOfIt · 23/10/2023 09:48

It's about trying to create a fairer society op. You clearly don't care about this.

GreenAppleCrumble · 23/10/2023 09:39

CurlewKate · 23/10/2023 09:09

Also-there is so much anecdotage. My godson was relentlessly bullied throughout his time at his very well known prep and public school and nothing was done about it. But it would be absurd of me to extrapolate anything about private schools from that. But one bad experience at a state school, often 20 years ago condemns the entire sector.

Not sure about this. You’d have to be living under a rock not to be aware of the crisis of staff recruitment/retention and chronic under-funding in state education just for starters.

CurlewKate · 23/10/2023 09:09

Also-there is so much anecdotage. My godson was relentlessly bullied throughout his time at his very well known prep and public school and nothing was done about it. But it would be absurd of me to extrapolate anything about private schools from that. But one bad experience at a state school, often 20 years ago condemns the entire sector.

JustAMinutePleass · 23/10/2023 08:46

Also Sutton Trust research implies on people being honest. The research points out that 30% of those who filled in the questionnaire self-reported no tutoring but that might be a pack of lies or tutoring might have been done by a parents.

JustAMinutePleass · 23/10/2023 08:45

inapropertyquandry · 23/10/2023 08:29

You do all realise that very often those living in the best catchments are also paying private? Definitely the case in SW London where I lived. Leafy comp, lovely houses, and futures galore to get into Tiffin and LEH and the rest.

As for the the oft- repeated claim that those in leafy comps pay for extra tuition, the Sutton Trust put paid to that not long ago with a report saying in fact privately educated children are more often given extra tuition. Privilege upon privilege.

That is not what the research said. It said black and asian parents are more likely to tutor (over 50%) across all income groups & wealthy parents are more likely to tutor overall with private tutoring highest amongst grammar school pupils (23%). London under pins the private tutoring industry as you’d expect as many independants and grammars have no catchments & so can be superselective

MariaVT65 · 23/10/2023 08:34

I went to a (non-selective) private school as I was physically bullied by boys at my state primary (I only escaped being beaten up by a scooter by climbing a fence). The teachers were lovely and the education itself great, but they couldn’t handle the behaviour and did nothing to stop bullying. These boys would have gone to my state secondary school, which is still 25 years later getting poor ofsted ratings and has issues with crime.

I am very grateful that my dad had enough money to buy me out of that situation. If my state catchment wasn’t so extremely bad, I would have definitely gone to state school.

I totally recognise it’s utterly horrible for other parents in the same situation not to be able to buy their way out of this. But my question is: My dad is an immigrant from a very poor country, moved here without any wealth and became more wealthy through setting up his own import business from scratch. He didn’t inherit anything and his parents never owned property. If it’s not ok for him to spend his money on a better life for kids, then what is it ok for him to spend money on? Stuff?

It’s highly unlikely I’ll have money to send my kids to private school, but after my own experience, the thought of sending my daughter to a mixed-sex school scares me.

I personally would not vote Labour until they actually clarify either how they intend to spend this extra VAT, and specifically what they intend to do to improve the situations in state schools that have behavioural problems. It’s all very well saying ‘it will create extra funding’ but I want specifics about what will actually be done.

inapropertyquandry · 23/10/2023 08:29

You do all realise that very often those living in the best catchments are also paying private? Definitely the case in SW London where I lived. Leafy comp, lovely houses, and futures galore to get into Tiffin and LEH and the rest.

As for the the oft- repeated claim that those in leafy comps pay for extra tuition, the Sutton Trust put paid to that not long ago with a report saying in fact privately educated children are more often given extra tuition. Privilege upon privilege.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 23/10/2023 08:25

I find the idea that you can improve a taxpayer-funded service by deliberately increasing demand on it really perverse.

CurlewKate · 23/10/2023 08:11

"However, privately schooled children will not be going to the types of schools that you and I did. They will be going to the “good” schools in the expensive catchment areas."

Although if Mumsnetters are to be believed (they aren't) by some strange demographic process, families who use private schools all live in the catchment of the absolute worst state schools with catastrophic results, daily knife fights, rampant bullying and an established drug and gang culture. Which is odd, because the most challenging schools are almost always in areas of significant social deprivation. A mystery, I tells 'ee. A mystery.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 23/10/2023 08:03

You say that moving privately schooled children into state schools will improve schools because “those parents with pointy elbows will focus on how to improve the school”. However, privately schooled children will not be going to the types of schools that you and I did. They will be going to the “good” schools in the expensive catchment areas. There will be no change to the schools that actually need improving.

This is so true. Anyone who thinks that ex-private school parents will use their resources and social influence to improve failing state schools is living in cloud cuckoo land. They won’t, and why should they? They’ll use the cash they were spending on private school fees to pay the SDLT on their new houses in the catchments of the best state schools - most likely taking places away from poorer children who would otherwise have got in, who’ll then be allocated places at worse state schools.

I have never really understood the handwringing over wealthy people opting to pay for services rather than getting them for free from the taxpayer.

My children are state educated. Although we pay for private football, swimming, gymnastics and tennis lessons. I’m not looking forward to an extra 20% on those. Seems counter-intuitive when so many children and adults are overweight but I assume the VAT has to be on all private educational activities because they’re all unfair advantages.

tuvamoodyson · 23/10/2023 07:53

yoube12345 · 17/10/2023 22:52

Why do I have to send my child to the local state school to raise the standards there? Why is it my responsibility to raise the standards of the local state school by gambling with my child's education? Because I am an engaged parent I have to try and make up for other parents who aren't bothered and so produce children who aren't bothered.

For context I work in a difficult primary and the behaviour I see from parents and children is awful. I spend so much of my day dealing with behaviour. This is not a funding issue it's a poor parenting one!

A 1000,000,000 this!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

sep135 · 23/10/2023 07:30

But I do think it should be taxed for the majority.

For the vast majority, it's already being paid out of taxed income (which goes into the pot for education and other public services). And probably double taxed income if it's been in a savings account. The VAT addition would be a further tax.

I went to a state school, my kids don't so I wear two hats. For me, the VAT addition is envy politics. It's likely to put pressure on an already squeezed education system and I genuinely believe it will be a net cost to the government. Even if it's not, the magic utopia where private school parents sweep in like shining knights and miraculously transform underperforming schools isn't going to happen.

renthead · 23/10/2023 07:24

What I find interesting is that no other country is having this hand-wringing moment over independent schools that the UK is experiencing right now. It's got everything to do with the complex history of the British class system and how it is tied up with public schools, I think. The US has a larger proportion of children in private schools than the UK, and going to a top private school gives you a vastly better chance of getting into the Ivy League (I'm not saying it's right, but it's true, there is tons of data on the effect of private school on college admissions). And people don't really think twice about it, it isn't even a societal conversation. I live in Canada and a similar percentage of children are educated privately as in the UK, and really no one cares.

MotorwayDiva · 23/10/2023 07:20

yoube12345 · 17/10/2023 22:52

Why do I have to send my child to the local state school to raise the standards there? Why is it my responsibility to raise the standards of the local state school by gambling with my child's education? Because I am an engaged parent I have to try and make up for other parents who aren't bothered and so produce children who aren't bothered.

For context I work in a difficult primary and the behaviour I see from parents and children is awful. I spend so much of my day dealing with behaviour. This is not a funding issue it's a poor parenting one!

I agree it's a partly a parenting issue, looking at the comments a few weeks back about kids being given homework and most parents refusing to do it. That's an example of the missing engagement, it doesn't take long to do 15/30 mins of times tables/spelling/reading of an evening.

Boomchuck · 23/10/2023 06:44

I’m not against private education existing—I don’t think everyone should be forced into a single education system as a matter of principle—but I do think it should be taxed for the majority. It is a luxury, and a particularly socially problematic one in terms of entrenching inequality. It is true that life isn’t fair, but it is also true that a society with high inequality and low social mobility is bad for all of us.

I think there could be some nuance to taxation, though, as not all private education is purely about giving kids a leg up. Some SEN kids really need an atmosphere that is different to what their local state option can provide, so I think it would be good for people to be able to apply for VAT exemptions on a case by case basis for this, as for those families, private may be nearer to a need than a luxury.

LameBorzoi · 23/10/2023 05:51

@Caterpillarsleftfoot Yes, but a school that's a safe, supportive environment, with teachers who actually have the opportunity to get to know students, is a huge protective factor for disadvantaged or at risk students.

Caterpillarsleftfoot · 23/10/2023 05:34

Sigmama · 17/10/2023 20:52

I think all children have a right to an equal education, how you can compare that go fancy cars is beyond me

Most of this is affected by parenting though

LameBorzoi · 23/10/2023 03:24

The problem with private schools is that they directly harm government run schools. You need a minimum number of students with academic aspirations in order to have a classroom that can cater well to academically high achieving students. Private schools tend to poach academically high achieving students. This means that the academicially high achieving students left at government run schools have fewer peers, which creates more pressure to move to private schools... and the cycle continues.

Yes, school catchments are a thing, but it plays out differently. It's just not as predatory.

Swipe left for the next trending thread