Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private school vs private anything educational

771 replies

stopitstopitnooow · 17/10/2023 20:38

If you have an issue with private schools, why? Do you have an issue with:

Buying houses in expensive catchment areas
Extracurricular activities such as music lessons, swimming, sports coaching
Tutors; language, 11+, GCSE

(Also, private healthcare, dentists, opticians)

I honestly don't understand the angst when it comes to private schools. Let people spend their money however they see fit.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
PestoQueen · 25/10/2023 02:15

We scrape together the money for 2 out of 3 of our children to go to private school as they have specific learning difficulties and (dyslexia, DCD, ADHD and NVLD) ugh, a real mixed bag and despite being bright they were falling behind year on year with little or no support in an environment that exacerbated it, eg 30 in a class, loads of distractions and teachers who were not interested in supporting them. I'm left leaning and we were both state educated. We were desperate and stuck.

We are fortunate to have some help from grandparents towards fees and have a car that's falling to bits and go on camping holidays. The private schools' my kids go to are not elitist, they are just smaller with reduced class sizes, and a nurturing ethos who are good with learning issues.

We have no spare money whatsoever and go without in order to do this and I thank my lucky stars that we are fortunate to be able to do this... it makes me feel so sad at Labour gunning for private schools, if my kids could cope in state schools I would send them!! My third child is state educated and very happy but has no additional needs thankfully as we could not send them.

I feel privileged as I know we have food on the table and it's a first world issue for us, however I am sick of the sweeping judgements about those who choose private school 🙁

Bluegreenseasoffoam · 25/10/2023 01:37

MasterBeth · 24/10/2023 18:13

Does anyone think that getting rid of private schools would mean that the quality of education in state schools would really improve?

Yes.

If Rishi Sunak and Theresa May and David Cameron and the editor of the Daily Mail = had to send their children to state schools, do I think state education would be better funded? Er, yes.

No. What happens in socialist states is that you have good public provision for the elite and rubbish for the rest of us.

Education is far too important to be nationalised.

Another76543 · 24/10/2023 22:18

DuesToTheDirt · 24/10/2023 18:24

If Rishi Sunak and Theresa May and David Cameron and the editor of the Daily Mail = had to send their children to state schools, do I think state education would be better funded? Er, yes.

I don't think the problems in state schools are primarily down to funding. I think one of the most important issues currently is behaviour - it is now very difficult to exclude pupils, and they know they can do what they like.

Exactly this. A lot of the problems in state schools run far deeper than a lack of funding. Increasing funding isn’t going to stop children messing around, being violent and generally not caring about their education. In our local area, the best resourced schools seem to have more problems.

Astonymission · 24/10/2023 19:16

DuesToTheDirt · 24/10/2023 18:24

If Rishi Sunak and Theresa May and David Cameron and the editor of the Daily Mail = had to send their children to state schools, do I think state education would be better funded? Er, yes.

I don't think the problems in state schools are primarily down to funding. I think one of the most important issues currently is behaviour - it is now very difficult to exclude pupils, and they know they can do what they like.

Yep funding doesn’t solve everything. I once taught at a school in Liverpool that was second to last in academic league tables. It has been rebuilt and had state of the art facilities etc.

it was the worst school I’d ever taught in and all the teachers said they’d never seen anything like it too.

a large proportion of the children were incredibly disruptive aggressive and violent. I was told to be careful in disciplining the kids as a lot of them had “gangster” parents so i ignored the teenage boy who told me he’d smash my face in.

I finished my day there and told the agency not to send me there again and they said “yeah everyone says that after one day”

Circe7 · 24/10/2023 19:00

@paintingvenice
I think it is much more about levelling down. Just people don’t want to say that overtly though people will talk about removing unfair advantages.

A model of forcing more people to use an inferior system by shutting off a better alternative is just such an odd way to try to improve the overall system. It’s like shutting down Oxford and Cambridge to improve the quality of UK research or banning private gyms and swimming pools to improve UK sport and fitness.

@DuesToTheDirt
I think there are structural issues with the state model which means it will never overall compete with private provision. I agree that not easily being able to exclude pupils is part of that but also not being answerable to parents in the same way as private schools. Most parents won’t pay for a service which isn’t delivering particularly when there’s a free alternative so to survive private schools have to provide a good service (some don’t but it’s hard for those schools to survive). The state sector doesn’t really have much incentive to meet the needs of pupils on an individual basis and it ends up being one size fits all. I think a fully comprehensive model with little choice of school doesn’t help either.

If people were serious about improving state education then addressing some of the structural issues might actually help. But people who are ideological opposed to private schools usually don’t like selective education, pupils being excluded and on a broader level free market economics so I don’t really see there being much change even though there is broad agreement that the state sector isn’t currently good enough.

More funding may sort out issues with buildings and allow higher teacher pay and better retention etc which would help a bit. There are really brilliant prep schools priced at £9k a year though which is not much over the state budget.

DuesToTheDirt · 24/10/2023 18:24

If Rishi Sunak and Theresa May and David Cameron and the editor of the Daily Mail = had to send their children to state schools, do I think state education would be better funded? Er, yes.

I don't think the problems in state schools are primarily down to funding. I think one of the most important issues currently is behaviour - it is now very difficult to exclude pupils, and they know they can do what they like.

MasterBeth · 24/10/2023 18:13

Does anyone think that getting rid of private schools would mean that the quality of education in state schools would really improve?

Yes.

If Rishi Sunak and Theresa May and David Cameron and the editor of the Daily Mail = had to send their children to state schools, do I think state education would be better funded? Er, yes.

CurlewKate · 24/10/2023 16:47

@paintingvenice I would like there to be no private schools, but I don't think it's doable. Whoa I do want and which is doable, is to stop them having the financial benefits given to charities.

paintingvenice · 24/10/2023 16:07

Does anyone think that getting rid of private schools would mean that the quality of education in state schools would really improve?

If removing private education didn’t result in state schools improving, then it is all about removing opportunities from some kids. We should be looking to level up, not drag down. The things that make private schools better should be aspired to by state schools, not removed from existence. If someone chooses a private school because it has small class sizes, then let’s aspire to have more teachers and smaller classes in state schools, not remove the private option. Private schools should be targets for state schools to achieve- rather than railing against them, instead ask your MP why can’t my school be like that. Give more money for education, improve teaching standards, encourage better links to the local community for work placement opportunities and networking.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 24/10/2023 15:57

Thirty years ago I wanted to apply for Oxbridge and my average/poor state comprehensive said they couldn't help and hadn't had anyone go for years. My parents had left school at 15 and couldn't help. So I wrote to the admissions office (pre-internet), got the prospectuses and paper copies of past entrance exams, applied to an open day targetted at people from schools like mine. I worked at my subject, got recommended reading from the library and badgered my teachers to look at my entrance paper answers. I got in.

That is really impressive. A shame nobody was able to support you, but what drive and determination! My grammar school didn't select me as Oxbridge material, so I went to see the Head and told her I wanted to apply. I thought I was being determined, but I'd never have had the gumption to do what you did in your situation!

CurlewKate · 24/10/2023 15:39

Generally speaking in my experience, sets in year 7 are determined largely by SATS results and reports from primary school. That's why I always jump up and down in outrage when people say "Oh, SATS are meaningless." They are then adjusted after assessments.

sep135 · 24/10/2023 15:31

How do sets work in the UK?

Not like that! Decided by the teacher with some element of discussion with pupils and parents if needed. The alternative would have created riots amongst the overly competitive parents at my school..

Mooshamoo · 24/10/2023 14:52

I'd like to hear more about sets in the UK. Because we didn't have that in my school in Ireland. I don't know about it.

Does the teacher place the student in the set?

In my school in Ireland, we didn't have set at all for the first two years of secondary school. All children of all abilities were in every class. Then from third to sixth year , I could choose my own set. The teacher didn't put me in it.

There were three sets to choose from, I could choose to do higher, medium or lower maths for example. They were called honours, pass, and foundation classes.

It was my choice which level to put myself in.

How do sets work in the UK?

ACGTHelix · 23/10/2023 19:54

Mia85 · 23/10/2023 10:39

That's a bit defeatist. Thirty years ago I wanted to apply for Oxbridge and my average/poor state comprehensive said they couldn't help and hadn't had anyone go for years. My parents had left school at 15 and couldn't help. So I wrote to the admissions office (pre-internet), got the prospectuses and paper copies of past entrance exams, applied to an open day targetted at people from schools like mine. I worked at my subject, got recommended reading from the library and badgered my teachers to look at my entrance paper answers. I got in.

Yes it's much easier if you have a school that puts on classes etc but Oxbridge are much more switched on to diversity of applicants (many of whom won't have had a 'good' comp education) and there is a vast amount of information on the internet. If he can't do this himself then he's likely to struggle with the independent learning needed on a degree.

Edited

most impressive, where there is a will and a way.

ACGTHelix · 23/10/2023 19:50

Bornonsunday · 23/10/2023 10:26

My son has emailed the Head of sixth form to ask about applying for oxbridge next year, in his average/Good state comprehensive.

He hasn't heard anything back. They have no extra classes/help and no interest in helping him. Privilege isn't just about academics, it's about expectations, attitudes and prejudice.

He probably won't be able to apply without support as I've no idea how to help him with the extra exams etc.

in this day and age, youtube and google should at least give you a road map, i know oxford itself has many videos for people wanting to apply to eg oxford

Astonymission · 23/10/2023 18:13

inapropertyquandry · 23/10/2023 08:29

You do all realise that very often those living in the best catchments are also paying private? Definitely the case in SW London where I lived. Leafy comp, lovely houses, and futures galore to get into Tiffin and LEH and the rest.

As for the the oft- repeated claim that those in leafy comps pay for extra tuition, the Sutton Trust put paid to that not long ago with a report saying in fact privately educated children are more often given extra tuition. Privilege upon privilege.

Of course private school kids will have a higher percentage receiving tuition because the vast majority of them have middle class educated parents compared to state schools where it’s more mixed socially . It didn’t need the Sutton trust to tell us that.

And you if look specifically at the same type of middle class parents ( or to some extent educated immigrant working class parents) who send their kids to state schools, a larger proportion of those will also be paying for tuition than those in state schools who have less educated/affluent parents . The key thing is the parents.

And yes some who live in a good catchment still pay private, but it doesn’t erase the fact that many families used their resources to buy houses in good catchment areas?? I can only imagine house prices would go up in those catchment areas if a larger amount of parents needed to access those “good” schools.

Mia85 · 23/10/2023 15:26

Bornonsunday · 23/10/2023 11:00

Maybe ... he has already been massively self motivated to get fantastic grades. But my wider point stands that privilege us about more than academics. Kids from state schools can have a massive uphill battle to get into oxbridge.

Well I think it is probably too simplistic to look at state vs private on this. Kids at some state schools have a massive uphill battle to get in to Oxbridge but others are in a very privileged school and home environment where the barriers are far lower. Some of the schools with the highest number of Oxbridge offers are state schools (https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-oxbridge-files-which-schools-get-the-most-pupils-in1/) and the acceptance rate for state and private pupils is very similar, particularly once you note that a higher proportion of state applications are for the most competitive courses.

It's another example of the point that's been made a lot on this thread i.e. that there are huge variations between state schools and many middle class parents are buying privilege via catchment rather than paying the fees.

The Oxbridge Files: which schools get the most pupils in?

Oxford and Cambridge have released figures showing how many offers they gave to pupils from schools in the 2021 Ucas application cycle. We have combined the figures in this table. It shows how well state grammars and sixth-form colleges compete with in...

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-oxbridge-files-which-schools-get-the-most-pupils-in1

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 23/10/2023 12:58

Imagine all the private schools were turned into state schools.

But that’s an entirely different proposition. And also, not what will happen.

Bornonsunday · 23/10/2023 11:00

Maybe ... he has already been massively self motivated to get fantastic grades. But my wider point stands that privilege us about more than academics. Kids from state schools can have a massive uphill battle to get into oxbridge.

Mia85 · 23/10/2023 10:55

CurlewKate · 23/10/2023 10:50

The Oxbridge thing is interesting. Running groups would be an excellent way for private schools to tick the "public benefit" box for their charitable status. None anywhere near me do. I wonder why not....

The schools in my town do this - a consortium of 4 state and 2 private who run university information and subject enrichment together. It's often at the private schools as they have more space but lots of students from all the schools attend. TBH I doubt that they'd get visits from e.g. Oxbridge outreach if it were just to the private schools.

CurlewKate · 23/10/2023 10:53

@Bornonsunday- it's shit that you ds isnMt getting the support he needs-can he actually go and talk to the Head? A student in his office might concentrate his mind a little!

There is loads of information online though-he should be able to find everything he needs. He shouldn't need to-but he can.

CurlewKate · 23/10/2023 10:50

The Oxbridge thing is interesting. Running groups would be an excellent way for private schools to tick the "public benefit" box for their charitable status. None anywhere near me do. I wonder why not....

Mia85 · 23/10/2023 10:39

Bornonsunday · 23/10/2023 10:26

My son has emailed the Head of sixth form to ask about applying for oxbridge next year, in his average/Good state comprehensive.

He hasn't heard anything back. They have no extra classes/help and no interest in helping him. Privilege isn't just about academics, it's about expectations, attitudes and prejudice.

He probably won't be able to apply without support as I've no idea how to help him with the extra exams etc.

That's a bit defeatist. Thirty years ago I wanted to apply for Oxbridge and my average/poor state comprehensive said they couldn't help and hadn't had anyone go for years. My parents had left school at 15 and couldn't help. So I wrote to the admissions office (pre-internet), got the prospectuses and paper copies of past entrance exams, applied to an open day targetted at people from schools like mine. I worked at my subject, got recommended reading from the library and badgered my teachers to look at my entrance paper answers. I got in.

Yes it's much easier if you have a school that puts on classes etc but Oxbridge are much more switched on to diversity of applicants (many of whom won't have had a 'good' comp education) and there is a vast amount of information on the internet. If he can't do this himself then he's likely to struggle with the independent learning needed on a degree.

CurlewKate · 23/10/2023 10:31

I think that most sensible people who oppose private education are realistic about the possibility of actually getting rid of them. Most of us would be happy with them no longer getting tax breaks.

Feralgremlin · 23/10/2023 10:29

I have a few points on this.

Firstly, to those saying that education should be fair and equal: my SEN child could not get a “fair and equal” education in the state system, there just isn’t the staff or provision, and local authorities very much have a “let’s see how they cope with no support but when they finally break that will prove that they need the support so we will agree to provide half of what they need” attitude. My child only gets a fair and equal education because he’s at a private school who will give him the support he needs without us having to fight tooth and nail for it. If private schools suddenly disappeared then I would have to find a way to home educate my child because the large class sizes and lack of support in state schools would have a really negative impact on my child’s mental health and his ability to learn.

Secondly, this belief that an influx of previously privately educated children will raise the standards of state schools. It doesn’t work like that in reality. Back when academies were being formed in our city, they put the highest achieving state school (the type where people buy houses in the catchment purely for a space at the school) with two of the lower achieving schools precisely for the reason that it would bring the lower schools up. It did the opposite. The academy now has a PCSO permanently stationed in the school to deal with the antisocial behaviour. I have witnessed children throwing chairs across classrooms and swearing at the teachers. I think we can all agree that isn’t an environment that is conducive to learning. The debate around education should not be a race to the bottom, it should not be about removing the things that give private schools their perceived edge, it should be about raising state schools up.

Thirdly, what are these connections that people talk of? They may well exist in schools like Eton and Harrow, but in the whole, the parents and families at independent schools aren’t the mega wealthy who can pull strings to get a leg up in life, they are GPs and accountants and farmers and IT analysts. Okay they might be able to give a year 10 a week of work experience but that’s about as far as the connections stretch!

Finally, I know the poster who claimed fees are £30k has already been rebutted, but to add further to that, I think people have a misconception of how expensive private schools really are. Obviously in London and further south, they are likely to be much more expensive, but where we are primary school is around £10k a year (which I understand is still prohibitively expensive for a lot of people) and secondary is £11-16k a year. A vast difference from the £30k mentioned earlier in the thread.

Despite all this, most of the private school parents I know are planning on voting Labour and just hoping they can absorb the extra costs, because they have seen how much damage the Tories have done over the last decade or so, and could not in good conscience vote for it to continue.