Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private school vs private anything educational

771 replies

stopitstopitnooow · 17/10/2023 20:38

If you have an issue with private schools, why? Do you have an issue with:

Buying houses in expensive catchment areas
Extracurricular activities such as music lessons, swimming, sports coaching
Tutors; language, 11+, GCSE

(Also, private healthcare, dentists, opticians)

I honestly don't understand the angst when it comes to private schools. Let people spend their money however they see fit.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
ElonGates666 · 25/10/2023 11:03

Papyrophile · 25/10/2023 09:19

Private school parents are customers, paying for a service and they can and do walk away if they don't feel they receive value for the after-tax income, so teachers and schools are compelled to respond to complaints. They have already paid their tax to fund state education.

State schools don't have to satisfy individual requirements, so just deliver 'one size fits all' on a take-it-or-leave-it model. There will never be levelling up to match the private schools, as parents have no leverage in maintained schools. The offering is pitched to be adequate for the average, rather than outliers with any SEN including G&T.

I don't recognise these private schools, perhaps they have changed since my day. My parents sent me to a private school after I failed my 11-plus twice. At that school nobody was given the choice of learning a musical instrument and there was no proper sports coaching.

If you couldn't keep up with the academic side then you got left behind. Children were divided into sheep and goats (a biblical reference). They were quite happy to write off numbers of children as hopeless. If you were struggling they would put more pressure on you, including sarcasm which to me was worse than the canings.

ACGTHelix · 25/10/2023 11:01

Also society itself could be improved by having focus on scientists achieving the popularity that footballers or pop, film, TV stars etc, that may also help to improve aspirations of many to study better, regardless of the education institution.

JustAMinutePleass · 25/10/2023 11:01

Londiniumrocks · 25/10/2023 10:42

Well, it creates a privilege divide like no other and really is just for the wealthy but if you want to send your child to a school where everyone looks the same, behaves the same, thinks the same, comes from the same background - you do you.
Just don’t come in to MN bleating about it or the cost or the fact that you will soon have to pay tax on fees.

The area I grew up was and still is a predominately Indian Gujarati Muslim area (most people are immigrants from Southern Gujarat and parents don’t always value religion as they come from business backgrounds). All 4 state schools there have kids that all come from similar backgrounds, same race, same religion. As an Indian Hindu person who lived in that area I found it extremely difficult and my family is from Southern Gujarat too so I had points in common!

Astonymission · 25/10/2023 10:58

Vivi0 · 25/10/2023 10:46

Why don’t we strive to bring states schools to the same standard so we can enrich the lives of all children?

Tbh I don’t believe that world class facilities would solve the state school problems. Often private school kids are doing better not because of superior or specialised teaching or their parents making complaints as pp implied, but the fact they are from families which value education and foster an environment of learning and expect their kids to come away with decent if not good grades and go onto uni in most ways.

And their home lives are often more conducive to learning too as they’re not worried about crime outside their house or their parents not being able to feed them or struggling to pay the energy bill or getting by on zero hour contracts .

The most radical to make poorly performing state school better would be the hardest way - and that is for their homes to be improved . In some cases this would also involve the help of the government so parents aren’t stressed out working two low paid jobs to make ends meet and worrying about paying energy bills for example or stuck on a council waiting list living in temporary housing. I do appreciate if parents are failing to adequately instil respect and desire for learning in children it’s sometimes because of wider social and economic issues.

Richer parents pay money to move into good catchment areas, pay for tutoring, extra curricular activities, cultural enrichment through frequent travel with children…when they’re a bit older some teens get a car and driving lessons from their parents, some receive inheritances and don’t have to work while at uni, or get to live in a flat owned by their parents which is then gifted to them so they don’t need to scrimp and save to get their first deposit . Some young adults get funded while doing unpaid internships in competitive industries like journalism or the creative sector.

The fact is affluent parents whether they sent their kids to state or private school will use all their resources and connections to make sure their kids thrive in the long term.

As many have pointed out removing private schools won’t suddenly make everything a level or fair playing field. It seems to be a very unimaginative way to deal with the huge inequalities we have in society.

ACGTHelix · 25/10/2023 10:54

Then it's not just about grades, it's the soft skills , people's ability to network, etc that can also make a difference

ACGTHelix · 25/10/2023 10:52

Londiniumrocks · 25/10/2023 10:42

Well, it creates a privilege divide like no other and really is just for the wealthy but if you want to send your child to a school where everyone looks the same, behaves the same, thinks the same, comes from the same background - you do you.
Just don’t come in to MN bleating about it or the cost or the fact that you will soon have to pay tax on fees.

Why does it, based on the way humans learn if everyone had the exact same education and subjects, some would excel due to natural talent, some would achieve average or good grades and some would need help, then factor some parents would then use outside methods eg tutors, summer camps etc, education will always be unequal due to the way humans learn.

Vivi0 · 25/10/2023 10:46

Londiniumrocks · 25/10/2023 10:43

Private schools promises ‘enrichment’ with ‘world-class’ facilities while actually providing the exact opposite.

Why don’t we strive to bring states schools to the same standard so we can enrich the lives of all children?

Londiniumrocks · 25/10/2023 10:43

Private schools promises ‘enrichment’ with ‘world-class’ facilities while actually providing the exact opposite.

Londiniumrocks · 25/10/2023 10:42

Well, it creates a privilege divide like no other and really is just for the wealthy but if you want to send your child to a school where everyone looks the same, behaves the same, thinks the same, comes from the same background - you do you.
Just don’t come in to MN bleating about it or the cost or the fact that you will soon have to pay tax on fees.

Vivi0 · 25/10/2023 10:39

DdraigGoch · 25/10/2023 10:17

No one can honestly say that given the choice they would prefer to send their child to an awful school on a matter of principal.

@CaveMum didn't Jeremy Corbyn's second wife divorce him because she wanted to send the kids to a grammar but it would have been against his principles?

His principles, or his career?

His ex wife said she wasn’t prepared to put Jemery’s career before their son’s future. He, however, was quite happy to.

Mischance · 25/10/2023 10:37

Philosophically I am wary of the idea of private schools; but in practice I have GC at both state and private schools and I can see why the parents have made the choice of private. They can afford it and the opportunities are wonderful - a whole range of add-on clubs of all sorts (so no need for out-of-school classes), access to brilliant facilities, serious attitude to learning where no-one is taunted for being a "swot", great pastoral care, clear discipline leading to a structured learning environment, musical opportunities that are lacking at the state schools (choirs, instrumental teaching, several bands/orchestras) etc. etc. The private schools are streets ahead of the comprehensives here. I wish I could afford to help the other GC to go there.

It goes against the grain with me to be saying this, but the difference is glaringly obvious to me.

What I would like to see is properly funded education for ALL children - I would like to see every child have these opportunities. Instead we have underfunded schools who struggle at every turn - I know, I am chair of governors at a state school. Teachers in the state system are dedicated and desperate to give of their best for their students, but are tied by narrow curricula and lack of funding to make sure that every child of every ability has the input they need. Is there a government that might offer this? I doubt it.

DdraigGoch · 25/10/2023 10:17

No one can honestly say that given the choice they would prefer to send their child to an awful school on a matter of principal.

@CaveMum didn't Jeremy Corbyn's second wife divorce him because she wanted to send the kids to a grammar but it would have been against his principles?

VashtaNerada · 25/10/2023 09:20

Increased funding for the school would come at the cost of making more children hungry and cold.
I would never advocate for funding schools at the expense of other vital public services. There are so many other ways to get the money. Closing tax loopholes for billionaires would be a good start!
I wouldn’t necessarily want private schools to shut but it is an unfair system especially when it relates to children who can’t help which family they’re born into.

Papyrophile · 25/10/2023 09:19

Private school parents are customers, paying for a service and they can and do walk away if they don't feel they receive value for the after-tax income, so teachers and schools are compelled to respond to complaints. They have already paid their tax to fund state education.

State schools don't have to satisfy individual requirements, so just deliver 'one size fits all' on a take-it-or-leave-it model. There will never be levelling up to match the private schools, as parents have no leverage in maintained schools. The offering is pitched to be adequate for the average, rather than outliers with any SEN including G&T.

ACGTHelix · 25/10/2023 09:17

Bluegreenseasoffoam · 25/10/2023 09:01

You aren’t reading the chain are you?

No I've not read the full details so apologies

Bluegreenseasoffoam · 25/10/2023 09:01

CurlewKate · 25/10/2023 08:58

"Weather its state or private, the knowledge and information is still the same, and people can teach themselves the knowledge rather than just relying on a teacher"

Tell that to supporters of private schools!!

You aren’t reading the chain are you?

CurlewKate · 25/10/2023 08:58

"Weather its state or private, the knowledge and information is still the same, and people can teach themselves the knowledge rather than just relying on a teacher"

Tell that to supporters of private schools!!

Bluegreenseasoffoam · 25/10/2023 08:51

VashtaNerada · 25/10/2023 08:47

I teach at an outstanding state primary and our current issues are 100% down to funding. It’s hard not to be bitter when the nation’s most vulnerable children are being neglected by their government. Proper funding would mean that children with SEND would get the support they needed, whether that’s at a special school (no special school places where I live due to funding) or in mainstream education (virtually impossible to get an EHCP nowadays and even if you got the full whack it still wouldn’t fully pay for the staff or resources that child needs). Children are coming to school hungry. Many aren’t safe at home. Parents are battling poverty, addiction, domestic violence and mental health problems without the services that used to exist to support them.
A system that rewards children from rich families and leaves those from poor families to languish cannot be right. I love my school but it’s not the same place it used to be with the cuts getting worse and worse every year.

Increased funding for the school would come at the cost of making more children hungry and cold.

The Government parasite has grown enough that more and more people find it hard to live.

VashtaNerada · 25/10/2023 08:47

I teach at an outstanding state primary and our current issues are 100% down to funding. It’s hard not to be bitter when the nation’s most vulnerable children are being neglected by their government. Proper funding would mean that children with SEND would get the support they needed, whether that’s at a special school (no special school places where I live due to funding) or in mainstream education (virtually impossible to get an EHCP nowadays and even if you got the full whack it still wouldn’t fully pay for the staff or resources that child needs). Children are coming to school hungry. Many aren’t safe at home. Parents are battling poverty, addiction, domestic violence and mental health problems without the services that used to exist to support them.
A system that rewards children from rich families and leaves those from poor families to languish cannot be right. I love my school but it’s not the same place it used to be with the cuts getting worse and worse every year.

Soffii87 · 25/10/2023 08:45

I can’t afford lost private things. But I do pay private dental care because it’s an affordable
monthly fee and includes the kids for free and dental treatment is a lot regardless. This actually works out pretty good deal.
but I also don’t have a problem with how anyone else chooses to spend their money.
move been fortunate with anything I’ve ever needed from nhs. But I know some people went private for quicker treatments.
and i honestly can’t say what else I would pay for if I had the money as I am not in the position to make the choice so I really don’t know what I would do.
I did know a kid who’s parents were letting him choose between private and non private school and he was stuck choosing because the private school focused more on rugby and the other more on football and he was exceptional at both.

Bluegreenseasoffoam · 25/10/2023 08:40

GreenAppleCrumble · 25/10/2023 07:53

I’m really not sure of the logic of this. There are plenty of powerful people who do want to improve state schools, people who, like you, are ideologically opposed to them. Why can’t it be done? Citing that handful of Tory names as the reason why state schools remain poor makes no sense. For one thing, Londoners with money would have no trouble at all finding a decent state school anyway!

Everything Governments touch goes bad.

And the more money and power you give to Government the more difficult it will become to feed ourselves.

ACGTHelix · 25/10/2023 08:36

MasterBeth · 24/10/2023 18:13

Does anyone think that getting rid of private schools would mean that the quality of education in state schools would really improve?

Yes.

If Rishi Sunak and Theresa May and David Cameron and the editor of the Daily Mail = had to send their children to state schools, do I think state education would be better funded? Er, yes.

How ?

One would presume they would use the ££ for extra tutors etc rather than just ploughing more £ into the school on the theory that it will raise standards overall, plus then there's the issues of behaviour and a conductive learning environment that can also limit learning potential

Bluegreenseasoffoam · 25/10/2023 08:35

ACGTHelix · 25/10/2023 02:29

Weather its state or private, the knowledge and information is still the same, and people can teach themselves the knowledge rather than just relying on a teacher

This is true.

But still very negative for the Govt to nationalise and destroy the system.

Whilst a parent can teach/child can read all that’s needed to DO most jobs, teaching well enough to get the best credentials to GET the jobs is a full time job and nearly impossible for one person.

GreenAppleCrumble · 25/10/2023 07:53

MasterBeth · 24/10/2023 18:13

Does anyone think that getting rid of private schools would mean that the quality of education in state schools would really improve?

Yes.

If Rishi Sunak and Theresa May and David Cameron and the editor of the Daily Mail = had to send their children to state schools, do I think state education would be better funded? Er, yes.

I’m really not sure of the logic of this. There are plenty of powerful people who do want to improve state schools, people who, like you, are ideologically opposed to them. Why can’t it be done? Citing that handful of Tory names as the reason why state schools remain poor makes no sense. For one thing, Londoners with money would have no trouble at all finding a decent state school anyway!

ACGTHelix · 25/10/2023 02:29

Bluegreenseasoffoam · 25/10/2023 01:37

No. What happens in socialist states is that you have good public provision for the elite and rubbish for the rest of us.

Education is far too important to be nationalised.

Weather its state or private, the knowledge and information is still the same, and people can teach themselves the knowledge rather than just relying on a teacher

Swipe left for the next trending thread