Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder if all these parents who expect family support have given family support

120 replies

lesserspotted · 17/10/2023 20:00

I'm always amazed at the people on here who add " we don't have any family support" to their posts, as if "family support" is an expectation, and you are hard done by if you don't get it. It seems like people expect their relatives to come and do work for them, child care, housework, DIY, etc.

Surely relatives have their own lives, and their own work? I don't know how people are expected to find hours of free time suddenly just because someone they are related to has a baby.

"Family support" is not something I have ever witnessed or experienced in my own life, as a child or a parent, or among friends.

I wonder if the people who are upset they don't have any have actually given "family support" themselves when relatives have had children

OP posts:
JustAMinutePleass · 17/10/2023 23:18

I gave a lot of support for my siblings in childcare back when they thought I was going to be the single childless aunt who would leave their children some money. I also supported my DP extensively. When I had a child none of them returned the favour

Fizbosshoes · 17/10/2023 23:14

My own GPs died either before I was born, or when I was a toddler so my parents had no family support. I remember having a weekend with my uncle and auntie maybe 3 or 4 times.

My mum was involved when my DC were born and wanted to help out but she was unwell with cancer and died when the eldest was 4.
PIL had been very involved with SILs family and lived very locally to them. They told me the novelty had worn off when my first DC was born, although they had them overnight maybe 3 or 4 times (ages 0-13)
Hopefully if my DC have children I'll be in a position to help (if they want it)

stayathomer · 17/10/2023 23:12

I always think it’s weirder that it’s announced as if everyone else has family support, in the same way people announce we got no help from our family to buy. I only know one person who got help from family to buy, and I know very few people who have parents capable of helping out with young children!

Cocomelt · 17/10/2023 23:04

When I have written about not having family support in the context of childcare, it's not been in a negative way, just factual. I didn't expect support in that way, they both worked full time & I didn't expect them to spend their free time looking after my children. On the odd occasion they have. And they have always supported me emotionally & in any way they physically can.

I like to think when I become a grandparent I'll be able to offer more physical support, but that all depends when they have their children. If they have them young like I did, then there's a big chance I'll still be working myself.

MargaretThursday · 17/10/2023 22:55

We had a relative announce that it would be lovely to share babysitting with us after the birth of their first born.

Our oldest was by then 16yo and youngest nearly 10, so we didn't need a babysitter any more... And they had shown no interests or offered any support whatsoever in the previous 16 years.
I think dh may have laughed and pointed this out.

Lostcotter · 17/10/2023 22:39

Wzn · 17/10/2023 21:26

Yes I stopped babysitting! She called me a selfish bitch because she would lose her job. I ignored her. She 'told on me' to everyone and was told she was an idiot basically. She hasn't spoken to me for 7 years, doesn't come to family events if I go, ignores any conversations where I am mentioned and basically acts as if I don't exist. Which is fine by me, it's better not to exist than to exist solely to be used.

Sheesh! Her follow up actions have proven further that she was a user who only wanted a one sided relationship with you, so once you weren’t of any “use” to her she showed her true feelings!

That’s a shame but well done for putting your foot down. I’d have done the same!

Giveuprobot · 17/10/2023 22:13

TooBusyGazingAtStarss · 17/10/2023 21:41

This

Another for this. I thought this was sort of the point of family...

lesserspotted · 17/10/2023 22:06

KeepTheTempo · 17/10/2023 21:21

"Family support" is not something I have ever witnessed or experienced in my own life, as a child or a parent, or among friends

Really? Really really? You must have an incredibly unusual - and likely entirely white and well-off - group of friends. Family support of one kind or another is the norm in most of the world.

I think the real question is also about the support that the grandparents (or other relatives) have received themselves.

My parents come from a culture where they were expected to do all the care for an older generation, not vice versa, and it would be even more unfair than usual to expect grandparents to do a lot of childcare when they never got it themselves. They have intentionally saved a lot for care and organized their housing as they don't want me to be physically responsible for caring for them if/when the time comes as my mum had to for her relatives, but as the only girl I do expect to be sorting a lot of it.

However my in-laws had huge amounts of help from their parents growing up - entire school holidays spent at grandparents' houses, and you barely see a picture of the kids without a relative somewhere in the background - yet despite being fairly young and in good health, they've never even looked after the kids for an hour while they watched TV, and that does feel unfair.

I find this a very racist, snobby and inaccurate response

OP posts:
TooBusyGazingAtStarss · 17/10/2023 21:41

roseopose · 17/10/2023 20:13

My grandparents helped with me and my sister a lot and we were very close. My mum helps me out with DD and helped her parents when they were old. I also helped my grandparents before they died with getting to appointments, took them shopping etc which took some of the load off my mum. I plan to help my own mum when she needs. None of this is transactional or expected in my family, it is just what we do, because we care about each other and want to support one another.

This

Brilliantlydone · 17/10/2023 21:29

Ah I add this to my posts sometimes and I don't mean 'somebody should help me', it's just short hand for 'they're dead so can't'
I'm also not in a position to offer support to anyone else unless for now and then. Work FT and barely keep my own head above water !

Wzn · 17/10/2023 21:26

Lostcotter · 17/10/2023 21:19

@Wzn I agree it’s a shame people who want help with childcare are often reluctant to give that help or any other help.

just out of interest what was your sisters reply ? Did you really stop babysitting?

Yes I stopped babysitting! She called me a selfish bitch because she would lose her job. I ignored her. She 'told on me' to everyone and was told she was an idiot basically. She hasn't spoken to me for 7 years, doesn't come to family events if I go, ignores any conversations where I am mentioned and basically acts as if I don't exist. Which is fine by me, it's better not to exist than to exist solely to be used.

KeepTheTempo · 17/10/2023 21:21

"Family support" is not something I have ever witnessed or experienced in my own life, as a child or a parent, or among friends

Really? Really really? You must have an incredibly unusual - and likely entirely white and well-off - group of friends. Family support of one kind or another is the norm in most of the world.

I think the real question is also about the support that the grandparents (or other relatives) have received themselves.

My parents come from a culture where they were expected to do all the care for an older generation, not vice versa, and it would be even more unfair than usual to expect grandparents to do a lot of childcare when they never got it themselves. They have intentionally saved a lot for care and organized their housing as they don't want me to be physically responsible for caring for them if/when the time comes as my mum had to for her relatives, but as the only girl I do expect to be sorting a lot of it.

However my in-laws had huge amounts of help from their parents growing up - entire school holidays spent at grandparents' houses, and you barely see a picture of the kids without a relative somewhere in the background - yet despite being fairly young and in good health, they've never even looked after the kids for an hour while they watched TV, and that does feel unfair.

SarahAndQuack · 17/10/2023 21:21

Dinosaurpoo · 17/10/2023 20:42

I’m always bemused at people who move miles away from family and then cry about not having family support. What did they think would happen? Most people don’t realise how hard having kids is until they have them.

I don’t really understand families who live near by not helping each other out. Especially with kids. It takes a village and all that.

we are very much a family support family on my side. My parents live nearby and help out with childcare. We help them out now they’re getting older. My mum had cancer recently and we all pitched in with driving to appointments and stuff. My sister lives about 40 mins away, but we are all very much supportive to each other. I did loads of looking after her kids when they were little. Her eldest babysits for us now! We help out with each others pets, house moves, DIY etc. we are emotionally supportive too. Taking an interest in each others lives is important to us.

mil is totally different. Wouldn’t ever inconvenience herself to help us. But expects us to drop everything on a whim for her. Also gets really pissed if about how often we see my parents. But those visits are usually around the business of family life - pick up’s and dropping off shopping etc. she wants us all to sit around drinking tea and listening her complain 🙄

But remember, for many people moving away for jobs is the norm?

I have to go back 4 or 6 generations (mum's side/dad's side) to get to people who stayed within the same area as their parents to raise children. Many people have always had to move to where there's work. My family has generations of experience of grandparents being hundreds of miles away from grandchildren (or even in different countries). That's not unusual.

Motheranddaughter · 17/10/2023 21:20

I did a lot of looking after my nieces and nephews when they were kids and have a great relationship with all of them now they are in the 20s
You reap what you see

cartagenagina · 17/10/2023 21:20

I think YABU. Often people are explaining they don’t have family support in order to head off comments resolving their “issues” that say “can’t you get help from family?”

Not everyone has family support, but why do you suggest this is somehow their own fault?

If their parents are deceased, live 300 miles away, have disabilities, other issues that prevent them from being able to support, that’s just how it is for them.

Most people I know whose parents/siblings are healthy and local do what they can to support each other. It is usually appreciated but I wouldn’t say it’s expected.

It sounds like you have a specific problem with someone. Perhaps you should explain what that is and posters can advise?

Lostcotter · 17/10/2023 21:19

@Wzn I agree it’s a shame people who want help with childcare are often reluctant to give that help or any other help.

just out of interest what was your sisters reply ? Did you really stop babysitting?

SilasMarnerJekyll · 17/10/2023 21:19

When I read the title I thought it would be about elderly parents demanding support.

My mother is extremely needy and expects to receive a high level of support from me. There are frequent dramatics about how other daughters help their mothers every day and she is unlucky with me as I only see her 2 or 3 days a week. Interestingly, she never provided any help to her own parents in their old age and she didn't help me when my children were young.

Wzn · 17/10/2023 21:15

YANBU and not sure why people are saying no one in their family has children as if that's the only time someone could expect support or saying they will look after their grandchildren if their children have children rather than discussing the help they give family members who help them.

Eg I am childfree and for years I looked after my sister children as she worked shifts and I am freelance and work from home. One day she said she'd be a couple of hours late picking her kids up from my house as she had to go to Tesco. My car was at the garage and I asked her to pick me up bread, milk and sugar. She said she wouldn't have time to do all my shopping as well as hers. I messaged her that night and told her I didn't have time to take care of all my responsibilities as well as hers and could no longer provide free babysitting six days a week across three shift patterns as I had been doing for 9 years for 4 children.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/10/2023 21:11

I think offering whatever support you can should be the norm. This might mean practical help, if physically able to do this, or emotional help; someone to turn to in a crisis.

Most families I know work like this.

However, in my own family, my mum had no help, and was a full time working mother of 4, at a time when it really did entirely fall on the woman regarding child & domestic duties. Her own mother didn't live close by but even still, would barely help (she stayed with us when my mother had the youngest, a very premature baby & she was very ill); she waited to hear that the baby was born & then drove off leaving us 3 there alone before my father came home from the hospital.

I really missed that support when my DC were little - my mum was still working, then by retirement didn't feel like coming up to where I lived. It was ok as I was used to it.

But I see lots of her friends flying around the country delighted to help, so plenty do.

I'm a single parent & she has helped me out hugely recently financially - it was the only way through a horrendous divorce.

But there hasn't been a crumb of emotional support, not a kind word. It's been so hard. She has her own issues but for me, that 'shoulder to cry on' would mean the world.

I look at my DC, and wonder what I'll truly be like? I hope that I will always do what I can & be clear & honest when I can't, to try to avoid those awkward dynamics.

I see lots of families locally who have this easy 'pop in' type relationship, ad hoc help with kids & it's lovely on both sides, I think.

Motheranddaughter · 17/10/2023 21:03

We got masses of support
TBF I was only part time and we paid for childcare
But both sides babysat any time we wanted to go out ,in school holidays etc
My MIL did all my ironing and FIL did the gardening
I will try and do what I can for my DC if they have DC

Blessedbethefruitz · 17/10/2023 21:03

To add, I'm the first in my wider family to have children, so have had no one to support. I have a few parent friends, and 1 neighbour friend family, who I could ask in an emergency. But my oldest (4) is anxious, someone would have to be dying for me to ask for that help. I also help and offer to host families/playdates/childcare for these same people, and deliver. I'm working on that village!

moleeye · 17/10/2023 21:02

This is us

2 primary aged children, I work 60-70 hours a week and DH is self employed.

No help with childcare. Use a mixture of wraparound care and flexibility within our roles to make it work.

Hard slog though

MightyFine · 17/10/2023 21:00

Weird thread!

Families do normally support each other.

I spent most weekends at my granny's house and dh did at his too. We don't have that sort of support but I don't hold it against my parents (one is dead and the other lives in Ireland so it would be pretty silly to expect my dcs to be spending every other weekend there). Like a lot of gps, my PILs are still working so don't have time to babysit as much as all of us would like. That's life.

But a lot of people do get regular help from family if they haven't left their home town for example. It is worth mentioning in some threads like if someone is saying they have been invited to a child free wedding or they've been offered a great job with awkward hours. The support network they have or don't have is relevant

HamBone · 17/10/2023 21:00

lifeturnsonadime · 17/10/2023 20:58

Where people don't have GP support for ad hoc babysitting etc why don't you join with a group of other parents in your area and help each other out? That's what we did with the NCT group and later with pre-school parents etc.

@lifeturnsonadime That's what we did, we have some close friends whom we helped out and vice versa. Plus paid babysitters.

We’re still there for each other, it’s lovely to have such good friends. 😀

AliasGrape · 17/10/2023 20:58

If you mean ‘family support’ as in regular childcare then no, I don’t think that should be an expectation - although it’s far more the norm around here than not, lovely if grandparents want to offer it and it works for everyone, but nobody should be guilted into it.

We have the kind where we’ve people to call in an emergency, and also to ask for occasional babysitting, and sometimes moral support or someone to moan to, somewhere to go and drink tea and see DD be made a fuss of for a while - not all from the same person there but across both families yes we have support. And we absolutely give it too - I couldn’t begin to count the hours I’ve spent babysitting nieces and nephews from when I was 13, and now great nieces and nephews. Cared for my mum through her illness until she died. Giving my sister in law a lift to hospital tomorrow. Walked dogs. Held babies whilst their mums grabbed a shower. Taken toddlers out for the day, or just a few hours out of the way whilst parents were packing or moving or studying. Provided tutoring and homework support. DH setting up computers and solving tech issues. Shopping for in-laws, doing odd jobs around their house or tip runs. Etc etc.

There are lots of shitty families out there (one side of mine are so I do know), and obviously ill health, bereavement etc complicate things- but outside of that it’s really normal for families to want to help and support each other AND want to spend time with each other and to love/ want to spend time with each other’s children. I actually find DH’s parents weird because they’re that bit more standoffish with DD, I know my mum would have been very different if she was still here for example, but by mumsnet standards they’re positively hands-on.

Of course a huge part of it is luck, and I do feel very lucky to have that network. But it’s also an active choice we’ve made - to move/ live near family, to put the effort into maintaining and building those relationships, to consider ourselves as part of a wider family rather than our ‘own little family’. Obviously that only works because we have nice family members to make the effort with though, some people don’t.