Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 2 x full-time parents and no family support is quite unusual?

384 replies

bluepurpleangel · 17/10/2023 18:47

I have read a lot of threads on MN recently where juggling life, work, childcare etc with both parents working full time and no family support seems to be the norm.

Is this really a reflection of real life? Thinking of people I know with younger children (say primary age or younger), I don’t think I know many two-parent families at all in this situation. In the vast majority of cases at least one parent works part-time and I also know quite a lot of families with a SAH parent.

Of those families where both parents work full time, they usually have some grandparent support with childcare or school pick ups etc.

Just seems a really sharp contrast to the situations I seem to read about on MN. Are my circles unusual or do others also find that 2 x FT working parents juggling everything on their own is quite rare?

OP posts:
DeeCeeCherry · 18/10/2023 18:01

I dont know any family like this in real life. Maybe with 1 side of the family not supporting. But not both. I do read about it a lot on here though and think it must be such a slog. Hard work all round. Obviously there can be various sad reasons for no support, that goes without saying. But the ones where a woman moves miles across the country away from family and friends then feels lonely, stuck and tired after kids come along with no support network I just think - why? I couldn't do it but we're all different, maybe husband & children only is enough for some.

thenovice · 18/10/2023 17:59

Both full-time and never had any grandparent or other help EVER.
DH and I are both orphans.

lucywho123 · 18/10/2023 17:55

We both work FT with no family support when it comes to childcare. DM will have DS as and when we need her (4 times in 3 years)

Childcare costs are crippling without the support though so I’d give anything to have it esp with cost of living crisis right now

1974devon · 18/10/2023 17:53

Single parent and carer to elderly mum..so no support here either. Oh and work full time.

Pollydarling · 18/10/2023 17:53

3 children no support. Both work FT. DH parents made it clear from DC1 that they had "done their bit with their own children" went to the beach in the summer and these fit, healthy able-bodied 60 year olds didn't move from their deck chairs to engage or play once. They recently moved to the other end of the country too. Don't speak to either of my parents due to childhood abuse

whittingtonmum · 18/10/2023 17:49

I think because you are in a London commuter town that's why the SHAM/part-time set up is so common. I think people choose these places on the understanding that one parent commutes into London and the other parent picks up the child care slack because otherwise unmanageable without family nearby as commute too long, trains to unreliable for both to work & commute full time. You live in a particular bubble that's why you only know the same type of arrangements.

SamAndEIIa · 18/10/2023 17:48

PersistentSniffles · 18/10/2023 17:10

@Waspie do you think it's been more manageable to have both of you working FT because you only have one child? Asking, as I have toddler DS, and am leaning towards staying one and done.

We had a 6 year age gap and it’s been pretty manageable thus far.

Mememe9898 · 18/10/2023 17:43

You probably surround yourself with similiar type of people to you.
Both my husband and I work full time in senior roles and I’ve got a nursery and infant school age kids. We have zero family support. We hire help when we need a break which happens very rarely.

ImpeckableChicken · 18/10/2023 17:43

I don’t know any SAHP. I’ve just gone full time now my daughters at school and luckily our hours mean we can each do a school run. No family support cus they either work or are too old.

Most people I know have family support though.

PersistentSniffles · 18/10/2023 17:10

Waspie · 18/10/2023 10:29

We both work full time (and always have done) and had no family support at any point.

DS was at private day nursery until he started school. At primary he was in breakfast and after school club. Since he's been at secondary - early years were mostly through pandemic and lock downs - and now, at 15 yo, he can take himself to school and get himself home afterwards.

We know a mixture of families - some where both work full time, some where one parent is part time (usually the woman) and even a few where the mother doesn't work at all or has a "mum job" like cake making for friends and family or selling stuff online.

@Waspie do you think it's been more manageable to have both of you working FT because you only have one child? Asking, as I have toddler DS, and am leaning towards staying one and done.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 18/10/2023 15:47

This was my situation when mine were young
My parents had died exh was NC with his
No one to help or even babysit

SamAndEIIa · 18/10/2023 12:09

arintingly · 18/10/2023 11:27

Yes it clearly is very area dependent. I was just making the point that statistically it's more unusual to know so many SAHPs

Yes but what I mean is that the definition of what a SAHP is will vary depending on many factors. In a wealthy area, a SAHP would be someone who opts out of the workplace due to a household income meaning they don’t have to work (eg family wealth or a husband with a well paying job) however in a poorer area a SAHP could well be in a household claiming out-of-work benefits. And there is no way to tell what category someone comes into.

arintingly · 18/10/2023 11:27

SamAndEIIa · 18/10/2023 10:03

Again, this is area dependent. About 50-70% of my child’s class were picked up by their mother every day (I only discovered this during my maternity leave) - it’s not a very affluent area; therefore I’d assume that they were unemployed rather than SAHP’s living off their partners wage.

Yes it clearly is very area dependent. I was just making the point that statistically it's more unusual to know so many SAHPs

Waspie · 18/10/2023 10:29

We both work full time (and always have done) and had no family support at any point.

DS was at private day nursery until he started school. At primary he was in breakfast and after school club. Since he's been at secondary - early years were mostly through pandemic and lock downs - and now, at 15 yo, he can take himself to school and get himself home afterwards.

We know a mixture of families - some where both work full time, some where one parent is part time (usually the woman) and even a few where the mother doesn't work at all or has a "mum job" like cake making for friends and family or selling stuff online.

SamAndEIIa · 18/10/2023 10:03

arintingly · 18/10/2023 08:08

@bluepurpleangel TBH I am surprised you know so many families with a SAHP and school age children, I would have thought of that as quite unusual.

In fact I think the lates ONS stats have only 9% of mothers as SAHMs and you would think a lot of them are SAHMs to children under 5, not school age

Again, this is area dependent. About 50-70% of my child’s class were picked up by their mother every day (I only discovered this during my maternity leave) - it’s not a very affluent area; therefore I’d assume that they were unemployed rather than SAHP’s living off their partners wage.

Catchthebreezeandwinterchills · 18/10/2023 08:34

This was always us, closest family member lived 300 miles away with half my family also living overseas.

arintingly · 18/10/2023 08:08

@bluepurpleangel TBH I am surprised you know so many families with a SAHP and school age children, I would have thought of that as quite unusual.

In fact I think the lates ONS stats have only 9% of mothers as SAHMs and you would think a lot of them are SAHMs to children under 5, not school age

riotlady · 18/10/2023 07:18

I think you’re more likely to know other people in the same situation as you- most of the parents I know, I know from school pickup, so naturally more likely to be part time or have grandparents around (lots of shift workers too). I assume there’s a whole contingent of full time working parents collecting from after school club but I don’t see them as much because I don’t use it.

Likewise people living in London are often not from London, so less likely to have grandparents around. Where I live in Northumberland, the majority of people are local so tend to have grandparents (people tend to have kids younger too, so more likely to have living/healthy grandparents)

VerasRaincoat · 18/10/2023 07:12

We don’t have any help. My partner’s family live nearby but have never helped in even the slightest way and my family live on the other side of the world.

I know my partner is disappointed in his family, but I’m unsurprised. They only come around to get pictures to pretend they are grandparents of the year then leave after making a barrage of nasty remarks, commenting on my choice of clothes for my baby, the house etc. Wish I could tell her that she has no taste and is trashy, but I
won’t rock the boat.

We just get on with it. We have had multiple surgeries of mine to contend with as
well which makes it more difficult but that’s life. Some people’s lives are harder than others.

Gingerbee · 18/10/2023 07:05

Think it depends where you live.
We never had support as our families lived between 4 and 8 hours away.

happyduckk · 18/10/2023 07:00

In our case both work full time. No help from family. One of us is studying for a master's while working full time too.
I think it's a fairly frequent situation even if not the majority.

Sewfrickinamazeballs · 18/10/2023 06:41

We both with full time, no family help at all. One able grandparent who isn't interested in her grandchildren.

All my friends and most of the parents in class have loads of grandparent help and/or work part time. I admit to being jealous as it means they don't need to spend £500+ on childcare and have more leave to take holidays together whereas we get one week off together a year if we are lucky,

autiebooklover · 18/10/2023 06:40

When I had my dds 20 years ago. Dh mum gave up work to look after them my parents were both working.

When I had ds 6 years ago my parents had died and (new) dh parents were both working full time. We used childminder and wrap around care. But I did end up going part time.

GrammarTeacher · 18/10/2023 06:27

Well, we both work full time and have no support although everyone thinks we do because my mum lives in an annexe of our house. You may well not know the full story of the people you know.

MrsMurphyIWish · 18/10/2023 06:21

Oh, so childcare is always paid for (nurseries and out of hours club). DD now in high school so she leaves the house after us and returns before us, sometimes we use her to collect DS!