Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 2 x full-time parents and no family support is quite unusual?

384 replies

bluepurpleangel · 17/10/2023 18:47

I have read a lot of threads on MN recently where juggling life, work, childcare etc with both parents working full time and no family support seems to be the norm.

Is this really a reflection of real life? Thinking of people I know with younger children (say primary age or younger), I don’t think I know many two-parent families at all in this situation. In the vast majority of cases at least one parent works part-time and I also know quite a lot of families with a SAH parent.

Of those families where both parents work full time, they usually have some grandparent support with childcare or school pick ups etc.

Just seems a really sharp contrast to the situations I seem to read about on MN. Are my circles unusual or do others also find that 2 x FT working parents juggling everything on their own is quite rare?

OP posts:
Mumofsons87 · 18/10/2023 21:06

YABU and very lucky. Both full time and only support I have is paid support from childminder, babysitter etc. I wake my small kids at 6.40 to get out the door by 7am , we get home by 5pm I cook dinner, clean do lunches, sort clothes for next day, do bath and bedtime etc. Activities for older kid
(6) and have to drag smaller one along. No cleaner, no nanny, no grandparent help no family in the area. OH leaves for work at 6.30 and gets home at 6.30pm. Weekends we Spend as a family and I catch up on housework , if we want to go to the cinema or out for a few hours then thats a paid babysitter called in and onr person has to drive to drop babysitter home.
i envy anyone who has free grandparent childcare and isnt handing over 13k cash a year like me for childcare or thoss who can afford to stay at home and get to do school runs etc. it's hard going but my little family is worth it and we have lovely family time and they want for nothing and know how loved they are by their mammy and Daddy.

bluepurpleangel · 18/10/2023 20:59

I never said I was a SAHM or that I have family support locally - I’m not and I don’t…

OP posts:
Superscientist · 18/10/2023 20:55

My partner is ft and I'm on 80% for my health.
My in-laws live 250 miles away and my mother has a broken back so rather than getting help from her I have spent most of my days off since the accident looking after my mum. Prior to this she was the primary carer for two 90+ yos so unavailable.
My daughter is 3 and from a child care perspective my mum has done 1 afternoon, my sister has done 1 day and my mother-in-law has done 10 days and all three was during 11 weeks of no childcare at all after our nursery closed 2 months before we moved to a new area with just 20minutes notice so couldn't get into a new childcare setting. The rest of the child care was covered by me and my partner and a pay by the hour nursery of we could get a slot - it was very busy owing to the closure of the nursery.

HappyValleyFan1 · 18/10/2023 20:52

I think it is quite rare but I know a few in this situation.

Not exactly in this situation ourselves but we both work FT and have very limited family support ie just for emergencies only. ILs live 40 miles away and have shown no interest in helping/wanting to do any childcare. Many other of our kids friends have lots of family help.

Probably unpopular opinion but I think a lot of it is the shift in attitude of this 'grandparent generation'. Many people my age had lots of involvement with hands on grandparents. Unfortunately the dynamic does not seem to have shifted through the generations and a lot of people have 'no village' these days

Retiredfromearlyyears · 18/10/2023 20:46

Bluepurpleangel. You are so lucky. My daughter and son in law, live in England. Her dad and I live in Scotland. Our little granddaughter has been in nursery since just before her 1st birthday. My daughter works 4 days .My son in law 5days. We go down roughly every 6 weeks and always suggest that they go for coffee ,out with freinds or even just shopping on their own. Likewise when they are up in Scotland. We have our 'little darling' and let them meet freinds etc. Other than these little mini rests. It's all the support they have.. I wish I was able to do more.

Brefugee · 18/10/2023 20:39

Me. Friend of mine, until her DH upped and left. And in my wider circle several other families.

simiisme · 18/10/2023 20:38

21 years ago, when we had our first child, my Mum had Alzheimer's, my Dad passed away when I was 18. Paternal grandparents - whilst fabulous - were over an hour's drive away. They did come to help in emergencies, such as when my husband fell out of the loft & broke his shoulder when I was heavily pregnant. But they were not close enough to help day to day.

Penguinmouse · 18/10/2023 20:34

Both work full time - very supportive families but not as formal childcare as both live 2 hours away.

tiredmama23 · 18/10/2023 20:28

It's real life for us. Zero family support and both work long hours in stressful jobs.

Sillyname63 · 18/10/2023 20:24

My DD and SiL both work full time and they don't have any family support either we live nearly an hours drive away and I look after my disabled DH, so it wasn't feasible to commit to childcare. Her DH family live 5 hours drive away.
So if your family live locally and are available great but not everyone has that.

Wolvesart · 18/10/2023 20:21

It’s quite normal even though managing it requires a school with wrap around care and a network of holiday clubs and activities planned well in advance. If I’d been 33 not 43 when I became a mum, I would definitely have continued full time work. However, I felt I’d been there and done that so could afford to work part time and not worry about my career. As it was, I just picked it all up again once the DC was older

LookingforMaryPoppins · 18/10/2023 20:15

We both work full time and have zero help from family!

Jl2014 · 18/10/2023 20:14

Both work full time. No family support. Lots of friends in the same boat.

Schooldilemma2345 · 18/10/2023 20:12

We both work full time, never had any support from grandparents. My parents might babysit in the evening 2 or 3 times a year if we’re lucky! We have 3 kids, 2 currently in primary and the oldest in year 8. I work from home and don’t have wrap around childcare of any sort, we just juggle. We are both self employed though so can be a bit more flexible with the actual hours we work although it’s never less than 40 per week each.

AegonT · 18/10/2023 20:12

Up to a year ago we both worked full-time with no family support plus caring for my Mum. We'll have to do it again soon out of financial necessity. It helps that I can leave the office during the day for school events if I make up time and I can work from home. We also have short commutes.

RockyReef · 18/10/2023 20:11

I work PT now but that is a fairly recent thing, and is due to a long term illness more than anything. However before, we both worked FT, had nothing in the way of family support (as it all goes to the other grandchildren) and it was very difficult. It’s still very difficult even with me having reduced my hours slightly. It doesn’t reflect our local area at though (very affluent) where most mums are SAHMs through choice and the dads work and earn enough to support the family. Family support seems to be 50:50 as to whether people have help or not. Many people have nannies for their children to fill the family support gap (we do not as I grew up with a nanny that I saw more than my parents).

Curiosity101 · 18/10/2023 20:05

It's very normal in my circle OP. Out of my immediate circle of parents that I work with / know well (8 including us)

6 have 2 full time working parents and often grandparents are oversees/a long way away so no help
1 has 2 full time working parents but grandparents down the road
1 has 1 full time and 1 part time parent with lots of family support nearby.

The kids are all aged from 2-7

Generally I find people either pay for full time child care (8 - 5 Mon - Fri) in our case, or make sure their shifts don't overlap or they utilise after school clubs or childminders for pick ups.

kikisparks · 18/10/2023 19:57

Of those I know with kid(s) under 8-

We work f/t, but compressed, and have family help.
Friend 1 works 4 days, her DH works 4.5, they have family help.
Friend 2 both work f/t but different shifts and have family help.
Friend 3 she works f/t her DH p/t, no real family help except emergencies.
Friend 4 due to have baby, both plan to work f/t with no family help.

Gemma2003 · 18/10/2023 19:54

Not sure where you hang out but its real life for us. Two parents working full time (one 60 plus hours) and parents not even in same hemisphere. Its the same for most of our friends. This was standard for everyone I worked with in London when my kids were born. Many had parents overseas, had long commutes and big career demands.

It did mean that there was a parallel universe between our experience and the parents at the school or nursery gate who would head off for coffee or play groups or yoga. I was more the harried parent racing for the tube that never attended anything. My source of support was my colleagues, not other local mums.

IncomingTraffic · 18/10/2023 19:51

It can depend on many things. In some job sectors, it’s so common for people to have relocated (often internationally, multiple times) just to establish or maintain a career. People in those sectors often, disproportionately know people in a similar situation. New people to an area tend to make up the majority of people seeking new friends for fairly obvious reasons too - so they meet more people who don’t live near family.

Similarly, people who stay local tend to know lots of people who’ve also stayed local. They have established networks in their local area. So they often just know fewer people with no family support.

Similar things probably contribute to women who’ve always maintained FT careers having networks made up with a greater number of people in the same situation.

Lindyloomillion1 · 18/10/2023 19:39

We were both working ft with 3 kids and no family help, in London. Not with big money jobs.
But dp worked sessional hours and I managed to negotiate a couple of days with compressed/extended hours and we just about coped.
Nightmare when child sick though.

M2B19 · 18/10/2023 19:33

We are both full time and have grand parent support on one day a week. Nothing further. We have had to pay a fortune in nursery still. In my friendship circle we are the rarity. Almost all others have part time jobs and parental support.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 18/10/2023 19:28

bluepurpleangel · 17/10/2023 18:53

Interesting to read the responses so far and that the majority are in this situation! Do you all find that other parents you know via nursery/school are in the same situation?

If so it must be very area dependant because that doesn’t seem to be the case at all where I live.

No, I think it is education dependent!
if you are a graduate and want a decent graduate job you HAVE to be prepared to live wherever the job is . I’m 60 now, and knew this way back. After university I moved 200 miles from my parents, my dh parents were 500 miles away. My dbs had to do similar things, so we were all spread out over the country.
all my friends who went to university (as did most of my school friends) were similarly dispersed right around the country.
we both worked full time, I did go part- time until eldest was 3.5 and youngest 2, but needed to go back full time. We managed with child minders (few nurseries then), and then au pairs once they were both at primary (cheaper basic care and flexible) . School holidays and sickness was a nightmare but somehow we did get through it - bosses got pissedmoff sometimes but because we both were good at our jobs and would put “the hours in “ they learnt to be flexible in their own interest. Most people I knew and women I worked with were in same position.

The issue has become more common with the opening up of university eduction under new labour. Kids are going to university now, without really understanding that to get good graduate jobs they can’t stay at “home” area (unless vocational or lucky). I think that’s a big shock to many families. Including the parents of that generation who never went into further education and don’t understand how the graduate job market works.

I have literally never lived anywhere in my life longer than 12 years: I’ve lived as far north as Newcastle, as far south as Kent and Sussex, been both sides of the Pennines, and a number of other counties. I don’t have a place I really call “home” where my routes are …and that suddenly becomes a problem when I retired (knew before). I’m now in my “carry me out in a box” home and working hard at finally putting roots down. But my own dc are settling down 100s of miles away for the exact same reasons - they have to go where they can get good graduate jobs.

but , the net result of this is that families are broken up geographically and new parents just don’t automatically have that support they would have had in previous generation by living and working in the “home” area. It is what has led to the massive rise in childcare providers and needs.

so, I’d say amongst graduates, it will be common, but less so if you both didn’t go to university.

Mba1974 · 18/10/2023 19:27

Would say it’s 75/25 in my circle.. 75% 2 x FT parents with no local family support but generally paid for support, and 25% 1 x FT and 1 x PT or SAHM.. was the same where we previously lived too. Most adults I know left home for uni and didn’t go back, or have moved for/with work. and most mums I know have careers they’ve spent years developing. Even those with family locally tend to have moved home later and have parents who will help out occasionally but definitely not “on hand” as have busy lives still themselves. so for me it’s the opposite of your experience.

SpatulaSpatula · 18/10/2023 19:22

I'm 4/5, my partner is 5/5. I don't personally know many people who work less than that though there are definitely lots. They're either wealthy or don't earn enough for childcare costs to be significantly covered by their wages.

We have never had any family support and don't think that will change. I know plenty of people with zero family support. I suspect that having children later in life means grandparents are much older these days so helping out is more difficult for them, but I'm also not sure it even occurs to some people to help.

However! I'm in the process of changing my career so I can be more flexible. Can't imagine how we'd handle school without much more flexibility. Don't know how so many people do it.