Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents who can't lead their own lives because of Grandchildren?

236 replies

girlfriend44 · 17/10/2023 14:50

Why should grandparents have to run their lives round the grandchildren?

Talking to someone today, they have family coming to stay this week. Its the only time their visitors can come because the grandkids are away on half term and they've gone away as a family.

Seems the grandchildren rule some people's lives.

OP posts:
80sMum · 17/10/2023 18:07

Icopewhenihope · 17/10/2023 14:54

Won’t be me!

Hahaha! That's what I used to say! 🤣

Acornsoup · 17/10/2023 18:00

My MIL did next to nothing with by DC. Didn't invest her time, energy or joy. SIL even less. Now MIL lives in my house ruining all of our lives because she has dementia. She was horrid before and now she is unbearable. We are all affected by it (SIL managed to side step again) and I wish she was someone else's problem. We are a family though, so just have to suck it up.

It works both ways - consideration and care. I really wish she'd appreciated her 'family' before it became all about her. It even effects how much time I can spend with my own DM and friends because MIL is always with me, even when I'm working from home.

BTW your post reads like, my friend has plans. They can't fit me in when I want them too. How selfish of the 'insert person/activity'. It really just sounds like you are being selfish. Is it really that hard to fit with their plans? People have busy lives.

Tribblesarelovely · 17/10/2023 17:57

Sorry, but everyone saying it’s the Grandparents choice is not always the case. My friend is totally buggered because she originally agreed to look after the first baby for one afternoon a day week. She now has two to care for for two days, one of whom has to be picked up from school. Her and her DH are newly retired and their life is ruled by this commitment, not to mention they’re absolutely knackered. We just arranged to meet for lunch and she has to leave early to pick one of the children up. She will continue to help, but between that and her very elderly mother, it’s not fun.

Gooseysgirl · 17/10/2023 17:56

I'm light years away from having grandchildren but when the time comes we hope to help out a little if we're not too old and knackered. But what childcare we do will be absolutely on our terms!!!

Flossflower · 17/10/2023 17:54

Halfemptyhalfling · 17/10/2023 17:28

I totally agree with this but most grandchildren, including ours, go to nursery 3/4 days a week. The day we look after them just helps their parents out with the fees and provides variety in their lives.

sh0rtbread · 17/10/2023 17:47

Sometimes the grandparents choose this.
My BIL and his wife live with his parents and 4 kids. My MIL (Grandmother) is doing the school run 3 times a day because the children are different ages so different schools etc.
Part of the perks of insisting your son lives with you, I suppose.

ShippingNews · 17/10/2023 17:42

I'm a grandmother and yes, my life does revolve around my grandchildren. I spend three days a week at my daughter's place, taking the children to their hobbies , etc.

I love it. You only have them for a few years, then they fly away. Spending time with them is a great joy to me. Just knowing how their lives are going, it's lovely. So don't feel sorry for the grandparents who do this - I bet they are loving it.

I

Caipirovska · 17/10/2023 17:35

rwalker · 17/10/2023 17:28

My mums friend used to volunteer to have gc all the time then tell anyone who would listen how hard and what a big commitment it was it was 110% her choice

DH aunt does this - but also turn on water works when her DIL get wind and tries to stop her having GC.

My MIL - who never wanted to babysit or give childcare - takes opportunity to tell her how lucky she is and how much she would do if we were closer - accept we did live closer and this wasn't true which was fine.

DH says it seems to make them both very happy doing this <shrug>.

Sewingdabs · 17/10/2023 17:32

I was a young Grandparent working whilst my Grandchildren were little, I reorganised my work life to look after them for the summer holidays and other holidays. I was fortunate as I could work fixed term contracts. Now I have a close relationship with them. The youngest is now 16. I have just retired and am looking forward to eventually having Great Grands to dote upon. Though with all my hobbies the new generation will have a little less of my time and more of their grandparents time.😊

LuckyPeonies · 17/10/2023 17:32

Grandparents who can't lead their own lives because of Grandchildren?

i know several who are raising their small grandchildren and are bitter about not being able to enjoy the retirement they wanted. You could say this is entirely self-inflicted, but if you are attached to your grandkids you don’t want them to end up in foster care, or stay with a neglectful parent.

i also know of grandparents who allow themselves to be financially and generally exploited by threat of withholding the grandchildren if they don’t do what is expected. And a retired couple who divorced because the husband wanted to travel and enjoy life, but the wife wanted to babysit the grandkids full time. But on balance, most grandparents seem to do what they are comfortable with and what is convenient for them.

2jacqi · 17/10/2023 17:29

you dont know what you are talking about!! our daughter passed away 3.5 years ago leaving 2 children. her husband, their father, works away and is only home for 3.5weeks every 2 months. The kids live with us when he is away. my hubby is 70 and I am approaching that but there is no alternative because they would lose their home!

Flossflower · 17/10/2023 17:28

No we love it. We have 2 days a week that we look after our grandchildren. I day a week each for each family. Yes we cant have appointments etc on these days but that still 5 days a week for ourselves. When we go on holiday we just give our children lots of notice. We love being part of their lives.

rwalker · 17/10/2023 17:28

My mums friend used to volunteer to have gc all the time then tell anyone who would listen how hard and what a big commitment it was it was 110% her choice

AngelinaFibres · 17/10/2023 17:26

onlyoneoftheregimentinstep · 17/10/2023 15:05

My life absolutely revolves around childcare and my DGC and I wouldn't have it any other way. I had a very rewarding career and am now enjoying my very active retirement. It keeps me fit and young at heart and I'm making the most of it before they're too grown up to need my help.

This with bells on. I have my grandson on a monday. He's 20 months and he's utterly wonderful. My DIL is expecting again and we will look after that baby too. I have the rest of the week to do whatever I want . He lives 10 minutes from me so I can see him / look after him whenever his parents want a break. I am not doing it to be saintly or a martyr. Most people can identify with the joy of spending time with people you love. I happen to love a small boy and want to spend time with him.

readbooksdrinktea · 17/10/2023 17:24

Lookingatthesunset · 17/10/2023 16:59

Grandparents don't have caring responsibilities for their grandchildren...

Some parents seem to think so. There are enough threads about it on here; 'no childcare now, no help when parents are elderly'.

margotrose · 17/10/2023 17:23

Surely it's down to the grandparents if they choose to devote so much time to their grandchildren?

Pumpkinpieandcoffee · 17/10/2023 17:22

Halfemptyhalfling · 17/10/2023 17:10

Would be better if nurseries were more subsidised so grandparents didn't have to childminders so grandparents could do as hoc or fun stuff . On average outcomes are worse for children looked after by grandparents. As the pension age and cost of living rises fewer grandparents will be available anyway in future.

Very intrigued to hear about on average outcomes being worse :D Could you point us to some research about this? i can imagine there would be so many caveats in this type of pseudo science: which country, whether grandparent is poor and hates having to be care giver, parents cant afford nursery therefore granny has to look after, the family is dysfunctional, countries where nursery care is not great etc etc etc....how do you untangle that mess with some simpleton conclusion like that...

Certainly in southern europe and really, much of the rest of the world bar northern european countries, grandparents looking after grandchildren is the norm. My italian parents look after mine with all their heart and my children are very happy to be part of an extended big family.

AuntieMarys · 17/10/2023 17:22

We don't do any childcare for dh's 3 gc. It doesn't fit in with our life and we don't want to.

Pumpkinpieandcoffee · 17/10/2023 17:16

it really is a choice moderated by the grandparents' personality, and relationship with their children. Most grandparents i know absolutely love theirs and look for opportunities to spend time with them, even if it involves "chores". if a gp doesnt want to be involved equally, noone should be forcing anyone to be involved.

However the OP's post comes across as some wish to generalise a "rule" so they dont feel a stigma or guilt towards not wanting to be with their gc. You cannot create a general rule for this OP, everyone is different. You dont need to feel guilty, but equally, you cannot stigmatise the other way around either - when grandparents absolutely love to spend time with grandchildren. It is perfectly normal.

fortnumsfinest · 17/10/2023 17:16

Some people want their grandchildren to rule their lives, if they didn't the wouldn't agree to it.
Every set up is different. From my own families perspective my sister had her DC's quite late compared to myself and my parents regularly look after her DC's and love it. They say it keeps them young and I would say compared to my PIL, who were great when their grandchildren were young, they do seem physically fitter, they don't seem to have "grown old" as quickly and I would say it's def down to then having younger grandchildren
That said I don't think it's fair if childcare is expected to the grandparents detriment

AlexaCanYouHearMe · 17/10/2023 17:13

Sounds like you're jealous of people who have their grandchildren a lot @girlfriend44 Wink Everyone I know who has their grandchildren on a fairly regular basis, loves every minute of it. The presence of their grandchildren doesn't stop them doing anything. Confused What a very bizarre thread.

Halfemptyhalfling · 17/10/2023 17:10

Would be better if nurseries were more subsidised so grandparents didn't have to childminders so grandparents could do as hoc or fun stuff . On average outcomes are worse for children looked after by grandparents. As the pension age and cost of living rises fewer grandparents will be available anyway in future.

Notmetoo · 17/10/2023 17:10

Lizzieregina · 17/10/2023 17:00

I’ve been the paid childcare provider for many families, and if I was getting paid for listening to the grandparents complain about being asked to babysit, I’d be rich! Parents: “oh my parents love to watch the kids” Grandparents: “the kids are exhausting. Do you do evenings? Why can’t they get you?” I’ve only had 2 grannies that said they loved having the kids.

My kids already know that I won’t be providing daily child care, but I will be a supportive back up caregiver. I’m hoping to spend my winters somewhere more pleasant than where I live, so I can’t commit continuously, although I’d love to do a day a week when I am around.

Well I am a grandparent and yes it is tiring and sometimes difficult But I wouldn't have it any other way. I love that by caring for them we have built a strong relationship with our GC so they know us well and are comfortable enough to feel at home in our house.
We love spending time with them and seeing them grow we are proud that we have played a part in that and we also love that we are helping our DC. For me being a parent is a lifetime commitment and I'm happy about that.
I honestly do think caring for our GC keeps us young. And I recently read a survey that shows just that.

Mari9999 · 17/10/2023 17:09

@Tryingmybestadhd
The best thing about your post is that you acknowledge that grandparents have a right to choose and there is no obligation to act in a specific way.