Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents who can't lead their own lives because of Grandchildren?

236 replies

girlfriend44 · 17/10/2023 14:50

Why should grandparents have to run their lives round the grandchildren?

Talking to someone today, they have family coming to stay this week. Its the only time their visitors can come because the grandkids are away on half term and they've gone away as a family.

Seems the grandchildren rule some people's lives.

OP posts:
Spacecowboys · 17/10/2023 20:27

I don’t plan on being free full time childcare when I am a grandparent. When I am retired I want to be able to make last minute plans if I want to. Not being able to go away for a random few days as a couple because we have children to think about (well into our 60s) isn’t something that appeals. We have been there and done that raising our own ( and were happy too). Retirement will be about us-spending quality time with family will absolutely be a part of that but on mutually agreeable terms, not in a way that stops us living our lives.

CrasyoDrago · 17/10/2023 20:05

I mean, I go to visit my parents during half terms etc as it's when they can see their grandchild... I do ask first - "what are your plans for X?" And they'll let me know and I'll ask if it's OK for us to have a visit etc. It's not set in stone.

WeightoftheWorld · 17/10/2023 20:01

80sMum · 17/10/2023 19:27

Life's perhaps not as simple as you imagine.
When parents choose to have children, they don't plan for their relationship to break down and they don't get to choose whether or not their child has disabilities that can be hard to manage alone.

Sure, so what do the parents do in those situations where they have no grandparents around who can or will help? As that's often the case.

I'm not saying grandparents should never assist but disagree with the idea that they have no choice. Everyone has choices over who they care for and ultimately young children are the responsibility of their own parents.

User1789 · 17/10/2023 19:44

Lookingatthesunset · 17/10/2023 16:59

Grandparents don't have caring responsibilities for their grandchildren...

I'm going to remember this the next time there is a 'grandparents have the right to see their grandchildren' row.

80sMum · 17/10/2023 19:27

WeightoftheWorld · 17/10/2023 18:46

What? Don't understand this. People should obviously think about how they're going to care for their own children before they have them. There are always choices. What do you think people do who have no grandparents willing or able to care for their kids?

Life's perhaps not as simple as you imagine.
When parents choose to have children, they don't plan for their relationship to break down and they don't get to choose whether or not their child has disabilities that can be hard to manage alone.

Badsisters · 17/10/2023 19:26

Wish my mum and mil made more effort tbh 🤣 none of this takes a village bullshit here. All on their terms and all over them at special occasions getting in their faces 🤣😅 my present first mine mine mine! Mil didn't want to know when we were going through miscarriages and wouldn't look after our first for each d and c. A balance would be nice!!! Just saying you can't just be there when it suits you.

wintertimeisbest · 17/10/2023 19:21

It may sound harsh but I was raised with the following word's.
You had children you look after them don't be like your mother.
Above comment came from my grandmother that constantly had us she basically brought us up
If nan couldn't have us she would find someone else.
it wasn't that mum was working all the time she would just say bringing the kids as I need a night out or I need a break.
my nan told her you shouldn't have so many kids if you can't look after them. That was a week after my grandad past away my mum said she needed a break.
I've been NC with my mother in years.
Grandmum as we call her is now 98 old and frail my mother stole her years with tantrums and nan had to be a mum again to 4 kids.
From birth on and of most weeks until I was a teen.
She had raised her family and somehow had to raise her grandkids.
I had 2children and didn't ask once for help.

If I need childcare I would pay a professional or just work around it.
I will be there for my grandchildren when or if my children want children but I'm not gonna be playing second mum.

Hooplahooping · 17/10/2023 19:07

WeightoftheWorld · 17/10/2023 18:48

See, I think that all sounds lovely, but that's absolutely worlds away from someone who is for example providing a full 5 days care every week. I presume OP wasn't at all talking about situations like yours but about full time care.

Sure, maybe they have horrible boundaries + are being asked to do more than they want and not saying no. But maybe they love it and are really happy about it.

Summerbay23 · 17/10/2023 19:03

Totally up to them I guess 🤷, if it was too much of a problem then I assume they’d change it?

Tinkerbyebye · 17/10/2023 19:01

Someone sounds bitter

catmothertes1 · 17/10/2023 19:00

Differentstarts · 17/10/2023 18:42

The problem is situations change so gps may agree to look after a 7/8 month old baby while parents return to work part time but soon that cute easy baby who sleeps alot becomes a toddler who throws tantrums, breaks things and needs constant chasing around. Then further grandkids come along and it's only fair to look after others as you have to treat everyone equally. Then work hours change and before you know it people in their 70s are running round after several small children from 6am to 6pm and their children say but they agreed to it and was so excited to do it.

I've seen this happening so many times. A couple I know are now each doing school drop off/pick up in 2 different towns. It's just like a full time job but unpaid.

Rewis · 17/10/2023 18:53

My mom has so many friends that can only make conditional plans. "Yes, I can have coffee on Tuesday unless the kids need a babysitter" and they had friends who got together every summer (one day between june and august) but now can't cause "the grandkids have very unpredictable schedule". She's so sick of it. I'm friends with a lot of the kids and I know for a fact that they'd have no issue if the grandparents said no, can't do. But they make themselves always available so they don't have a clue that they are cancelling plans to accommodate them.

stargirl1701 · 17/10/2023 18:51

It's how humans evolved, OP. We lived in communal multi-generational groups.

I can't imagine many grandparents choosing to go 'away' in the holidays either - term time prices are far more reasonable.

WeightoftheWorld · 17/10/2023 18:48

Hooplahooping · 17/10/2023 18:40

My parents are 100% like this. Is also very much their choice. I’m a SAHM with a supportive husband +
good friends locally who can help out. My brother + his wife are the same - well supported + don’t need bailing out.

our parents just like to be around. They chose to pick the boys up from school on Wednesday for an ‘adventure’ (usually trip to the park to find treasure or hunt for elves etc - 5yos are magic!), to come for Monday breakfast pancakes - and to take Mine and my brother’s children on Friday evenings for a movie night once a month etc.

they never miss a school play or a harvest festival or a rewards assembly.

their friends definitely take a back seat to their grandparent-ing - and that is very much their choice. They just really love being with their grandchildren (who reciprocate 1000 fold) - and chose to prioritise being part of the rituals of their daily lives.

It’s not for everyone (and it’s certainly net an expectation from their children - although it is unequivocally great for us) - but some people are wired that way. I think that’s fine!

my in laws are totally different - always working or busy - and come and see us for more intense visits a couple of times a year. They are endlessly out with walking groups / playing bridge / birdwatching / at choir practice. They’re equally brilliant grandparents - because they’re happy + busy + loving - but very constitutionally different to my parents.

my point being - even in very happy environments there are lots of valid ways of showing up as a good grandparent…

See, I think that all sounds lovely, but that's absolutely worlds away from someone who is for example providing a full 5 days care every week. I presume OP wasn't at all talking about situations like yours but about full time care.

WeightoftheWorld · 17/10/2023 18:46

80sMum · 17/10/2023 18:13

You're absolutely right, there isn't always a choice. If an adult DC needs help with their children and there's nobody else who can provide it, what can a grandparent do but step in? If the grandparent chooses not to help, wouldn't that damage the relationship with the DC? The DC would feel unsupported.

There can be few parents who wouldn't offer to help, I think.

Yes, it does unfortunately dictate our lives, as we're committed and relied upon. But there is no actual choice involved. It's just the situation in which we find ourselves.

What? Don't understand this. People should obviously think about how they're going to care for their own children before they have them. There are always choices. What do you think people do who have no grandparents willing or able to care for their kids?

newamsterdam · 17/10/2023 18:44

Tribblesarelovely · 17/10/2023 17:57

Sorry, but everyone saying it’s the Grandparents choice is not always the case. My friend is totally buggered because she originally agreed to look after the first baby for one afternoon a day week. She now has two to care for for two days, one of whom has to be picked up from school. Her and her DH are newly retired and their life is ruled by this commitment, not to mention they’re absolutely knackered. We just arranged to meet for lunch and she has to leave early to pick one of the children up. She will continue to help, but between that and her very elderly mother, it’s not fun.

She doesn't HAVE to do anything! She is choosing to.

Differentstarts · 17/10/2023 18:42

The problem is situations change so gps may agree to look after a 7/8 month old baby while parents return to work part time but soon that cute easy baby who sleeps alot becomes a toddler who throws tantrums, breaks things and needs constant chasing around. Then further grandkids come along and it's only fair to look after others as you have to treat everyone equally. Then work hours change and before you know it people in their 70s are running round after several small children from 6am to 6pm and their children say but they agreed to it and was so excited to do it.

Hooplahooping · 17/10/2023 18:40

My parents are 100% like this. Is also very much their choice. I’m a SAHM with a supportive husband +
good friends locally who can help out. My brother + his wife are the same - well supported + don’t need bailing out.

our parents just like to be around. They chose to pick the boys up from school on Wednesday for an ‘adventure’ (usually trip to the park to find treasure or hunt for elves etc - 5yos are magic!), to come for Monday breakfast pancakes - and to take Mine and my brother’s children on Friday evenings for a movie night once a month etc.

they never miss a school play or a harvest festival or a rewards assembly.

their friends definitely take a back seat to their grandparent-ing - and that is very much their choice. They just really love being with their grandchildren (who reciprocate 1000 fold) - and chose to prioritise being part of the rituals of their daily lives.

It’s not for everyone (and it’s certainly net an expectation from their children - although it is unequivocally great for us) - but some people are wired that way. I think that’s fine!

my in laws are totally different - always working or busy - and come and see us for more intense visits a couple of times a year. They are endlessly out with walking groups / playing bridge / birdwatching / at choir practice. They’re equally brilliant grandparents - because they’re happy + busy + loving - but very constitutionally different to my parents.

my point being - even in very happy environments there are lots of valid ways of showing up as a good grandparent…

CornishClott · 17/10/2023 18:38

My grandparents help look after my 2 older siblings and then me full time . By the time my youngest sibling arrived my Grandparents said no . They were then pushing 70 and their health had started to decline . My mother held a grudge against me over this saying I had been favoured and my sibling had been pushed out . I can't say I blame my Grandparents , they needed some time to themselves .

IDidntKnowMyOwnStrength · 17/10/2023 18:36

I have never had any help and wouldn't have expected any. My parents never had any help with us.
I do think a lot of people take it for granted that the Grandparents will help out, however as parents are leaving it later in life now to start a family maybe that will alter things. My Mum needs quite a lot of help now.
I' m a lone parent, still working lots of hours, with two young adults still at home and am very much looking forward to when all l have to worry about is myself. When l was younger l would have the mindset that yes l would love to help, and l probably will help out but l don't wan to feel pressured.

Notmetoo · 17/10/2023 18:34

Yalta · 17/10/2023 18:19

This thread isn’t about childcare. I think girlfriend would have a serious issue with this person looking after gc regularly.

This is about the son or daughter coming to visit their parents for a week and bringing their own family unit.

I don't think it is. She says she was talking to someone today who has family coming to stay (she doesn't say who the family are) and it's the only time the family can come because the grandchildren (presumably OPs friends grandchildren ) were away. Then she goes onto says GC rule some people's lives. So she is criticizing the friend for arranging her families visit to coincide when the grandchildren are away.

Yalta · 17/10/2023 18:19

This thread isn’t about childcare. I think girlfriend would have a serious issue with this person looking after gc regularly.

This is about the son or daughter coming to visit their parents for a week and bringing their own family unit.

80sMum · 17/10/2023 18:13

Tribblesarelovely · 17/10/2023 17:57

Sorry, but everyone saying it’s the Grandparents choice is not always the case. My friend is totally buggered because she originally agreed to look after the first baby for one afternoon a day week. She now has two to care for for two days, one of whom has to be picked up from school. Her and her DH are newly retired and their life is ruled by this commitment, not to mention they’re absolutely knackered. We just arranged to meet for lunch and she has to leave early to pick one of the children up. She will continue to help, but between that and her very elderly mother, it’s not fun.

You're absolutely right, there isn't always a choice. If an adult DC needs help with their children and there's nobody else who can provide it, what can a grandparent do but step in? If the grandparent chooses not to help, wouldn't that damage the relationship with the DC? The DC would feel unsupported.

There can be few parents who wouldn't offer to help, I think.

Yes, it does unfortunately dictate our lives, as we're committed and relied upon. But there is no actual choice involved. It's just the situation in which we find ourselves.

Yalta · 17/10/2023 18:07

girlfriend44

*Why should grandparents have to run their lives round the grandchildren?

Talking to someone today, they have family coming to stay this week. Its the only time their visitors can come because the grandkids are away on half term and they've gone away as a family.

Seems the grandchildren rule some people's lives*

They have family coming to stay, not visitors. It sounds like they enjoy seeing their child and their spouse and their grandchildren. They are probably looking forward to it.

Doing something you enjoy now and then doesn’t mean it rules your life

Either you don’t have children or grandchildren or you find your children and or grandchildren boring.
Some people love their family and some people don’t

Did someone cancel plans or not make plans with you this week?

Lookingatthesunset · 17/10/2023 18:07

readbooksdrinktea · 17/10/2023 17:24

Some parents seem to think so. There are enough threads about it on here; 'no childcare now, no help when parents are elderly'.

Yes, it's like a trade-off! We never had parents doing childcare - they were too far away and I don't honestly think they would have wanted to do it really.

My adult children already say they wouldn't expect it. None of them has a partner so I think gc are in the future, and I doubt I will be fit enough to mind babies/small children on a regular basis.