Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents who can't lead their own lives because of Grandchildren?

236 replies

girlfriend44 · 17/10/2023 14:50

Why should grandparents have to run their lives round the grandchildren?

Talking to someone today, they have family coming to stay this week. Its the only time their visitors can come because the grandkids are away on half term and they've gone away as a family.

Seems the grandchildren rule some people's lives.

OP posts:
Yourcatisnotsorry · 18/10/2023 20:28

My mum lives for her grandkids! She would drop everything for them if needed. They make her the happiest she’s ever been. I cannot wait to be a grandma.

now the people I worry about are those who have their lives ruled by their dog 😂

DreamTheMoors · 18/10/2023 20:23

I spent half my life with my grandparents.
I had the luxury of being raised by two different generations.
My grandparents loved me, doted on me and treated me like one of their own.
I spent the rest of their lives devoted to them.
It’s a low down dirty shame@girlfriend44that you didn’t have that in your life, but don’t take it out on those of us who did.

Ilovecleaning · 18/10/2023 20:12

I have talked to pissed off grandparents on holiday abroad because they have to holiday during school holidays and pay nearly double because of caring for grandchildren in order to save nursery fees for the parents. One grandfather said he’d had enough of it.

luluw41 · 18/10/2023 19:58

And also about the GP’s circumstances. I’m 56 but still working and will be for the foreseeable as will my husband. Because of several redundancy situations, retirement isn’t an option for us. If it were I would love to help my daughter out by looking after her LO. I’d also value (and need) my own time too. GP’s have been parents too.

Ponoka7 · 18/10/2023 19:39

BrendaMcPherson · 18/10/2023 19:29

Bollocks have you fixed it. Why are grandkids the responsibility of grandparents?

It isn't just about the GC. Your child has a need and you are helping, while gaining an important relationship. Children do best in extended families.

Ponoka7 · 18/10/2023 19:37

I think that I would have aged more if it wasn't for my GC. I keep my fitness levels up and drink less than I probably would. Some plans have to evolve around any children in the family, because of school, bed time etc. Or family don't see the little ones. I'm my DD's childcare, four days a week. It's a case of that, or seeing them live on benefits. She got out an abusive relationship. I made myself permanently available so she could recover. In our family it works well. My GPs, my Mum was never lonely or without care. I like still going to bounce/soft play Halloween/Christmas/Easter events. Booking stuff in December means I'm conscious of my health and keeping energy levels up etc. Being an involved GP is good for you.

BrendaMcPherson · 18/10/2023 19:29

User1789 · 17/10/2023 16:33

Seems the grandchildren rule some people's lives.

'Seems some people taking their caring responsibilities seriously.'

There. Fixed it for you.

Bollocks have you fixed it. Why are grandkids the responsibility of grandparents?

Pixie2015 · 18/10/2023 19:28

I hope one day grandchildren rule my life

cccarol · 18/10/2023 19:27

MotherOfBengals
like your granddaughter our granddaughter loves us just as much as we love her i know everyone is different but i think those grandparents that choose not to be involved are missing out xx
Well done for being there for her and your son wishing yous all the best xxx

Mumtobeebee · 18/10/2023 19:27

My in laws live a couple of houses down and don’t often have our children or ask to see them. My parents come from the other side of the country as often as they can to see and have the children. My parents would love to swap with my in laws which in turn would make our lives easier. It’s down to the grandparent as to how often they want to see and have their grandchildren. Personally I can’t wait to be like my parents and have them as often as possible! I was always at my grandparents house but my dads mum never bothered that often and in turn we weren’t that close to her growing up!

FelicityFlops · 18/10/2023 19:26

My sister retired early at the end of last year. She has 4 grandchildren (good effort there), who all live close to her.
She is directly engaged with them a lot of the time, Thursdays in particular. She told me that her husband, not the father of her children, hadn't picked up (yet) that Thursdays were a thing. I think he has and lets it go as he is 10 years younger and seems to like to engage with the smalls.
My sister also volunteers for the Samaritans, including the odd night session.

Middleagedspreadisreal · 18/10/2023 19:22

Grandchildren are awesome, I'm more than happy to let them run my life.

cccarol · 18/10/2023 19:22

we are very involved with our granddaughter lucky for us we are a very close family and seeing her and doing things for her fills our life with happiness we love every minute we spend with her and if we can’t be there for her we would just say its up to the grandparents to choose if they want to be involved or not
we would be quiet sad if we couldnt do it xx

MotherOfBengals · 18/10/2023 19:21

I am one of those grandparents. My granddaughter has lots of additional needs, making the education system unsuitable for her so she is home educated.
I have her 4 days a week, set days, set times so we all know where we are. Dad (my son) is single parent, sole residency but has a partner now who is able to help out. He works odd, sometimes long hours in his own business.
Granddaughter is 11, with the emotions of a 6-8 year old. Demanding, needs constant supervision very active, highly anxious if she hasn’t got the attention and supervision needed.

I plan my life around her,and my ‘days off’ .
I am also slave to 8 house rabbits and two active cats.
my partner works long odd shifts and sleeps odd hours, comes in late some nights and needs dinner.

no, I am not superwoman, I have multiple health issues myself and am bloody knackered most of the time.

however I choose to be this way, for my dedication to my Granddaughter who has said as soon as she’s 18 she moving in with me!
I’m hoping she has found peace in herself by then, however if she hasn’t and still wants to move in, my door and heart are always here for her.

AIBU? Is her dad BU for letting me? (Admittedly he would be stuck without me).
or is it just my choice?

Madamum18 · 18/10/2023 18:49

Their choice! Although there are cases where they fear losing contact if they make themselves unavailable! Relationships in making such arrangements matter!

McIntire · 18/10/2023 18:38

I love having my GC!

RB68 · 18/10/2023 18:35

They have a choice to be involved Grandparents - they chose this way. Half term is not the only time but that makes it fit for everyone. again its a choice.

anonibubble · 18/10/2023 18:17

Gizlotsmum · 17/10/2023 14:52

Well I assume it is their choice to have the grandchildren and allow their lives to work around them so unless there is something else going on surely it only affects them?

Yes, I'm a grandparent and some weeks I've done most of the school runs, but it is my choice.

This academic year I'm doing less because of my daughter's new job, but last year we were tied to only going away when we weren't taking the children. It's only for a few years and I'm happy to do it because it helps her (as a single parent) to have reliable, free help. Don't get the wrong idea, she's paying for school clubs this year, but if I can help her keep the costs down and do the hours she needs to do at work that's fine by me.
In some ways the school holidays are more difficult because the holiday clubs finish earlier.

AmazingSnakeHead · 18/10/2023 12:59

Oh, give over. they're adults and it's their choice. "Rule their lives", honestly.

ForfarBridie · 18/10/2023 12:54

jhy · 18/10/2023 12:40

I feel like it's the opposite way round and wish GP had their own lives instead of relying on family to do things with at any given chance. They take it personal and offensive if they are not invited out every time and I have to rehearse what I'm going to say everytime I want to do something alone with the kids / husband / friends !

I have a very full life outside of my time with my grandchildren. I travel, go to the gym, do volunteer work. Lots of things. And if I wasn’t so involved with the children my life would still be very full.

Can you try and encourage your parents to maybe even start going to keep fit classes at the local leisure center just for something to do that will also benefit their health.

WeightoftheWorld · 18/10/2023 12:52

Fairyliz · 18/10/2023 12:41

I think it’s the gradual drift that is the problem.
My friend had her grandchild one day a week and she loved it and had so much fun.
Her Dd then had another child and she was asked to look after them two days a week (childcare is so expensive). This was fine and doable.
But then they had another child and now she has three to look after in the school holidays which is a struggle.
She’s now 10 years older with more health problems and her other DD has had two children. How can she not help out? Wouldn’t that be unfair to help one Dd for 10 years and the other not at all?
She could say they need paid childcare but there is a cost of living crisis and her DD’s simply cannot afford hundreds of pounds each month.
So what can my friend do?

Explain her age and health means she can no longer help out? If that's the case, obviously. If her children actually care about her and appreciate the help they've received they will thank her for the help they have had so far and make alternative arrangements. What else would they do?

We can't afford loads of childcare even so we had to reduce our working hours. Plenty of families don't have grandparents to help and have to make decisions like this all the time.

As for 'fairness', adults would be ridiculous to expect parity in childcare offered if they have their kids later when their parents are older and may tire more easily or have worse health. If anyone actually would have an issue with that on the grounds of 'fairness' they're being very selfish and inconsiderate of their own ageing parents health.

Fairyliz · 18/10/2023 12:41

I think it’s the gradual drift that is the problem.
My friend had her grandchild one day a week and she loved it and had so much fun.
Her Dd then had another child and she was asked to look after them two days a week (childcare is so expensive). This was fine and doable.
But then they had another child and now she has three to look after in the school holidays which is a struggle.
She’s now 10 years older with more health problems and her other DD has had two children. How can she not help out? Wouldn’t that be unfair to help one Dd for 10 years and the other not at all?
She could say they need paid childcare but there is a cost of living crisis and her DD’s simply cannot afford hundreds of pounds each month.
So what can my friend do?

jhy · 18/10/2023 12:40

I feel like it's the opposite way round and wish GP had their own lives instead of relying on family to do things with at any given chance. They take it personal and offensive if they are not invited out every time and I have to rehearse what I'm going to say everytime I want to do something alone with the kids / husband / friends !

ForfarBridie · 18/10/2023 12:33

Pandora55 · 17/10/2023 15:26

It makes me so sad when I think that my in-laws have lost their retirement years to minding their grandkids full time so sil could work. They had to arrange their life around sil work. It drained them. And now that grandchildren are grown they are too frail and bloody worn out to do anything.

Is it possible that you have a jaundiced view of the situation? For personal reasons perhaps? I’m very hands on with my many grandchildren. I’m also well into my sixties and have had cancer plus a few other health problems. I’m far from being drained though and if I’m ever frail and worn out I won’t be blaming it on being a hands on granny who’s in effect an extra pair of hands to her children. It will be because of lifestyle choices I made over the years. And nothing to do with my grandchildren.

Yalta · 18/10/2023 12:27

*Notmetoo

Yalta · Yesterday 17:19

This thread isn’t about childcare. I think girlfriend would have a serious issue with this person looking after gc regularly.

This is about the son or daughter coming to visit their parents for a week and bringing their own family unit*

I don't think it is. She says she was talking to someone today who has family coming to stay (she doesn't say who the family are) and it's the only time the family can come because the grandchildren (presumably OPs friends grandchildren ) were away. Then she goes onto says GC rule some people's lives. So she is criticizing the friend for arranging her families visit to coincide when the grandchildren are away*

I will be honest it is a badly written post as it could be read both ways. But if you take the post to mean the grandchildren who this person looks after regularly (although it doesn’t say anything about giving regular childcare) have gone away with their parents because it is half term then how are the grandchildren ruling this persons life.

Presumably this person could have said no to this other family coming over.

This family who are coming to stay for a week and won’t come any other time probably because they have their own school aged children then isn’t this about school term times ruling people’s lives

I presume this person could if she wanted say no to regular childcare and no to seeing family.

The thing is when people don’t have children and grandchildren and you don’t know the reasons behind it. You don’t make out you are overjoyed because your children and grandchildren are visiting or how lucky you feel about being part of your gc’s lives it would be hurtful to the other person as it might be something they really would have loved for themselves.

The problems come when people don’t understand the subtext and take what you say literally and think you are not enjoying doing something when you only give that impression to spare the other persons feelings