Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to buy presents for someone who doesn't buy back?

341 replies

notputtingupwithit · 17/10/2023 11:18

Now I know you shouldn't buy to receive but we've never received a birthday or Christmas card or present from our adult son ever, our daughters all do but my son doesn't.
Every Christmas he comes around and opens presents from aunts, cousins, grandparents and us and his sisters while giving no presents in return.
Also every family birthday goes by with out any acknowledgment whatsoever but he'll happily sit and open presents on his birthday.

His sister brought him a very special birthday present this year and as expected got nothing for her birthday just 2 weeks later.

AIBU to just let his next birthday slide and see how he feels? I don't buy to receive but do feel he is taking the piss out of grandparents and wider family which irritates me.
Also want to add he's a very high earner so it has nothing to do with money.

OP posts:
H007 · 18/10/2023 19:24

You need to parent him. Tell him.

AliMonkey · 18/10/2023 19:15

@aSofaNearYou

But I don’t agree with the message that you don’t do acts of kindness for people who don’t do them for you. Surely we do that because it’s the kind thing to do - you wouldn’t run after someone who’d dropped their purse because they’ve been kind to you, you do it because it’s kind

TeenMum87 · 18/10/2023 19:07

Last Christmas my DD had a boyfriend who didn’t send her a card and produced a nice gift but several days after Christmas. Same happened on Valentine’s Day. He didn’t last much beyond Valentine’s Day.

I’m sorry OP, but I blame his mother. He is the youngest of 3 boys, no girls in the house. I absolutely would not let my son treat his girlfriend in this way.

RooRoo456 · 18/10/2023 19:00

YANBU. A relative of mine always forgets birthday presents and this year I have decided I won't buy her anything for her birthday as why should the relationship be one sided. You get to the point that you feel if they don't make the effort than why should you!

LuckySantangelo35 · 18/10/2023 18:58

He sounds lazy and entitled.

TolkiensFallow · 18/10/2023 18:30

I really don’t understand why no one has discussed this with him.

aSofaNearYou · 18/10/2023 18:26

AliMonkey · 18/10/2023 18:23

I'm finding this really interesting. When they were little, we used to take DD and DS out to buy gifts, and they were quite enthusiastic about it. DD now 18 is still a generous present giver from her own money (well until recently, it was from her pocket money / allowance from us), in fact I've frequently told her to spend less on us. DS16 can just about be persuaded to buy a card on line if we nag him enough (he has anxiety so avoids shops), but hasn't given presents for years. We've called him out on it several times (particularly re not buying anything for DD, given she has less money than us so buying presents has more effect on her than on us), but he's just not bothered. So I don't see that it's bad parenting for them to be like this, as we treated both the same and they're actions are now different. And it's not as if calling them out on it leads to a better outcome.

I really don't think it's right for us to stop buying him presents (and neither does DD, though I'd completely understand if she did), as it does send the message that we give to receive or that we love him less than his sister. Also, he withdraws from family life as much as possible anyway and this would just be one more thing that would lead to him withdrawing even more - he has no social life as it is, due to his anxiety, so it's not as if he's being a typical teenager spending more time with peers than parents.

However, I'm now wondering whether,once he's left school, I should use the "as you're clearly not bothered about presents, shall we just stop?" line. But due to the above reasons am feeling quite conflicted.

If you're not going to stop buying him presents now then I definitely would when he's an adult.

I don't think it sends a message that they are loved less or that you give to receive, I think it sends the more general message that you should not expect acts of kindness you will not do for other people.

AliMonkey · 18/10/2023 18:23

I'm finding this really interesting. When they were little, we used to take DD and DS out to buy gifts, and they were quite enthusiastic about it. DD now 18 is still a generous present giver from her own money (well until recently, it was from her pocket money / allowance from us), in fact I've frequently told her to spend less on us. DS16 can just about be persuaded to buy a card on line if we nag him enough (he has anxiety so avoids shops), but hasn't given presents for years. We've called him out on it several times (particularly re not buying anything for DD, given she has less money than us so buying presents has more effect on her than on us), but he's just not bothered. So I don't see that it's bad parenting for them to be like this, as we treated both the same and they're actions are now different. And it's not as if calling them out on it leads to a better outcome.

I really don't think it's right for us to stop buying him presents (and neither does DD, though I'd completely understand if she did), as it does send the message that we give to receive or that we love him less than his sister. Also, he withdraws from family life as much as possible anyway and this would just be one more thing that would lead to him withdrawing even more - he has no social life as it is, due to his anxiety, so it's not as if he's being a typical teenager spending more time with peers than parents.

However, I'm now wondering whether,once he's left school, I should use the "as you're clearly not bothered about presents, shall we just stop?" line. But due to the above reasons am feeling quite conflicted.

redribbonrose · 18/10/2023 18:22

Why can’t you address this with him?

he is your son. You raised him, taught right and wrong. Instilled your values

why can’t you have an open and honest conversation? What are you afraid of?

Myhusbandearns150k · 18/10/2023 18:18

Some people won’t change after being told. I’ve experienced this and have given up, some people just can’t be generous.

TwilightSkies · 18/10/2023 18:07

Send him a list of what everyone wants. See what he says.

Sandflea9900 · 18/10/2023 18:03

I’m in a similar position with DH’s brother and sister in law. We always buy birthday and Christmas gifts for them and their now adult kids, they stopped buying for me a couple of years ago. Frankly I’m tempted to just stop buying for them all and be done with it.

BMW6 · 18/10/2023 18:02

I am another simply astounded that this has been going on for years and years and no-one has ever said anything!!!

Weird as hell

1974devon · 18/10/2023 17:58

Ask him? Although also annoying is I am v thoughtful with gifts for others in family..siblings and neices/nephews and they give me and daughter a tenner in a card for birthdays/Xmas.. no thought.. People can be v blinkered/tight maybe..

Thatsridiculous · 18/10/2023 17:24

I don’t know how to write this without it sounding unkind - I am always shocked by how disfunctional some families are that can’t even communicate with each other.

A simple “where are your presents?” Or “what did you get your sister” would have been sufficient 8 years ago.

Now people are resentful - yet keep buying for him!

Come on OP! Ask your son why he thinks it’s ok to accept gifts and not buy for others?

I would be desperately disappointed if my child behaved in this way - the difference? I would address it with them.

Also at Christmas people DO generally buy because they know they will receive something. The EXCHANGE of gifts has become a tradition - a tradition within your family OP. Your son has been raised in these traditions, presumably has been present and witnessed Christmas gift exchanges every year for 27 years - he knows he should buy gifts but he chooses not to. It says a lot about his character.

TheFormidableMrsC · 18/10/2023 17:12

Whalewatchers · 18/10/2023 17:01

I don't give gifts to be honest, or birthday cards. Waste of time and money. If someone wants to give them to me, then that's up to them. I do send Christmas cards, but not gifts. Again, waste of time and money.

I only buy for my wife and young children.

You really should have the good manners to tell your relatives not to bother buying for you. It's beyond rude.

OhDoSitDownAndShutUp · 18/10/2023 17:10

Sweet F A. He's never even bought you, his mum, a card or present? He's a disgrace.

TheFormidableMrsC · 18/10/2023 17:08

Bloody hell, why is everybody pussyfooting around this selfish, rude man. If my son did this I'd pull him up immediately and ask him why he was not gift buying for others but expecting gifts nonetheless. It's utterly outrageous.

He'd not be getting a single thing from me or my family if he were mine. Lesson learned. He's old enough to know better.

Whalewatchers · 18/10/2023 17:04

... And I do send my mum a birthday card. Don't both with Dad as like me he doesn't see the value in it, far better to give him a call on the day to wish him a happy birthday and have a chat.

Whalewatchers · 18/10/2023 17:01

I don't give gifts to be honest, or birthday cards. Waste of time and money. If someone wants to give them to me, then that's up to them. I do send Christmas cards, but not gifts. Again, waste of time and money.

I only buy for my wife and young children.

kingkongs · 18/10/2023 17:00

Blimey, I'd definitely push him off the Christmas list and tell everyone else to do so as well! Even if he can't be arsed to go shopping, tesco sell numerous gift cards. He has no excuse other than selfishness.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/10/2023 16:57

I think stopping buying presents but without saying anything is understandable but quite a passive aggressive way of dealing with it to be honest. Why wouldn't you just say to him that you felt a bit embarrassed on his behalf that his aunt bought him a present and he didn't reciprocate. And that made you think about the fact that everyone buys presents for everyone else in the family for christmas and birthdays, other than him who is the only one that receives but doesn't give. Ask why he thinks this is, and what he thinks would be the best way of making things fair going forward? Tell him he is likley coming accross as rude. Suggeations include secret santa so everyone buys for one person with a set budget. No presents at all but maybe an activity like a meal out. He opts out of presents if he doesn't want to give, but everyone else carries on. Or you all give him suggestions of what you'd each like, so he has plenty of ideas of appropriate gifts.

Climbingthehillfast · 18/10/2023 16:44

So OP, are you going to call him out???

NotaDryEye · 18/10/2023 16:41

OP - what has stopped you saying anything in all this time, calling him out on his selfish behaviour? Maybe he doesn't want presents and this is why he does not give any? Without talking to him, you'll never know!!!

Mamma2017 · 18/10/2023 16:41

MrsMara · 17/10/2023 15:02

27 and only had one girlfriend. Hardly any surprise as he sounds astonishingly selfish, lacking any grace or manners whatsoever. Would be deeply unattractive to most people.

You have raised and now enable a self-serving freeloader.

I usually dislike blaming women for men's issues, but in this case I fail to see any other reason for his staggering attitude than poor parenting. Excusing it with your distorted 'don't give to receive' attitude is ALSO part of the problem.

Next gift from me would be a kick up his leeching backside.

Wow. His selfish behaviour at 27 is not down to poor parenting -he has been an adult 9 years now-long enough now to understand the world and to know better and make better choices, treat people better. Absolutely unfair to blame his mum for this yes she could’ve called him out sooner but sorry he should’ve known not to behave like this! Your post smells of internalised misogyny -women getting the bloody blame for everything, even here the behaviour of a GROWN MAN.