Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s a bit odd when teachers refer to themselves by their surname yet address parents by their first name.

137 replies

Nonplusultra · 17/10/2023 09:21

Since the dc have started secondary, and we’ve a wider pool of teachers, I’ve noticed this a few times.

If I email a Mr Smith and sign off Jane Jones, most people will respond Dear Jane, and sign off Sam Smith, and after that you’re on first name terms. Or they’ll write Ms Jones and sign off Sam Smith retaining a degree of formality.

But I’ve noticed that some teachers will use my first name but sign off as Mr Smith. If they want to retain their professional persona, that’s fine (although in this day and age it’s slightly odd), but in that case I think they should also address me as Ms Jones. It’s especially weird when I’m old enough to be their mum.

It’s not even in front of the children. I’ve even spoken on the phone like this “Hi Jane, It’s Mr Smith from dc’s school….”

It’s only a minority of teachers tbf , but I’ve only encountered this with teachers.

OP posts:
Ontheperiphery79 · 18/10/2023 15:05

I honestly don't give a flying fuck what my twins' teachers call me. They have SO many parents and carers to deal with, not all of whom have the same surname as the child(ren).

I tend to struggle with names anyway, and have (mainly) polite nicknames for all school staff to help me remember which one is which and, luckily, I have never slipped up by calling them in person or correspondence.

LolaSmiles · 18/10/2023 14:57

Conkersinautumn
I also liked a bit of professional distance with parents when I was still teaching. As a parent now I appreciate the professional boundaries.

I think overfamiliarity can cause issues at times. For example an overfamiliar or more informal member of staff has the great relationships, informal banter, especially in situations where the child/parents are hard to engage, and then when the member of staff has to share bad news, or escalate something, or can't pull some strings then it feels quite personal. I've had some awkward conversations at work when parents and students have felt quite let down that the "sound" member of staff appeared to change the rules of play, and that usually ended up expressed as anger to me because I was the bad cop trying to get some boundaries back in place.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 18/10/2023 14:56

Do some teachers still sit you on a child's chair whilst occupying an adult one themselves? That used to feel odd to me.

Conkersinautumn · 18/10/2023 14:34

I remember a teacher in person introducing himself as Mr Green, so I used Mrs Autumn for a meeting about safeguarding. I was the only parent who didn't use the simpering just call me Firstname. But I always respond in kind, keeping others at the boundary they are comfortable with. I'm not interested in getting informal with teachers.

JudgeJ · 18/10/2023 14:28

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 17/10/2023 10:51

These days I do not really care as long as they are being proactive in responding to my queries and taking action promptly!

Hopefully, for their sakes, I hope that 'promptly' will be during schools hours only and when they have the time!

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 18/10/2023 14:19

I come from a family of teachers. In my experience most teachers hate parents (unfairly in my opinion). I think this is just another sign of how little respect teachers have for them.

Not my experience at all.

teachers don’t see you as professionals

Ummm... no. Teachers mostly have no idea whatsoever whether you are a professional (why would they?) and almost certainly the way they speak to you or address you will have nothing to do with what job you do. It almost sounds as though you think we should show more respect to professionals than to parents who aren't professionals. Do you? I teach hundreds of students. I know what job the parents of about 5 of them do, and four of those are teachers at my school!

Everydayimhuffling · 18/10/2023 09:08

@InterFactual I think that's just your family... Occasionally I feel sorry for the children of particular parents, but I certainly don't despise parents!

Everydayimhuffling · 18/10/2023 08:51

I (teacher) always give my full name on the phone and in emails because if I just call myself Everyday then how will you know what your child knows me as? I usually say "is that first name? I'mfull name. I teach child my subject " to give as much information as possible. I also mimic the parents' sign off myself. It is tricky when people put their full name and you have to guess their title though!

It's not a contempt thing though, when teachers give their teacher name: it's just making sure you know who they are.

ReadyForPumpkins · 18/10/2023 08:25

I can't be worked up about this. I hate being addressed with a title. Just call me by my name. For the teachers, I'd imagine it's because most parents don't know their first names. It's like the brownie leader calling herself brown owl. There's nothing wrong.

bakedbrain · 18/10/2023 08:22

My child's teachers use their first names but I hate it because I've got to ask (or often forget to ask) their surnames so that I know who they are in my child's version of things

frenchfries111 · 18/10/2023 08:22

DDs primary school HT used to ring up and use her first name! It was an unusual name and threw me every time.

DappledThings · 18/10/2023 08:19

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 08:14

DappledThings

Why are you faffing about in the database rather than just responding?

Because, bizarrely on a thread about teachers using a formal name to sign off, more parents get pissy if you don't use honorific then last name, and if you get the honorific wrong its a complaint straight to the head.

And just to add to some of the weird comments here, schools will have a policy about how teachers are to write and respond to emails.

Sounds like yet another bit of pointless shit teachers have to deal with. You must have the patience of saints.

And if anyone on here is one of the parents complaining about being addressed by name instead of title you need to really get over yourself.

FrippEnos · 18/10/2023 08:14

DappledThings

Why are you faffing about in the database rather than just responding?

Because, bizarrely on a thread about teachers using a formal name to sign off, more parents get pissy if you don't use honorific then last name, and if you get the honorific wrong its a complaint straight to the head.

And just to add to some of the weird comments here, schools will have a policy about how teachers are to write and respond to emails.

DivingForLove · 18/10/2023 08:04

@Mama1209 ”teachers don’t see you as professionals”

🙄

Of course we do but your role in our lives is as the child’s parent. I don’t know what a lot of my kids’ parents do for a living so I don’t give it a thought as to whether you’re “professional” or not.

DappledThings · 18/10/2023 07:57

I always reply Dear Mrs Jones but find increasingly that parents are signing off with just a first name which means I have to go into our MIS to find out if that is Mr/Miss/Mrs/Ms (in a multicultural school I’ll be honest and say that actually sometime I don’t know what gender goes with some names) and if their surname is the same as their child’s! I wish they’s all sign off in a way that means it doesn’t take me a couple of minutes clicking through a clunky MIS to find the correct salutation etc
But why? If I sign off as Dappled (and I always do because signing off as Mrs Things is weird) I'm obviously happy to be responded to as Dear Dappled. Why are you faffing about in the database rather than just responding?

spitefulandbadgrammar · 18/10/2023 07:57

I’m actually fine with being addressed as Mum or Thingy’s mum in a school context: my “job” as far as school is concerned is being Thingy’s mum, and I wouldn’t expect a teacher to memorise the names of all 30 kids’ parents.

And in the context of school, the teacher’s name is Miss/Mrs/Ms/Mr Teach. It makes sense that they use that, and I can be first name if that’s easiest.

Coffeeismyfriend1 · 18/10/2023 07:51

I always reply Dear Mrs Jones but find increasingly that parents are signing off with just a first name which means I have to go into our MIS to find out if that is Mr/Miss/Mrs/Ms (in a multicultural school I’ll be honest and say that actually sometime I don’t know what gender goes with some names) and if their surname is the same as their child’s! I wish they’s all sign off in a way that means it doesn’t take me a couple of minutes clicking through a clunky MIS to find the correct salutation etc. It becomes less of an issue with my tutor group (whose parents I’m most likely to hear from) once I’ve had them a little while and get to know their parents better but when I have a new tutor group it takes time.

Mama1209 · 17/10/2023 20:21

They are Mr / MsSmith when they are writing to you because they are in their job where all of the kids call them mr / miss. They obviously want to remain professional when it’s regarding work. I guess we as parents aren’t seen as professionals. I wouldn’t have a problem with it BUT I DO think teachers are very condescending and patronising at times. I once replied with my full professional title at the end lol

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 17/10/2023 18:50

I have a lot of children so have dealt with lots of teachers over the years and I’ve found them 85% excellent, 13% pleasant but useless and 2% rude and useless. Which is a great deal better than in most professional jobs.

Grin Thanks for that. It's quite irritating and illogical that many parents seem to expect or demand that all teachers be outstanding. I often wonder what proportion of those parents are outstanding at their jobs. By definition outstanding means you stand out.

CesareBorgia · 17/10/2023 18:45

I've noticed generally that the use of honorific/surname is dying out. People go straight to first name on calls from business to customer, for example. I don't mind it, but back in the days when I used to speak to customers on the phone, I would never have used their first name unless invited.

80skid · 17/10/2023 18:44

The bit I find odd is when they speak to another teacher in your presence and address them as Mr or Mrs.

I also find it odd that a lady I used to know in a different setting by her first name, who is now office manager at my kids school, now expects me to address her as Mrs x on the phone and by email.
I don't like being addressed as Mrs 80skid for a few reasons, one being that I feel that women who are "Miss" or "Ms" are subject to judgement about their private lives. Men's relationship status isn't given away in formal settings, and I think women should be afforded the same option of privacy. I'd definitely select Mme if it was an option!

INTERNETEXPL0RER · 17/10/2023 18:37

I have the opposite problem . Teachers from my children’s school will phone and say “ Yhis is Jane Smith, Emma’s maths teacher “ and I think “ Oh it’s Mrs Smith the scary / lovely Math teacher “.

They always address me as Mrs MychildsSurname, which is fine. I’m neither Mrs not that surname but I think they have enough to remember so I forgive then.

I have a lot of children so have dealt with lots of teachers over the years and I’ve found them 85% excellent, 13% pleasant but useless and 2% rude and useless. Which is a great deal better than in most professional jobs.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 17/10/2023 18:33

It's not a status thing. We are used to being called Mr/Ms Surname by your children, and in a way our relationship with parents is like an extension of our relationship with pupils. Kids will call their teachers Mr/Ms Surname when mentioning them at home, and so parents are often already in the habit of referring to us as Mr/Ms Surname.

Lots of parents seem quite uncomfortable at the idea of calling teachers by their first name (a hangover from their own school days maybe!). It's kind of a combination of all of that, I think. I don't call parents by their first name in person or in emails, even if they've signed off Jane Smith. I'd sign off similarly - Firstname Surname. They always carry on calling me Mrs Surname.

celticprincess · 17/10/2023 18:27

I usually just get a Hi n an email and no name. In the phone it’s is that Freddy’s mum and then I often get Mrs first and surname when they say who is calling.

what annoys me most is I sign off example celticprincess and then I get a reply Dear Celtic!! Sorry my name is NOT Celtic, o don’t shorten it, I have a complete name which I go by and by signing off with that name then I expect to be addressed by it. This is never school. This is general email enquiries I make as well as colleagues at work. I have colleagues not who know how much it annoys me as it happens in earrings when we meet new face - hi my name is Celticprincess - later in meeting - oh Celtic what is your opinion on xyz? One particular colleague will sometimes counter respond with their opinion and either agreeing or disagreeing with Celticprincess added in just to make a point.

Samelly · 17/10/2023 16:15

My name is Sam Smith so I found this post bemusing :)

Swipe left for the next trending thread