Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who left wing Jews should vote for?

155 replies

LemonyTicket · 17/10/2023 02:38

I had this chat with my adult kids tonight as as left wing Jews, we've got no idea who we will vote for.

We don't really agree with Tory economic ideas, we believe in equitable distribution of resources. We appreciate Tories are generally supportive of Jews, but find they're hostile to other minorities. Maybe I could bring myself to vote Tory if there was a milder option, like John Major, but I don't think I could vote for this lot.

We think the left is in the thralls of an antisemitic nervous breakdown to a point of being a very uncomfortable, so that's a deal breaker for us. And while we're extremely socially liberal, we think the stuff has gone a bit far and basic common sense has left the building.

Who will you be voting for?

OP posts:
GreenVelvetCushions · 18/10/2023 08:08

https://www.instagram.com/p/CyTXa5SI96n/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==

Labour look pretty supportive of Israel to me.

Angrycat2768 · 18/10/2023 07:59

Jeezypeepers · 18/10/2023 00:45

I’ve nothing sensible to add here as I’m a Scottish Jew so vote SNP/Alba/one of the other independence type parties as I really believe that’s the best way forward for Scotland; but I’m following with interest as the issues being discussed will still effect the Jewish community up here. Scotland hasn’t voted Tory in like 20 years, so we never feel represented in Westminster anyway :(

I’m really interested in what the previous Hindi poster said and why the Tories manage to ‘do’ multiculturalism so much better despite (or because?!) of their very capitalist agenda. If only we could bottle some of that and give it to Labour Confused

I am Indian and not Hindu. My background is similar to Suella Braverman, and ( I think?) I disagree with what she was saying. I am left wing too, but it does irritate me when people say all the Brown people in the Cabinet are ' traitors'.To what? Why are Black and Brown people not allowed to have an opinion based on their own background and beliefs? Do they say that Gillian Keegan is a Class traitor because she didn't go to university? Black and Brown people have agency themselves outside of their race. They can also decide for themselves what party they want to belong to without looking themselves in the mirror all the time, or because they are Uncle Tom's or Coconuts or in thrall to their colonial overloads. I think that is the difference, sadly. I do think a PP that said the Left idealise people they think should be oppressed on very Black and white lines. Black/ Brown/ Working Class oppressed, White people the oppressors. I think that does come from Marxist ideology, which was, let's face it, some wealthy middle class blokes theorising about how they were going to rely on other people ( the poor working class) to rise up and smash the system. They didn't want to dirty their hands doing it themselves. Now I think the Tories see ' people like us' and ' people not like us' rather than race, whereas Labour see PoC and think they should be 'people like us'. They see the world as they think it should be rather than how it is, and if it is not how it should be its because of ' people not like us' which include wealthy Jews and yes, Hindus. And if you are an anti immigrant Brown person, you can't be an anti immigrant Brown person. You must be oppressed into doing it. I know from my own family that many Asians are fairly right wing and, yes, anti immigrant, because Brown people arent all the same. My dad was a dyed in the wool Marxist. It was basically a dirty little secret in our family. I had to fight my mother to have that bit of his life put into his eulogy when he died because it was an embarrassment to the family, but one of my memories was standing in Brixton trying to sell the Socialist Worker with him. At his funeral his sister said ' Oh your Daddy was always ringing me and telling me not to vote Tory' when we thought he had long forgotten that part of his life. Many people of Indian origin are Islamophobic in the true sense of the word. Many people who have escaped persecution want immigration restrictions because they don't want people who persecuted them living next to them because someone who lives miles away thinks they should all get on. If 2 million Palestinians came to the UK and I was Jewish, I would not feel safe at all. That's just my morning brain dump. The previous Hindu poster may disagree from her experience.

GreenVelvetCushions · 18/10/2023 07:48

keffie12 · 18/10/2023 00:21

Exactly

Jeezypeepers · 18/10/2023 00:45

I’ve nothing sensible to add here as I’m a Scottish Jew so vote SNP/Alba/one of the other independence type parties as I really believe that’s the best way forward for Scotland; but I’m following with interest as the issues being discussed will still effect the Jewish community up here. Scotland hasn’t voted Tory in like 20 years, so we never feel represented in Westminster anyway :(

I’m really interested in what the previous Hindi poster said and why the Tories manage to ‘do’ multiculturalism so much better despite (or because?!) of their very capitalist agenda. If only we could bottle some of that and give it to Labour Confused

LemonyTicket · 18/10/2023 00:39

etmoietmoietmoi · 18/10/2023 00:36

@LemonyTicket Weirdly the explicit and obvious shite like hers doesn't upset me as much as the more insidious, subtle stuff.

Same here, the subtle stuff is far worse for me.

It's like any abuse.

Being punched in the face is horrible, but no one is going to gaslight you over it or debate that punching you in the face isn't abuse.

It's the more subtle, get in your head, DARVO nonsense that sends you mad.

There has been so much of that on Mumsnet, which shows how prevalent it is in society in general.

OP posts:
etmoietmoietmoi · 18/10/2023 00:36

@LemonyTicket Weirdly the explicit and obvious shite like hers doesn't upset me as much as the more insidious, subtle stuff.

LemonyTicket · 18/10/2023 00:33

etmoietmoietmoi · 18/10/2023 00:18

It REALLY winds me up. In fact, four days on Mumsnet shows pretty much every left wing Jew was experiencing the same and they never told that story.

YES! @LemonyTicket

Unfortunately a PP has seen our posts as some kind of green light to go full-antisemite. Hope her post doesn't get deleted - it's fucking textbook.

I enjoyed the full blown "Jews are lying cheats and are going to take money in order to do corrupt things with it and tell lies" rhetoric, but describing being Jewish as a "lifestyle choice" is hilarious to be fair!

Imagine being that big a complete fuck wit.

OP posts:
etmoietmoietmoi · 18/10/2023 00:23

We need a government over haul. There should be no money given to religious organisations from public money. Everyone should be treated equally but preferences should be given to the elderly/vulnerable and disabled as that is not a choice.

So much of your post is antisemitic but let me pick up on this - people don't choose their ethnicity. I am Jewish, but I have never practised Judaism. Do schoolkids not deserve protection? Because that's where the money is going.

jewish business get away with a lot in my area and many are breaking the law. when you complain about them nothing gets done because of the jewish influence in the council. everyone knows what is happening but if you speak out about is you get told you are anti semetic.

I have no words to describe how appalling this is, but I'm copying it into this post in the hope that if your actual post gets deleted, at lease some of it will remain so that next time a poster demands that we show evidence of left wing antisemitism, your words will be right here. Absolute textbook. @Boredoutmymind

keffie12 · 18/10/2023 00:21

I presume most of you don't realise that Keir Starmer wife is Jewish

www.google.com/amp/s/www.timesofisrael.com/uk-labour-leader-starmer-opens-up-about-his-familys-jewish-traditions/amp/

etmoietmoietmoi · 18/10/2023 00:18

It REALLY winds me up. In fact, four days on Mumsnet shows pretty much every left wing Jew was experiencing the same and they never told that story.

YES! @LemonyTicket

Unfortunately a PP has seen our posts as some kind of green light to go full-antisemite. Hope her post doesn't get deleted - it's fucking textbook.

etmoietmoietmoi · 18/10/2023 00:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I mean, your whole post is infested with antisemitism but do crack on.

LemonyTicket · 18/10/2023 00:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Your entire post is dripping with worrying antisemitism. Why have you come to this thread?

OP posts:
LemonyTicket · 18/10/2023 00:08

@etmoietmoietmoi

What genuinely fucks me off like mad is that every single newspaper, tv station, radio show etc. for years on end did NOTHING but talk about Labour antisemitism and I frankly can't remember any of them

a) explaining what antisemitism is
b) explaining what was actually happening in the Labour party

It REALLY winds me up. In fact, four days on Mumsnet shows pretty much every left wing Jew was experiencing the same and they never told that story.

I remember they pulled out the ridiculous examples: like the woman on the Panorama things who claimed she went to work at Labour HQ and every day her colleagues told her Hitler was right and hadn't gone far enough.

I mean, obviously only an imbecile would believe that happened, so why weren't they telling the real stories?

Like the things we've been through?

It shows to me that it was a convenient weapon, and the people weaponising it cared as little about Jews as the ones doing the antisemitic things did

OP posts:
Boredoutmymind · 18/10/2023 00:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Maatandosiris · 18/10/2023 00:06

Scatterbrainbox · 17/10/2023 23:02

Once people start saying things like 'he's just too stupid...' I switch off an don't expect to hear a balanced or researched view.
Totally different to the pp who is talking about the Forde report, their own experiences etc.
But I won't be convinced that anti Zionist and anti semitic are the same thing.
I have actually pulled up the Forde report as I am very interested in some of the points posters have raised.
My friends/family/ people I know through the labour party are from a diverse range of backgrounds. DH is of Sri Lankan heritage (family are Catholic but he's not particularly religious), kids mixed race, friends from a range of economic/religious/cultural backgrounds. All would identify as supporting equal rights in every sense. We do all work predominantly public sector... NHS, social care, teaching... In services that have been decimated by Tory policy and resulting in catastrophic effects for some of the people we work with. And this is probably quite typical regionally in terms of the number of people employed in public sector or disproportionately affected by Tory policy. So Tory is practically a swear word to us.
So I think that despite the issues raised up thread about lack of diversity at the top of the labour party are a big issue , it's just that there are probably other issues that have drowned that out for us.
I do feel that there is more hate directed at labour politicians from minority backgrounds...look at the treatment of Diane Abbot, David Lammy. And Angela Rayner for the crime of being working class. I don't think I have seen that directed at Tory politicians from minority backgrounds in the same way (hatred for their policies...Suella Braverman for e.g., but not their background).

The IHRA would probably disagree with you re the anti Zionism https://holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definitions-charters/working-definition-antisemitism

What is antisemitism?

About the IHRA non-legally binding working definition of antisemitism The IHRA is the only intergovernmental organization mandated to focus solely on Holocaust-related issues, so with evidence that the scourge of antisemitism is once again on the rise...

https://holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definitions-charters/working-definition-antisemitism

LemonyTicket · 18/10/2023 00:02

etmoietmoietmoi · 17/10/2023 23:30

@LemonyTicket

I thought some Jewish leaders, certainly some Rabbis, behaved badly around it.

Yes! I hardly ever hear anyone say this. I used to wince at some of them during that entire period, especially those that were pandering a bit too much to the Tories (and not just the moderates). They effectively tried to make the right look like credible and natural supporters of Jews, which is bonkers really. A certain former editor of a popular Jewish newspaper didn't cover himself in glory either in my view, but as an editor of a right leaning paper I suppose he's entitled to political bias.

From my end, the left is more antisemitic than it was before it all started

I was talking to my DH about this. He not Jewish so a different perspective obviously, but he thinks the antisemites were there all the time but I don't agree. I think repeated slogans by the far left on social media - mostly concerning Jews lying about antisemitism - whipped up so many into a tribal frenzy and encouraged them think about Jews in a way they never had before. I have never known the left to be as prejudiced about Jewish people as it is now. Social media and populism are a dangerous combination. I'm finding it terrifying if I'm being honest

Yes, I just felt people who would have opposed Corbyn regardless really milked the antisemitism and actually a lot of the most publicised cases didn't really expose the problem. Ultimately we ended up with a country who heard about "Labour antisemitism" day after day for years and none of them are the wiser about what that actually meant.

It was a weapon to stop a socialist getting into government, rather than the serious issue that it actually should have been. It really pissed me off to be honest. I couldn't understand why anyone wasn't actually talking about it and explaining what it meant - like we all have here. People could have learned a lot if there had been honest reporting.

Stuff like Jews saying they'd leave the UK if Corbyn was elected was painful. I mean, he wasn't planning to throw us in a ghetto, so if anything, that kind of hyperbole undermined the message and made it look like a joke. The truth was that whether he was elected or not made little material difference because my kids and your kids still have to deal with the antisemitism!

I think repeated slogans by the far left on social media - mostly concerning Jews lying about antisemitism - whipped up so many into a tribal frenzy and encouraged them think about Jews in a way they never had before

Absolutely this. And they have told themselves "it's not Jews, it's zionists" and they have a few Jews who agree with them to prove it.

I have never known the left to be as prejudiced about Jewish people as it is now. Social media and populism are a dangerous combination. I'm finding it terrifying if I'm being honest

Same here, we have all largely had to stop using it. It's reached a level of deranged fixation IMHO and this conflict will only make it worse!

OP posts:
Maatandosiris · 17/10/2023 23:47

grumpypedestrian · 17/10/2023 14:55

The Forde report really was quite damning in proving that Corbyn wasn’t an anti semite, it was a political tactic within the party (purposefully made worse by the media) to stop him from gaining popularity. It was a tactic to stall his campaign.

It’s disappointing that people still believe this lie.

Well you only had to look at his response to the attacks in Israel to see why people still believe it.

He is an awful man and I will be forever grateful he never made it to number 10

jlpth · 17/10/2023 23:35

I felt that at the last election, all options were atrocious. So I didn't vote.

Scatterbrainbox · 17/10/2023 23:31

JustTheOne11 · 17/10/2023 23:29

This is the point, they abhor all forms is just a sound byte. Corbyn’s LP indulged in antisemitism, they were found guilty. If you want to understand more about antisemitism, which as I’ve already stated is a distinct form of prejudice, I’m more than happy to help.

I wasn't talking about the party line. I was talking about my personal experience. As I stated. Repeatedly.

etmoietmoietmoi · 17/10/2023 23:30

@LemonyTicket

I thought some Jewish leaders, certainly some Rabbis, behaved badly around it.

Yes! I hardly ever hear anyone say this. I used to wince at some of them during that entire period, especially those that were pandering a bit too much to the Tories (and not just the moderates). They effectively tried to make the right look like credible and natural supporters of Jews, which is bonkers really. A certain former editor of a popular Jewish newspaper didn't cover himself in glory either in my view, but as an editor of a right leaning paper I suppose he's entitled to political bias.

From my end, the left is more antisemitic than it was before it all started

I was talking to my DH about this. He not Jewish so a different perspective obviously, but he thinks the antisemites were there all the time but I don't agree. I think repeated slogans by the far left on social media - mostly concerning Jews lying about antisemitism - whipped up so many into a tribal frenzy and encouraged them think about Jews in a way they never had before. I have never known the left to be as prejudiced about Jewish people as it is now. Social media and populism are a dangerous combination. I'm finding it terrifying if I'm being honest

JustTheOne11 · 17/10/2023 23:29

Scatterbrainbox · 17/10/2023 23:22

My point was that my personal experience of the left wing is that they abhor all forms of racism and I accepted that this might be because of the effects of careers choices/regional dynamics/issues that affect us most prominently too. It's ok to widen the conversation so that people understand each others experiences. Otherwise we just shout into an echo chamber which is not going to improve anything for anyone.

Edited

This is the point, they abhor all forms is just a sound byte. Corbyn’s LP indulged in antisemitism, they were found guilty. If you want to understand more about antisemitism, which as I’ve already stated is a distinct form of prejudice, I’m more than happy to help.

Scatterbrainbox · 17/10/2023 23:25

LemonyTicket · 17/10/2023 23:23

I don't think they support them.

I think they romanticise them.

I think it's hard to accept what they actually want is quite far from the equal rights, liberty, life and freedom of the average western lefties imagination

I don't know anyone who sees Hamas in any positive light at all to be fair, but I accept that is anecdotal.
You do use very emotive language 'average western leftie's imagination'. It really undermines you when you might be making a valid point. It's very dismissive of anyone who isn't exactly the same as you...that their opinion must be the product of a fanciful imagination. It's quite arrogant.

LemonyTicket · 17/10/2023 23:23

Scatterbrainbox · 17/10/2023 23:14

I agree about the idealist outlook. Although I still choose idealism over prejudice.
I am very uncomfortable with the example given being about Hamas(who are abhorrent btw) as though left wingers routinely support them (not something I have come across either), the fact that I disapprove of the actions Israeli government doesn't mean I support Hamas and I am sure that is a widely held sentiment. I have massive frustration with both parties and my main concern is for the civilians caught up in it either way.
I think the right stumble at times in assuming that people wanting to find a peaceful way forward are pathetically naive, I know we can't have a perfect situation but we can strive for a better one than there is at present (in situations around the world).

I don't think they support them.

I think they romanticise them.

I think it's hard to accept what they actually want is quite far from the equal rights, liberty, life and freedom of the average western lefties imagination

OP posts:
Scatterbrainbox · 17/10/2023 23:22

JustTheOne11 · 17/10/2023 23:17

This is about antisemitism, quite a distinct form of racism. Look it up

My point was that my personal experience of the left wing is that they abhor all forms of racism and I accepted that this might be because of the effects of careers choices/regional dynamics/issues that affect us most prominently too. It's ok to widen the conversation so that people understand each others experiences. Otherwise we just shout into an echo chamber which is not going to improve anything for anyone.

JustTheOne11 · 17/10/2023 23:17

Scatterbrainbox · 17/10/2023 23:02

Once people start saying things like 'he's just too stupid...' I switch off an don't expect to hear a balanced or researched view.
Totally different to the pp who is talking about the Forde report, their own experiences etc.
But I won't be convinced that anti Zionist and anti semitic are the same thing.
I have actually pulled up the Forde report as I am very interested in some of the points posters have raised.
My friends/family/ people I know through the labour party are from a diverse range of backgrounds. DH is of Sri Lankan heritage (family are Catholic but he's not particularly religious), kids mixed race, friends from a range of economic/religious/cultural backgrounds. All would identify as supporting equal rights in every sense. We do all work predominantly public sector... NHS, social care, teaching... In services that have been decimated by Tory policy and resulting in catastrophic effects for some of the people we work with. And this is probably quite typical regionally in terms of the number of people employed in public sector or disproportionately affected by Tory policy. So Tory is practically a swear word to us.
So I think that despite the issues raised up thread about lack of diversity at the top of the labour party are a big issue , it's just that there are probably other issues that have drowned that out for us.
I do feel that there is more hate directed at labour politicians from minority backgrounds...look at the treatment of Diane Abbot, David Lammy. And Angela Rayner for the crime of being working class. I don't think I have seen that directed at Tory politicians from minority backgrounds in the same way (hatred for their policies...Suella Braverman for e.g., but not their background).

This is about antisemitism, quite a distinct form of racism. Look it up