Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not see the difference between saving and inheritance?

242 replies

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:00

If you were planning a fairly expensive holiday with a partner, and you’d agreed to save the money for it, but when it came time to book and pay Partner A revealed that they hadn’t saved anything and would use gifted money from a recent birthday to pay their half, would you be annoyed?

I can’t understand the difference between saving and spending money I have been gifted, but I’ve really upset my husband.

For various reasons we have separate savings accounts so he wasn’t aware that I hadn’t “saved” my half from my salary.

OP posts:
Kitkatfiend31 · 16/10/2023 22:02

Khvdrt · 16/10/2023 21:17

There’s a lack of honesty here that would bother me. Also DH and I have fairly separate money but if I had money come to me in the way you describe I’d use it to pay towards our holiday as a whole and then we each pay more rather than watch him save money and use it for my part

I think this is a good point. You're attitude towards money is a bit self centred. He is annoyed because you have again shown him you can't save. Being bailed out all the time doesn't make you look like an adult in control of their finances. I'd be worried for the future if I was him.

Charlingspont · 16/10/2023 22:00

Lougle · 16/10/2023 21:10

I guess if I had sacrificed my standard of living to save my share and a DP just plucked it out of savings, when we both agreed to save for it over time, it would feel a bit jarring.

^This.

Ponderingwindow · 16/10/2023 22:00

If you had used a bit of
birthday cash that had recently come tucked in a card it wouldn’t be an issue.

Money in your trust is your savings. Not only didn’t you save, you dipped into your existing savings.

BananaSquiggle · 16/10/2023 22:00

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:15

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist I do live within my means though. That’s the discrepancy - he would like me to live within smaller means.

“I have on one previous occasion failed to save what I had claimed I would for a very big purchase and was given some of the rest of the money by my surviving parent, and he covered the rest of my shortfall of the half”. That’s not living within your means.

“he thinks I’m spoiled and can’t save money”. Sorry but it sounds like he’s right. Maybe try to change that?

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:59

@Dotcheck I take all that on board, thank you. I guess where I feel irritated or like something is unfair is that his financial outlook comes from an extreme place, just like mine, and has created what some people would definitely think of as an unhealthy attitude to money, like mine. I’m absolutely not the only one causing a problem and making us not a team - he is the one who refuses to pool money in the way I want, and has refused offers by me to match his private pension to what I have.

OP posts:
Libraryloiterer · 16/10/2023 21:59

I can really, really relate to your partner. As someone who grew up with a lot of financial instability it leaves you with an indelible sense of anxiety around money - no matter how successful you go on to be in later life.

I couldn't be with someone who was unpredictable and a bit spendthrift in their approach to finances, no matter how reliable their income streams. That's not to say you're wrong, you're just playing the hand life dealt you, but you do sound fundamentally incompatible. Your disparaging comment about him having a chip on his shoulder is proof of this.

HowAmYa · 16/10/2023 21:58

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:53

@HowAmYa I’d like us both to change our attitudes a bit, really.

But will you?

You haven't thus far. Neither has he.

I think the issue here is neither of you are really wrong but on the face of it, if we talk about being honest, committed and sensible, then that's something you haven't been in this particular incident. I think it shows a total lack of care and control that you didn't bother saving, where he did. No matter how much you earn you have to make a choice to NOT so certain things or buy certain things to be able to save that money. All you've done is shown that you're not willing to sacrifice ANYTHING at all to pay for a family venture. You use money thats coming to you anyway.

He probably doesn't want to share finances because he's probably worried you'll burn through it like you do your own money.

This is how I personally would see it.

LizzieSiddal · 16/10/2023 21:57

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:47

Thanks for all the thoughts so far, they’re interesting. Really would be interested to hear from anyone who has a spouse with a vastly different financial background. When you got married did you feel your finances were joint? I did feel like that, or I wanted to, but my husband does not. It’s starting to feel like a problem, but I’m not sure which of us is wrong?

He doesn’t want to have joint finances because he doesn’t trust you with money. Prove to him you can save up, instead of relying on it coming “down the line”, and he may well trust you enough to join finances.

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:53

@HowAmYa I’d like us both to change our attitudes a bit, really.

OP posts:
Dotcheck · 16/10/2023 21:52

If you have thing coming ‘down the line’ it means you don’t have them.

Look, perhaps you both do have a solid safety net which is in your possession, and shared by both of you. Or maybe you are happy to speculate while he isn’t.

I think there are a few issues ( and I’m not having a go!).
You have different early experiences with money. This is fundamental- you cannot expect him to feel comfortable with spending. I wonder if you could have some couples therapy so you can understand each other better? This is not a surface issue, it is deep.

In his position, I would feel like I couldn’t trust you, that we weren’t a team if you don’t stick with the original plan. It would highlight the inequality, which again would make me feel insecure. It’s disrespectful.

OP it is really unfair to write off his concerns by saying he’s the child of a single parent and he’s jealous. That seems to give you a get out of jail card to do as you please.

Can you genuinely not see that your attitude toward money , and changing the goalposts reads as not pulling with him as a team?

He has lived for many years on a financial precipice, so may never feel safe. You have had layers of protection, so may not recognise when you are being reckless.
You guys need to find a way to meet in the middle.

minipie · 16/10/2023 21:51

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 16/10/2023 21:16

I'm not sure you recognise what he's seeing when you keep doing this. He's looking into your future, and seeing a life where you are never, ever able to save. Your parent won't always be there to bail you out, and if you never save you will continue to burn through money with your expensive hobbies etc. That isn't a good quality in a life partner.

This.

Also someone who lies.

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:50

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist This isn’t a fair representation. I have various things that are mine and are in my name that I will get access to along the line. They are guaranteed. Plus the inheritance I got when I was younger. The “bail outs” from my other parent and the inheritance they hope to give me when they die is not guaranteed, I agree

OP posts:
HowAmYa · 16/10/2023 21:50

There is an absolute heaven and earth difference in how you both view money. Not a good sign.

You'll NEVER change your blasé attitude towards saving. And he will NEVER stop being frugal.
Where do you go from there?

These things only cause resentment in both sides over the years that builds and builds until there is a break down and a break up. Personally, id see this is as a major incompatibility. You gotta think about whether you want to live with someone like this and he should think the same. Sounds harsh but trust me, financial are one of the biggest causes of break ups.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 16/10/2023 21:48

You're spending freely, kidding yourself that you live within your means because you count your parents bailouts as being "your means". Your future plans are all built on money that isn’t actually yours yet.

While he is, quite sensibly, making sure that he can support himself independently without debt or bailouts.

It's a really fundamental incompatibility, and then you were dishonest on top of that. You lied to your partner about money, which is a big issue.

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:47

Thanks for all the thoughts so far, they’re interesting. Really would be interested to hear from anyone who has a spouse with a vastly different financial background. When you got married did you feel your finances were joint? I did feel like that, or I wanted to, but my husband does not. It’s starting to feel like a problem, but I’m not sure which of us is wrong?

OP posts:
Malarandras · 16/10/2023 21:47

But you said you were saving for something and you were not. So it sounds like you lied. That’s the big deal for your husband, I am guessing. That and you have a completely different view on money than him - money ranks right up there with sex in a relationship. If you don’t share the same view on these issues the chances of your relationship working is slim I think.

NutellaEllaElla · 16/10/2023 21:43

I know it's a bit of a stereotype to suggest counselling, but I do wonder if you guys would benefit from it. You have some peculiarities in how you approach money, with your approach sounding like (frankly) you're loaded and never have to worry about it running out, whereas he sounds like he is saving to fund his own lifestyle and future. These different approaches don't tally in one relationship. You know inequality in a relationship is corrosive. One person can't be more well off than the other, it builds resentment and causes endless day to day difficulties. If you're married then you are both as rich as each other and need to get on the same page.

LizzieSiddal · 16/10/2023 21:43

@Raincloudsonasunnyday Really where you’re being U is (1) in resting on your laurels (2) being so disdainful of someone who knows penury or hardship when you don’t. You sound like you sick and dive because you know there will always be more. That’s an EXTREMELY unattractive quality in a person.

Agree with this!

My dh had money issues when we first got together. He did prove to me he’s changed drastically, if he hadn’t I’d have been off!

LolaSmiles · 16/10/2023 21:42

I suspect he's upset about this particular situation because you said you would save, but actually you've spent and then got yet another bail-out from another source
I agree with this.

Different attitudes to money is often a major contributor in relationships ending. You're not wrong in your outlook and he isn't wrong in his. You don't sound financially compatible though.

I suspect that part of the problem is that this is yet another situation where you've not saved because some money will appear from somewhere, and then there's some dishonesty as well because he was under the impression you were saving but you haven't.

nocoolnamesleft · 16/10/2023 21:40

I'm not surprised he doesn't want to merge finances, you'd quickly spend his savings too. Due to your "fortunate" upbringing you don't seem to have the concept of the value of money.

LizzieSiddal · 16/10/2023 21:40

So you have a history of not saving for a “significant” purchase and he had to bail you out? No wonder he’s pissed off with you. You broke his trust and you still haven’t proved to him that you can save for a joint purchase.

You say you’ve got money “coming down the line” but what if something happens and you don’t get that money? Unless it’s in your bank account now you shouldn’t be relying on it.

Show your H you can save so he can stop worrying about him having to bail you out again.

Retrievemysanity · 16/10/2023 21:40

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable. If you’re both paying 50/50 for a holiday it really doesn’t matter where your share comes from. If you have joint finances then that’s different but it sounds like he wants to control how you save and spend even though it’s separate which isn’t on in my opinion.

Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic · 16/10/2023 21:39

Maybe you should go on Ramit Sethi’s I Will Teach You To Be Rich podcast!!!

Or…get your partner to listen to some of the episodes on people who are still
living with a scarcity mindset.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 16/10/2023 21:39

The dilemma posed in your OP is a complete red herring. The choice isn’t between using savings and using inheritance money. It’s between spending and saving.

In a couple, attitude towards money is just as important as attitude towards sex. There’s no right or wrong. There’s just compatible and incompatible. You’re not compatible. Some people think like you. Some people think like your DH.

Really where you’re being U is (1) in resting on your laurels (2) being so disdainful of someone who knows penury or hardship when you don’t. You sound like you sick and dive because you know there will always be more. That’s an EXTREMELY unattractive quality in a person.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/10/2023 21:38

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:26

Just to be super clear - I have offered to pay for things from my inheritance and other money for us both on lots of occasions. I have tried to pool our savings and suggested lots of ways of doing this. It’s my husband who refuses and wants to stay 50/50.

I personally believe this attitude from him
is what causes a lot of my spending - I don’t need to save for me, and he doesn’t want us to have fully joint money, so I don’t see the point. I’ve tried to have this conversation with him.

He's hardly forcing your hand onto the keyboard to buy clothes, shoes, handbags, pressing Starbucks into your hand or dragging you bodily into salons, gyms, jewellers, car showrooms or IKEA now, is he?

You are making the decision to spunk money (no wonder he doesn't want to blend finances - you'd burn through that as well) on the assumption that your parents, both living and deceased, will come through and bail you out as though you've spent your lunch money on fifteen bags of Haribo and a copy of Cosmo Teen and started complaining you're hungry on Wednesday at break.

You're behaving like a child - including blaming him for you behaving as though he's a boring, mean and stingy Dad when you can always get your own way by sounding all sad in front of your actual parent.