Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not see the difference between saving and inheritance?

242 replies

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:00

If you were planning a fairly expensive holiday with a partner, and you’d agreed to save the money for it, but when it came time to book and pay Partner A revealed that they hadn’t saved anything and would use gifted money from a recent birthday to pay their half, would you be annoyed?

I can’t understand the difference between saving and spending money I have been gifted, but I’ve really upset my husband.

For various reasons we have separate savings accounts so he wasn’t aware that I hadn’t “saved” my half from my salary.

OP posts:
Livingoncaffeine · 16/10/2023 22:52

Yeah me and DH have separate money to some extent but any trust funds etc (not that we are lucky enough to have them would be pooled). He’s basically sacrificed his disposable income to save for a holiday whereas you haven’t had to. I’m usually all for independence in a marriage but that doesn’t sit quite right with me

EllieQ · 16/10/2023 22:49

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:09

He didn’t expect I would do anything else with it apart from keep it in the investment.

I suppose to be totally transparent there’s some backstory here - I’m a spender but I’m an only child from wealthy parents, one of whom died when I was young, so I have always been “bailed out” and had money coming to me for things. He’s the child of a single mother and literally grew up with nothing. It makes savings stuff complicated - he thinks I’m spoiled and can’t save money and I think he’s jealous with a chip on his shoulder. I have on one previous occasion failed to save what I had claimed I would for a very big purchase and was given some of the rest of the money by my surviving parent, and he covered the rest of my shortfall of the half. But to be very clear - I’m not in debt, I earn my own salary (slightly more than him) and we pay 50/50 on everything.

When you say ‘he covered the rest of my shortfall on the half’ - do you mean your parent or your DH?

I’d be annoyed if I had to bail out my DH because he hadn’t saved money that he’d said he would save!

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 22:49

@laclochette I think yours might be the best answer I’ve ever read on here. Very balanced and helpful. I’m going to think about a lot that you’ve said.

OP posts:
vibecheck · 16/10/2023 22:47

LizzieSiddal · 16/10/2023 22:37

If you have all this money why did he have to bail you out? And how much did he bail you out for?

Edited

It was around £3000, at the time I didn’t have access to most of the money I have now as I wasn’t yet 25. We agreed not to ask my living parent for more money than they had already given us and he would pay the remainder of our balance (it was for our wedding).

OP posts:
saraclara · 16/10/2023 22:46

titchy · 16/10/2023 22:31

Because your respective efforts are hugely unequal. And you don't really want to understand his pov or move an inch towards him. It's all what YOU want.

He knows the value of money, and the benefit of working hard towards something, of both of you having a shared goal and working and sacrificing equally towards that. You don't. You're an adult who goes to mummy/daddy when you want a shared goal. At which point it is no longer something shared.

Exactly that.

saraclara · 16/10/2023 22:45

I just think it’s completely unreasonable. I can’t really understand why someone would feel like that, I know I wouldn’t.

You might well do had you had the life experience that he had. Can't you see that? You can't say what you would definitely not do, when your life is so fundamentally different from his.

You're glossing over your earlier accusation that he's jealous. I don't see it at all. For goodness sake, he could have sponged off you forever, but instead he's not let you top up his pension etc, because he has some self respect.

Your attitude to money is SO casual and confident, like you simply don't need to give it a thought. That must be maddening to him. You are able to be so thoughtless about money because you have this money tree that you're able to take for granted. He just sees you being irresponsible and is really frustrated.
You're really not seeing his point or empathising with his life experience at all.

largeprintagathachristie · 16/10/2023 22:38

I’d recognise I was being a bit unreasonable but I would feel the same as him.

LizzieSiddal · 16/10/2023 22:37

If you have all this money why did he have to bail you out? And how much did he bail you out for?

Womencanlift · 16/10/2023 22:35

It is the in the way I want that stood out for me from that post of yours

Why should the financial side of your relationship only be on your terms?

laclochette · 16/10/2023 22:33

Ooh this is complicated and as others have said I think it is a microcosm of wider issues.

Looking at this from a pure accountancy perspective, ultimately you both agreed to contribute your fair share. I'm not sure it matters where that share comes from unless you have spent money you had told him was earmarked for another purpose, for example. It's interesting that you both agreed to SAVE for it rather than simply to PAY for it. I wonder why that was?

I do not come from wealth but I have a (weirdly large!) number of friends who do and ultimately their income from things like trusts is another source of income, just like a salary. It's a totally different way of being in the world / with money, I think, to people who are used to income equalling salary. A bit more akin to how people think of income from a pension, to compare it to something more people are familiar with.

But ultimately this speaks perhaps to a bigger issue, whereby his financial security and spending power has always had to rest entirely on his own hard work and prudence/sacrifice, whereas yours hasn't. It's hard not to feel resentful about that sort of thing in his position, and I don't think it makes someone a bad person if they feel that way.

On top of this, as others have said, he might be looking at this as an example of your wider inability to save. If he's seeing this as part of a general and perhaps future pattern of behaviour then it makes his reaction more understandable, given his personal history with money.

Equally, in his position, I might wonder why you hadn't used that windfall to put towards your shared costs of the trip, leaving you both with half the amount to fund out of personal savings. You are married after all. Shouldn't you share life's financial upsides and downsides equally?

Can you ask him to unpack why he's upset? It might be worth undergoing some joint counselling, as others have said, as there's usually a lot of complex emotional dynamics around money and this could be beneficial to your relationship long-term.

Thelnebriati · 16/10/2023 22:33

You have such different attitudes towards money and saving, would you consider relationship counselling?

titchy · 16/10/2023 22:31

Because your respective efforts are hugely unequal. And you don't really want to understand his pov or move an inch towards him. It's all what YOU want.

He knows the value of money, and the benefit of working hard towards something, of both of you having a shared goal and working and sacrificing equally towards that. You don't. You're an adult who goes to mummy/daddy when you want a shared goal. At which point it is no longer something shared.

Lougle · 16/10/2023 22:30

For me, the issue would be trust. If you had no intention of saving, you should have said "Happy to go on holiday but will use my savings to fund my half." But instead, you agreed with his wishes "We should both save" then didn't.

From your OP, you didn't save anything. It wasn't a case of misjudging how much to save, or getting a few too many Costa Coffees so having to dip into savings to make up the shortfall. You didn't even make the effort to do what you said you'd do.

To me, if you say you'll do x, you should do x. A stupid example: I told DH that I didn't feel too good tonight, so he offered to cook macaroni cheese for dinner. I was grateful. When it was almost done, DH mentioned that 250g of pasta probably wasn't enough. I was confused and asked why he'd only cooked 250g of pasta. He told me that the dinosaur pasta bag only had 250g in it. I was pretty annoyed. I didn't want dinosaur pasta (thanks, teen DDs!!). He had said he'd make macaroni cheese and that was what I agreed to, and what I was expecting. He shifted the goal posts without telling me. Yes, it was still pasta, but it wasn't macaroni and macaroni cheese isn't macaroni cheese without macaroni.

I see your situation as the same. You changed the goal posts and told your DH that his wish that you put the same effort into your holiday wasn't important to you.

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 22:28

And to add - he’s been happy to accept certain things that come from my money, like our home or the private healthcare I pay for for both of us. It just feels like for things like this holiday which he now says he won’t go on that he’s doing something to deliberately make our lives less nice for no good reason.

OP posts:
vibecheck · 16/10/2023 22:26

@titchy @Womencanlift I’m sorry, I really don’t understand what I’ve done wrong there?

All I have ever wanted to do is share our money. Our house is bought with money from “me” but is in our name and always has been, even pre-marriage. As I said, I have tried to pay the same amount into his private pension as is in mine so we’re equal on that front, I have suggested we pool our savings and my investments so everything is in both our names and we both have equal access. What am I doing wrong in saying that him not wanting to do that holds us back from being a team just as much as me?

OP posts:
Womencanlift · 16/10/2023 22:20

titchy · 16/10/2023 22:08

I’m absolutely not the only one causing a problem and making us not a team - he is the one who refuses to pool money in the way I want

Wow - reread that OP - you're blaming him for not doing what YOU want! You are causing a problem.

Oh I missed this little bit of insight. Wow OP I thought you were being unreasonable before, now I think you are very unreasonable

If this is genuine of course

Dotcheck · 16/10/2023 22:18

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:59

@Dotcheck I take all that on board, thank you. I guess where I feel irritated or like something is unfair is that his financial outlook comes from an extreme place, just like mine, and has created what some people would definitely think of as an unhealthy attitude to money, like mine. I’m absolutely not the only one causing a problem and making us not a team - he is the one who refuses to pool money in the way I want, and has refused offers by me to match his private pension to what I have.

It does sound like you are both operating from extremes!

Womencanlift · 16/10/2023 22:17

I am actually very surprised you have got as far as marriage when you such fundamental differences when it comes to money. Financial compatibility is imo one of the most important factors when it comes to a successful relationship

I don’t mean always bringing in the same amount of money to the pot, but more that both people are on the same page when it comes to saving vs spending

Your husband is being very sensible in keeping money separate as he likely always has it in the back of his mind that the future windfalls that you seem to be relying on are not always guaranteed and so he is protecting his own financial security, very likely because of his background/history

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/10/2023 22:13

I don’t really know tbh!

I think you should probably have saved from your salary if you said you were going to. And still have the only money in the bank for later in life, I guess.

Youve got to come to an agreement both of you are comfortable with.

SD1978 · 16/10/2023 22:12

And I would not ever combine finances with you- because you demonstrated repeatedly that you can't be trusted or responsible with money. Wouldn't mean I didn't love you (as a partner) but I wouldn't trust you not to fritter away everything because that's what you're used to. I couldn't combine finances with someone I didn't fiscally trust either.

SD1978 · 16/10/2023 22:10

Yes I would- but I'd be annoyed by your general attitude. You could save, you chose not to, and have assumption/ back up that you'll always be bailed out. You were supposed to save for this holiday and didn't. You don't have any savings, despite being capable of having them financially because you know someone will always give it to you. The attitude would irk me too.

nocoolnamesleft · 16/10/2023 22:08

Ponderingwindow · 16/10/2023 22:00

If you had used a bit of
birthday cash that had recently come tucked in a card it wouldn’t be an issue.

Money in your trust is your savings. Not only didn’t you save, you dipped into your existing savings.

I think that's a very good way of explaining it.

titchy · 16/10/2023 22:08

I’m absolutely not the only one causing a problem and making us not a team - he is the one who refuses to pool money in the way I want

Wow - reread that OP - you're blaming him for not doing what YOU want! You are causing a problem.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 16/10/2023 22:06

vibecheck · 16/10/2023 21:59

@Dotcheck I take all that on board, thank you. I guess where I feel irritated or like something is unfair is that his financial outlook comes from an extreme place, just like mine, and has created what some people would definitely think of as an unhealthy attitude to money, like mine. I’m absolutely not the only one causing a problem and making us not a team - he is the one who refuses to pool money in the way I want, and has refused offers by me to match his private pension to what I have.

With this post, you’ve demonstrated that you know the price of things, but not their value.

Your partner is right. He should remain financially separate from you.

titchy · 16/10/2023 22:05

It’s starting to feel like a problem, but I’m not sure which of us is wrong?

Neither of you is right or wrong. You need to reframe that - that's immediately suggesting one of you is to blame.

Though you saying you spend because of his attitude to money is rather childish and very unfair to him. You're supposed to be equals, you're not supposed to put him in the position of being the parent to your child. Think about it - is that what you're doing?