Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister demands half the profit from the sale of the house after not paying for 16 years.

212 replies

TheBorgPrincess · 16/10/2023 20:50

Usual disclaimer- all names have been changed for privacy.

I (41F) bought a house with my younger sister Claudia (34F) 17 years ago (2006). Both our names went on the Mortgage at my parent’s behest. To make Claudia ‘Feel grown up’ and perhaps she would be inclined ‘to take the bills seriously’. As was earning more money than her at the time, we agreed that I would pay two thirds of all bills and Claudia would pay the remainder. (Somewhere in all the paperwork, I do remember ticking a box that said Tenants in common and not tenants in Law. Which I believe recognises an uneven split in ownership?)
Anyway, after 9 months of living together and after a silly argument about the washing up. Claudia packed up her things and left to go back home and live with our parents. I really don’t think she could afford her share of the bills and didn’t like spending her money on living essentials. Claudia promptly handed her key over to our dad and nothing was discussed or agreed. Our relationship was slightly fractured after this, but we remained cordial at family gatherings.
I really struggled to afford the bills on my own at first, but by taking a second job and knuckling down at work I earned a promotion and was soon comfortably able to afford everything with a decent quality of life.
Skip to 10 years later and Claudia is in a relationship with Matt. Matt ‘Flips houses’ for profit. Selling some and renting out others. He’s made a successful business out of this. Out of the blue I receive a scathing text message from Claudia demanding I remortgage immediately to take her name off the mortgage. From what I understand Matt had maxed out the amount of properties he could get with just his name and wanted to start using Claudia’s. She states that she doesn’t want to be bought out, just her name taking off the mortgage. She’ll even help pay for the legal fees. I get to own 100% of the house, she gets to build a property empire with Matt. Win-Win! Off I trot to a Mortgage advisor and explain the situation and there’s a few options- I just need to get the house valued. I pay my fee. Alas, the house is in negative equity! The mortgage advisor completely vanishes in the ether, doesn’t return my calls. I get a nasty text message from Claudia (GOD! I wish I’d kept these!) that she’s going to get a solicitor involved and force me to sell the house at a loss. I was absolutely heartbroken at the thought of being forced to give up my cute little house and my home of over a decade. I really didn’t what to do. My Parents aren't much help- they just shrug their shoulders. A few months later Claudia and Matt split up- all goes quiet, and I breathe a sigh of relief.
Fast forward another 5 years. I get offered a fantastic job opportunity BUT it involves a relocation ASAP! The company I work for offers to pay for a full relocation package- the whole she-bang plus they’ll pay for rent on a house for 6 months close to where I need to be so I have chance to sell my house.
No takers. The Estate agent recommend renting it out. It’s in a great location if you commute and it’s close to a lot of amenities, the area has had a bit of gentrification. It’s barely on the rental market for 24hrs before It’s snapped up. I rent it out for just enough to cover the mortgage and the landlord insurance, hoping it’s an investment for further down the line.
So, to be clear I try to sell the house – Claudia is aware but is not interested. I rent the house out- Claudia is aware but not interested and makes no comment on the situation.
4 years ago, the tenants stop paying rent (Just scumbags, but that’s a whole other story). After a lengthy year long battle which nearly broke me mentally and financially-They tried every trick in the book. I secure a successful eviction order and after the bailiffs have kicked them out, I am left with a completely trashed house. It was disgusting. Claudia is aware of this and makes no comment. My parents after seeing me struggle financially help me with the costs of a quick whitewash, several tip runs and a professional deep clean so I can get it back on the market to sell.

For the past year I had to pay both the mortgage and my own household bills. There’s just my wage, as a single person in a Cost-of-Living Crisis. I’ve blown all my savings, maxed out my credit card and had to take a loan out to make ends meet. I was hoping that the proceeds of the sale would allow me to pay everything off, get me a new car and a modest deposit on another house.

In what feels like the only good news of 2023. I have a buyer for the house. I didn’t quite get what I wanted, but I can’t afford to go on like this any longer. I want rid and quick.

Claudia is now asking about how much her share of the profit is, and how much is left on the mortgage. To be quite clear she hasn’t paid a penny towards the upkeep or mortgage of that house for over 16 YEARS! I am shocked but not surprised by the sheer audacity. Somebody has whispered in her ear that as her name is still on the mortgage she’s entitled to HALF of the profits from the sale! I have also found out that she’s taken out a large loan (for a boob job) stating that she is a property owner. My parents don’t want to get involved. They don’t want to come between sisters! My Mother hints that I should take pity on her as she’s now a single mother of two, while my dad thinks I should get legal advice and try to fight her in court.

Is there anything I can do? Or is it more fool me for not remortgaging sooner? She’s set foot in the house twice in the 16 years since she left, and apart from when she was in a relationship with Matt hasn’t said anything and was quite happy to let me keep her credit score nice and high as I’ve never missed a payment. I’m worried that if she doesn’t get her own way she’ll refuse to sign for the sale of the house.

OP posts:
DotAndCarryOne2 · 22/10/2023 15:15

EsmeSusanOgg · 21/10/2023 22:38

Do you have proof she has paid none of her share of bills/ upkeep? Age owes you whatever percentage her share would be. That can be deducted from any profit she would derive as repayment of a loan (effectively). But that may not be too easy to argue in court. Get advice from a solicitor.

I'd also suggest that, if your mum is keen for you not to pursue, she ponies up the money that you will lose.

Nope. Unless there is a clear agreement to something other than a 50/50 split of the profits there is nothing that can be done. Sharing bills/mortgage is irrelevant when it comes to how the property is owned and in this case it’s a 50/50 split after selling costs are covered.

EsmeSusanOgg · 21/10/2023 22:38

Do you have proof she has paid none of her share of bills/ upkeep? Age owes you whatever percentage her share would be. That can be deducted from any profit she would derive as repayment of a loan (effectively). But that may not be too easy to argue in court. Get advice from a solicitor.

I'd also suggest that, if your mum is keen for you not to pursue, she ponies up the money that you will lose.

prh47bridge · 21/10/2023 22:28

Lupita123 · 21/10/2023 19:35

Seriously, there is a load of rubbish in these comments, you need to speak to a solicitor as many have said. There is definitely case law relating to proof of payments of mortgage/towards house costs and having an impact on any entitlement. I remember this coming up in my Property law modules, I just don't recall the details as it was a long time ago and I don't feel it appropriate to offer 'of course' advice on matters I am not qualified to advise on!! Your parents haven't helped the situation at all

Such case law relates to instances where the house is owned by one person and their ex-partner is trying to establish an entitlement to a slice of the house. That is not the case here. The house is jointly owned. Absent any evidence of an agreement for a different split, OP and her sister are each entitled to 50% of the proceeds from any sale after the costs of sale are deducted.

Coco1379 · 21/10/2023 21:53

The profits will be what is left after your expenses are taken out. You can show your expenses and share what is left. It’s a pity you didn’t get this settled at the time, but that doesn’t help now.
My brother, sister and I had a similar arrangement but my contribution was less than theirs so it was no problem that I recieved less. BUT when our mother died they were executors and not only took more money than they were entitled to under the will, but robbed the estate blind. I haven’t received the legacy I was due nor the residual entitlement and I’ve lost £18k. It just goes to show you should never trust family arrangements.

Lupita123 · 21/10/2023 19:35

Seriously, there is a load of rubbish in these comments, you need to speak to a solicitor as many have said. There is definitely case law relating to proof of payments of mortgage/towards house costs and having an impact on any entitlement. I remember this coming up in my Property law modules, I just don't recall the details as it was a long time ago and I don't feel it appropriate to offer 'of course' advice on matters I am not qualified to advise on!! Your parents haven't helped the situation at all

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 21/10/2023 18:39

If you read the OP it is obvious that her sister is on the deeds. As they are tenants in common, this will be recorded in the title deeds held at the land registry.

jrc1071 · 21/10/2023 18:25

You need to speak with an attorney, because if her name is on the deed, by law, you will need to split the profit.

If her name is not on the deed, deduct all the costs for maintenance/tax/upkeep/management plus the mortgage payments from her half she did not make and whatever’s left from that then she can have it. And obviously those deductions swing into your column.

Jojofjo44 · 21/10/2023 16:47

She's entitled to your original agreement I'm afraid. Stick with your solicitors advice.

Imaginemissmarple · 21/10/2023 10:48

Poor you, so stressful, your sister sounds selfish and materialistic.

if you add up all of the costs over the 16 years including the repairs, mortgage payments, eviction coasts, you could argue she needs to pay half in return for half of the asset gain, you don’t say how much the latter is but based on new car/Deposit then I am assuming the 50% of costs could wipe the gain?

Mrsgreen100 · 20/10/2023 09:18

To be fair , it would be a plan to allow the half share of mortgage she paid solo on your behalf when you stopped paying,
profit is a whole other matter
mad without your joint initial investment
and joint ownership there wouldn’t be a flat

timesaretight · 19/10/2023 20:04

Did you read the post through?

EarringsandLipstick · 19/10/2023 16:13

This is a message board right and not a legal forum? Or am I mistaken

It is. But regardless of any legal knowledge, you must realise your advice (treat sister like a bitch, ensure she gets nothing) is poor and not going to actually be possible. Surely?

Quitelikeit · 19/10/2023 15:24

I said she could try telling her sister if she wants half the profit would she mind paying back half of the costs?!

I didn’t say she legally had to!

Honestly you are actually making stuff up - are you ok?

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 19/10/2023 15:00

No, because you said "Tell her if she wants a shard then she needs to back pay you half of the costs you incurred during the 16 years"

The (fictional) OP has no legal right to place conditions on her (fictional) sister before deciding how much her sister would receive. And it wouldn't be the OP divvying up the proceeds regardless - it would be the conveyancer, who would do it in accordance with legal ownership in the absence of any ruling to the contrary.

Quitelikeit · 19/10/2023 14:17

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist

why because I said a judge wouldn’t award her half?

pollymere · 19/10/2023 11:43

I would treat it like a divorce. You need to detail everything you've paid into the house, including receipts if possible. Document as much as possible. If you've evidence of what your sister paid in, great. I would suspect she is entitled to what she paid in PLUS 50% on top of whatever profit has been made on the house. However, if you have spent money on improvements and cleaning etc that should be offset against that profit as added value. What was it worth after being trashed for example? Any valuation after this would be yours for fixing the problem.

Your Dad is right that you need to get a solicitor pronto. A few letters will probably be sufficient rather than it needing to go to court.

Lattims83 · 19/10/2023 10:41

EarringsandLipstick · 19/10/2023 09:54

How helpful. 🙄

This is a message board right and not a legal forum? Or am I mistaken?

Ilovecleaning · 19/10/2023 10:05

EarringsandLipstick · 19/10/2023 07:27

Well, why is anyone's first port of call MN? 🤷🏻‍♀️

For almost any situation here there's an 'expert' out there from home to relationship, medical to legal matters - but posters still post here for advice as it's accessible, easy & a first port of call.

Yes, you do have a point. I just hope the OP gets the professional advice she needs.

EarringsandLipstick · 19/10/2023 09:54

Lattims83 · 19/10/2023 09:52

I'm not sure how issues like this work legally in the UK but your sister sounds like a bitch. I would fight her and try to make sure I can get as close to paying her nothing as I can.

How helpful. 🙄

Lattims83 · 19/10/2023 09:52

I'm not sure how issues like this work legally in the UK but your sister sounds like a bitch. I would fight her and try to make sure I can get as close to paying her nothing as I can.

DadBodAlready · 19/10/2023 08:47

Your dads right get legal advice, but under Tenants in Common you can own different %ages. Its not a straight 50:50 split. So if you can prove 0 contribution from your sister in 16 years then you should have an argument for a greater share

EarringsandLipstick · 19/10/2023 07:27

Ilovecleaning · 19/10/2023 06:33

I sympathise very much but why was your first port of call Mumsnet and not a solicitor?

Well, why is anyone's first port of call MN? 🤷🏻‍♀️

For almost any situation here there's an 'expert' out there from home to relationship, medical to legal matters - but posters still post here for advice as it's accessible, easy & a first port of call.

Ilovecleaning · 19/10/2023 06:33

I sympathise very much but why was your first port of call Mumsnet and not a solicitor?

Mumof3confused · 18/10/2023 21:13

Get legal advice. If she’s entitled to her share then surely you’re entitled to take off your share of the costs she hasn’t contributed to, before paying her share.

Avidreader99 · 18/10/2023 19:04

My partner was in a very similar position with his brother. Went court and brother was awarded his share of the sale minus the mortgage payments, cost of repairs/work to the house which he had to pay to my partner. Get good legal advice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread