Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What does fairness look like to you in this scenario?

840 replies

JonahAndTheMinnow · 16/10/2023 19:34

Parent 1 and parent 2 have been married for a long time and have four adult children. They’ve recently sold an asset and want to share £300k amongst their children.

All children are aged between 35 and 48.

Child A - Eldest child. Married with grown-up children who live independently. Mortgage cleared recently. Household income isn’t very high and they don’t have much of a pension pot so will likely rely on state pension and likely work to full retirement age.

Child B - Was a very young single parent. Their child is now grown up and B has a partner. They live together in B’s house (bought by B’s parents) and B has no mortgage. B is a very low earner with no personal pension and will rely on state pension and work until full retirement age. Their job is tough and very physically demanding and working to 65+ will be a challenge.

Child C - Has two children (teens) in full time education, one with severe physical disabilities who will never live independently. C can’t work due to caring needs. Her husband works and he has a pension which should see them both live a modest but comfortable retirement. Child is in receipt of disability benefits. C and her husband have about 4 years left on their mortgage. Monthly payment is low on a house worth over £500k, thanks to generous gifts from parents, but they’ll never be able to downsize as it’s custom built to meet needs of disabled child. They have a lot of additional costs linked to their child- physio, need for a vehicle that can meet their needs rather than a cheap run-around etc.

Child D - Youngest child. Vey high earner married to a very high earner. No children. High mortgage costs on a large home but will clear in next five years. Own several investment properties and an holiday home outright. D and spouse will retire early with significant pensions. Current unmortgaged assets valued in the millions and had an inheritance from spouse’s parents of £600k in 2020.

Parent 1 wants to split the money between children A, B, and C so they’ll each have £100k. 1 thinks they need the money more than D and it’s a life changing opportunity for them whereas it’s not for D. 1 thinks that treating people fairly doesn’t always mean treating people equally and circumstances have to be taken into account.

Parent 2 wants to split the money equally between all 4 giving them £75k each. 2 believes that all children in the family should be treated equally, regardless of their current position.

What do you think?

OP posts:
Missjd87 · 18/10/2023 10:21

Parent 2.

All children equally

HolidayHappy123 · 18/10/2023 10:21

I am in the position of child D.

My parents made substantial contributions to pay for each of my siblings weddings. They didn’t do the same for me. While I understand their reasoning and still had the wedding of my dreams, it still hurts 15 years later.

Daisyblue77 · 18/10/2023 10:12

Parent 2 is correct it should be split equally

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 18/10/2023 10:05

Split it equally.

The other solution is to have an honest and open talk.

My SO will waive some of his inheritance rights (not in the UK, children /offspring have a legally protected minimum inheritance where we live) because his younger brother lives in their family home with his children.

But that was agreed upon and talked about. And I am honestly still not sure it was the best solution in regards to family dynamics, resentment etc.

But getting a lesser inheritance is still not the same as getting nothing at all for the sake of your siblings, which seems genuinely cruel.

And wouldn´t 75k still be a live changing amount to siblings 1 - 3?

SarahCares · 18/10/2023 09:53

I agree with you that they should all get an equal share regardless of their financial situation.

Goldie2021 · 18/10/2023 09:52

Needs to be shared equally

Sallyh87 · 18/10/2023 09:42

Obviously, split equal. Unless you enjoy drama and want a family rift and D to go NC with you.

Im the high earner out of my siblings and I am so sick of them getting everything. Just because I worked hard and had success doesn’t me I don’t like free stuff. It’s makes me resent my siblings.

Yes, I know I sound horrible and materialistic!

Georgeandzippyzoo · 18/10/2023 09:33

My DM always used to say you all get treated fairly but not always 'the same', so I do get where P1 is coming from.
However when it comes to inheritance I really think that it needs to be an equal split. Noone knows what the future holds so to give more to a DC because in the 'now' they would probably benefit from it more, is unfair on those who might need it in the future.
Also when parents have both gone, anything but equal shares is gonna cause upset/bad feeling between the siblings.
Parent 2 all the way.

Timeforchangeithink · 18/10/2023 09:29

I didn't read the individual circumstances, as always split things equally between your children.

ColleenDonaghy · 18/10/2023 09:28

ilovemydogmore · 18/10/2023 08:57

I don't agree, their current level of challenges are very different.

I think equity only comes into it in relation to child C, who has already been supported terms of the house adapted to their child's needs. OP has also said there is separate provision for the grandchildren, given the generosity re the house I suspect this is enhanced for the grandchild with a disability.

The others have all made their own choices in life.

PrincessNoteSpelling · 18/10/2023 09:27

ilovemydogmore · 18/10/2023 08:57

I don't agree, their current level of challenges are very different.

What's so challenging for b? Doing better than most. Have always fully owned a property never had worry of rent/mortgage so if both they and partners have always worked full time they must have a good disposable income?

LondonLass91 · 18/10/2023 09:25

HairyMaclairey · 18/10/2023 09:13

I have 2 siblings. One is very rich, and the other doesnt have much money. One worked their arse off, and the other made poor life choices. I am somewhere in the middle.

If you decided to give one of my siblings one thing, and the others a lesser share I would be mighty pissed off with you and it would affect our relationship. It is not about the money, it is about favouring one child over the other. They are all your DC, and they should be treated equally, irrespective of how much money they have. Your DC4 may say, we don't need this, and pass it to the others, but that is their choice.

You are essentially penalising DC4 for making different life choices.

Please don't do it. Honestly, if you were my parent and you did that to me, I wouldn't speak to you again. I also know that my siblings would be mortified and horrified that you did that.

I agree. I think i'd tell you to shove the money and never speak to you again if you did that to me.

LondonLass91 · 18/10/2023 09:24

Split equally. I was a high earner, as was my husband. I then had my children older, in my 40s, and gave up my job to raise them. My husband was made redundant. You don't know what the future holds for any of them. Split equally.

HairyMaclairey · 18/10/2023 09:13

I have 2 siblings. One is very rich, and the other doesnt have much money. One worked their arse off, and the other made poor life choices. I am somewhere in the middle.

If you decided to give one of my siblings one thing, and the others a lesser share I would be mighty pissed off with you and it would affect our relationship. It is not about the money, it is about favouring one child over the other. They are all your DC, and they should be treated equally, irrespective of how much money they have. Your DC4 may say, we don't need this, and pass it to the others, but that is their choice.

You are essentially penalising DC4 for making different life choices.

Please don't do it. Honestly, if you were my parent and you did that to me, I wouldn't speak to you again. I also know that my siblings would be mortified and horrified that you did that.

MikeRafone · 18/10/2023 09:11

Child A - Eldest child. Married with grown-up children who live independently. Mortgage cleared recently. Household income isn’t very high and they don’t have much of a pension pot so will likely rely on state pension and likely work to full retirement age.

most people will work to retirement age and they have a roof over their head

Child B - Was a very young single parent. Their child is now grown up and B has a partner. They live together in B’s house (bought by B’s parents) and B has no mortgage. B is a very low earner with no personal pension and will rely on state pension and work until full retirement age. Their job is tough and very physically demanding and working to 65+ will be a challenge.

This child has already been given a free house to live in and that is worth thousands

Child C - Has two children (teens) in full time education, one with severe physical disabilities who will never live independently. C can’t work due to caring needs. Her husband works and he has a pension which should see them both live a modest but comfortable retirement. Child is in receipt of disability benefits. C and her husband have about 4 years left on their mortgage. Monthly payment is low on a house worth over £500k, thanks to generous gifts from parents, but they’ll never be able to downsize as it’s custom built to meet needs of disabled child. They have a lot of additional costs linked to their child- physio, need for a vehicle that can meet their needs rather than a cheap run-around etc.

they have a house they worked for and paid for

Child D - Youngest child. Vey high earner married to a very high earner. No children. High mortgage costs on a large home but will clear in next five years. Own several investment properties and an holiday home outright. D and spouse will retire early with significant pensions. Current unmortgaged assets valued in the millions and had an inheritance from spouse’s parents of £600k in 2020.

They don't actually need any money

you could split it Child C gets £200,000 - after all they might need the money for the child and making life easier
Child A gets £80,000, they can supplement their income and the other two get £10,000 both have already inherited and been given a house etc

If we are doing it as need for money not a gift - but it'll cause resentment all round

MikeRafone · 18/10/2023 09:03

Giving a gift to someone isn't about how much they already have, its giving a gift because you want to gift them something - if you then leave one child out and don't give them a gift - its sending a message that you don't want to give them a gift.

ThreeLocusts · 18/10/2023 09:03

Interesting thread. Unlike most ppl here, my gut reaction is that giving 75,000 to people who really don't need it when there are other recipients to whom the extra 25,000 would mean a lot would be a waste.

But I think a lot depends on relationships and communication within the family. Would the wealthy child accept this reasoning? Is there some gesture that could be made to show them appreciation in a non- monetary way?

OP gope you get this sorted without damaging relationships. Doing good is so complicated sometimes.

ilovemydogmore · 18/10/2023 08:57

MaisyAndTallulah · 18/10/2023 08:53

It is equitable because they all had the same level of support from parents.

I don't agree, their current level of challenges are very different.

MaisyAndTallulah · 18/10/2023 08:53

ilovemydogmore · 18/10/2023 08:46

It's fair and equal. But it's not equitable.
Equitable means to provide people with something based on their situation. Parent A is going for equitable. Parent B is going for equal.

Edited

It is equitable because they all had the same level of support from parents.

MaisyAndTallulah · 18/10/2023 08:52

Parent 2 unless you want the offspring to be forever divided

ilovemydogmore · 18/10/2023 08:46

DreamTheMoors · 16/10/2023 20:37

Three kids in my family. One extremely wealthy, one’s husband lost all their money in schemes, one disabled.

Our parents divided their money equally and honestly nobody gave it a second thought.

Because it was fair and equitable.

It's fair and equal. But it's not equitable.
Equitable means to provide people with something based on their situation. Parent A is going for equitable. Parent B is going for equal.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/10/2023 08:42

DiabolicalFinial · 18/10/2023 06:46

If my parents had treated their 4 kids “equally”, then I would have most probably been dead 20 years ago. And I would now be homeless and destitute.

All 3 of my siblings are healthy, have partners, 2 have children, all own their own houses/cars/go on overseas holidays very regularly and are financially able to buy whatever they want (eg technology/caravans/clothes/jewellery/etc).

I have several medical conditions and disabilities, I can’t work, I live with chronic pain and deteriorating health, I cannot afford market rent and rent a small place from my parents, I cannot meet my bills (mainly medical), and never go on holiday/eat out/go out/buy alcohol. I will have no home once my parents are gone, I don’t know what I will do.

Sometimes it isn’t about being equal or trusting that siblings will even think of helping when life is shit, sometimes being fair is about meeting needs and the shit life has thrown at someone, because otherwise they would be completely lost.

Are you in UK? Just wondering re having to pay medical bills. If so are you getting appropriate benefits? Would your parents not leave you the rental property?

PrincessNoteSpelling · 18/10/2023 08:39

shockthemonkey · 18/10/2023 08:15

@PrincessNoteSpelling

"Why did the parents ask if there was only one right answer?" - actually the parents didn't "ask" - the surviving parent made an announcement to D1 and D2 that their intention was to split inheritance equally across the five. D1 knew that the surviving parent worried a lot about A, B and C, so spontaneously volunteered to forego their share...

It could be argued that the 5-way split announcement was actually the surviving parent's way of fishing for the response D1 gave, to answer your first question.

After saying they did not need money, D1 assumed D2 would make the same offer but has no direct information about this. Things then went a little frosty between D2 and D1. Meanwhile, surviving parent called A, B and C to tell them the inheritance would be split between the three and that D1 and D2 were happy with this. This suggests that at least initially, D2 made the same offer as D1.

Did D2 know it was a trick question? I don't know but I guess they must have felt pressured, especially after D1's offer to forego the money.

Some months later, D2 called D1 and said "I have spoken to surviving parent and the inheritance is going back to the 5-way split". No discussion, quite a tense phone call. D2 lives very close to surviving parent and looks after their financial affairs when needed. Surviving parent is now very frail and A, B and C were not made aware that the split had gone back to 5 ways - they only found out recently when an unguarded remark alerted them.

I don't know if D2 knows they are being judged... A, B and C have been told by D1 that they will be getting D1's share split between them. They have of course had no similar assurances from D2. They are pretty sure that D2 is being influenced by their partner who is quite money-oriented.

So the siblings moaning amongst themselves about not getting as much money as they want are calling someone else money orientated? 🤔

Lelliekellie · 18/10/2023 08:39

Regardless of their choices and life position. You need to split it equally. Any other option will have your children grow to resent each other and escalate the feelings of favouritism. Potentially damaging your children’s relationships with each other.
Spoken as one of three with a mother than very clearly played favourites. ♥️

Mikimoto · 18/10/2023 08:28

Without wishing to be clinical, imagine it's a company with 4 shareholders holding 25% each. Imagine how the profits would be distributed...no other conditions taken into account.
What each "shareholder" then does is up to them!