Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What does fairness look like to you in this scenario?

840 replies

JonahAndTheMinnow · 16/10/2023 19:34

Parent 1 and parent 2 have been married for a long time and have four adult children. They’ve recently sold an asset and want to share £300k amongst their children.

All children are aged between 35 and 48.

Child A - Eldest child. Married with grown-up children who live independently. Mortgage cleared recently. Household income isn’t very high and they don’t have much of a pension pot so will likely rely on state pension and likely work to full retirement age.

Child B - Was a very young single parent. Their child is now grown up and B has a partner. They live together in B’s house (bought by B’s parents) and B has no mortgage. B is a very low earner with no personal pension and will rely on state pension and work until full retirement age. Their job is tough and very physically demanding and working to 65+ will be a challenge.

Child C - Has two children (teens) in full time education, one with severe physical disabilities who will never live independently. C can’t work due to caring needs. Her husband works and he has a pension which should see them both live a modest but comfortable retirement. Child is in receipt of disability benefits. C and her husband have about 4 years left on their mortgage. Monthly payment is low on a house worth over £500k, thanks to generous gifts from parents, but they’ll never be able to downsize as it’s custom built to meet needs of disabled child. They have a lot of additional costs linked to their child- physio, need for a vehicle that can meet their needs rather than a cheap run-around etc.

Child D - Youngest child. Vey high earner married to a very high earner. No children. High mortgage costs on a large home but will clear in next five years. Own several investment properties and an holiday home outright. D and spouse will retire early with significant pensions. Current unmortgaged assets valued in the millions and had an inheritance from spouse’s parents of £600k in 2020.

Parent 1 wants to split the money between children A, B, and C so they’ll each have £100k. 1 thinks they need the money more than D and it’s a life changing opportunity for them whereas it’s not for D. 1 thinks that treating people fairly doesn’t always mean treating people equally and circumstances have to be taken into account.

Parent 2 wants to split the money equally between all 4 giving them £75k each. 2 believes that all children in the family should be treated equally, regardless of their current position.

What do you think?

OP posts:
carduelis · 18/10/2023 13:14

I think it’s a little short-sighted to frame people’s earnings entirely in terms of life choices. I worked much harder than my brother all the way through school and got a better degree. I went into a caring profession which is demanding but poorly paid; he went into a high-earning job. I resent the idea that he made “better life choices” than me.

DiabolicalFinial · 18/10/2023 13:06

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 18/10/2023 08:42

Are you in UK? Just wondering re having to pay medical bills. If so are you getting appropriate benefits? Would your parents not leave you the rental property?

Not in UK, no.

My initial surgeries were not covered by the public health system where I live as they were considered “experimental” (due to being so rare, but the ones done were successful). My options at 19 years old, after a lifetime of progressively worsening symptoms, was to find the $$$$$ for private surgery costs or likely either die or be on a respirator paralysed for life.

Since then, I have received Disability payments - the total per month would not cover a room in a share house for a fortnight at market rate, let alone any other bills. That is the sum total of benefits I (and anyone else disabled here) am entitled to. Any housing/physiotherapy/transport/medications/specialists/etc have to be paid by me aside from 10 therapy sessions per year.

My siblings want their “equal” share, so the rental will have to be sold. I don’t know yet if they also expect the medical costs I have been helped with to come off my ‘share’. According to most posters here, that is what should happen…

MarkWithaC · 18/10/2023 13:01

Hooplahooping · 16/10/2023 21:39

Divide it up according to descendents. That’s what my grandparents did. With your Example 300k - 4 children + 5 grandchildren = 9 shares of 33.3k
A + 2 children = 99k
B + 1 = 66k
C + 2 = 99k
D solo = 33k

I think it’s either got to go that way or totally equal. Otherwise all the other variables are so subjective.

That's a terrible suggestion. How about the scenario of a friend of mine: she has three siblings who each have one child. She herself is childless, but very much wanted children; she has sadly got to the life stage where she is highly unlikely to be able to conceive without having found a partner with whom to have children.
How would a division like this make someone like her feel?

EmeraldSakara · 18/10/2023 12:51

Parent 2 is 100% right. All 4 children get equal amounts.

Chocolateboxhero · 18/10/2023 12:41

If child 2 has already had a house bought for them the other three should get the money in equal shares. The house is probably worth more than the 100k the others will receive!

YankeeDad · 18/10/2023 12:34

Let me just add another perspective.

I am in the position of child D. There has been no inheritance yet, but I have already asked parents to favour the other siblings when the time comes, because I have more than enough financial assets, and getting more would not add in any way to my happiness. In fact, I have suggested that the other siblings should receive everything of financial value when the time comes.

What I actually want is to be able to reduce the potential pressure to become my brothers keeper, so to speak. There is a house with a mortgage that the siblings could both live in, except that they might not be able to afford the mortgage, so the house might need to get sold. If I were included as a beneficiary of the estate, I would be entitled to 1/3 of the equity in the house but I would feel pressured to instead pay off the mortgage myself so that they can both live there. Even if that also got me or my descendants full ownership of the house after their deaths, it would not help me at all: they are younger and will probably outlive me, my kids will inherit more than enough when the time comes, and I do not want the long-term responsibility for a house that I own but cannot use. However, in that situation, if I were to say that I wanted my share of the equity and the house needed to be sold, I do worry that my siblings might feel I was being nasty and greedy since I have more than enough, and was in effect forcing a sale by refusing to pay down the mortgage. That is convoluted perhaps, but it is how they might feel, even if they were to think otherwise. What actually matters is how people feel.

If they do get absolutely everything from my parents estate as per my own request, and then they still cannot work out a way to keep the house themselves, then I can tell them that they have already been favoured in the will, they can either accept to sell and keep the equity 50-50, or try harder to find a way to keep the house, but I have already been more than fair. I I think they would most likely accept that.

If I were child D in the family described by OP, I would worry about potentially getting hints from parents that they worry about what will happen to C when they are gone, with implicit request that since I have more than enough, maybe I should take their place in subsidising C. I would not worry at all about missing out on £75k that I really did not need, and I would not feel less loved for missing out on that. In fact I would instead feel relieved and loved if I received full emotional permission from my parents to let go of any responsibility for C..

shockthemonkey · 18/10/2023 12:32

PrincessNoteSpelling · 18/10/2023 08:39

So the siblings moaning amongst themselves about not getting as much money as they want are calling someone else money orientated? 🤔

As far as I am aware, only the sibling giving away their portion is calling the other one’s partner money-oriented.

I have not mentioned any moaning.

Hope that clarifies ☺️

caringcarer · 18/10/2023 12:29

RedLolly101 · 17/10/2023 14:12

Definitely not Parent 2.

Those posters who think each sibling should receive an equal portion regardless of individual circumstances, haven’t been brought up properly and they’re clearly self centred gits too. Glad I’m not related to anyone like that.

We had a similar scenario where child 3 was left the majority of parents money because of their disability and it was something that I helped the parents to set up legally. All siblings were in agreement that this was the fairest solution.

It’s been over 20 years since our parents died and no-one has fallen out because of it, presumably because we’re not selfish twats. 🤷🏻‍♀️

That is a different scenario because none of the siblings is disabled. A DGC is disabled but that family has already been gifted over £100k already because of disabled DGC.

caringcarer · 18/10/2023 12:25

ColleenDonaghy · 17/10/2023 08:08

Don't do this. D will rightly see what they're expected to do and it won't leave them any good options. If you're going to exclude D at least do it yourself.

OP has updated there is other money for DGC.

Notmetoo · 18/10/2023 12:09

If it was my children I would normally split it equally between all four. But given how wealthy child and is and how much the money will mean to the others I can understand parent 1s thinking and I would probably agree with that approach. Child D doesn't actually need anything but is still getting something
The problem is child D may then feel less loved so I think a conversation would be necessary to explain

ChickenT2b · 18/10/2023 12:07

Parent 2 is right. Why should D be punished for doing well? That is not right.
£75k is also still very much life changing for A, B and C. And what about D’s children? Aka the grandchildren; not only would parent 1 be snubbing their own child but also their grandchildren. Who’s to say they are going to live a financially stable life and be high earners just because their parents are. Anything can happen in life, fortune changes and whilst D is looking good now, you never know what’s round the corner.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 18/10/2023 12:07

ilovemydogmore · 18/10/2023 08:46

It's fair and equal. But it's not equitable.
Equitable means to provide people with something based on their situation. Parent A is going for equitable. Parent B is going for equal.

Edited

Actually, in terms of inheritance/assets etc, your equitable share is what you would be "entitled to" (for want of a better phrase). So if you had put up 100% of the funds for a house, your equitable share is 100% of that property value. If you put in 30%, whatever 30% of the sale price is, that's your equitable share.

The sale of your parents house after their death, with no will in place...Your equitable share would be your equal share of the remaining funds following repayment of any debtors as one of their next of kin.

In this case, equitable doesn't relate to their circumstances.

Graciebobcat · 18/10/2023 12:00

I'd generally go for equal, amounts, the only thing that should possibly affect it is if one child has already been given money by parents. So if Child C has already had big handouts they should get less.

caringcarer · 18/10/2023 11:59

.

caringcarer · 18/10/2023 11:59

.

MoaningMolly · 18/10/2023 11:58

Parent 2 is right.

Though, depending on the relationships. The parents could ask child D what their opinion is. Giving them the choice. They may feel happy to split their share between their siblings.

Maybe87 · 18/10/2023 11:55

as suggested already I would talk to child 4 make sure that he doesn’t feel abandoned and still give a small amount just to relief 1-2 months of mortgage fees (£3-4k maybe?) and get expensive presents for them.
i would give the rest to children 1 and 3. I would financially manage the amount for child 2. Maybe invest a part? She clearly made wrong decisions in her past and I would like to protect her future from herself. Would give her in hand 2-3k the same as child 4.

thecatsthecats · 18/10/2023 11:24

To me, it's still pretty wild that people are suggesting including D in a conversation.

If nothing else it's pretty fucking infantalising to the other siblings.

"Hey Dinah, you're our only non-screw up kid. What do you think about these allowances we've planned for the others? We know Christine has her disabled kid, Becca was never going to amount to much, but what about Abby?"

Terrible suggestion, yet people keep making it.

IncomingTraffic · 18/10/2023 11:23

The OP might not even be the parent here. Lots of people suspect the OP is C. Not least because C’s situation has been presented so as to elicit maximum sympathy for their greater ‘needs’ (while D has been presented as some sort of rich kid of instagram).

As soon as you get into assessment of ‘challenges’ and ‘needs’ and definitions ‘equitable’ as some sort of distribution of resources activity you are making a set of extremely contestable and often highly partial value judgements.

It’s one thing for the state or an organisation to make these (highly political!) value judgements to drive decisions about the allocations of collective resources. But this is a family. Parents deciding which of their children are more or less deserving of help (financial, practical, whatever) only have themselves to blame if their children decide to distance themselves from what may very well feel like a dysfunctional and toxic environment.

Then those parents are probably confused because they feel they are morally right and their now more or less estranged child is being nasty.

SeaMonkeysTookMyMoney · 18/10/2023 11:17

I'm in agreement with parent 2, but is is something that could be discussed with D to get their input? Going along with parent 1 is probably going to cause problems amongst the siblings and likely feelings of resentment.

Ameteurmum · 18/10/2023 11:16

B and C sound like they’ve already done well from the bank of mum and dad. It should be split evenly as is a gift and no one’s future is guaranteed, it is up to child D if they want to pass their share on but that should be their decision alone

HairyBanana · 18/10/2023 11:01

There is only one answer - equal division. Anything else is favouritism and is wrong. It would be the modern equivalent of not giving to girl because her husband will provide for her. The circumstances of the individuals are irrelevant and you will set your children up for future resentment and conflict if you act with unfairness now.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 18/10/2023 10:28

Sallyh87 · 18/10/2023 09:42

Obviously, split equal. Unless you enjoy drama and want a family rift and D to go NC with you.

Im the high earner out of my siblings and I am so sick of them getting everything. Just because I worked hard and had success doesn’t me I don’t like free stuff. It’s makes me resent my siblings.

Yes, I know I sound horrible and materialistic!

You don´t.

I see it with my SO.

His mother expects him to pay the money back she lent him for university. He went as an adult/in his mid 20s so that´s her reasoning. Which I could understand if the same rules also applied to his younger brother...

His younger brother lives in the family home (huge house, annex for the MIL) and pays rent that is considerably lower than market rate.

The younger brother made some choices that lead to my SO having a somewhat (not massively) higher income. And my SO does not have children (with 2 different women).

But it still seems unfair to give the younger one a financial break (with no strings / expectations of payback) whilst expecting the older one to pay back every last penny he received for university.

But not my family. So all I do is support my SO and offer my opinion when he asks...

WaystarRoy · 18/10/2023 10:27

The parents should split the money equally.

if the wealthier children want to split their share between their siblings they can.

is OP going to come back and say which parent they are?

jlpth · 18/10/2023 10:27

75k each, parent 2 is right

D is young enough to have kids. D could have a disabled child just like C. D could get ill. D could have 5 kids. D could get into a messy breakup. High earners often have shockingly large expenses. Nobody knows.

There is no possible agreeable way to divide it up other than 75k each.

75k is still life changing for A, B & C.

Imagine being D and watching all siblings get 100k and you get nothing. Plenty of people would cut you off for good in D's position.

Swipe left for the next trending thread