Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What does fairness look like to you in this scenario?

840 replies

JonahAndTheMinnow · 16/10/2023 19:34

Parent 1 and parent 2 have been married for a long time and have four adult children. They’ve recently sold an asset and want to share £300k amongst their children.

All children are aged between 35 and 48.

Child A - Eldest child. Married with grown-up children who live independently. Mortgage cleared recently. Household income isn’t very high and they don’t have much of a pension pot so will likely rely on state pension and likely work to full retirement age.

Child B - Was a very young single parent. Their child is now grown up and B has a partner. They live together in B’s house (bought by B’s parents) and B has no mortgage. B is a very low earner with no personal pension and will rely on state pension and work until full retirement age. Their job is tough and very physically demanding and working to 65+ will be a challenge.

Child C - Has two children (teens) in full time education, one with severe physical disabilities who will never live independently. C can’t work due to caring needs. Her husband works and he has a pension which should see them both live a modest but comfortable retirement. Child is in receipt of disability benefits. C and her husband have about 4 years left on their mortgage. Monthly payment is low on a house worth over £500k, thanks to generous gifts from parents, but they’ll never be able to downsize as it’s custom built to meet needs of disabled child. They have a lot of additional costs linked to their child- physio, need for a vehicle that can meet their needs rather than a cheap run-around etc.

Child D - Youngest child. Vey high earner married to a very high earner. No children. High mortgage costs on a large home but will clear in next five years. Own several investment properties and an holiday home outright. D and spouse will retire early with significant pensions. Current unmortgaged assets valued in the millions and had an inheritance from spouse’s parents of £600k in 2020.

Parent 1 wants to split the money between children A, B, and C so they’ll each have £100k. 1 thinks they need the money more than D and it’s a life changing opportunity for them whereas it’s not for D. 1 thinks that treating people fairly doesn’t always mean treating people equally and circumstances have to be taken into account.

Parent 2 wants to split the money equally between all 4 giving them £75k each. 2 believes that all children in the family should be treated equally, regardless of their current position.

What do you think?

OP posts:
DelphiniumBlue · 16/10/2023 21:57

"You need to reread what I actually said.

B was bought a cheap house over 25 years ago for an amount that would be less than £100k in today’s money. It’s a small house in a cheap area."

Where can you buy a house for less than 100k today? A small house in a cheap area is going to be upwards of 200k in the UK, surely?

Anyway, I wonder why the earnings and pensions of anyone except C is relevant, as they are all 20 years+ off retirement age and could retrain and change careers if they felt they needed more money.

Blinkingbonkers · 16/10/2023 21:57

Your options are: 1. Split it all equally 2. Have a chat with dc4, ascertain their thoughts, ask their opinion and move on from there!

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 16/10/2023 21:56

And what do people think D could say if their parents who clearly have their favourite children out of their 4, are telling them they don't need the money and their siblings (parents favourite who have already been bought a house each) deserve it more than them?

ColleenDonaghy · 16/10/2023 21:55

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 16/10/2023 21:51

These circumstances described. Is this where the parents have already shown extreme favouritism by only buying 2 of their 4 children houses outright?

I think we can exclude child C's house given the circumstances, that will secure the disabled grandchild's future and you would hope no one would begrudge them that.

If I slogged through school, uni, professional qualifications etc while always covering my own housing but my sibling got pregnant at 16 and then stayed in low paying jobs never paying rent or mortgage however...

Tremour · 16/10/2023 21:54

Also as you said you have additional money for the grandkids, except D doesn't have any but what if they do in the future, so if you don't split equally and D gets nothing, they also get nothing because they haven't had a child yet. SEems very unfair, even if they have millions.

JonahAndTheMinnow · 16/10/2023 21:54

Hooplahooping · 16/10/2023 21:39

Divide it up according to descendents. That’s what my grandparents did. With your Example 300k - 4 children + 5 grandchildren = 9 shares of 33.3k
A + 2 children = 99k
B + 1 = 66k
C + 2 = 99k
D solo = 33k

I think it’s either got to go that way or totally equal. Otherwise all the other variables are so subjective.

Apart from the fact that grandchildren have been taken care of separately, there’s only three years between D and B’s child. Do you really think it’s fair that D and an adult grandchild get the same?

OP posts:
Scottishskifun · 16/10/2023 21:53

I don't necessarily believe what is fair is the same as equal division at that point but it does have the potential to cause serious issues between siblings if not split equally like parent 2 suggests.

If it were me I would probably have a conversation with D about it. I would make sure D would still receive a sum but probably 50k as realistically they don't need it but make provision elsewhere.

My DB has received in excess of 50K from my parents as a adult I have been completely financially independent since 18. But my DPs have been clear in their wills my DBs share is minus that sum. He initially went ballistic when my mum told him that was their plan, saying it wasn't fair etc. My mum was quite clear about it and it stands.

Hooplahooping · 16/10/2023 21:52

ColleenDonaghy · 16/10/2023 21:51

OP has said the 300k isn't the full sun, with the rest going to the grandchildren so they aren't under consideration here.

Ah, good, I’ll try reading next time 🤦🏼‍♀️🤡

Tremour · 16/10/2023 21:52

Given your post about favourites, just split it equally this time. You've helped them out to different levels before based on need. I think on this occassion and to ensure no mor resentment about favourites is built up just split is equally. As you said there is additional money going to the grandkids anyway

LindaDawn · 16/10/2023 21:51

Smartfox · 16/10/2023 20:53

Years ago I watched a series of tv programmes about Wills and inheritance.
Each one featured a different (real) dilemma with families looking for guidance to explore what would be fair to beneficiaries.
The overwhelming message I took from the series was that whatever their circumstances all children saw whatever they were bequeathed as a measure of their worth to their parents no matter what their personal circumstances.
I agree with parent 2

I watched this series too. It was brilliantly done and such an eye opener as to how parents can get it wrong!

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 16/10/2023 21:51

Neither Parent 1’s option nor Parent 2’s.

A-D are adults. Families and lives of their own.

This should be a conversation. A serious conversation where they all agree on what’s right. I would expect D to say “I don’t need it, give it to my nephew”. I would expect A-C to say variations on that theme. I would expect ALLLLL of A-D to take responsibility for their own lives and their own families. This inheritance is a bonus.

The key to all of this is for money not to spoil the relationships. These bonds are far more important than £75,000 apiece.

Highlyflavouredgravy · 16/10/2023 21:51

You split it equally

ColleenDonaghy · 16/10/2023 21:51

Hooplahooping · 16/10/2023 21:49

I really didn’t express myself clearly. I’m advocating that the grandchildren’s shares be assigned to the grandchildren / put in trust for them.

OP has said the 300k isn't the full sun, with the rest going to the grandchildren so they aren't under consideration here.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 16/10/2023 21:51

BlueMongoose · 16/10/2023 20:51

What kind of wealthy person with no dependents would even want to insist on an equal share in the circumstances described? Anyone that greedy deserves nothing. I'd have thought they would have had the decency to spare their parents and would have anticipated the problem and said, look, we really don't need anything from this- it might be nice to have something as a token, but give the bulk of it to the others as it could make a big difference to them and it really wouldn't make much difference to us'. And I say this as someone with no kids. If they were in the same circs as the others with no kids, I'd say equal shares, as they might need more money in their old age for care. But they're not, they are a great deal better off.

These circumstances described. Is this where the parents have already shown extreme favouritism by only buying 2 of their 4 children houses outright?

Tinkerbyebye · 16/10/2023 21:51

I am with parent 2. Otherwise I would make sure they all know it’s parents 1 idea, and they can the flak from the fourth child who will be extremely hurt

each child has made decisions that has out them in the place they are now, why should one child have to forfeit because of their decision

Snugglemonkey · 16/10/2023 21:49

44PumpLane · 16/10/2023 19:43

Am I reading correctly that child B had a house bought for then by the parents already? Meaning that they have already received a considerable sum?

What do all the other children think about that?

However, to answer the actual question, I think you talk to child D, say you have £300k and you want to talk to them about how to split it. You are happy to split it between all 4 but given their personal circumstances how would they feel about it just going to the other 3 (or even just A and C if B has had a house bought for then already)?

You must absolutely express that you will happily follow whatever D chooses and never tell the others.

To cut out D without consultation would be terrible, and you can't guilt them into giving up their share, they may happily tell you to give it to their siblings, they may not. But you can't cut them out.

Nor can you put this on them. Totally unfair.

Merryoldgoat · 16/10/2023 21:49

You split it equally, however if I were D I’d tell them I didn’t need it.

Hooplahooping · 16/10/2023 21:49

SacAMain · 16/10/2023 21:41

HOW is giving one child 99k and another one 33k fair in any possible way?

Punish one child for not having children, or for having less?

What a awful way to treat your kids.

I really didn’t express myself clearly. I’m advocating that the grandchildren’s shares be assigned to the grandchildren / put in trust for them.

SacAMain · 16/10/2023 21:48

Ilovelifeverymuch · 16/10/2023 21:44

What does you mean? D has an expensive home that will be paid off in 5 years, investment property and houses abroad etc and yet you claim he or she has to be given a share because life is not straightforward???

And giving the money they don't really need will make it straightforward?

who are you to decide they don't need it?

You can't accuse them to have everything handed on a plate by their parents!
They must have worked their arse off to buy a house, an investment property.

Of course they should be given the same share as their siblings. What kind of parents punish their kids because they do "too well". It's ridiculous.

And what a life lesson, siblings do less, so they deserve more. How does that work.

Snugglemonkey · 16/10/2023 21:48

Octavia64 · 16/10/2023 19:39

Parent 2 is right.

If they do what parent 1 is suggesting child D will feel that they are unloved. It will not be seen as a money issue at all but a which child is loved more issue.

This. An equal split is the only possible answer.

updownleftrightstart · 16/10/2023 21:48

Hooplahooping · 16/10/2023 21:46

is if? perhaps I wasn’t clear - I’m not suggesting that they give it to the parents sorry - to be given directly to the grandchildren.

My brother has 4 children - I have 2. If my parents estate was divided so his children and mine got the same amount per individual I wouldn’t feel like I had been treated differently at all.

But child D is only 35 - they may still have children yet

Hooplahooping · 16/10/2023 21:46

SacAMain · 16/10/2023 21:41

HOW is giving one child 99k and another one 33k fair in any possible way?

Punish one child for not having children, or for having less?

What a awful way to treat your kids.

is if? perhaps I wasn’t clear - I’m not suggesting that they give it to the parents sorry - to be given directly to the grandchildren.

My brother has 4 children - I have 2. If my parents estate was divided so his children and mine got the same amount per individual I wouldn’t feel like I had been treated differently at all.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 16/10/2023 21:46

windmill26 · 16/10/2023 21:41

Share equally. My mother has done some crap like parent 1 want to do ( I am the sibling that didn't receive the share of the pot). As a daughter all I see that in my mother's eyes I am not the same as my sibling . We have not been on good terms since and I expect my sibling to do all the caring and running around when the time comes.

The question is did you need the money??? Was it a similar situation where your sibling truly needed it more than you or did your mother just decide to give it all to your sibling because she doesn't love you?

You can't claim favorite child in this case as she is splitting it among 3 children not just 1.

I'm sorry but I don't see it that way at all. I earn significantly more than my siblings and will happily tell my mother to give to the other 2 who need it more. That does not in anyway affect our relationship. If your mother truly gave it to another sibling because she prefers them that that is different.

poppettypop · 16/10/2023 21:46

Share it equally.

Wo knows what the future brings.

ColleenDonaghy · 16/10/2023 21:45

Just thinking further - if B stayed at home and was then bought a house does that mean they've never paid for housing? No rent or mortgage, ever? I wouldn't be surprised if there's some resentment about that even if it's never been said. That's a phenomenal leg up in life.