Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What does fairness look like to you in this scenario?

840 replies

JonahAndTheMinnow · 16/10/2023 19:34

Parent 1 and parent 2 have been married for a long time and have four adult children. They’ve recently sold an asset and want to share £300k amongst their children.

All children are aged between 35 and 48.

Child A - Eldest child. Married with grown-up children who live independently. Mortgage cleared recently. Household income isn’t very high and they don’t have much of a pension pot so will likely rely on state pension and likely work to full retirement age.

Child B - Was a very young single parent. Their child is now grown up and B has a partner. They live together in B’s house (bought by B’s parents) and B has no mortgage. B is a very low earner with no personal pension and will rely on state pension and work until full retirement age. Their job is tough and very physically demanding and working to 65+ will be a challenge.

Child C - Has two children (teens) in full time education, one with severe physical disabilities who will never live independently. C can’t work due to caring needs. Her husband works and he has a pension which should see them both live a modest but comfortable retirement. Child is in receipt of disability benefits. C and her husband have about 4 years left on their mortgage. Monthly payment is low on a house worth over £500k, thanks to generous gifts from parents, but they’ll never be able to downsize as it’s custom built to meet needs of disabled child. They have a lot of additional costs linked to their child- physio, need for a vehicle that can meet their needs rather than a cheap run-around etc.

Child D - Youngest child. Vey high earner married to a very high earner. No children. High mortgage costs on a large home but will clear in next five years. Own several investment properties and an holiday home outright. D and spouse will retire early with significant pensions. Current unmortgaged assets valued in the millions and had an inheritance from spouse’s parents of £600k in 2020.

Parent 1 wants to split the money between children A, B, and C so they’ll each have £100k. 1 thinks they need the money more than D and it’s a life changing opportunity for them whereas it’s not for D. 1 thinks that treating people fairly doesn’t always mean treating people equally and circumstances have to be taken into account.

Parent 2 wants to split the money equally between all 4 giving them £75k each. 2 believes that all children in the family should be treated equally, regardless of their current position.

What do you think?

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 16/10/2023 23:18

Given the complicated nature of all the financial gifts they've got or not got from you, splitting it evenly 4 ways is the right thing to do IMO.

Loopsy123 · 16/10/2023 23:13

Should be split equally. Situation for any of them could change overnight. Let them decide how best to use the money and at least you know you won’t cause any family divides or resentment. Also do you really know everyone’s situation financially?

ThornInMySide84 · 16/10/2023 23:11

This is so sad. Poor D. The inequality will hurt them, no matter how they try and hide it. I thinks it’s awful they’ve already helped out 2 children and giving money to Grandchildren when D doesn’t have any children of their own really sticks the knife in.

LeavesOnTrees · 16/10/2023 23:11

Equal split. Or else you are going to create resentment and problems.

Child D could end up a single parent, lose their job, anything really which would mean a change in their circumstances.

But mainly an equal split is better, as parents you'll be saying we love you all equally and want you all to benefit from our good fortune.

PrincessNoteSpelling · 16/10/2023 23:11

Ilovelifeverymuch · 16/10/2023 22:57

Because D has a more expensive house which he or she will pay off in 5 years due to higher income, plus a holiday house abroad plus rental property. Yes D is way way way better off than the others.

And b and c have both got mortgage free houses they've not paid or worked for. Op is quite clear in the fact that they (or parent 1) have favourites in their children!

SacAMain · 16/10/2023 23:09

Ilovelifeverymuch · 16/10/2023 22:57

Because D has a more expensive house which he or she will pay off in 5 years due to higher income, plus a holiday house abroad plus rental property. Yes D is way way way better off than the others.

so? D worked for everything, what stopped the siblings to choose the same career path?

You'd think the gift of a free house would have been a massive boost, why didn't they make the most of it?

What kind of parents make judgement on what lifestyle is best, and give the most money to their favourite one? It's bonkers.

caringcarer · 16/10/2023 23:09

FallingAutumnLeaf · 16/10/2023 20:12

Have A and D already had less of a helping hand from Mum and Dad?
And parent 1 is suggesting B and C get more, whilst D continues to get nothing??

Either split is qmequally between the 4, or balance up the gifts already handed out by assisting A and D more.

Yes, B and C already had help, A and D never had any help yet 1 parent wants to give their siblings, some of whom have already received generous help, more help at A and D's expense. You can see which the favoured DC are in this family.

Blackcatballoon · 16/10/2023 23:08

Equal split or D will hate their parents.

Channellingsophistication · 16/10/2023 23:07

I think it has to be equal split otherwise a lot of family resentment will be caused. Situations can change also

Quitelikeit · 16/10/2023 23:04

Gosh this is hard.

I would run this idea past D and offer say 20k given their lucrative circumstances

They might accept it happily and appreciate the difficult circumstances of their siblings

caringcarer · 16/10/2023 23:02

44PumpLane · 16/10/2023 19:43

Am I reading correctly that child B had a house bought for then by the parents already? Meaning that they have already received a considerable sum?

What do all the other children think about that?

However, to answer the actual question, I think you talk to child D, say you have £300k and you want to talk to them about how to split it. You are happy to split it between all 4 but given their personal circumstances how would they feel about it just going to the other 3 (or even just A and C if B has had a house bought for then already)?

You must absolutely express that you will happily follow whatever D chooses and never tell the others.

To cut out D without consultation would be terrible, and you can't guilt them into giving up their share, they may happily tell you to give it to their siblings, they may not. But you can't cut them out.

I think putting D in that position is dreadfully unfair. It pressurises them to agree because a parent has made the suggestion so hinted that they think that is right, otherwise why would they be told?

My Mum left everything split exactly equally between me and my sister's. My sister's and I have differing levels of personal wealth. That is not any of my Mum's doing.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 16/10/2023 22:59

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 16/10/2023 22:57

Parent 2 is correct. I don't agree with punishing your children for being successful. If child D doesn't want or need it, they can decide that for themselves.

It's not punishment, it's being compassionate and wanting to support your siblings. Parents will definitely have to explain the reasoning to the children so it's not a case of make the will and let them find out after parents pass, that's wrong.

Parents should be able to have a mature conversation to explain and I'm sure of D is reasonable he or she will be fine.

updownleftrightstart · 16/10/2023 22:59

RedHelenB · 16/10/2023 22:56

This. I'd like to think my kids woukd want most venefit to go to the sibling that needed it most.

And which sibling needs it the most in your opinion?

TiredRetired · 16/10/2023 22:58

Any scenario but an equal split will cause resentment and problems.

Namerequired · 16/10/2023 22:57

Split it equally or you could cause hurt feelings. I can’t imagine anyone would get hurt by splitting it properly regardless of their circumstances. But I can see hurt and resentment from D otherwise. Plus if D is still young they could have children yet who won’t benefit either.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 16/10/2023 22:57

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 16/10/2023 22:46

Why do posters keep saying D who still has a mortgage and hasn't been helped by parents is better off than B and C who've been bought property and have no mortgage they haven't had to do anything to earn?

Because D has a more expensive house which he or she will pay off in 5 years due to higher income, plus a holiday house abroad plus rental property. Yes D is way way way better off than the others.

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 16/10/2023 22:57

Parent 2 is correct. I don't agree with punishing your children for being successful. If child D doesn't want or need it, they can decide that for themselves.

RedHelenB · 16/10/2023 22:56

BibbleandSqwauk · 16/10/2023 19:37

I'd say talk to child D and explain your reservations. I'd like to think in those circumstances I'd want to give my share to my needier siblings. Id be wary of child B's situation and want to make sure the money was legally protected from her low earning partner should they split.

This. I'd like to think my kids woukd want most venefit to go to the sibling that needed it most.

caringcarer · 16/10/2023 22:56

Parent 2 is right. Always treat DC equally. If a parent leaves them out they will feel deep hurt and feel unloved.

TheBeef · 16/10/2023 22:55

£75k each

SacAMain · 16/10/2023 22:54

Ilovelifeverymuch · 16/10/2023 22:42

C'mon cut it out, how is D being disinherited????

This is a mature conversation which if D was a compassionate person who loves her siblings will understand. Stop taking it to the extreme.

If I was D, have an expensive house that I will pay off in 5 years, houses abroad, houses being rented etc I would be happy to help my siblings who are not doing as I am. My love for my parents is not tied to inheritance. If there are other issues that's different.

why does it have to be D who must be the only compassionate person who loves their siblings in this story?

You'd expect A, B and C to be just as compassionate and loving, and be indignant about getting more than their sibling and refusing not to share the money equally.

You could even argue that normal older siblings tend to be protective of the youngest one, and more generous towards them.

To keep things clear, simple and fair, divide equally, house included. Don't let the older ones spoil the youngest, and don't let the youngest sacrifice his share.

SoShallINever · 16/10/2023 22:53

Parent 1 is an idiot.

easylikeasundaymorn · 16/10/2023 22:53

Hooplahooping · 16/10/2023 21:39

Divide it up according to descendents. That’s what my grandparents did. With your Example 300k - 4 children + 5 grandchildren = 9 shares of 33.3k
A + 2 children = 99k
B + 1 = 66k
C + 2 = 99k
D solo = 33k

I think it’s either got to go that way or totally equal. Otherwise all the other variables are so subjective.

I think this is the nastiest and most unfair suggestion of all.
what if d doesn't have kids because they are infertile? or the others wanted more but couldn't for the same or any other reason? their siblings get extra money to add salt to the wound.
what if one of them has another kid after the money has been paid out? all the other grandkids get 33k each but the last one gets nothing because they were born six months too late?
ridiculous!

1FootInTheRave · 16/10/2023 22:53

Split it equally.

SacAMain · 16/10/2023 22:50

Ilovelifeverymuch · 16/10/2023 22:28

I'm sorry but as a parent you have insight into your children's lives and from what OP has stated D has or a lot better than the others so not sure what you mean by "who are you decide they don't need it" I'm sure everyone who reads their situation can see that the others need it more, its not rocket science.

Working their arse off doesn't matter, what matters is D is financially well off and doesn't need while it would go a long way to help the others simple. I worked my arse off to get to where I am today, that doesn't give me the right to begrudge my siblings when I know they really need it. Frankly it's a very selfish and grabby attitude to get upset and conclude your parents don't love you because they have your sibling who needs it a lot more than you money. Again if it's a case of parents favoring one child that's different but that's not the case from what OP has written.

How the hell is it punishment? I guess it will be punishment if your love and acceptance of your parent is tied to inheritance.

Maybe this will help you understand what I am saying. Equity v Equality

We claim we should be practicing this in society but somehow not in the family is when it comes to inheritance.

Edited

Indeed you have insights, and having kids given the same childhood/ background and opportunity, it's awful to neglect one because they've "done well".

The equity vs equality really does not apply between siblings.

Giving more to one child is literally favoring that child. You can't blame children to notice their siblings gets more help, one even got a house no less, will keep having more help.

Parents playing favourite that way are awful.