Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What does fairness look like to you in this scenario?

840 replies

JonahAndTheMinnow · 16/10/2023 19:34

Parent 1 and parent 2 have been married for a long time and have four adult children. They’ve recently sold an asset and want to share £300k amongst their children.

All children are aged between 35 and 48.

Child A - Eldest child. Married with grown-up children who live independently. Mortgage cleared recently. Household income isn’t very high and they don’t have much of a pension pot so will likely rely on state pension and likely work to full retirement age.

Child B - Was a very young single parent. Their child is now grown up and B has a partner. They live together in B’s house (bought by B’s parents) and B has no mortgage. B is a very low earner with no personal pension and will rely on state pension and work until full retirement age. Their job is tough and very physically demanding and working to 65+ will be a challenge.

Child C - Has two children (teens) in full time education, one with severe physical disabilities who will never live independently. C can’t work due to caring needs. Her husband works and he has a pension which should see them both live a modest but comfortable retirement. Child is in receipt of disability benefits. C and her husband have about 4 years left on their mortgage. Monthly payment is low on a house worth over £500k, thanks to generous gifts from parents, but they’ll never be able to downsize as it’s custom built to meet needs of disabled child. They have a lot of additional costs linked to their child- physio, need for a vehicle that can meet their needs rather than a cheap run-around etc.

Child D - Youngest child. Vey high earner married to a very high earner. No children. High mortgage costs on a large home but will clear in next five years. Own several investment properties and an holiday home outright. D and spouse will retire early with significant pensions. Current unmortgaged assets valued in the millions and had an inheritance from spouse’s parents of £600k in 2020.

Parent 1 wants to split the money between children A, B, and C so they’ll each have £100k. 1 thinks they need the money more than D and it’s a life changing opportunity for them whereas it’s not for D. 1 thinks that treating people fairly doesn’t always mean treating people equally and circumstances have to be taken into account.

Parent 2 wants to split the money equally between all 4 giving them £75k each. 2 believes that all children in the family should be treated equally, regardless of their current position.

What do you think?

OP posts:
stichguru · 19/10/2023 17:54

I would say two option: 1) give ALL children EQUAL shares NOW. 2) Keep the money and give it to children as they need it. Finally leaving them equal shares of whatever is left in your will if it isn't used up when you pop you clogs! It IS fair to give a child that needs more, more, but it isn't really fair to predict who might need more a way into the future, based on the situation now. There are lots of things which might happen which would change how much they needed the money.

ILovePie01 · 19/10/2023 16:42

Before i read this update I was going to say parents should speak with D and see what she wishes. I can’t see why your mum is so upset if you’ve agreed that you don’t want the money. I’d be proud of my child making such a kind decision.

If you do end up with the money, maybe you could invest it, as you’ve clearly done well with your own money, and pass it on later. Or a small holiday home somewhere cheap all could use..

amiboverd · 19/10/2023 16:37

Split it equally between the four children

Ladyluck22 · 19/10/2023 16:19

Parent 2 is right. I think it is not the amount but the thought and leaving one out, what ever their financial situation is, is unkind. It almost like well you’ve not had children and decided to work on your career so we’re going to penalise you for this decision.

HoHoHoliday · 19/10/2023 15:31

OP, as you say yourself, your dad did the wrong thing by approaching you with this (albeit for the right reasons), it wasn't a choice or decision for you to make.
Your mum is understandably upset.
If you go with what your dad wants, your mum is still going to be upset. If you go with what your mum wants, neither of them will be upset. Surely that's the most diplomatic option?
You can give your share out to your siblings without telling your mum.
If you don't think they will accept it from you, and you genuinely don't want it, there are a million charities who could really benefit from even a fraction of your spare £75K. You can even get your dad to choose some charities if it helps balance things with him.
This is not a burden you need to stress about any further. You taking the money will make your mum happy, you passing it in will make others happy. Your siblings are still getting £75K, they are not struggling by any means. Most people can only dream of this amount of money.

YankeeDad · 19/10/2023 14:36

ilovemydogmore · 19/10/2023 12:36

I think the 'right' thing for him to do was to split equally but I think it's really poor taste that you are now kicking up a fuss. You are eye-wateringly wealthy from your description of multiple mortgage free homes. Richer than probably any of us on this thread.

I think it is interesting that you think that, while posting a cartoon that suggests the opposite.

Everybody can see the game, but only if the crates are distributed unequally.

I also do not think the OP is in poor taste or "now kicking up a fuss." Everybody wants their family to get along, whether financially rich or poor, and they presumably posted this thread looking for ideas to help move things in that direction.

ilovemydogmore · 19/10/2023 12:36

I think the 'right' thing for him to do was to split equally but I think it's really poor taste that you are now kicking up a fuss. You are eye-wateringly wealthy from your description of multiple mortgage free homes. Richer than probably any of us on this thread.

ilovemydogmore · 19/10/2023 12:33

for those still arguing

What does fairness look like to you in this scenario?
ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 19/10/2023 12:05

I actually thought you might be A rather than D.

I fully agree with everything you said. Your father appears well intended but clearly should have got agreement with your mum rather than you. I you see a very similar situation in my household - my dad would agree with yours and my mum would also mirror your mum's thoughts.

I would speak to your mum. Tell her that you really respect her position and that it means so much to you that she would want you to have your fair share and that you'll always be grateful that that's how she views things. I would go on to tell her that given your fortune position, you agree that your siblings need it more and while you would like that too happen, it means that about world to you that she would fight your corner but that hive the funds to you and you transferring it to them would sure tax issues you are anxious to avoid for everyone etc.

You shouldn't have been put in this position and are a very decent sibling to want to share.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 19/10/2023 11:35

I posted waaaaay upthread to say that neither parent was doing the right thing, that the right thing was for the parents to have a conversation with all their children, all mature adults, and explain what they hope to achieve and what their reasoning is.

My parents did this with us. We do not have an equal split. We have a very fair split.

The starting premise of any such conversation (or will, if there’s no conversation) is to ensure that each child (and subsequently, grandchild) understands completely and wholly that there is no correlation between bequests and love. This is the root cause of so much distress on these inheritance threads. Yes OP’s dad should have come to agreement with his wife first. But, OP, all you have to do is reassure your mum that you KNOW that they both love you just as much as they love the others. That this is “only” money and that that same love is being extended by you to your siblings and nephew, that you want absolutely to ensure that their needs and physical comfort is assured just as yours already is.

In our family, each sibling has different numbers of DC, from zero to many! All the siblings were well educated, all earn very well, all have married well (ie sensibly, not to rich people!). No child needs the money. Nor will any grandchild. But it will certainly help with university costs and housing costs for the DGC. And so it makes sense that the inheritance is effectively “for” the DGC via their parents. The split is very far from equal, but our parents and we discussed this, agreed this, it was all settled many years ago and everyone is happy. We’ve all subsequently made our own wills accordingly. In fact, the whole process brought us adult siblings closer as we know we’ve “done” something for each other. We’re bound together in an extra, meaningful way, not just adults with a shared childhood and shared memories.

All isn’t lost, OP. Be gentle with your mum and help her get over the hump of money = love. It’s within your gift to achieve this.

WowOK · 19/10/2023 11:28

JonahAndTheMinnow · 19/10/2023 10:26

I think my dad did the wrong thing, but possibly for the right reason. His intentions were very good but he shouldn’t have moved the discussion to include me before he cleared everything with Mum.

I think he was hoping that me going to her to say I was happy to not have the money would wrap it up nicely in a bow and she’d be happy.

I really don’t like the idea of taking the £75k and giving it to my siblings as a gift from me. Apart from the fact that it’s hassle for me, it’s not money that I should be taking the credit for. I want them to receive money from our parents. Me getting involved will make at least one of the siblings feel like it’s a charitable thing when it’s not and the money should be going to them anyway, but from the source of the money; my parents.

For those saying to take it and put it into trust for my sister’s disabled child, it’s not as easy as that. I think a decision like that is up to the child’s parents. Also, I have several nieces and nephews across a varied age range and they all have needs (by which I mean some are at the stage now where they’re scrimping for house deposit, going to uni etc). I’m very generous to them but me overstepping and creating trusts outside of an inheritance situation wouldn’t be well received.

The joy of growing up with four sisters! My husband has just one brother and it all seems so much more straightforward.

Why don't you set up premium bond accounts for each of your nibblings or divide it equally between them if you don't want it? They can use it as they please. It doesn't need to be the exact £75k divided. Do something nice for yourself with it as well to satisfy your parents buy a car or have a holiday.

JonahAndTheMinnow · 19/10/2023 10:26

I think my dad did the wrong thing, but possibly for the right reason. His intentions were very good but he shouldn’t have moved the discussion to include me before he cleared everything with Mum.

I think he was hoping that me going to her to say I was happy to not have the money would wrap it up nicely in a bow and she’d be happy.

I really don’t like the idea of taking the £75k and giving it to my siblings as a gift from me. Apart from the fact that it’s hassle for me, it’s not money that I should be taking the credit for. I want them to receive money from our parents. Me getting involved will make at least one of the siblings feel like it’s a charitable thing when it’s not and the money should be going to them anyway, but from the source of the money; my parents.

For those saying to take it and put it into trust for my sister’s disabled child, it’s not as easy as that. I think a decision like that is up to the child’s parents. Also, I have several nieces and nephews across a varied age range and they all have needs (by which I mean some are at the stage now where they’re scrimping for house deposit, going to uni etc). I’m very generous to them but me overstepping and creating trusts outside of an inheritance situation wouldn’t be well received.

The joy of growing up with four sisters! My husband has just one brother and it all seems so much more straightforward.

OP posts:
Lattims83 · 19/10/2023 10:08

I've just recently had a similar conversation with my husband. His parents have been talking about inheritance too, well before they go so tax isn't involved. Anyway, my husband is 12 and 13 years younger than his 2 older sisters. The middle sister is financially ok as she and her husband spent many years working in Dubai but between me and my husband, we probably make more than 10 times what his oldest sister and her partner make. She is also a single mother of 2 while we have no kids and no desire to have them, not that I think that should factor in BC it shouldn't. The nice part of me feels that the oldest sister should get more as she needs it more, but I'm the only person who thinks that, the inheritance will be split equally. I think most people here are probably saying the same thing, equal Vs equitable. If you don't want any resentment it probably needs to be equal, otherwise one is being rewarded for making poor decisions and one is being penalised for being successful and choosing not to have kids.

Lattims83 · 19/10/2023 10:00

Parent 2 is right, should go equally to all children. The ones who have done better in life shouldn't be penalised for being successful. Just like the ones who haven't shouldn't get a handout for no reason.

Merrymouse · 19/10/2023 09:42

Having read the update, the money should be given to each sibling equally then the OP can share their £75k amongst the other 3 siblings.

JustAMinutePleass · 19/10/2023 09:34

I’m child D in my family too. It seems my DP are always using my siblings’ poor decisions against me. Nobody told them to get married and have kids when they were too young to support them, or take / stay in low paid jobs for a chilled life while DP gave them all the free childcare possible (often at my expense). Dad used to beg them to save / invest money and they never did. While I did everything right and DP are now talking about cutting me out ‘as I don’t need the money’. It makes me so angry.

Devora13 · 19/10/2023 09:27

Sounds from what's written that some of 'children' have already received parental help, so splitting evenly would seem the most balanced overall, taking into account good relationships etc. £100k may well be 'life changing' but then so would £75k.

IncomingTraffic · 19/10/2023 09:26

That doesn’t mean the wife’s view is the only one that matters. what a weird interpretation.

If it were the other way round and the wife was enlisting the children to ensure she gets her way, it would be equally crappy behaviour.

IncomingTraffic · 19/10/2023 09:24

He needed to find a way to agree a course of action with his wife. And then communicate that decision to their children.

What he definitely shouldn’t have done is taking the manipulative route of talking to one child to just get around his wife and ensure he gets his way.

YankeeDad · 19/10/2023 09:17

IncomingTraffic · 19/10/2023 06:31

I think it is sad that the father is being labelled by so many here as manipulative, when he is clearly trying to do what he feels is the right thing.

He intended to undermine his wife - who he knew disagreed with him. Rather than talk to his wife he decided to manipulate the situation by talking to the OP about her mother and siblings.

He decided he knew best and would manipulate the situation to get the outcome he wanted.

It’s actually a bit worrying you see this as ‘doing the right thing’.

Does this mean you feel that the only "right thing to do" for the father would have been: talk to her, tell her his point of view, and then if she still insisted on an equal split, to follow her wishes without saying anything else to his children?

If yes, then why do you think the mother's preference should trump the father's?`

If that is not what you are saying, then what would you propose that the father should have done if, after speaking with his wife, he still had one point of view (share money according to perceived need) and she still had a different point of view (share money equally)?

carduelis · 19/10/2023 07:57

IncomingTraffic · 19/10/2023 06:31

I think it is sad that the father is being labelled by so many here as manipulative, when he is clearly trying to do what he feels is the right thing.

He intended to undermine his wife - who he knew disagreed with him. Rather than talk to his wife he decided to manipulate the situation by talking to the OP about her mother and siblings.

He decided he knew best and would manipulate the situation to get the outcome he wanted.

It’s actually a bit worrying you see this as ‘doing the right thing’.

“Trying to do what he feels is the right thing” is not the same as “doing the right thing” at all though. I don’t think OP’s father did the right thing but I also think that, in a rather short-sighted and careless way that ended up upsetting both OP and her mother, he was trying to do what he thought was right. He seems really misguided rather than deliberately manipulative to me.

carduelis · 19/10/2023 07:44

Ilovelifeverymuch · 19/10/2023 00:43

It's not leaving one child out, it's having a mature discussion with your child who hopefully is a compassionate person which thankfully OP is based on her update.

And this narrative of her father must not love OP because of this is absolute rubbish. And I'm so glad OP recognizes and confirms that she knows her father loves her and is proud of her and her accomplishments. Her father's love is not tied to a share of inheritance.

Edited

Agree - clearly lots of people think money = love, but on the contrary it says a lot about OP’s relationship with her father that he thought she was magnanimous enough to see his viewpoint. I don’t necessarily think he did the right thing - though I think OP’s point about her father’s anxiety about everyone having enough makes it more understandable - but it sounds like there’s a lot of love and generosity in this family.

FlitterBug · 19/10/2023 07:05

I agree you need to split It equally or put in a trust for grandchildren.

IncomingTraffic · 19/10/2023 06:31

I think it is sad that the father is being labelled by so many here as manipulative, when he is clearly trying to do what he feels is the right thing.

He intended to undermine his wife - who he knew disagreed with him. Rather than talk to his wife he decided to manipulate the situation by talking to the OP about her mother and siblings.

He decided he knew best and would manipulate the situation to get the outcome he wanted.

It’s actually a bit worrying you see this as ‘doing the right thing’.

Ponderingwindow · 19/10/2023 04:49

I would support your mother on this. The only fair way to split the money is equally between all siblings.

i don’t understand why people say that extra money shouldn’t towards families that had more children. Inheritance should go evenly through each branch of the family tree. It may get subdivided more or less in some branches, but you don’t give more money to one child’s branch just because there are more grandchildren.

there is one other way to distribute the money, but I wouldn’t split it. There was mention of a grandchild who will never live independently. Setting aside the entire 300k solely for that child’s care needs might also be fair because of the level of need.

Swipe left for the next trending thread