Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What does fairness look like to you in this scenario?

840 replies

JonahAndTheMinnow · 16/10/2023 19:34

Parent 1 and parent 2 have been married for a long time and have four adult children. They’ve recently sold an asset and want to share £300k amongst their children.

All children are aged between 35 and 48.

Child A - Eldest child. Married with grown-up children who live independently. Mortgage cleared recently. Household income isn’t very high and they don’t have much of a pension pot so will likely rely on state pension and likely work to full retirement age.

Child B - Was a very young single parent. Their child is now grown up and B has a partner. They live together in B’s house (bought by B’s parents) and B has no mortgage. B is a very low earner with no personal pension and will rely on state pension and work until full retirement age. Their job is tough and very physically demanding and working to 65+ will be a challenge.

Child C - Has two children (teens) in full time education, one with severe physical disabilities who will never live independently. C can’t work due to caring needs. Her husband works and he has a pension which should see them both live a modest but comfortable retirement. Child is in receipt of disability benefits. C and her husband have about 4 years left on their mortgage. Monthly payment is low on a house worth over £500k, thanks to generous gifts from parents, but they’ll never be able to downsize as it’s custom built to meet needs of disabled child. They have a lot of additional costs linked to their child- physio, need for a vehicle that can meet their needs rather than a cheap run-around etc.

Child D - Youngest child. Vey high earner married to a very high earner. No children. High mortgage costs on a large home but will clear in next five years. Own several investment properties and an holiday home outright. D and spouse will retire early with significant pensions. Current unmortgaged assets valued in the millions and had an inheritance from spouse’s parents of £600k in 2020.

Parent 1 wants to split the money between children A, B, and C so they’ll each have £100k. 1 thinks they need the money more than D and it’s a life changing opportunity for them whereas it’s not for D. 1 thinks that treating people fairly doesn’t always mean treating people equally and circumstances have to be taken into account.

Parent 2 wants to split the money equally between all 4 giving them £75k each. 2 believes that all children in the family should be treated equally, regardless of their current position.

What do you think?

OP posts:
FarEast · 17/10/2023 07:08

Parent 2 is right. This isn’t about need it’s about sharing and showing all their children are considered.

SunshineAndFizz · 17/10/2023 07:05

Wow. Of course it should be split evenly. £75k is still a large amount of money to receive each. You can't treat kids differently. D could lose it all tomorrow.

Hotchocolatemousse · 17/10/2023 06:51

Equal spilt between all 4 children to avoid resentment and family fallouts. Keeping the relationship going is more important than cash.

I would encourage the low earners to buy a small investment property in the north to let out to generate additional income. Then use that income to retrain to better paid jobs and bulk out their pensions.

AgentJohnson · 17/10/2023 06:49

This isn’t about right and wrong, it’s about personal beliefs of which both parties are entitled to.

tinytemper66 · 17/10/2023 06:44

Equal amounts to all children

bakedbrain · 17/10/2023 06:43

@ColleenDonaghy I don't think "punished" is quite the right word. I would personally view 75k as a bit of a drop in the ocean in terms of adding to my net worth. I wouldn't at all feel deprived monetarily. (That said, I also know wealthy people for whom enough is never enough and even 10K is worth getting all grabby for, so...)

Money not really being the main factor, I think the main issue here would be the background of family relations. If I were D, I might feel upset about perceived bias/difference in parental levels of care and concern, rather than about losing out financially.

For me personally, I have a somewhat healthy and assured relationship with my parents and siblings (but it took quite some time for our family to arrive at that semi-healthy place as adults), but we don't know what the dynamics in their family are even though OP claims D is the favourite. There appears to be the issue of sibling rivalry and jealousy (which could also be held by D just as much as by OP), which I think supports the idea of an equal split. D can give their share or more to the rest if they want to, but only if they want to.

FallingAutumnLeaf · 17/10/2023 06:40

DelphiniumBlue · 16/10/2023 21:57

"You need to reread what I actually said.

B was bought a cheap house over 25 years ago for an amount that would be less than £100k in today’s money. It’s a small house in a cheap area."

Where can you buy a house for less than 100k today? A small house in a cheap area is going to be upwards of 200k in the UK, surely?

Anyway, I wonder why the earnings and pensions of anyone except C is relevant, as they are all 20 years+ off retirement age and could retrain and change careers if they felt they needed more money.

A 4 bed detached in a decent area of my (not great) bit of the uk would set you back 200k.
Not sure about under 100k, but 150k would get you a family home.

ColleenDonaghy · 17/10/2023 06:21

Mydogmybestfriend · 17/10/2023 02:32

Morally child D shouldn't accept anything as they are clearly not in need

Between A B C they made their own choices and have their own struggles with life and should have it split between them.

But D also made their own choices and had their own struggles - there's no way that high earning job hasn't come from a huge amount of work and sacrifice. It seems harsh to punish them for that.

givemeasunnyday · 17/10/2023 05:29

I'm with Parent 2. The children should be treated equally, no matter what their circumstances. However, Child B living in a house which their parents bought for them muddies the waters a little.

drspouse · 17/10/2023 04:15

Enough to C to enable them to pay off their mortgage.
Then equal shares. C has greatest immediate and short term needs.

Or if you want to do it a bit differently, equal shares to each grandchild, or even each dependent grand or great grandchild.

MysteryBelle · 17/10/2023 03:03

You might find that D would rather you give the money to ABC. Then there’d be no resentment.

MysteryBelle · 17/10/2023 02:51

Basically, D is the sticking point. D is worth millions, has no children at all to consider, has many properties, is a very high earner married to a very high earner. The other 3 are nowhere near D financially. That said, only C has underage children to support, one for lifetime special needs.

If going by need, C has highest need, A and B are pretty equal in need, then D really has no need at all. So, if divvying up by need, 150,000 would go to C, and 75,000 each would go to A and B. D would get zero because D would still have millions and millions more than A, B, and C out together.

But D is the favorite of op (parent 2) even though op claims that D is favorite of parent 1 😂

D is the youngest and the baby and the favorite of the op (parent 2) proven by the post that says it’s not fair for a grandchild to get same as D 😂

I’m usually all for equal treatment but the difference between ABC and D is obscene. It seems deeply unfair to give a multimillionaire the same as a relatively poor person with a manual labor job and very low income.

The only person who could possibly be resentful if you didn’t divide it equally is D 😂 The other 3 would be resentful if you divided it equally because D is so rich. It would in fact show that D is the pet and dividing it equally actually would not really be ‘equal’.

Saying all that, I understand that dividing it equally is kind of the only thing you can do because they’re all your children and you of course want to ‘treat them equally.’ This is a hard one. Surely D would want his/her share to go to his/her siblings?? I would ask D. That’s my advice. Ask all 4 and see what their opinions are. I would base my decision on their reasonings and feelings about it.

bakedbrain · 17/10/2023 02:33

@BibbleandSqwauk I'm familiar with that image / concept of equity vs equality, and agree with that distinction.

However, intuitively, somehow helping on a needs basis (eg we'll buy you a house as you need somewhere to live, we'll give you cash gifts for your hard times, etc) feels different from splitting a windfall / parental legacy. It's not about the amount as I'm quite sure the price of the house they bought for B then was hefty as well, plus the house payments they've made for C, and so on.

It is perhaps an arbitrary distinction between needs-based help and cash sale split, but I think because it's one large cash sum obviously divided by the number of heirs, it's quite in-your-face. This may sound materialistic, but the latter feels a bit like an indication of caring, thought, prioritisation, and perhaps even love.

Maybe parents can help other siblings with retirement in terms of gifting property or bonds or shares or etc...

Mydogmybestfriend · 17/10/2023 02:32

Morally child D shouldn't accept anything as they are clearly not in need

Between A B C they made their own choices and have their own struggles with life and should have it split between them.

Rudderneck · 17/10/2023 02:26

I don't always think an equal split is the way to go, but I think in this case it likely is if I had to choose one of those options.

But - I think the parents might also make a reasonable argument that they want to set aside some money in trust for the disabled grandchild, or something like that, and then split the rest between the four children. I realize that might seem unfair to the other grandkids, but I do think families have a kind of obligation to work together to make sure members like that who are truly unable to care for themselves are provided for long term.

Maybe the parents of the disabled child would prefer to see their share go into such a trust. Maybe the wealthy sibling would too. It might be best to ask them. In an ideal world I think the wealthy sibling would offer something like that, but people don't always do what is ideal.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 17/10/2023 02:25

321user123 · 17/10/2023 01:08

Child D may be made redundant tomorrow and have a few tenants not pay (and god forbid) go bankrupt in 6 months time.

I’d split it evenly with each child getting £75K.

Really, that's your logic? By that logic the disabled child may need urgent expensive care soon that the £75k will help with.

The chance of both child D and her husband being made redundant, and tenant stop paying at same time is so slim ors.nor going to happen, and guess what child D has options. She should have savings and investments if she earns such a high income, not having one is foolish on his or her part. They can sell the rental property if they cannot find another tenant, they can sell their holiday home as well. I'm sure you will agree doing away with your holiday home pales in comparison to what the other children have to deal with.

MissTrip82 · 17/10/2023 02:23

BibbleandSqwauk · 16/10/2023 19:43

I'm obviously in the minority here but I really disagree. I always dislike actions done on broad sweep "fairly" when the outcome is not. It's the difference between equality and equity. I can't link it but there's an image of three people trying to see over a fence. They all get one box. The shortest still can't see over, the tallest already could and the middle one now can. In the "equity" image, the tallest gives his box to the shortest and they can all see over. I think adults with healthy family relationships ought to be able to appreciate different needs and not equate it with love, preference or affection.

I’d also expect adults to be able to recognise that the most successful sibling has worked hard for that success and it is open to all the others to do the same.

I certainly wouldn’t find it fair that the sibling who was given a house was seen as more deserving than the sibling who has worked to pay for their own house.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 17/10/2023 01:49

I'm a strong believer that fair doesn't have to mean equal and these parents have obviously helped their children differently in the past according to their needs. However, in this case divide equally amongst all 4. Anything else is trying to second guess the future and likely to cause unnecessary ill-feeling.

LaurieStrode · 17/10/2023 01:33

Four equal shares. Why should D be punished for doing well??

bakedbrain · 17/10/2023 01:31

I think what's not appreciated (pun!) is that B also got on the property ladder early compared to their siblings. The initial price of the house is less relevant than the timing. You keep mentioning the small investment capital (under 100k in today's money) but how much is B's house/area worth now?

I was able to buy early and get on the property ladder because my parents helped me out. Friends who waited years, because they didn't have that initial capital, can no longer buy in my area.

Many young people would buy a "cheap" house if they even had that sum of money, but sadly they don't. House prices appreciate like crazy even in a few years, and if you buy earlier, you'll be sitting on a lot more than you bought it for.

bakedbrain · 17/10/2023 01:12

My natural inclination is to agree with Parent 1 but in reality, Parent 2 has the most realistic grasp of the situation. Think of it not just as a monetary gift to your children, but gifting them continued family and sibling bonds and support, instead of sowing sibling rivalry.

It sounds complex anyway as it looks like you've already helped both Child B and C a lot financially with their houses?

Plus, you don't know what is really going on in D's life. Unlikely as it may seem, you also don't know what will happen to D decades into the future (burnout, divorce, family disability or death, secret debt, investment losses, etc).

Also finally, D could feel resentment as they might feel (whether fairly or unfairly) that they have striven to make good choices in earlier life like waiting until financially stable to have kids, making sacrifices for their career, etc.

321user123 · 17/10/2023 01:08

Child D may be made redundant tomorrow and have a few tenants not pay (and god forbid) go bankrupt in 6 months time.

I’d split it evenly with each child getting £75K.

Indoorcatmum · 17/10/2023 01:02

Equal. Always equal

Epidote · 17/10/2023 00:57

Parent 2 regardless of any other money gifts they can or already had given before.
One thing is day to day help to those who made need it like sibling B and C and another split an asset and leave one of the children out.

Why they will leave it out, just because his luck choosing a career was better?, because doesn't have kids yet?

Parent 1 is thinking with the heart looking for the future of the siblings/grandkids. But the future is unknown and siblings D should not be left behind.
Parent 2 is thinking with the brain making a fair split.

Stompythedinosaur · 17/10/2023 00:55

There's a fair bit of complexity to the family set up. Some dc feel others are favourites already.

Anything other than splitting equally sounds like it will lead to hurt feelings and family relationships being damaged.