Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think phones should be banned for kids?!

92 replies

Glassesfrompubs · 16/10/2023 16:17

I'm kinda ranting here because I can do it anonymously, where really I want to stand in the playground and scream at the top of my lungs... so to save me from social death I'm going to do it here instead!!

My DS is 7 (yr 2). He has kids in his class who have their own mobile phones, who use TikTok and other social media. I'm pretty pissed off because my son was told he was a "loser" because he doesn't know what TikTok is. FFS no seven year old should have a phone!

I just do not understand it and I think it's pretty negligent parenting - none of these kids are travelling to school by themselves. There is literally no reason for young children to have a phone other than their parents giving themselves and easy life and giving into pester power.

For older kids too... everyone I know who is a teacher or has secondary-aged kids says phones are the single worst thing in their kids' lives. teachers spend far too much time dealing with this crap and not actually teaching. Parents feel totally beholden to allow their kids to have them, but equally feel like the devices and constant social interaction is ruining their children's lives.

I really feel like kids shouldn't even be allowed their own devices. If they have to have them for getting to/from school then they should be locked in a box at the start of the school day, and returned at the end. Am I the only one who feels like this?!

OP posts:
CoQ10 · 16/10/2023 21:56

Just FYI

We are in the process of choosing secondary schools. Every single school tour, I've asked the child 'guide' whether they needed a phone in years 7 and 8.

Overarching response??

No.

CoQ10 · 16/10/2023 21:52

SpicedAppleAndFreshCider · 16/10/2023 21:37

I don't agree. Are you saying they shouldn't be allowed to play on a Nintendo Switch?

That's comparing apples and pears!

Startyabastard · 16/10/2023 21:37

YANBU. Phones are so fucking damaging, I wish they were 'illegal' too. Why a little child is allowed free rein of tiktok is not something I can understand.

SpicedAppleAndFreshCider · 16/10/2023 21:37

CoQ10 · 16/10/2023 21:31

Its not actually. When you consider a child's brain is not fully developed before age 25 (and therefore ability to avoid addiction and self regulate) then banning until age 16 doesn't sound so bonkers.

I don't agree. Are you saying they shouldn't be allowed to play on a Nintendo Switch?

CoQ10 · 16/10/2023 21:31

SpicedAppleAndFreshCider · 16/10/2023 21:16

This is very dramatic. I have two adult Children who had phones from secondary school and they are fine.

Its not actually. When you consider a child's brain is not fully developed before age 25 (and therefore ability to avoid addiction and self regulate) then banning until age 16 doesn't sound so bonkers.

CoQ10 · 16/10/2023 21:27

sellote · 16/10/2023 17:11

Where does that end? Must get the expensive trainers and designer labels too because they’ll be bullied etc?

My DC are 10 and 8 and have no phones and don’t game either. They’ve mentioned friends having phones but didn’t argue when we said that they’re too young.

My DD goes to secondary school next year and will only have a short walk so a phone won’t be necessary then either. Her teacher mentioned at parents’ evening the grief that they cause in her year and the time the teachers spend dealing with the upset from messages that the children send to each other, and said from experience it’s best to hold off for as long as possible into secondary school.

I think it’s important for them to have a break from their school day. Schools had bullies pre phones - imagine coming home and it possibly continuing in the evenings too.

Edited

Agree.

CoQ10 · 16/10/2023 21:26

Rudderneck · 16/10/2023 16:53

I think that 50 years from now, there will be all kinds of widely accepted evidence of the affect of online gaming and social media on kids brains, and we will look at giving them smartphones in the same way we now look at letting kids smoke.

Not just at 7, either, but probably until some time well into adolescence. An acquaintance of mine who does research in the area of internet addiction says that there is more and more evidence that is really damning and when it starts to filter out to the public, it will be a big shock to a lot of people.

I totally agree.

My kids will not get a phone til they are at least 14 for this reason.

SpicedAppleAndFreshCider · 16/10/2023 21:16

Mydogmybestfriend · 16/10/2023 21:12

Should be illegal to have a phone unless you're 16
It's destroyed kids

This is very dramatic. I have two adult Children who had phones from secondary school and they are fine.

Mydogmybestfriend · 16/10/2023 21:12

Should be illegal to have a phone unless you're 16
It's destroyed kids

Siameasy · 16/10/2023 20:49

DD is year 4 and there are some with phones in her class so she has weakly mentioned it to me but was shut down immediately. I know a year 3 with a phone and kids in her class have TikTok. I despair of parents who seem to lack common sense and the ability to actually have some sort of authority

DumpedByText · 16/10/2023 20:30

I work in a school, we take their phones off them for the day if they are seen using them inside or in class.

I've seen 15 year old kids have full on meltdowns because they haven't got their phones, literally panicking, sweating, crying because they cannot live without them.

They'll feign sickness so they go home to get it back. It's a sad sad addiction for some kids.

merrymelodies · 16/10/2023 20:24

She was 7.

merrymelodies · 16/10/2023 20:23

Back in 2007 my DS had a phone but that was because of her epilepsy. She could call me if she had a seizure or wasn't feeling well.

ChickenNugget6 · 16/10/2023 20:20

We should have lockers in schools where kids place their mobiles before school. They can take them out after!

oohsharon · 16/10/2023 20:14

"Unfortunately they will be socially ostracised if they don't have Snapchat and Tiktok in high school."

Not my experience at all. At my kids high school phones are completely banned whilst on site though. Maybe that's the difference.

Leah5678 · 16/10/2023 20:11

Agreed. Unironically I agree they should be actually banned for children (under 13 or so not 18) it makes more sense to ban them outright then to say "it's your decision as a parent" because everyone else will give their kid an iPhone and yours will be the outcast.
So yeah it's better to just ban them outright for kids.
People will say "that's tyranny" but you could argue the same thing about cigarettes being illegal for under 18s. So yeah I don't care call me a tyrant

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 16/10/2023 20:02

I guess I think maybe less socially acceptable!?

You can't really just decide to make things less socially acceptable though. Or make them illegal. It is down to parents to control their dc's phone access, and a large proportion of parents are addicted themselves, both to their own phones and to using tech to keep their children quiet/busy. And are incapable of saying no.

Sweetlily99 · 16/10/2023 20:00

Aso secondary school they are not allowed phones out during school day. They are switched off.

Sweetlily99 · 16/10/2023 19:59

Yanbu

Y7 (11.5yr) child and 💯 its awful and the worst thing. Held off until near end of y6 and will do the same with our other kids.

Would be v happy if smart phones banned!

7year olds with phones, wow

Growlybear83 · 16/10/2023 19:57

I agree that it's completely unnecessary for children to have phones in primary school. I very reluctantly gave my daughter a phone when she transferred to secondary school and she had a journey of an hour each way, part of which was often on her own. But I had to get special permission from her head of year, and if anyone who was allowed to being a phone to school was caught using it during the day, it was confiscated until the end of term. This was quite strictly enforced until she started in the sixth form.

oohsharon · 16/10/2023 19:56

My kids were allowed phones at 11, WhatsApp only with pre-agreed friends and no TikTok.

Phones are also to be switched off and out of site at all times whilst on school grounds so it doesn't affect their school days at all. I believe all schools should follow suit

Imjusttootired · 16/10/2023 19:02

I have never understood the outrage for phones Vs tablets ?? Lots of small kids have tablets and by 7 a lot do.
what is the actual difference apart from one is easier to make calls on.

BooseysMom · 16/10/2023 18:56

cansu · 16/10/2023 18:45

Tbh as a teacher I think kids should only be allowed phones without internet access. It would solve lots of issues. First they wouldn't want one so only the kids who did need it for walking home alone etc would have one. Second, there would be much less bullying and mental health issues. Lets be honest the internet and access to it has caused massive damage to children and teenagers. The explosion in self harm is I think significantly linked to social media and online activity.

Yes, absolutely

BooseysMom · 16/10/2023 18:51

Ponderingwindow · 16/10/2023 17:16

I agree that there is no reason a 7yo needs TikTok.

the problem is that people are jumping from that to banning children from phones. That is taking it too far. Phones and tablets can be fantastic devices, even for younger children, if used wisely.

That many parents are irresponsible and don’t know how to use parental controls and even actively circumvent the age restrictions set by content providers is not justification to prevent responsible people from using devices wisely.

Better education would help.

the phone manufacturers making the parental controls easier to understand and less bug prone would also help. That would be an excellent parental campaign. Making our voices heard to ask them to make the parental controls easier to use and absolutely never-fail.

I was a victim of this and put my hands up to the fact it was my fault what happened.. DS (8) had my old phone and was always playing on Roblox. I would put the pin number in for him to access the phone. Then one day I had a huge shock when I discovered daily amounts coming out of my bank account for Google Play. It turned out that he had been buying Robux at £3 - £7 per day for over a month! I hadn't got phone banking so didn't realise until I got my statement through. I asked him what did he do to get the Robux and he said it was easy to do it with a finger print which he set up himself...yes i know, I'm a twat!! I went mental, took the phone off him and he wasn't allowed on it again. It's just scary how much they can do on phones, and they can be very clever. Certainly cleverer than me!

cansu · 16/10/2023 18:45

Tbh as a teacher I think kids should only be allowed phones without internet access. It would solve lots of issues. First they wouldn't want one so only the kids who did need it for walking home alone etc would have one. Second, there would be much less bullying and mental health issues. Lets be honest the internet and access to it has caused massive damage to children and teenagers. The explosion in self harm is I think significantly linked to social media and online activity.

Swipe left for the next trending thread