Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Motorbikes and fatal accidents

133 replies

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 13:36

The vast majority of fatal accidents I read about involve a motorbike (and often a lorry).

Motorcyclists seem so vulnerable on the roads. AIBU to think something should be done about this?

I'm not trying to victim blame, but I often see motorcyclists weaving around the queues, speeding ridiculous speeds on motorways and generally not abiding by the usual rules of the road.

It's a bit like XL bullies. When you hear of a fatal dog attack, you can almost guarantee it includes a Bully. Same with fatal road accidents, it seems nearly each time it involves a motorbike.

AIBU to think, for their sakes, those of their families and for those traumatised by killing cyclists, that something needs to be addressed?

OP posts:
Mothership4two · 16/10/2023 13:54

In our area there are several motorcycle deaths a year. Unfortunately in a collision cyclists have zero protection. We do see many motorcyclists driving too fast and overtaking when it is not safe. There are several long straight country roads that bring out weekend riders. There have been loads of complaints from residents as they feel unsafe and from the constant noise. However, at least four of the fatal accidents involving motorcycles over the past couple of years were not the cyclists fault - these are just the ones I am aware of, there may have been more.

A massive clamp down on speeding would help and maybe some education, but I don't see an outright ban ever happening.

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 13:54

Testina · 16/10/2023 13:51

“I rarely see any motorcyclist keeping to the speed limits on any type of road.”

This seems unlikely.

Remember that you are most likely to notice a motorcycle when it is overtaking you. Therefore, you are going to see the small % that are speeding, but you’ll also misjudge the illusion that they’re breaking the limit just because they’re faster than you. The noise of them contributes to an incorrect perception of relative speed. Plus your obvious confirmation bias.

You just don’t see the motorcyclist who set off 6 mins after you, on your route, doing the same speed as you.

That doesn't make sense to me. I look out of the front windscreen 98% of my driving time. Therefore I can see all vehicles in front of me. So I can see what speed they're driving at.

For the other 2% of my time, I'm checking my side and rear mirrors, and I can see them there too.

If someone can only notice other drivers by seeing them overtake, that's rather worrying!

OP posts:
EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 13:52

Testina · 16/10/2023 13:47

Motorcyclists are certainly vulnerable on roads.
But the vast majority?
Confirmation bias on your part. Motorcyclists are not the majority group of reported RTA fatalities. Nowhere near.
Given the sheer number of car drivers, it’s unsurprising they are the ones most often fatally injured.
That said, the risk of dying from a RTA is something like 50x higher on a bike. There’s only so much you can do about that difference, given the physical difference.

As to “something needs to be addressed” - it already is being addressed. See graph.

I think it is victim blaming to talk about bikes weaving around, unless you’ve already looked at the statistics on what accidents for bikes are fatal, and the circumstance?

The graphic you posted is numbers, not rate, so it's possible that just reflects a decreasing number of motorcyclists on the road, rather than an improvement on them being involved in RTA.

If motorcyclists are 50x more likely to die on the roads that car drivers, something needs to be done?

I hear of loads of accidents involving cars. But the vast majority with fatalities seem to involve bikes, which is what your 50x stat would support too.

I didn't write the post to bash motorbike drivers, but to ask if something needs to be done to reduce the fatal accidents.

OP posts:
Testina · 16/10/2023 13:51

“I rarely see any motorcyclist keeping to the speed limits on any type of road.”

This seems unlikely.

Remember that you are most likely to notice a motorcycle when it is overtaking you. Therefore, you are going to see the small % that are speeding, but you’ll also misjudge the illusion that they’re breaking the limit just because they’re faster than you. The noise of them contributes to an incorrect perception of relative speed. Plus your obvious confirmation bias.

You just don’t see the motorcyclist who set off 6 mins after you, on your route, doing the same speed as you.

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 13:48

@evilkitten I'm not so sure. They whizz around bends and I rarely see any motorcyclist keeping to the speed limits on any type of road.

Speeding and weaving makes it very difficult for motorists to actually see them with enough time to change their driving. One nearly went into the side of my car the other day as they weaved between traffic to get to the front of the queue. I mean, do you ever see a motorcyclist waiting in line at lights?

BUT that's not to say they're always at fault. There are definitely some shocking car drivers on the road too!

OP posts:
Testina · 16/10/2023 13:47

Motorcyclists are certainly vulnerable on roads.
But the vast majority?
Confirmation bias on your part. Motorcyclists are not the majority group of reported RTA fatalities. Nowhere near.
Given the sheer number of car drivers, it’s unsurprising they are the ones most often fatally injured.
That said, the risk of dying from a RTA is something like 50x higher on a bike. There’s only so much you can do about that difference, given the physical difference.

As to “something needs to be addressed” - it already is being addressed. See graph.

I think it is victim blaming to talk about bikes weaving around, unless you’ve already looked at the statistics on what accidents for bikes are fatal, and the circumstance?

Motorbikes and fatal accidents
evilkitten · 16/10/2023 13:42

They’re more vulnerable, but the victim blaming is misplaced. They are usually not the ‘at fault’ party in the accident, just most affected.

Motorcyclists (and cyclists) need to make sure they’re visible, predictable and wearing the right kit, but those in cars need to remember to look out for them - it’s easy to just look for cars when pulling out of a junction for example.

Dotjones · 16/10/2023 13:41

All that needs to happen is that riders who behave inappropriately get properly sanctioned. It's already illegal to do 150mph on the motorway, the riders that do this just need to be caught.

I think it's the same with cyclists, they need to be made responsible for their actions. Obviously a speeding motorcyclist is most likely to harm themselves more than other road users, but cyclists are more likely to harm pedestrians more than themselves.

The thing that needs to happen is prosecution, banning from riding, and jail for those who flout the law by speeding through red lights.

Swipe left for the next trending thread