Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Motorbikes and fatal accidents

133 replies

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 13:36

The vast majority of fatal accidents I read about involve a motorbike (and often a lorry).

Motorcyclists seem so vulnerable on the roads. AIBU to think something should be done about this?

I'm not trying to victim blame, but I often see motorcyclists weaving around the queues, speeding ridiculous speeds on motorways and generally not abiding by the usual rules of the road.

It's a bit like XL bullies. When you hear of a fatal dog attack, you can almost guarantee it includes a Bully. Same with fatal road accidents, it seems nearly each time it involves a motorbike.

AIBU to think, for their sakes, those of their families and for those traumatised by killing cyclists, that something needs to be addressed?

OP posts:
rwalker · 16/10/2023 14:45

I think it’s six if one and 1/2 a dozen of the other
the amount of people who just pullout is shocking
they see you and literally expect you to stop because your not a car

As for overtaking I think some people in cars are horrified and see manoeuvres that sat in your car seem dangerous
but in a bike your in a totally different position you can see directly over a line of car where to people in the car it looks like you’ve pulled out blind
and acceleration on bikes is many times faster than cars

so when they overtake you think dickhead they can’t see and won’t make it where as they can see and have 4 Times the acceleration of your car to get past

the biggest danger of weaving ( which is legal ) js car drivers being arseholes and deliberately blocking you because they have to wait bikes should
I always go slow with both feet down as cars zig zag to block u

FrankieStein403 · 16/10/2023 14:43

There are old bikers, there are bold bikers. There are no old bold bikers.

That said I believe the cause of many motorbike accidents is the disparity in speed between bike and car.
As a car driver I find I tend to believe that by necessity other vehicles are moving at a similar speed, so my reactions/movements are tuned to that speed - sometimes a bike is moving at a much faster speed simply because their acceleration is higher so we end up in dangerous situations.

Am in London at the moment and there are a huge number of 'L' plated delivery bikes that get ridiculously close to my rear. I don't think they realise that at night this means their headlight(s) drop below my rear window and they are effectively invisible.

There also seems to be a trend towards twin lights on bikes - crazy IMHO - these are close together so look like a car much further away - have turned in front of these a couple of times and frightened the shit out of myself and presumably the biker.

XelaM · 16/10/2023 14:41

There is a documentary on Netflix (I believe) called Road about the famous Dunlop family- generations of road motorcycling champions. Literally all of them (I think with one exception) died on the road. 😢

Testina · 16/10/2023 14:37

“Do you usually fact check every thread? It's fine you've done that here, I've learned something new to know that there are more fatalities from car driver than motorcycles (assuming the stats don't include passengers?). But it does seem a bit arsy, given this is Mumsnet, not a peer reviewed article. I'm just a normal person, who's heard of a few recent motorbike deaths and wondering if there's anything that can be done to reduce the deaths.”

Well no, I don’t fact check every thread. But if I’m going to comment, I like to add more than, “aw hun you’re so right”. There’s lots of intelligent posts on MN and I’ve learned a lot from them. From the speed of my response, you can see that the “research” took minimal time. I’m interested in statistics, and actually a million years ago part of my degree course was perception of hazards, and it’s relevant in my day job now. Not motorcycles! But behaviour around safety at work. So your thread interested me.

Motomum23 · 16/10/2023 14:36

I ride a motorbike. I ride it safely - within the speed limit and with great care - but in the last year I can tell you of at least 20 times a car has pulled out in front of me, over taken me dangerously and nearly knocked me off. Car drivers are a menace. Yes idiot riders are out there but believe me they all know the risks and are far far more careful. I tell my son that his biggest risk is car drivers not driving with care and attention and you have to mitigate for that at all times.

femalebiker · 16/10/2023 14:35

I'm a motorcyclist, so probably in a pretty good position to shed some light on this.
Motorcyclists, for the most part, do not do 150mph on the motorway. Althought the bikes are most certainly capable (mine will do 70mph in 2nd gear for example), it's just not very doable. TT riders sure, but the average Joe? No.

We undertake training, in particular I've trained with the police, Rospa and IAM in a bid to make myself safe on the road and to ensure that other road users actually see me.
Most bikers wear decent gear, Kevlar top to bottom, decent helmet, all the gear, all the time.
Even when it's hot weather and we're basically sat on a combustion engine, we wear the correct gear.
It may appear that we're 'whizzing around bends', but in reality, we'll take the bend at the speed of the road, it probably looks faster because we have to lean, it's basic physics really. And of course we lean, if we didn't, we'd end up in a field somewhere, or somebody's front garden.

We filter. Of course we do, we're allowed, in slow moving or static traffic.

A lot of accidents are, sure, down to rider error.

The rider overcooking it on a bend and ending up wrapped around a lamppost, the rider who was going too fast and didn't see that the traffic had slowed,.

But an equal number of accidents are down to car drivers not actually seeing us.
We're actually taught to weave on the road when we're approching a junction, to enable the car driver to see the moving light and not pull out.

More education needs to happen on both sides.

Motorcyclists undertake more further training than any other road users, and can do so at any time, thanks to proactive behaviour from the road safety organisations and police forces. We have a good understanding of the highway code, and ride accordingly.

It would be great if car drivers could do the same.

And finally, for transparency, I'm also a car driver.

Dulra · 16/10/2023 14:32

Motorcyclists are more vulnerable in road traffic collisions I don't necessarily think they drive more dangerously than car drivers. My friend was killed in a motorbike accident a number of years ago. A car pulled out from a junction onto a main road crashing straight into my friend, killing him instantly. Apparently the car never noticed the motorbike! We were told this is quite a common accident. My friend didn't stand a chance. Please don't victim blame. Every road user whether it's a car, motorbike, bike escooter etc needs to take care and be alert

CatOnAHotShedRoof · 16/10/2023 14:24

My car was destroyed by a motorcyclist slamming into the back of it at 90-100 mph many years ago. DH was driving, and he initially thought he was at fault, but witnesses all said no, it wasn't his fault at all. The Police knew who the motorcyclist was and said he'd done it before, and had nearly been killed that time. This time, he was very badly injured. There was no excuse - it was a long straight road, but was travelling too fast to stop in time. DH & I were both injured and had to be taken to hospital.

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 14:23

Testina · 16/10/2023 14:12

Look, I’m not having a go at you here!
Your 15 years of driving is as biased as my 35. That’s why we need statistics in order to guide policy exactly to achieve your aim of less deaths. I’m never going to disagree with you that that’s needed!

Your perception seems to be that “often” a lorry is involved. So maybe if you were trying to decide what must be done, you’d focus on a campaign around lorries, or some legislation. But the statistics don’t show lorries as being involved in the main circumstance of fatalities. That’s with just one other car. In fact, a motorcyclist is 4x as likely to die with no other vehicle involved, than with a lorry involved.

That’s why I’m questioning your perception. The statistics are the way to determine policy, not your or my biased experience.

I didn't mean a motorbike and a lorry. I meant motorbike or a lorry. Can see that wasn't clear.

Do you usually fact check every thread? It's fine you've done that here, I've learned something new to know that there are more fatalities from car driver than motorcycles (assuming the stats don't include passengers?). But it does seem a bit arsy, given this is Mumsnet, not a peer reviewed article. I'm just a normal person, who's heard of a few recent motorbike deaths and wondering if there's anything that can be done to reduce the deaths.

OP posts:
BCCoach · 16/10/2023 14:18

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 14:09

Bother to read about? I don't "bother" to read just about motorcycle deaths. I just generally read the news and local SM and hear disproportionate reports of motorcyclist deaths.

Well, good to hear that you realise they are disproportionately reported. Motorcyclists are the highest risk group of all road users (followed by pedestrians and cyclists) in terms of KSA per road user miles but the overall numbers are very low as there are simply not very many motorcyclists compared to other road users.

BabyDubsEverywhere · 16/10/2023 14:16

Me and my husband were bikers before kids. We were knocked off a few times and had so many very close calls. We werent speeding or riding dangerously. Car drivers simply didn't see us. In many cases the drivers actually looked at us, any carried on pulling out/moving into our lane. I think its because a motor bike doesn't fully register in the moment (and it only takes a moment for a collision to occur) because we're more used to seeing cars rather than bikes on the roads.

A good friend of mine was killed on his bike when doing 30 on a 30... the car pulled out on him and he was catapulted over the car. It was all caught on camera. He died at the scene.

We stopped riding after that.

Testina · 16/10/2023 14:12

Look, I’m not having a go at you here!
Your 15 years of driving is as biased as my 35. That’s why we need statistics in order to guide policy exactly to achieve your aim of less deaths. I’m never going to disagree with you that that’s needed!

Your perception seems to be that “often” a lorry is involved. So maybe if you were trying to decide what must be done, you’d focus on a campaign around lorries, or some legislation. But the statistics don’t show lorries as being involved in the main circumstance of fatalities. That’s with just one other car. In fact, a motorcyclist is 4x as likely to die with no other vehicle involved, than with a lorry involved.

That’s why I’m questioning your perception. The statistics are the way to determine policy, not your or my biased experience.

Motorbikes and fatal accidents
Pineapplemonkey · 16/10/2023 14:12

They are more likely to die in an accident because unlike a car, they do no have seatbelts and are not surrounded by several tonnes of metal designed to protect the people inside the car. There are obviously exceptions but most of the accidents I see tend to be the fault of car/van/lorry drivers not looking properly, in fact I had a friend that was killed on his bike due to the inattentive driving of a car coming the other way.

Also when you say weaving, are you perhaps referring to filtering which is entirely legal (and acceptable) on motorbikes (and bicycles!)

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 14:09

BCCoach · 16/10/2023 14:04

It might be the 'vast majority' that you bother reading about but the reality is that motorcyclists make up only about 7.5% of total road fatalities. The numbers are easily obtainable here: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/reported-road-casualties-great-britain-annual-report-2021/reported-road-casualties-great-britain-annual-report-2021

Bother to read about? I don't "bother" to read just about motorcycle deaths. I just generally read the news and local SM and hear disproportionate reports of motorcyclist deaths.

OP posts:
PinkFootstool · 16/10/2023 14:09

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 14:01

Regardless of fault, doesn't something need to be done to make them less likely to be in an accident and die?

Those of us who take motorbike safety very seriously wear expensive protective clothing, high quality helmets and often take extra training to protect ourselves.

The problems remain with idiot vehicle drivers who don't look around themselves properly and that's out of our control.

There are also the idiot motorcyclists who wear shorts and tshirts, no protective gear and ride like absolute see you next Tuesdays - that's Darwinism in action. Especially the teenage / 20 somethings riding out with their mates, popping wheelies on their derestricted 50cc mopeds on dual carriageways. Fortunately the vast majority of riders are nothing like this.

If you're not familiar with the Highway Code, please check it as motorcyclists are permitted to filter in slow or static traffic. You should be aware of this as a possibility as a driver and drive accordingly.

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 14:06

Testina · 16/10/2023 13:59

“If someone can only notice other drivers by seeing them overtake, that's rather worrying!”

Where did I say ONLY?
I said “most likely”.

You seem to have a lot of bias of both the ordinary and confirmation type!

Incidentally, I bloody hate motorbikes - but I love statistics.

Your post was insinuating that I've misjudged the frequency in which I've seen speeding motorcycles, because I'm noticing them when they overtake.

I was saying, no. I DO notice when they speed to overtake but I also notice when they speed in front of me, behind me, in the distance. You may like statistics, but I know what I experience having driven for over 15 years.

OP posts:
Testina · 16/10/2023 14:04

“The graphic you posted is numbers, not rate, so it's possible that just reflects a decreasing number of motorcyclists on the road, rather than an improvement on them being involved in RTA”

I don’t think you understood the graph I shared. The top line is the rate of traffic, so it allows for your point. It shows that there was a reduction in motorcycle traffic, but that the reduction in fatalities was larger than that effect alone.

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 14:04

@Testina I'm not sure what the relevance is. If they're 50x more likely to die from an RTA, then surely something needs to happen to address that?

And that's either;

  1. reducing the risk of RTA
  2. reducing the risk of dying once in an RTA

Or...do we just accept that theyre more likely to die?

I still stand by my concern that many drive like racing bikes and don't abide by the rules of the road. That's not all, of course.

OP posts:
EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 14:01

Regardless of fault, doesn't something need to be done to make them less likely to be in an accident and die?

OP posts:
Testina · 16/10/2023 13:59

“If someone can only notice other drivers by seeing them overtake, that's rather worrying!”

Where did I say ONLY?
I said “most likely”.

You seem to have a lot of bias of both the ordinary and confirmation type!

Incidentally, I bloody hate motorbikes - but I love statistics.

Testina · 16/10/2023 13:57

“The graphic you posted is numbers, not rate”

It’s not numbers. It’s an index, relative to 2004.

Cowlover89 · 16/10/2023 13:57

My partner got in an accident years ago and the car was at fault

Cowlover89 · 16/10/2023 13:56

A lot of accidents when it comes it is because cars don't look out properly for them!

Testina · 16/10/2023 13:56

“If motorcyclists are 50x more likely to die on the roads that car drivers, something needs to be done? “

That’s not what I said. I said that they’re 50x more likely to die from an RTA, not 50x more likely to die on the roads. When they have an RTA, they come off more badly than car drivers (just as do pedestrians and cyclists). They are not 50x more likely to die than car drivers in overall fatalities.