Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Motorbikes and fatal accidents

133 replies

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 13:36

The vast majority of fatal accidents I read about involve a motorbike (and often a lorry).

Motorcyclists seem so vulnerable on the roads. AIBU to think something should be done about this?

I'm not trying to victim blame, but I often see motorcyclists weaving around the queues, speeding ridiculous speeds on motorways and generally not abiding by the usual rules of the road.

It's a bit like XL bullies. When you hear of a fatal dog attack, you can almost guarantee it includes a Bully. Same with fatal road accidents, it seems nearly each time it involves a motorbike.

AIBU to think, for their sakes, those of their families and for those traumatised by killing cyclists, that something needs to be addressed?

OP posts:
Kimsey1509 · 16/10/2023 16:01

As the mum of a 22 yr old motorcyclist who was killed by an articulated lorry driven by a man who thought he owned the road , I think it’s the law that needs changing. RTC’s are treated differently in law with lesser sentences. Road Peace are a charity petitioning the Government for this change in the law. My son wasn’t speeding, weaving in and out being stupid, he was riding home after meeting friends. No alcohol in his system. Of course as with everything you get the idiots , cyclists motorbike riders but at the end of the day it comes down to the law.
My sons killer got 8 years ( the highest we could have hoped for due to sentencing laws) He thought it unfair he was given that sentence, thought it was too much, so he dragged us to the high court in London where 3 Appeal Court Judges upheld his conviction of 8 years. He even said during his barristers speech that he can’t see how he was at fault. So no acknowledgement of guilt. Despite being shown the reconstruction of what happened , showing clearly he was at fault.
Nothing will change until the Law does. And more people like us are left with shattered families.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 16/10/2023 16:01

I was rear ended by a women on her phone

Yes far more needs to be done about this (and general distractions in cars - why are those large displays allowed).

enchantedsquirrelwood · 16/10/2023 16:00

samupnorth · 16/10/2023 15:07

The only thing that needs addressing is aggressive driving by (usually) men in certain types of cars. We need more police presence on the roads and huge fines given out for this type of driving . All road users would be safer then. Motorbikes are so much more vulnerable to aggressive drivers doing stupid things and killing motorbike riders.

Totally agree with this.

I remember someone saying to me about 20 years ago that all accidents between cars and motorbikes are the car driver's fault. I am not sure - I have seen lots of stupid overtaking by motorbikes, but probably much less of it in recent years, so maybe all the training and advanced driving courses are paying off. Doesn't help when a car driver does something stupid though except to give you a chance of getting yourself out of a dangerous situation.

I can only say I am glad my DH and DS don't ride motorbikes and don't want to!

I am not keen on "filtering", I think it's undertaking and dangerous. If you want to get past, overtake (I think most people on motorbikes do, it's people on pushbikes who go up the inside and then wonder (if they are still alive) why they get squashed.

ClarkGablesMoustache · 16/10/2023 15:58

@EmmaDilemma5 Yes, something should be done, and that something is educating car drivers about being motorbike- and cyclist- aware.

PoachedEggSandwich · 16/10/2023 15:57

As a biker, I can say that education is needed. For all road users.

I'd love an element of the CBT to be included in the car test. I wonder how many car drivers will think about their behaviour, when they're the one having a multi tonne vehicle sat up their backside.

Of course we're going to come off worse in an accident. We get catapulted off our bikes, we slide along roads and smash in to lampposts, we get run over by other vehicles etc. I was rear ended by a women on her phone. She was fine, I was not, because strangely, bodies being hit by cars, come off worse than vehicles playing bumper cars.

That's not to say some bikers aren't a menace on the roads, and believe they're the next marquez, or Dunlop - but the worst are the SMIDSY, the 'sorry mate I didn't see you', because they are on autopilot in the car, not concentrating because little timmy in the back is having a tantrum, or whatever reason where they shouldn't be in control of a vehicle if they don't have the ability to concentrate on the road at all times.

wildwestpioneer · 16/10/2023 15:57

In 2021 310 motor cyclists were killed in the uk, that's 20% of all fatalities were motorcyclists. I think it feels more because you tend to hear about them rather than car drivers

I've ridden bikes for years and I'm a firm believer that riding a motorbike for 6 months should be a pre requisite to applying for a car licence.

Mothership4two · 16/10/2023 15:53

OMG just remembered I have had an accident with a motorbike. I was reversing into a space on a high street and he drove straight into the back of me at some speed. He was very apologetic and took full responsibility and stuck to it despite his aggressive insurance company trying to do a knock for knock and saying I had no proof. I actually also had a witness, a oldish man knocked on my window afterwards and handed me his name, address and telephone number. They restored a bit of my faith in human nature!

PeggyPoggleshaw · 16/10/2023 15:49

vitahelp · 16/10/2023 15:36

See this is where it gets silly and the argument weakens..the guy is still a tw*t if he drives a Ford. Nothing to do with what country the car was manufactured in!

That's true, but certain makes of car attract certain individuals, that isn't in doubt. Of course, a contributing factor is that German cars are so common.

Jayne35 · 16/10/2023 15:46

I am a biker a d a member of a bike club. We are al, doing fine thanks and encounter way more issues with car drivers not paying attention. Maybe concentrate on using all your mirrors when driving to check what's happening around you - not just at junctions.

I hit a motorbike years ago while I was taking a right turn, I did check my mirrors but as he was doing over 100mph in a 30 limit I didn't see him until he hit me. A driver pulled over to wait for the police and give a statement as though he was not involved, he was not surprised to see there had been an accident because of the speed and dangerous overtaking, in a built up area.

I get that car drivers need to check mirrors but bikers really need to stick to speed limits, and many don't.

ReturnOfTheRainMac · 16/10/2023 15:42

You've got this wrong. Bikes filter in traffic. They all do because they're allowed, I believe it encouraged. The reason there are accidents or near misses is because the cars aren't leaving them space to do so or are not looking at their surroundings.

I'm not saying bikes are blameless but it's usually the fault of the car/lorry that hits them.

Timeforchangeithink · 16/10/2023 15:39

I am a biker a d a member of a bike club. We are al, doing fine thanks and encounter way more issues with car drivers not paying attention. Maybe concentrate on using all your mirrors when driving to check what's happening around you - not just at junctions.

vitahelp · 16/10/2023 15:36

PeggyPoggleshaw · 16/10/2023 15:21

Absolutely true, it's almost a guarantee they'll be driving a German car.

See this is where it gets silly and the argument weakens..the guy is still a tw*t if he drives a Ford. Nothing to do with what country the car was manufactured in!

DeltaAlphaDelta79 · 16/10/2023 15:34

I've had a motorbike licence for nearly 30 years and passed my bike test before passing in a car. Until I started car lessons I did not realise how invisible I had been to car drivers. Thats not because I was not making myself visible, but things like car door pillars and street furniture can obscure a motorbike fairly easily. Even with hi-viz clothing and headlights on the bike switched on, it doesn't always help plus motorbikes, even when going at the speed limit, appear to be going faster than they are.

I commuted into the nearby city every day for 20 years and luckily only had minor scrapes, which were not my fault. The only serious off I had, I was on my own and slid on some black ice - some would argue I probably should not have been out in those weather conditions, but it was my only form of transport and I needed to get to work.

I lost three friends, had one lose an arm and another become permanently disabled and they were all the fault of car drivers.

I haven't ridden for a couple of years now, but I think the general standard of driving - mostly car drivers - has decreased significantly, and as much as I miss it, I don't think I am in any rush to return to two wheels.

PeggyPoggleshaw · 16/10/2023 15:21

samupnorth · 16/10/2023 15:07

The only thing that needs addressing is aggressive driving by (usually) men in certain types of cars. We need more police presence on the roads and huge fines given out for this type of driving . All road users would be safer then. Motorbikes are so much more vulnerable to aggressive drivers doing stupid things and killing motorbike riders.

Absolutely true, it's almost a guarantee they'll be driving a German car.

PeggyPoggleshaw · 16/10/2023 15:19

A large percentage of RTCs involving motorbikes are the result of idiots in cars having the anticipation and awareness of a turnip and not having a clue what's going on around them. That isn't to say a lot of bikers don't ride like goons, however.

Mothership4two · 16/10/2023 15:12

@BabyDubsEverywhere

A good friend of mine was killed on his bike when doing 30 on a 30... the car pulled out on him and he was catapulted over the car. It was all caught on camera. He died at the scene.

Same here Babydubs and the rider was only 17

rwalker · 16/10/2023 15:09

LemonLight · 16/10/2023 14:49

I ride, and the biggest danger I've consistently noticed isnt exuberant motorcyclists (of which I admit there are many) but car drivers who don't check their mirrors or look properly before changing lanes or pulling out of junctions or on to roundabouts. The amount of times I've almost been hit on a roundabout is frightening. It's such a risk that as part of your test you have to show that you can do a tight evasive maneuver at speed. Although I have noticed in recent years there's been a marked increase of scooters/mopeds doing very silly things like undertaking lorries on single carriageways 🤦🏻‍♀️ makes me absolutely cringe but they only need a CBT and that's very easy to pass.

The problem is the majority of MN think undertaking is correct and the right thing to do which is frightening
as proved by a thread on this the other month

samupnorth · 16/10/2023 15:07

The only thing that needs addressing is aggressive driving by (usually) men in certain types of cars. We need more police presence on the roads and huge fines given out for this type of driving . All road users would be safer then. Motorbikes are so much more vulnerable to aggressive drivers doing stupid things and killing motorbike riders.

TodayInahurry · 16/10/2023 15:01

I often watch the Air Ambulance programmes and the injuries to motorcycle riders is often really bad. I believe they are something like 9% of road users and 20% of accidents. We get them a lot around here, going fast and overtaking irresponsibly. There are large notices on several roads telling them to slow down because of high accident rates.

gotomomo · 16/10/2023 14:57

And even at 36 degree temperatures I wear Kevlar, the stuff bullet proof vests are made of, it's hot!

gotomomo · 16/10/2023 14:50

When my dp was knocked off it was due to a car overtaking on a blind bend on his side of the road. How about banning cars from overtaking on corners, oh no that's already illegal but they still do it.

Motorcycles, especially the new low powered electric ones are a great mix to our lower carbon economy. Ideal for those without adequate public transport and too far for standard bikes

whatausername · 16/10/2023 14:49

@FrankieStein403 interesting points about the acceleration and the lights, thanks!

LemonLight · 16/10/2023 14:49

I ride, and the biggest danger I've consistently noticed isnt exuberant motorcyclists (of which I admit there are many) but car drivers who don't check their mirrors or look properly before changing lanes or pulling out of junctions or on to roundabouts. The amount of times I've almost been hit on a roundabout is frightening. It's such a risk that as part of your test you have to show that you can do a tight evasive maneuver at speed. Although I have noticed in recent years there's been a marked increase of scooters/mopeds doing very silly things like undertaking lorries on single carriageways 🤦🏻‍♀️ makes me absolutely cringe but they only need a CBT and that's very easy to pass.

KnittedCardi · 16/10/2023 14:47

It's perception thought isn't it? I live on a rural road, in a village 30mph. It has twists and turns, a bridge, and goes into a long and winding uphill 40mph section. Unfortunately most motorbikes, and believe me, it is most, because I see and hear them, go anything up to 70/80mph around here, because, I assume, it is fun. I have had motorbikes overtake on the blind corner, and when I am stationary, with indicators on, trying to turn right into my drive, which is just beyond the corner.

The road has recently been relaid, and is now smooth and inviting, even more tempting to speed on.

The road is used by horses and many bicycles, who also enjoy the uphill section. It's also a popular walking route. It's notorious for accidents, but still they speed.

This weekend a 60 year old was killed on the hill. To be fair, I don't know the circumstances, of who was at fault, but accidents are frequent here, and it's always, always, speed.

gotomomo · 16/10/2023 14:46

@EmmaDilemma5

You have never seen us or our friends then, we keep to all speed limits, go round corners slowly and the max speed for filtering in heavy traffic is 20mph. We have heavy duty protective clothing. The only place I have gone over 100 mph is in Germany and it was legal, I didn't like it and made him slow down

Cyclists are far more vulnerable!