Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Motorbikes and fatal accidents

133 replies

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 13:36

The vast majority of fatal accidents I read about involve a motorbike (and often a lorry).

Motorcyclists seem so vulnerable on the roads. AIBU to think something should be done about this?

I'm not trying to victim blame, but I often see motorcyclists weaving around the queues, speeding ridiculous speeds on motorways and generally not abiding by the usual rules of the road.

It's a bit like XL bullies. When you hear of a fatal dog attack, you can almost guarantee it includes a Bully. Same with fatal road accidents, it seems nearly each time it involves a motorbike.

AIBU to think, for their sakes, those of their families and for those traumatised by killing cyclists, that something needs to be addressed?

OP posts:
ReturnOfTheRainMac · 18/10/2023 07:19

LouOrange · 17/10/2023 20:18

I cannot believe they don’t have to wear hi-viz, in fact I think every a-typical road user should legally have to (horse, bike, that twat who was jogging in the road last week, back to the traffic, wearing grey and with the worlds weakest head torch on his head).

If you open your eyes and look further than your nose, they don't need to wear hi viz. some people miss cars if they're not bright yellow...

LouOrange · 17/10/2023 20:18

I cannot believe they don’t have to wear hi-viz, in fact I think every a-typical road user should legally have to (horse, bike, that twat who was jogging in the road last week, back to the traffic, wearing grey and with the worlds weakest head torch on his head).

XenoBitch · 17/10/2023 20:15

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/10/2023 11:39

Despite many posters anecdotes about how bikers are only at risk because terrible drivers fail to look properly, the table posted yesterday showed that 22% of motorbike fatalities involved no other vehicles. Plenty of bikers are a significant hazard to themselves. To pretend otherwise is plain daft.

The one time I came off a bike was when it was wet and I hit a patch of diesel. There was no way to avoid it, and I was literally grinding to a halt in traffic anyway.
Had it been on a roundabout, with other traffic about going at normal speed, then I may not be here typing about it.

Basically, you can't say that the 22% of fatalities are the biker's fault. Sometimes it is the environment (or mechanical issues).

SinnerBoy · 17/10/2023 14:23

JemimaTiggywinkles · Today 11:39

Despite many posters anecdotes about how bikers are only at risk because terrible drivers fail to look properly, the table posted yesterday showed that 22% of motorbike fatalities involved no other vehicles. Plenty of bikers are a significant hazard to themselves. To pretend otherwise is plain daft.

I agree, many "born again" bikers are a menace to themselves and not a few die on country roads, overtaking on blind bends, or overcooking it and hitting a wall.

Then again, when there's a car, or van involved, the biker is innocent in a majority of cases.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/10/2023 12:56

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/10/2023 11:39

Despite many posters anecdotes about how bikers are only at risk because terrible drivers fail to look properly, the table posted yesterday showed that 22% of motorbike fatalities involved no other vehicles. Plenty of bikers are a significant hazard to themselves. To pretend otherwise is plain daft.

So nearly 80% aren't? And some of that percentage will include mechanical failure, sudden illness and things like freak weather, falling trees, etc.

ConfusedandLostt · 17/10/2023 11:52

XelaM · 16/10/2023 14:41

There is a documentary on Netflix (I believe) called Road about the famous Dunlop family- generations of road motorcycling champions. Literally all of them (I think with one exception) died on the road. 😢

You're aware they died while racing right? They weren't pootling and dicking about on a trip to Tesco... The Dunlops are incredible and Michael, having seen his uncle, dad and brother die due to racing is particularly special as far as I'm concerned. But it's not the same thing as a normal RTA

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/10/2023 11:39

Despite many posters anecdotes about how bikers are only at risk because terrible drivers fail to look properly, the table posted yesterday showed that 22% of motorbike fatalities involved no other vehicles. Plenty of bikers are a significant hazard to themselves. To pretend otherwise is plain daft.

SinnerBoy · 17/10/2023 10:49

PinkFootstool · Yesterday 14:09

The problems remain with idiot vehicle drivers who don't look around themselves properly and that's out of our control.

And the ones who just don't care and have the attitude of "You can get out of my way."

Last Saturday, I was going to the Tyne Tunnel at the 40mph limit, a woman came speeding down the slip road, with no intent to stop - there was a car close behind me and traffic in the right hand lane. I beeped her and she stuck two fingers up and I had to go close to the white line. She then followed me too closely and moved to the right hand lane dangerously, pulled alongside me and leant over her passenger to hurl abuse and give it more V signs.

I can't count how many similar incidents like that I've had after 30 years of riding!

I've been knocked off three times, none of them were my fault. One guy pulled out of a side road, I'd already slowed in anticipation and he looked me in the eye as he pulled out.

The Police arrived and he was still ranting and swearing, blaming me, saying it was my own fault, as bikes are dangerous and we don't pay road tax....

Testina · 17/10/2023 09:46

@Nothing2SpendOn “How many car drivers do you read on here who are anxious drivers”

This is one of my MN bugbears. Then get some bloody lessons! It’s like it’s perfectly acceptable. Especially motorways. If you’re too scared to be on a motorway then get off the road completely. But better still - take motorway lessons, and sort yourself out.

ReturnOfTheRainMac · 16/10/2023 22:39

@NeverDropYourMooncup so sorry for your experiences. I really hope people read what you've written here and take note. You've described it exceptionally well.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/10/2023 21:57

I stopped riding a bike after my second truly hairsbreath away from death experience - most bikers will recognise the 'Ah, I'm getting off now' moment when a van is charging towards you on your side of the road and there's nowhere for you to go other than sideways or the moment you're suddenly looking up at the sky and performing a discrete self test starting with 'can I feel my toes?' to the sounds of 'Sorry, mate, didn't see you there' - along with the staring up at a sump because the driver behind you at the roundabout had seen you, stopped behind you, watched you waiting for a gap in the traffic, looked away and then decided to floor it directly through you because they forgot you were still in front of them going at a speed of precisely 0 mph.

Walking (well, limping) out of A&E later one afternoon to wait for a bus with a fractured 2nd cervical vertebrae led me to believe that I'd had All of the Luck in the World and it was wise to not push it any further. The permanently numb two fingers and half my palm on the left are a useful reminder of just how bloody lucky I was, as is the way I still topple over sideways if I try to put a sock on whilst standing up.

Drivers are frequently utter morons with a complete allergy to mirrors and looking anywhere other than where they want to be. And some are outright murderous.

bombastix · 16/10/2023 21:43

I still like bikers as people. They are very nice ime. Good times even if it was dangerous.

blacksax · 16/10/2023 21:40

Cowlover89 · 16/10/2023 13:56

A lot of accidents when it comes it is because cars don't look out properly for them!

Well they do tend to appear out of nowhere at something approaching the speed of light. I saw an accident last year. I was driving along a country road, there were several cars in front of me, and a motorcyclist overtook the lot of us at high speed, totally misjudged the next bend and shot right off the road and into a ditch. Entirely their own fault.

Nothing2SpendOn · 16/10/2023 21:31

How many car drivers or lorry drivers do you see on mobile phones, eating & drinking, therefore not paying full attention

How many car drivers do you read on here who are anxious drivers

How many drivers do you see going too fast in very bad weather

I rode motorbikes before I owned a car. It makes you very aware of potential dangers

JemimaTiggywinkles · 16/10/2023 21:26

There are idiots on the roads of all persuasions. Pedestrians who cross without looking, cyclists who jump lights, bikers who speed, car drivers who pull out without looking, HGV drivers who use mobile phones.

The important thing is that all road users need to acknowledge that there will always be dickheads around, and we all need to use the roads as carefully and defensively as practical. Realistically, this means being aware and (for everyone other than pedestrians) staying within the speed limit. Being slow gives you more time to react to the unexpected and makes a collision less likely to be fatal.

Some people choose to take more risks - if they hurt themselves well that's on them and if they hurt others they need to be in prison. Ideally the roads would be better policed, but I think that's unrealistic in the current climate.

XenoBitch · 16/10/2023 21:16

YABU

I used to be a biker, and was very sensible on the road. You have to be, as you can't trust the idiots in cars to be awake, let alone see you. Hence the 'Think Bike!' campaigns.

I can no longer ride, and really miss those days.

bombastix · 16/10/2023 20:52

It is a UK issue I think. Riding in Europe drivers were very courteous, probably because many of them started out on mopeds or similar.

When I rode in London however that was not what happened! Lots of aggression.

FrankieStein403 · 16/10/2023 20:47

Being aware is not the solution just a mitigation.

IMHO the issue is relative speeds - the reason cyclists, scooters on pavements 'frighten' pedestrians is relative speed - stopping suddenly, moving sideways is not much of a problem for other pedestrians but is a gotcha when cyclists/scooters are nipping along the pavement.

The same thing happens with bikes/cars - drivers don't expect other vehicles to be moving significantly faster than "traffic", bikes often do. Bikes 'weaving' through traffic at speed are unexpected therefore frightening. (not necessarily for self but because of what might have happened)

A response to being frightened is often anger - hence car/bike aggro.

SoupDragon · 16/10/2023 20:45

I had a lot of men abuse me because well... I was faster than them

unusual to hear of so many men going below the speed limit .

waterlego · 16/10/2023 19:58

Funnily enough, reading your post made me realise I can’t really remember the last time I saw a motorcyclist riding really dangerously. It seems like something I used to see quite often but less so now. @Testina’s post is interesting and seems to suggest that those who ride motorcycles now are safer than those who rode motorbikes in the past. Whether that’s because they themselves are riding more carefully or because car drivers are being more careful around them, I don’t know, probably a bit of both.

bombastix · 16/10/2023 19:26

I used to ride a motorbike. One day a guy went through a crossroads red light when I was getting ready to go as my light was green.

I road the bike home and then sold it. I knew then it did not matter how good I was on the road. One idiot could kill me.

I still like them and ride them on holiday. Motorbikes are brilliant for going to difficult to reach places and mountain ranges where other vehicles cannot go. And there is a lot of freedom and friendship on those roads.

But never again in the UK. I had a lot of men abuse me because well... I was faster than them. Ridiculous

BishyBarnyBee · 16/10/2023 19:11

Dotjones · 16/10/2023 13:41

All that needs to happen is that riders who behave inappropriately get properly sanctioned. It's already illegal to do 150mph on the motorway, the riders that do this just need to be caught.

I think it's the same with cyclists, they need to be made responsible for their actions. Obviously a speeding motorcyclist is most likely to harm themselves more than other road users, but cyclists are more likely to harm pedestrians more than themselves.

The thing that needs to happen is prosecution, banning from riding, and jail for those who flout the law by speeding through red lights.

It's actually not true that cyclists are more likely to harm pedestrians than themselves. The number of collisions with pedestrians is incredibly low, and the number of deaths is only 1 or 2 a year. Obviously every death is a tragedy and I am not excusing bad cyclists at all, but they are far more likely to injure themselves than a pedestrian. And inattentive pedestrians are a genuine danger to cyclists. I know of a cyclist who died when a pedestrian stepped in front of them without looking, they hit their head and were killed.

As a careful cyclist, I am at risk daily from bad driving, poor cycling and careless pedestrians. There are inattentive and selfish road users of every type. Ideally, there would be consequences for all reckless behaviour on our roads, but in practice many people know they can break the law with impunity and just do whatever is easiest for them.

Bearcub101 · 16/10/2023 19:02

Bikes are allowed to weave in and out of traffic- it’s called filtering.
Problem is car drivers not looking out for bikes. Teach your child now to look out for bikes- it will be a habit they’ll keep for a lifetime.

vitahelp · 16/10/2023 18:56

gabsdot45 · 16/10/2023 17:15

DH used to ride a motor bike. He came off it one day and broke his collar bone. He got absolutely no sympathy in the hospital. One doctor told him that "Around here we call people like you organ donors".
Thankfully he sold the bike soon after.

That’s dreadful treatment by the doctor. Would he say the same to smokers with lung cancer and alcoholics with liver failure? I hope not.

BadgeronaMoped · 16/10/2023 18:51

I'm sure this has alredy been said, but nobody is forcing people to get on motorbikes, most bikers enjoy getting on their bike, actively choosing to do so! Let them ride, drive aware Smile