Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Motorbikes and fatal accidents

133 replies

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 13:36

The vast majority of fatal accidents I read about involve a motorbike (and often a lorry).

Motorcyclists seem so vulnerable on the roads. AIBU to think something should be done about this?

I'm not trying to victim blame, but I often see motorcyclists weaving around the queues, speeding ridiculous speeds on motorways and generally not abiding by the usual rules of the road.

It's a bit like XL bullies. When you hear of a fatal dog attack, you can almost guarantee it includes a Bully. Same with fatal road accidents, it seems nearly each time it involves a motorbike.

AIBU to think, for their sakes, those of their families and for those traumatised by killing cyclists, that something needs to be addressed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EmmaDilemma5 · 20/02/2024 21:25

Jc2001 · 20/02/2024 19:56

You should be checking your mirrors a hell of a lot more than that. You're not a good a driver as you think your are.

Righto...

OP posts:
Mothership4two · 20/02/2024 20:01

@LakieLady

Better driver awareness would be the best way to reduce deaths imo, although I'd probably support a restriction on riding the most powerful bikes until someone's held a full bike licence for a few years.

I agree there needs to be much more done about driver awareness. We have a handful of motorbike deaths ever year within just a few miles radius of here (and the amount is increasing). There are long straight roads that attract bike riders especially the "twats" LakieLady mentions at weekends - speed cameras have been set up due to them treating the roads like their own personal race tracks. You do see some idiotic riding, but most of the deaths seem not to be the fault of the riders but usually of a car driver. We see these sad stories all the time in the local news.

Jc2001 · 20/02/2024 19:56

EmmaDilemma5 · 16/10/2023 13:54

That doesn't make sense to me. I look out of the front windscreen 98% of my driving time. Therefore I can see all vehicles in front of me. So I can see what speed they're driving at.

For the other 2% of my time, I'm checking my side and rear mirrors, and I can see them there too.

If someone can only notice other drivers by seeing them overtake, that's rather worrying!

You should be checking your mirrors a hell of a lot more than that. You're not a good a driver as you think your are.

LakieLady · 20/02/2024 19:26

Mothership4two · 16/10/2023 15:12

@BabyDubsEverywhere

A good friend of mine was killed on his bike when doing 30 on a 30... the car pulled out on him and he was catapulted over the car. It was all caught on camera. He died at the scene.

Same here Babydubs and the rider was only 17

A friend of mine gave up riding after a similar accident, although she was doing 40 in a 40. It was a perfectly clear, bright day, excellent visibility, a dead straight road, she was wearing hi viz and the driver reckoned she "just didn't see" her coming. Amazingly, apart from some pretty bad bruising, her only injuries were 2 broken thumbs from braking so hard right up to the moment she hit the roof of the car.

The woman who pulled out in front of her got points and a fine for driving without due care and attention, and her car was written off because the roof was badly dented where my friend hit it. I think that was pretty lenient, she could have bloody well killed her.

My late DP rode bikes for over 40 years, and was a despatch rider for years, so did a lot of miles. Apart from a few spills in the first few months, he had 2 accidents in all that time: one when a car went into the back of him when he was stationary at a red light, and one when a driver changed lanes without checking his mirrors, leading to DP getting a dislocated hip and spending months in hospital (I don't count the time when someone opened the door of a parked mini in a narrow Soho street as DP passed as an accident, DP stuck his foot out and took the door of the mini off). We have several friends who are lifelong motorcyclists with excellent safety records.

I don't deny that there are bikers who ride like twats, especially the middle-aged, born-again bikers with "all the gear and no idea", and the odd one like my DF, who should never been allowed out on the road on a push bike, never mind a motorcycle, and was a dreadful driver in a car. But most of the near misses or accidents I see are where a driver has failed to properly check their mirrors or look over their shoulder, or has simply failed to see them (including a fatal one that I witnessed on my way to the station one morning, that was dreadful).

Better driver awareness would be the best way to reduce deaths imo, although I'd probably support a restriction on riding the most powerful bikes until someone's held a full bike licence for a few years.

WithManyTot · 20/02/2024 18:51

MintJulia · 16/10/2023 18:43

I rode a bike from aged 16-25. While I was studying, I had a (very well paid) part time job as a courier in London.

It is perfectly possible to ride a m/bike safely although it requires riders to slow down, be aware of all the traffic around them and to pay attention to tyre treads, brake pads, lights etc.

Bikers are vulnerable and extra caution is needed but speed and poor maintenance are usually the issues. You do obviously get the occasional idiot in a car or lorry but that applies to all traffic.

There is also a benefit for female riders. For 7 years I travelled by bike at night in central London, and was never once hassled by a man. 😊

^^This

The objective in all forms of driving is "Not to be involved in other people's accidents"

Motorbike, car, us, lorry, pedestrian it makes no difference, all the other road users are human, and humans make mistakes, it is unreasonable to expect them not to.

People say, its the fault of user A not looking, but it's also the fault of user B not acting defensively, and expecting user A not to have seen them, and not expecting the million other unexpected things that happen on the road because the other person is at fault.

CranfordScones · 20/02/2024 17:48

It's fine saying, "something must be done" but what are you suggesting?

The tiered licence system and training requirements are quite demanding and intended to stop young and inexperienced riders from getting on powerful bikes too soon or too young. That's a vast improvement on how it used to be. Years ago, the examiner would stand on the pavement and watch you ride round the block a few times!! Now they follow you and watch your every move. You really can't skimp on the training these days. Unfortunately, riders are much more vulnerable on two wheels and much more exposed in the event of an accident.

Coyoacan · 20/02/2024 17:24

But your comment about traffic police is ill thought out. Thanks to government cutbacks there's a massive shortage of them, just like all other specialist police roles, so they're already stretched

Well I was being a bit cross-cultural there, as I and my friend live in Mexico City. I don't know if there is a shortage of traffic police here, but that is the only thing that will make motorcyclists and drivers be more careful.

But I do think the food delivery services should be made to act more responsably too. They give short deadlines and pay their couriers very low wages or commissions.

PeggyPoggleshaw · 20/02/2024 17:13

Coyoacan · 20/02/2024 15:08

A friend of mine recently spent time in an orthopedic ward and the vast majority of patients were there because motorbike accidents. Maybe traffic police need to do their job better and I would suggest that delivery companies need to accept their share of the blame.

I used to work on an orthopaedic ward that specialises in pelvic surgery. A large percentage of patients were motorcyclists who'd been knocked off their bikes, usually T-boned.

But your comment about traffic police is ill thought out. Thanks to government cutbacks there's a massive shortage of them, just like all other specialist police roles, so they're already stretched.

MikeRafone · 20/02/2024 16:58

Dotjones · 16/10/2023 13:41

All that needs to happen is that riders who behave inappropriately get properly sanctioned. It's already illegal to do 150mph on the motorway, the riders that do this just need to be caught.

I think it's the same with cyclists, they need to be made responsible for their actions. Obviously a speeding motorcyclist is most likely to harm themselves more than other road users, but cyclists are more likely to harm pedestrians more than themselves.

The thing that needs to happen is prosecution, banning from riding, and jail for those who flout the law by speeding through red lights.

Can you show me the evidence that a cyclist is more likely to harm the pedestrians than themselves? I’ve always been lead to believe the reverse is true due to the cyclist being higher up & likely to fall, I turn harming themselves more. It would be good to show local highways as I’m not in favour of shared pavements for cycling & walking

Timeforchangeithink · 20/02/2024 16:49

GasPanic · 20/02/2024 14:57

Bikes frighten the hell out of me and generally I just want to let them past/get away from them if on a motorway. If I am on a single lane A road and a bike is close behind generally I will slow and pull over to give them room to overtake as soon as possible (most of the time they want to). Watch out for them, steer clear of them as much as possible.

As regards whether stuff should be banned. Well the world would start to get to be a pretty boring place if everything dangerous was banned. Drinking. Smoking. Takeaways. Sugary drinks. Chocolate. Crisps. Skiing. Sitting on your arse watching TV. The list would be pretty much endless.

Please don't slow down or pull over. If its safe to overtake they will do so. You xliwing down and pulling over means we've got to work out if you're turning/stopping as well as checking we're clear to overtaken. Just concentrate on your own driving.

Coyoacan · 20/02/2024 15:08

A friend of mine recently spent time in an orthopedic ward and the vast majority of patients were there because motorbike accidents. Maybe traffic police need to do their job better and I would suggest that delivery companies need to accept their share of the blame.

GasPanic · 20/02/2024 14:57

Bikes frighten the hell out of me and generally I just want to let them past/get away from them if on a motorway. If I am on a single lane A road and a bike is close behind generally I will slow and pull over to give them room to overtake as soon as possible (most of the time they want to). Watch out for them, steer clear of them as much as possible.

As regards whether stuff should be banned. Well the world would start to get to be a pretty boring place if everything dangerous was banned. Drinking. Smoking. Takeaways. Sugary drinks. Chocolate. Crisps. Skiing. Sitting on your arse watching TV. The list would be pretty much endless.

mumda · 20/02/2024 14:46

When driving young children about teach to play ispy motorbike.

Shout when they see a bike.

BishyBarnyBee · 19/10/2023 15:05

SinnerBoy · 18/10/2023 21:08

Wanker bikers, wanker car drivers, wanker lorry drivers wanker cyclists, wanker Amazon drivers. All absolutely 100% representative of their cohorts...

Absolutely this. But you missed wanker pedestrians. A percentage of all road users, of all kinds, are an absolute liability to themselves and everyone around them.

SinnerBoy · 18/10/2023 21:08

Wanker bikers, wanker car drivers, wanker lorry drivers wanker cyclists, wanker Amazon drivers. All absolutely 100% representative of their cohorts...

FrankieStein403 · 18/10/2023 20:50

>So, when I'm doing 20 in a 20 limit, or 30 in a 30 limit (which I always am) and some wanker comes hooning up behind to sit 2 feet off my back wheel, it's, erm, my fault for speeding. OK, I see.

Because all car driver always drive at, or below the speed limit, don't they?

More drivers get closer to the speed limits these days but yes IMHO the vast majority of car drivers run above the speed limit - some very much above the limit.

However I wasn't saying that bikers exceed the speed limit I was saying that they usually significantly exceed the traffic speed - cf I was coming down a wet M1 this pm, traffic was reasonably heavy North of Luton but in one of those spells where 4 lanes were running at around 55 the gantries saying 'reports of debris'.

Presumably the superhero biker batting down the outside at 70 thought he could dodge round flying bits of tyre - as if that would be the only risk he was taking.

Trampley · 18/10/2023 20:18

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/10/2023 11:39

Despite many posters anecdotes about how bikers are only at risk because terrible drivers fail to look properly, the table posted yesterday showed that 22% of motorbike fatalities involved no other vehicles. Plenty of bikers are a significant hazard to themselves. To pretend otherwise is plain daft.

Incorrect, they're not a hazard to themselves, they're more vulnerable.

Avoiding debris, potholes, having to emergency break because some dickhead driver has pulled in front of them, drivers going well over their lane, literally dozens of hazards you can easily swerve in a car, you can't do on a motorbike.

I think every driver should complete at least a CBT on a moped before getting a car licence.

Trampley · 18/10/2023 20:13

If motorcyclists are 50x more likely to die on the roads that car drivers, something needs to be done?

Yes! Drivers need to actually LOOK and be better drivers and be much more aware of motorbikes.

The majority of accidents are CAR/LORRY drivers at fault.

You clearly know nothing if you're victim blaming motorcycle riders.

BCCoach · 18/10/2023 19:56

Apologies @ReturnOfTheRainMac I clearly responded to the wrong post in my rage at the othering 😁

SinnerBoy · 18/10/2023 19:11

FrankieStein403 · Today 10:49

Combine that with bike going faster than the normal traffic flow (which it always is) and you have at best a near miss.

So, when I'm doing 20 in a 20 limit, or 30 in a 30 limit (which I always am) and some wanker comes hooning up behind to sit 2 feet off my back wheel, it's, erm, my fault for speeding. OK, I see.

Because all car driver always drive at, or below the speed limit, don't they?

"What's that, Lassie? The poster's stuck down a well with a strawman?"

ReturnOfTheRainMac · 18/10/2023 17:15

@BCCoach don't think that was meant for me. @LouOrange described as atypical.

BCCoach · 18/10/2023 17:11

ReturnOfTheRainMac · 18/10/2023 07:19

If you open your eyes and look further than your nose, they don't need to wear hi viz. some people miss cars if they're not bright yellow...

The fact that you class perfectly normal and legal road users as “atypical” speaks volumes about your attitude to other road users.

TheGooseDrankWine · 18/10/2023 10:57

I have had cause to spend many hours over 20 years in orthopaedic wards and limb reconstruction clinics

Top 3 causes of smashed limbs amongst those I talk to: motorbike accidents, construction site accidents, football!

FrankieStein403 · 18/10/2023 10:49

>people just don't see us, because they don't LOOK.

Many cases perhaps but in many cases 'look' simply does not spot the bike. Bikes are less than 1/3 the width of a car, front view with rider is almost always dark - you only need a road with dark metal surface, dark hedging on the verge for the bike to be effectively invisible to the normal "look".

OK the "look" should be more specific but the vast majority of times there isn't a bike there and learned behaviour means the "look" gets briefer.

Combine that with bike going faster than the normal traffic flow (which it always is) and you have at best a near miss.

Do drivers have to be perfect for bikes to be safe?

PoachedEggSandwich · 18/10/2023 07:21

LouOrange · 17/10/2023 20:18

I cannot believe they don’t have to wear hi-viz, in fact I think every a-typical road user should legally have to (horse, bike, that twat who was jogging in the road last week, back to the traffic, wearing grey and with the worlds weakest head torch on his head).

So that's what I've been doing wrong, all I needed to do was wear hi viz and other road users would see me.....

No dice.

I can categorically state, it literally doesn't matter what we wear, people just don't see us, because they don't LOOK.