Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move my child to a new school already?

56 replies

Cosycardigans · 16/10/2023 12:00

I think I'm being unreasonable, but I wanted some feedback.

So the current situation- lived in council house for nearly two years. Moved here from another area when DD was 2 as it was dire where we lived (drug dealer upstairs, loose dogs, fights outside the flat, neighbours making malicious reports to social services and council on me and most neighbours everytime they got a chance- mine was because my DD bumped her head and had an egg). Was glad to find this house to swap to, however it's starting to get really hard here.
I don't drive and am basically at the top of a hill and the bus route I'm on is the one most affected by the bus driver shortages. The other day it took me three hours to get home instead of 30 minutes from town, as the bus didn't show up after an hour and then had to cross town to the train station and wait 45 minutes for a 4 minute train journey and then had to walk up the very steep hill in the dark with a poorly DD in her buggy (had taken her to the walk in centre for antibiotics as it was a weekend). I'm going out less and less with DD now as it's so hard to get home when the buses are cancelled and they don't announce cancellations anywhere . I can pop out alone during school hours as I can walk back half the way and get a different bus half the way, but DD has suspected autism and doesn't walk far for very long (paediatrician says with autism pain or discomfort is more heightened so a slightly hard walk or ache is unbearable for her). DD is not quite 4.5 and petite and I have some physical difficulties since giving birth which make pushing a buggy uphill really agonising (fibromyalgia, hypermobility and seperated abs).

There's nothing in my area, at the top of the hill other than a small children's park, and a corner shop- ten minutes walk away. There's a butcher ten mins walk away but I'm veggie and talk of other shops being built at the end of next year, but nothing confirmed.

As a result, going anywhere is like a proper mission and I feel like our social life is declining. I don't take DD swimming or just to see friends in town or pop out any more, unless I know I've got enough for a taxi home as a back up. Mentally I feel like this all takes up so much space and I'm supposed to be job hunting for a job which fits into school time but I can't think straight and keep wondering 'but what if there's no bus to get back and pick DD up'. I waited about 45 mins for a bus to pick her up when I had to go into town the other day, but luckily I put her into after school club as I knew there would likely be problems. The buses are timetabled every 15 minutes. We can't be spontaneous or anything, ever. I've been stuck in the woods once with her in the rain when a bus didn't show up for an hour after we went to a nearby garden centre event. I paid 18 in a taxi to come out and get us and take us home. The event was only down the road but as it's countryside there was no pavement to safely walk back home on. The bus company didn't reply when I emailed asking for compensation. I'm not in a position to drive anytime soon, as I'd need a job and I'm getting depression from it.

So I've put an advert out for a house swap. I couldn't afford to privately rent anywhere off this hill, so I'm limited to choose from who I could swap with. So far, I've only had offers from towns 15 minutes drive away, but about 30 minutes by bus, including walking to the bus stop. However, there's been one which has really caught my eye. It's by the beach, opposite two affordable supermarkets, has a leisure centre literally next door, cafés, a soft play next door. The woman is very very keen to swap and sounds legitimate. She wants a garden and has a flat. I'm honestly not worried about losing my garden as it's extra work anyway for me atm and we would have the beach and a big park opposite. There's a lot more for us to do and I could walk around after school with DD and have places to go, things to do and people to talk to.

However it's the school situation which is killing me over the decision. DD started school six weeks ago and LOVES it. She loves her teachers and asks to go every day. Obviously I know she would be leaving her teachers anyway next sep to move to a new class but she's so attached to them already. She's really good at making friends and loves the routine. She's also on the SEN register and they so far seem to be supporting her. It would be a 40 minute commute to get her to her school from the new place and that's assuming the bus shows up on time. However I think they cancel day time buses more than the commuter ones. Obviously I know we couldn't maintain the commute for very long and would eventually have to move to the school near the swap flat (right next to it as well). The other thing is that a couple of girls are already picking on DD and the school haven't been able to nip it in the bud, so it would be good to get away from that situation. However, despite the 'mean girls' as she calls them, she loves everything else about school and they're supporting her needs to an extent. Maybe I could move, get a job in the supermarket opposite, and use my wages to learn to drive and then it would only be a 15 min commute to the school.

I really don't know what to do. The holidays are depressing as anything as I feel so stuck.

OP posts:
Hickry · 16/10/2023 14:04

Large class sizes versus tiny school with smaller classes isn't a black and white situation in my experience.

Sometimes a bigger school or class is more likely to make a little branch off group/cohort/pod if kids find it loud. Its not always the case that big school = bad, small school = good for Sen. They also when bigger may have more staff, funding, the options to move the groups of kids around each school year if there are clashes etc. My eldest was in a tiny primary school and my youngest is in a big school but that feels like a small school. They're all very different and you won't really know for sure until you try each school really, unless it has a massively huge bad reputation locally. 🤷

The lady who wants to swap probably wouldn't be open if her neighbours are asbo wannabies. I'd look at the address myself if possible. Not in the flat, just the building, block, street, neighborhood etc. Wander round/hang about. Ideally at a couple of different times of day.

In your shoes I'd join a local Facebook mums group or FB neighbourhood group and ask about the school and the street/general area. Hopefully someone local can advise you with a "boots on the ground" experience.

Cosycardigans · 16/10/2023 14:03

i guess it's true- nothing will ever be perfect and there may be some negatives whatever i choose, but the ones i have currently are too much to mentally cope with long term.

OP posts:
Pinkdelight3 · 16/10/2023 14:02

Move and move schools to the one close to the new place. Your DD will adapt and probably forget about this first school. The other pro's outweigh the cons.

UndertheCedartree · 16/10/2023 13:59

It definitely sounds like the positives outweigh the negatives. I say go for it and move DD's school. Good luck with everything!

Cosycardigans · 16/10/2023 13:55

btw my dd is sensory seeking so i'm not sure if the need for smaller groups is neccessary for her. as a baby she used to cry for me to take her into any crowds of children she could see (my worst nightmare as an introvert!)

OP posts:
Cosycardigans · 16/10/2023 13:54

the new school is split into infants and juniors, so even though there's three classes per year, there's only nine classes in the building. which makes it smaller than the current school of fourteen classes. i don't know if the junior and infant building have the same headteacher, i need to look into it. current school does have a lovely field but i guess as the get older they only use it at break times anyway!

exactly @SusiePevensie , most of the time these days i've only got energy and money to stay local. i like the idea of not having to do a weekly shop and just choose my dinner each day and be more spontaneous. there's a weekly workshop opposite which i had wanted to join a while ago but obviously didn't want to travel back home in the dark. i do need to check for any anti social behaviour. is there a way to do this, without asking the swap lady?

OP posts:
SusiePevensie · 16/10/2023 13:47

My kid is on the SEN register too - not dismissing @jeaux90's experience, but we've found the opposite.

SusiePevensie · 16/10/2023 13:46

Move. A bigger school is likely to have more resources, which could be helpful too.

Where you're moving to sounds like the 15m city idea. Lots of stuff near where you are - so days when you've got energy/cash/a car/a plan you can do ambitious stuff. And days when you are tired and broke life can still be ok.

jeaux90 · 16/10/2023 13:46

I'm going to say this a mum of a SEN kid with ADHD and ASD.

Larger schools and large class sizes are really bad for SEN kids. Smaller schools/classes is where they thrive. If the new school is similar then fine.

Is there any chance you can learn to drive? It feels like this is the killer thing in your life.

Hickry · 16/10/2023 13:43

I'd move.

I've been in your shoes, young child on the spectrum and not a car driver, it's tough. I'd not care about losing the garden if there's a park and beach near the flat at all. I love having a garden but every year the struggle to maintain it seems to grow.

The only thing I'd check before moving is the flats. What are the neighbours like, any noise, crime, anti social behaviour etc. These are tricky to manage in any living situation but in flats it can seem even worse. If that's all good then I'd go for it.

I used to worry about changing my eldest's life in big ways when he was younger and he always did really well. He followed my lead so any big positive change he did great and we both thrived. Trust your instincts and good luck. 🙂

DailyMailHater · 16/10/2023 13:43

After Christmas won’t be too far in at all, doing whilst she is in those early years is the best time

grab the opportunity as soon as you can

Cosycardigans · 16/10/2023 13:41

ah the support is so nice, thank you, all of you.

so i don't think we'd be able to move just yet. last time i did a swap, it takes the council a month to give you a decision after you submit the application. so i'm thinking we would end up moving after the christmas holidays? would that be too far into her school experience, does anyone think? this is assuming the new school has a space in the middle of the year. otherwise we would commute and wait it out.

i've asked about the neighbours and she said they are all quiet and welcoming. i'll have to go and view it obviously, and check it out properly. have looked on google maps and it's all a nice area surrounding the block. really clean streets, nice cafes around and brand new leisure centre next door. the main thing i keep seeing though is that it's all flat all around! it's got a communual garden. i know i might miss my garden but honestly i never go into my garden here- i always feel too exposed. i can see little granny benches outside some of the ground floor flats on streetview, so it looks like it's not too antisocial (or they wouldn't leave them out there?)

i'm in the process of doing DLA. i'm hoping it won't take too long. i've got all the evidence from school now so can finish it off and send it this half term. the only thing is the assessment team said they would wait until she's settled for six months in school, before observing her for a potential diagnosis. i don't know whether to wait for that to happen first, or let it happen in a new school.

i'll have to ask the new area school if they have places, and also if they would do a trial couple of days. it's half term here so could call them afterwards.

the new school has good ofsted, the current has outstanding. the new school is a three class year and the current school is two. she really really loves the school. i wasn't so sure at first, from a communication perspective, but i'm warming to it.

i agree, it might be hard to swap again once i'm in a flat, but maybe my prospects would change anyway with more energy from getting out more and opportunities around me.

OP posts:
DailyMailHater · 16/10/2023 13:29

move, she will settle in new school and the improvement to both of your quality of life outside of school will have a major (positive) impact for you both.

good luck x

Sugargliderwombat · 16/10/2023 13:25

Move, she'll be fine! She's only 6 weeks in, we often have this happen (I'm an eyfs teacher). Children haven't even really formed solid friendships yet and most are still settling.

Symphony830 · 16/10/2023 13:08

Moving sounds a good idea.

It’s so hard moving kids when they are happy and pulls at the heart strings, but you’re the grown-up and can see how advantageous this move would be for the both of you.

MaryShelley1818 · 16/10/2023 13:04

Definitely move! You sound like a fab mam by considering literally all of your DDs needs and making the best decision for both of you and her future. Rather move her after six weeks than a year or so when she's really settled. Sounds like it would be lovely for you both.

Nowherenew · 16/10/2023 13:03

If your DD has not long started school then I’d say this is the best time to move.

Its so much easier to move when they are young and not fully in the routine of school.

I would think very hard about the implications of moving to a flat and giving up your garden though.

Its much more difficult moving from a flat to a house if you ever change your mind.

I’d also look into what the new school is like and if there is any antisocial behaviour in the flats or near them.

But tbh the new flat sounds ideal for you both and I think moving will be the right decision.

Heatherbell1978 · 16/10/2023 13:03

It's a no brainer to move to improve your life. Remember to think about yourself as well as your child. Good luck!!

Tohaveandtohold · 16/10/2023 13:03

I’d move and change schools asap. She’ll adapt to the changes and will surprise you as well. Where you live currently does not work for you at all

Needmorelego · 16/10/2023 13:03

Move if you can but have you put in a claim for DLA for her?
That will help towards taxis etc if you need to use one.

Nousernamesleftatall · 16/10/2023 13:02

Move. Can she do a trial day or two in the new school?

Myyearmytime · 16/10/2023 12:59

Move
But check what the buses are like

ItWasntMyFault · 16/10/2023 12:57

I would move - it's much easier for little children to adapt to new schools than older ones and the new place sounds great.

mynameiscalypso · 16/10/2023 12:56

I have a well-settled reception starter too so I get where you're coming from. I'd still move her though. I didn't think my DS would settle at school as he was very attached to his friends/routines/key workers at nursery but he forgot them almost immediately. If I had to move him for a better quality of life overall, I'd do it for sure.

HattieIou · 16/10/2023 12:52

Move her definitely