Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Eurostar should be cheaper than flying?

94 replies

ClaudiaWankleman · 16/10/2023 11:42

I’m looking at £176 for a return flight to Amsterdam versus £246 on the Eurostar. Flight from London City so just as convenient (for me).

AIBU to think that the Eurostar should be cheaper? I remember going to Paris a couple of years before Covid for £120 return which seemed like a decent price. The same journey is presumably much more now.
Given the carbon cost and the number of passengers compared to flying, AIBU to think the Eurostar is very expensive?

OP posts:
ClaudiaWankleman · 16/10/2023 14:47

Aaron95 · 16/10/2023 13:23

You are paying for convenience. When you factor in the travel to/from the airport and the waiting required at airports, the train is quicker than the plane. It takes you right from the centre of one city to the centre of the other.

It's the same for train travel in the UK. It's quicker to go by train from London to Glasgow than it is to fly.

Train definitely not quicker than the plane unfortunately.

I'm quite down because I would have loved to do the Eurostar, but it just doesn't make any sense at all.

OP posts:
ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 16/10/2023 14:46

An even more illogical comparison .

Return flights to Dublin from Birmingham are cheaper than return train travel to Oxford .

They both take a similar amount of time, but still ......

There are probably other similar examples . I only know this one as they were journeys that DS and I had undertaken (separately).

Livelifelaughter · 16/10/2023 14:44

Pretendthatwearedead · 16/10/2023 14:40

Isn't the Eurostar more convenient? I've never used it but I assume you don't have to check in 2 hours before the train leaves, queue up at security or leave your car in a long stay car park that costs a fortune etc. You can just get on the train and go. I'd expect it to be more expensive as it would be a more convenient and more pleasant experience.

It used to be . I had a friend staying with me from the US and was telling him how fab the Eurostar was and how much calmer ...we were literally queuing outside the station, staff yelling, massive queues...they ask that you're there 90 minutes before and there's barely anything past security.

Pretendthatwearedead · 16/10/2023 14:40

Isn't the Eurostar more convenient? I've never used it but I assume you don't have to check in 2 hours before the train leaves, queue up at security or leave your car in a long stay car park that costs a fortune etc. You can just get on the train and go. I'd expect it to be more expensive as it would be a more convenient and more pleasant experience.

DdraigGoch · 16/10/2023 14:36

notimagain · 16/10/2023 13:32

It's quicker to go by train from London to Glasgow than it is to fly.

Out of interest, never tried it, but surely if Google is correct with it's claim of a typical rail travel time of 5 hrs 30 there can't be much in it.

(I appreciate a lot depends on how much of a buffer you put in at the departure airport)

4h32m from Euston to Glasgow Central. HS2 phase 2 would have cut that to 3h40m which would be genuinely competitive with air, but our helicopter-loving PM has cancelled that. If we were Spanish we'd have already built a high speed line all the way to Glasgow and the journey time would be as little as three hours.

By comparison Easyjet and BA advertise 1h15m (Luton/Stansted), 1h25m (Heathrow) and 1h30m (Gatwick). Obviously you've got to get to/from the airport so we're probably talking an extra 30m at the Glasgow end, an extra 30-60m at the London end depending upon which airport, plus the time to go through security.

Then you need some breathing space - if trains are delayed and you miss a connection you can get on the next train, not so easy by air. I got back into Amsterdam several hours late a little while back (long-distance trains through Germany have been a pain for more than a year). Eurostar staff just rebooked me onto the next train with no fuss at all. Would an airline do that?

oohsharon · 16/10/2023 14:35

"it's quicker to go by train from London to Glasgow than it is to fly"

Until they cancel the train while you're on it and leave you to rot in Preston 🤣🤣

ClaudiaWankleman · 16/10/2023 14:30

cartagenagina · 16/10/2023 13:50

Eurostar is a much better experience than flying, so to many people it’s worth any extra cost.

Also, you need to add on any additional travel costs to and from airports at both ends. Eurostar takes you into the heart of the city.

Plus the cost of baggage. A basic EasyJet fare will be for a small cabin bag, but you can take shitloads of baggage on Eurostar, including liquids, and a certain amount of your own booze.

I would never fly somewhere that I could get to by Eurostar, but appreciate I wouldn’t feel like that if I didn’t live in SE.

I'm not 100% sure I agree with the experience being nicer on the Eurostar. When I last went to Amsterdam (2017ish) on the Eurostar I seem to remember there was no Wifi available for at least 2 hours because the satellite signal it used was so poor. The flight is only 70 minutes so total time offline would be shorter. It's no different London end (City airport versus St. P) but definitely better Amsterdam side arriving at Centraal over Schipol.

OP posts:
ClaudiaWankleman · 16/10/2023 14:27

5foot5 · 16/10/2023 13:53

I also would think you can get cheaper than £246.

We have just booked Eurostar London to Amsterdam and return fare is £233 BUT we have booked the Premium Standard, or whatever it is called, for the outward trip. It would have been much cheaper if we had just gone Standard both ways.

I can get it for cheaper too, I am sure. But my point is that I compared flights and the Eurostar at the most convenient times to me, and the Eurostar is significantly more expensive. I've compared apples with apples. Flight would have been with KLM, so I would be able to bring a small suitcase in the cabin.

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 16/10/2023 14:18

Early December is definitely Christmas travel time and tickets will be more expensive

If you book ahead and not at busiest times Eurostar is quite reasonable. Personally I don't mind paying more to avoid hours in airports, transport to city centre, packing headaches to comply with baggage rules etc.

But it is a real scandal how expensive trains are here, within the UK as well. They're so much cheaper in other countries. You can't blame people for driving or flying when trains are so expensive.

crackofdoom · 16/10/2023 14:12

caspergutman
Looks like it might be worth your while checking out the price of a 4 day Interrail pass- 200 odd quid for an adult, less for "youths", FREE for under 12s. Then you just have to pay a Eurostar supplement- 38 euros pp each way for Amsterdam I think. And ALL UK train travel is 100% free!!! The only thing to watch out for is that you have to book your Eurostar reservations nice and early, because they do sell out at popular times.

PinkRoses1245 · 16/10/2023 14:10

You're right - but flights should be more expensive, and rail travel subsidised. The only cheap fares on Eurostar are at random times

CasperGutman · 16/10/2023 14:08

I'm looking at travel to Amsterdam in the Easter holidays. I actually thought the Eurostar fare of £432 return was relatively reasonable.

Then I priced up rail connections to St Pancras from the city we live in, a couple of hours away. That's an extra £603, taking the total to £1035.

I'd say the cost of the domestic leg of the journey was a bigger issue, rather than Eurostar in particular.

crackofdoom · 16/10/2023 14:06

As PPs have pointed out, demand is outstripping supply for Eurostar at the moment. They would love to put more trains on, but due to increased post Brexit passport checks taking way more time, hence passengers having to spend longer in the terminals, they can't fit any more people into the terminal at St Pancras (or Gare du Nord, for that matter). This is hoped to ease as epassport checks start working better (in April we discovered that the epassport gates couldn't do kids yet, so all the families with children had to go and wait in a VERY long queue at GdN 🙄).

That said, you can usually get a better price than that. Booking early helps, as does flexibility around times- but given you're aiming to go to Amsterdam and back in a day, I'm guessing you're looking for specific trains OP 🤔

MassageForLife · 16/10/2023 13:57

"it's quicker to go by train from London to Glasgow than it is to fly"

It's great when you can get a train that goes direct. My trip I have coming up (Scotland to England) needs two or three changes, but I can get a direct flight - cheaper, easier and quicker. Including the time and cost to and from the airport.

5foot5 · 16/10/2023 13:53

I also would think you can get cheaper than £246.

We have just booked Eurostar London to Amsterdam and return fare is £233 BUT we have booked the Premium Standard, or whatever it is called, for the outward trip. It would have been much cheaper if we had just gone Standard both ways.

cartagenagina · 16/10/2023 13:50

Eurostar is a much better experience than flying, so to many people it’s worth any extra cost.

Also, you need to add on any additional travel costs to and from airports at both ends. Eurostar takes you into the heart of the city.

Plus the cost of baggage. A basic EasyJet fare will be for a small cabin bag, but you can take shitloads of baggage on Eurostar, including liquids, and a certain amount of your own booze.

I would never fly somewhere that I could get to by Eurostar, but appreciate I wouldn’t feel like that if I didn’t live in SE.

notimagain · 16/10/2023 13:32

It's quicker to go by train from London to Glasgow than it is to fly.

Out of interest, never tried it, but surely if Google is correct with it's claim of a typical rail travel time of 5 hrs 30 there can't be much in it.

(I appreciate a lot depends on how much of a buffer you put in at the departure airport)

Aaron95 · 16/10/2023 13:23

You are paying for convenience. When you factor in the travel to/from the airport and the waiting required at airports, the train is quicker than the plane. It takes you right from the centre of one city to the centre of the other.

It's the same for train travel in the UK. It's quicker to go by train from London to Glasgow than it is to fly.

heathspeedwell · 16/10/2023 13:18

Eurostar is so much more civilised than flying. We usually book in advance so it's a lot cheaper too. I wish they would open Ebbsfleet up again.

Livelifelaughter · 16/10/2023 13:11

I booked a few Eurostar trips this year and I thought they were so expensive, booked in advance etc. Also it seemed quite fraught, massive queues etc. I also ended up paying extra for premium as the main carriages were just packed...

notimagain · 16/10/2023 13:10

@witheringrowan

Full capacity of Eurostar trains is about 850 passengers. I don't know how that compares to a plane.

For info for your common or garden short haul aircraft such a a 737 or an A320, think in terms of 180 per aircraft, but there's a big plus/minus on that depending on variant.

But because of the issues I mentioned before, they could only run 2 trains an hour - and that has to cover Paris/Brussels/Amsterdam. I think at the height of the problem capacity was down 30%, although it has eased slightly now. I don't know how many flights depart all London airports every hour for those destinations, but I'm happy betting its considerably higher.

Haven't got time to dig into now but top of the head you'd quite possibly looking at (again on average) one an hour out of somewhere like Heathrow to Paris, a bit less frequency for Brussels and Amsterdam...then of course as you say, factor in the other London airports, plus flights from the UK regions directly to those three destinations..(e.g Manchester - Paris)

Not sure what these subsidies on flights are that have been mention, always seemed like the money went the other way, for example Airport Passenger Duty (APD) which people pay on their tickets makes HMG a significant amount of dosh in a year...(over 3 Billion sterling in 22/23).

If people are thinking of the old chestnut of (no) tax on fuel well, unless you can reach an agreement to equalise any such tax across, say, the whole of the EU you're almost certainly doomed to see something called tankering increase on some routes, which would increase emissions

https://www.icao.int/environmental-protection/Documents/EnvironmentalReports/2022/ENVReport2022_Art38.pdf

https://www.icao.int/environmental-protection/Documents/EnvironmentalReports/2022/ENVReport2022_Art38.pdf

MojoDojoCasaHouse · 16/10/2023 13:03

Our family of four is doing Eurostar for the first time next week. It worked out half the price of EasyJet. I did book many months ago though.

MikeRafone · 16/10/2023 13:00

go through arrivals at Schipol.

be very care at departures - they have a problem with pickpockets on phones - then you are leaving the country

Comeasyouwere · 16/10/2023 12:38

If you are going to Amsterdam, the extra cost to go on Eurostar is (in my opinion) absolutely worth not having to go through arrivals at Schipol. Last time I was there (July 2023) it took 2 hours to get through passport control. The time you will save at the airport (at both ends, for both journeys) is worth it!

mn29 · 16/10/2023 12:37

Yanbu. I was looking at Paris for half term. For two adults, two teens it was £1,200 return on the Eurostar and that was the most basic tickets. The cost of flights is less than half that but I don’t want to fly due to the environmental impact. Most people will just go with the cheapest option, sadly, but flying shouldn’t be the cheapest option!

Swipe left for the next trending thread