Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Eurostar should be cheaper than flying?

94 replies

ClaudiaWankleman · 16/10/2023 11:42

I’m looking at £176 for a return flight to Amsterdam versus £246 on the Eurostar. Flight from London City so just as convenient (for me).

AIBU to think that the Eurostar should be cheaper? I remember going to Paris a couple of years before Covid for £120 return which seemed like a decent price. The same journey is presumably much more now.
Given the carbon cost and the number of passengers compared to flying, AIBU to think the Eurostar is very expensive?

OP posts:
MariaLuna · 16/10/2023 18:03

go through arrivals at Schipol. Last time I was there (July 2023) it took 2 hours to get through passport control.

That's due to Brexit. You are in the queue for "All other passports" now. (As opposed to the "EU passports" line).
Never taken me more than 15 minutes at Schiphol.

Steev · 16/10/2023 17:38

Maybe you'll get a discount because of all the alleged bedbugs currently crawling all over the Eurostar.

notimagain · 16/10/2023 17:35

Airlines pay much less for fuel than anyone else does, that is an indirect subsidy.

Care to put a figure on "much less"?

Aviation fuel in the UK is bought on the open commercial market, lots of negotiations involved, then hedging etc, so hard to pin down what any airline pays on any given day.

Now having said it's normally at this point "but VAT" gets mentioned.

Fair point, there's no VAT on aviation fuel so just for fun, how much difference do you think VAT on fuel would make on, say, the aforementioned London-Glasgow flight?

A slightly informed, back of envelope calculation follows, please bear with me...

London-Glasgow on something like a A320/B737 might burn 3 tonnes of jet fuel, that's very rough figure, but it will do for the purposes of the sums.

It's hard to work out the cost of fuel to any specific company (commercial agreements etc) but it could credibly be around 900 US dollars a tonne ATM, so the LON-GLA flight burns 2700 USD worth of fuel...

ATM no VAT so that's a 2700 USD fuel bill for the sector.

Now put VAT on at a, say, 25% hypothetical rate; fuel bill becomes roughly (rounding up ) 3400.USD....

i.e. the fuel bill has gone up by all of 700 USD.

Spread across a typical short haul load of 180 passengers that's an increase per ticket on that flight of just less than...4 ( yes four) USD....

So put VAT on fuel and you up the cost of a London Glasgow by less than five pounds...that'll really cause people to flock to the railways.

TBH no idea why rail fares in the UK can be as astronomic compared with air fares but I suspect it'll be that old favourite, market forces/ what the market will support..

kingkongs · 16/10/2023 17:01

They should be encouraging rail travel, the prices in the UK and from the UK are outrageous.

I'd love to travel by rail more but can't justify paying twice as much as it costs to go in the car or fly.

crackofdoom · 16/10/2023 17:00

ginmonkeyagain On the last weekend of the Easter holidays we arrived at GdN half an hour before check in opened. We got to the departure lounge half an hour after our train was supposed to have left (luckily it was delayed by 45 minutes 😆).

Other than that though, I really love Gare du Nord! I might be the only one though....

ClaudiaWankleman · 16/10/2023 16:59

Finbad · 16/10/2023 16:01

It’s supply and demand.

I paid £29 each way in the summer last year because I booked in advance.

Just book in advance

I am booking just as in advance for the Eurostar as I am for the flight. The comparison is completely valid.

Plus saying ‘book in advance’ isn’t really useful, and it’s not really advice. If I knew I wanted to be in Amsterdam on that weekend a year ago I would’ve booked it. As it happens, I didn’t.

OP posts:
crackofdoom · 16/10/2023 16:55

Regarding subsidies: Cornwall Council bungs Newquay Airport £3.5 million per year to keep it running- I don't know about anywhere else. That's a lot of bin collections, pothole maintenance and home carers. I haven't checked, but I suspect that it gives GWR/ Network Rail the sum total of £0.

Ginmonkeyagain · 16/10/2023 16:51

@PeloMom yes it is true - they were deliberately underbooking trains as they could not guarantee to get every one on in time due to all the extra checks.

We used to find 2 hours change over in Paris was more than enough time, now it is pretty tight (I mean GdN being unutterably shit hasn't helped the situation)

Fogwisp · 16/10/2023 16:49

It's because the most environmentally unfriendly things are subsidised by taxpayers, so, in the case of flights (but not gas bills) they're cheaper, rather than that the Eurostar is expensive. Though yes, I think it should be the other way round ideally.

PeloMom · 16/10/2023 16:47

I read somewhere this summer that the Eurostar services and cars per train have been reduced after Brexit due to the additional passport checks they have to do. Not sure how much truth here is to it but if there are less seats they sell, that may be contributing to the higher prices.

CatherinedeBourgh · 16/10/2023 16:40

Aaron95 · 16/10/2023 16:38

Rail travel used to be subsidised. It was roughly 50% subsidised until 15 years or so ago. Since then the government has reduced the subsidy paid to train companies to zero.

People seem to be inferring that flights are subsidised. Is that really the case? aside form lifeline flights to the outlying islands, I would be surprised if that really is true.

Airlines pay much less for fuel than anyone else does, that is an indirect subsidy.

CatherinedeBourgh · 16/10/2023 16:39

Yanbu. I live in France and looked at getting to London on the train for 4 of us and it came to 4x the cost of flying (and 4x as long).

I really want to travel by train but it has to at least come close to the same cost. I'm willing to put in the extra time, but there are limits.

Aaron95 · 16/10/2023 16:38

PinkRoses1245 · 16/10/2023 14:10

You're right - but flights should be more expensive, and rail travel subsidised. The only cheap fares on Eurostar are at random times

Rail travel used to be subsidised. It was roughly 50% subsidised until 15 years or so ago. Since then the government has reduced the subsidy paid to train companies to zero.

People seem to be inferring that flights are subsidised. Is that really the case? aside form lifeline flights to the outlying islands, I would be surprised if that really is true.

Aaron95 · 16/10/2023 16:35

oohsharon · 16/10/2023 14:35

"it's quicker to go by train from London to Glasgow than it is to fly"

Until they cancel the train while you're on it and leave you to rot in Preston 🤣🤣

Yes trains occasionally has issues. But the same can happen with flights. We just got bumped from a flight due to overbooking and had to spend 24 hours in Turkey. Not fun.

Ginmonkeyagain · 16/10/2023 16:22

We paid less than that to go all the way from London to Perpignan (inc. Eurostar) this summer - we did book tickets for July in early April though. We tend to go for the earliest morning train out and the latest train back (easy for us as we don't have to make a connection once we get to London) as they can be cheaper.

Your other problem is you are doing Friday to Sunday- those are always the more expensive Paris tickets.

We factor in lower transfer costs (we can get a bus or local train to St Pancras and when we got to Perpignan we walked to our Hotel) less waiting time and better baggage rules to our Eurostar usage.

There is no doubt that Brexit has rather fucked the Eurostar business model - you need to leave a lot more time to check in and they no longer run the direct London to Marseille train which was a good value way to get to the South of France.

Finbad · 16/10/2023 16:01

It’s supply and demand.

I paid £29 each way in the summer last year because I booked in advance.

Just book in advance

notimagain · 16/10/2023 15:33

@DdraigGoch

Thanks for the detailed reply...

With reference to some of the sums people have done, over the years I had one of the Heathrow terminals down to a fine art and reckoned you could reasonably arrive (car/Tube/Heathrow Express, these days Elizabeth line) an hour ahead of planned departure with hand baggage only and make the flight fairly comfortably...

..and as a general point aimed at no-one in particular I'm still waiting for all these details of subsidies for flights...I thought rail was the mode notorious for being subsidised?

One look at the things that airlines pay to HMG, airport operators and others per flight such as landing fees, ramp fees and handling charges, navigation charges etc etc would make most people's eyes' water..and then as mentioned earlier there is the Airline Passenger Duty...

The airlines keep prices down mainly due economy of scale.

DdraigGoch · 16/10/2023 15:23

ClaudiaWankleman · 16/10/2023 14:30

I'm not 100% sure I agree with the experience being nicer on the Eurostar. When I last went to Amsterdam (2017ish) on the Eurostar I seem to remember there was no Wifi available for at least 2 hours because the satellite signal it used was so poor. The flight is only 70 minutes so total time offline would be shorter. It's no different London end (City airport versus St. P) but definitely better Amsterdam side arriving at Centraal over Schipol.

2017 was a long time ago.

duchiebun · 16/10/2023 15:22

10 plus yrs ago it was cheaper for me to fly to Scotland vs the train, seems silly.

Aaron95 · 16/10/2023 15:19

LeefsPrings · 16/10/2023 15:09

We found similar a few years ago when we needed to get from Luton to Glasgow. £39 flight that took an hour or £120 train that took all day. No-brainer really.

If you compare only the time spent moving then yes it is a no brainer. But assuming you live in London, its not as simple as that.

Travel to Luton airport- 1 hour
Checkin,security/waiting time at airport - 2 hours
Flight - 1 hour
Travel from GLA to city - 1 hour

You can get on the train at Euston 5mins before it leaves and get off again right in the centre of Glasgow 5 hours later.

DdraigGoch · 16/10/2023 15:19

CasperGutman · 16/10/2023 14:08

I'm looking at travel to Amsterdam in the Easter holidays. I actually thought the Eurostar fare of £432 return was relatively reasonable.

Then I priced up rail connections to St Pancras from the city we live in, a couple of hours away. That's an extra £603, taking the total to £1035.

I'd say the cost of the domestic leg of the journey was a bigger issue, rather than Eurostar in particular.

Edited

Another case of prices being hiked due to limited capacity. Again the government have just abandoned the scheme that would have substantially increased capacity between London, the Midlands, and the North.

LeefsPrings · 16/10/2023 15:09

We found similar a few years ago when we needed to get from Luton to Glasgow. £39 flight that took an hour or £120 train that took all day. No-brainer really.

Comtesse · 16/10/2023 15:07

Book well in advance and it can be dead cheap, like 60 quid a return. Shorter check ins, everyone sitting together, and basically infinite baggage (we travel with SO much stuff it’s unbelievable).

They used to run so many more trains but nearly went bust during Covid and assume the recovery has been very tricky.

However, I don’t think the Amsterdam route is at all competitive - not many trains, whereas Paris/ Brussels a more compelling offer.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/10/2023 14:57

Whataretheodds · 16/10/2023 11:46

It sounds like you mean 'shouldn't we stop subsidising air travel and start subsidising train travel?'

This sounds like a good plan to me!

Not much chance with current govt though

DdraigGoch · 16/10/2023 14:52

cartagenagina · 16/10/2023 13:50

Eurostar is a much better experience than flying, so to many people it’s worth any extra cost.

Also, you need to add on any additional travel costs to and from airports at both ends. Eurostar takes you into the heart of the city.

Plus the cost of baggage. A basic EasyJet fare will be for a small cabin bag, but you can take shitloads of baggage on Eurostar, including liquids, and a certain amount of your own booze.

I would never fly somewhere that I could get to by Eurostar, but appreciate I wouldn’t feel like that if I didn’t live in SE.

Some airlines will even sting you for cabin luggage. Eurostar on the other hand permit two large cases, plus a smaller bag absolutely free.