Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sorry for my 4 year old

183 replies

ApologiesandSanctomony · 16/10/2023 10:36

With Halloween coming up, dc2 has been letting us know that he absolutely wants to go trick or treating. He loves dressing up, and has excitedly helped put indoor decorations up; it is becoming evident that he loves this time of year. The issue is he will be alone, with dh taking him around. I have tried to focus on doing fun things indoors, but he still wants to go. He is so little, and the thought of him standing at doors on his own, with dh hovering, upsets me.

DD who is 6 is ND, and under no circumstances wants to accompany him. She has made it clear that she wants to stay indoors. DD has said that she wants to play a game where she knocks on a door inside our house, and trick or treats me, then I'm to give her sweets. She doesn't want to dress up, but does wish to wear a Halloween themed top. I'm trying to make the evening fun for her with pizza with ds, and spooky treats. Trick or treaters knocking scare her, so I will be putting a bowl of sweets outside.

I feel so sorry for them both, ds being alone, and it is making it more upsetting to me by the indoor game dd wants to play. If they both were happy indoors having a spooky fun evening it would feel fine.

Has anybody experiencing a similar situation? I just feel abit sad for them both.

OP posts:
Crafthead · 17/10/2023 08:38

When I was little Halloween wasn't a big deal. It looked like it was one on American TV shows and films but round our way maybe one gaggle of raggedy unkempt kids would knock & ask for trick or treat and that was it. I certainly never trick or treated and we didn't decorate the house or garden or anything... It's up to you whether or not to make it a big deal in your family.

My eldest (now 21) is autistic and hates the noise of fireworks, so we never did that. In the grand scheme of things I don't think it deprived our family of much tbh.

DappledThings · 17/10/2023 08:36

CarpetLady · 16/10/2023 11:13

Like this 😂

Love that. I have to do it for the first time this year I will definitely be the lady in the orange coat labelled "mortified".

Urgh.

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/10/2023 08:33

LovedmyRaleighChopper · 16/10/2023 10:54

It is a bit sad if you don’t have any Mum friends with kids of similar ages. Most people have built these relationships at playgroups, childminders or nurseries by now but it’s not too late. Isn’t he at reception yet with a class WhatsApp group? In my area you get the odd single parent with a kid or two trick or treating but mostly it’s a few mums with a gang of kids who’ve probably got together over the kids. Ask the other parents wherever he mingles what they are up to that night, you’ll find others in a similar situation.

This just complete and utter rubbish.

There's no need for 'mum friends' unless you want them.

RedHelenB · 17/10/2023 08:30

Needmorelego · 16/10/2023 10:39

Why is it sad that he goes just with his Dad? Isn't that what most children do?

This.

DinnaeFashYersel · 17/10/2023 08:28

Your 4 yo won't care and he also won't be the only child by themselves.

This is all in your head.

emailstome · 17/10/2023 08:27

I don't think you need to feel sorry for him. Every year I open the door to a variety of trick or treaters. Some come in small groups, some are little ones on their own with a parent hovering in the background. To be fair, the little ones on their own usually get told to take two sweets instead of one, so your DS will probably come home with a double haul Grin

Gerrataere · 17/10/2023 08:23

Some people are being very harsh to the op. Have some sympathy, when we have babies we can’t help but imagine all the typical things we will do with our kids, that come so easily and naturally to other families. When you have a child that struggles with things that other children enjoy - parties, yearly events, simply going on a family outing - it can be heartbreaking. Parents of ND children are often just told to ‘suck it up and get on with it’ like we had to leave any feelings of sadness or even grief at what could have been at the door of diagnosis. No, these feelings shouldn’t even be placed on the child but that doesn’t mean they can’t be felt.

Partyqueen005 · 17/10/2023 08:14

It's ok to feel a bit sad that the reality isn’t fitting your preferred vision (we all do that sometimes!) but I’m afraid it is unhelpful for you to feel that way, and an overreaction to the actual situation.

My DD is 4. I will be taking her out trick or treating solo, as we did last year (she wanted to go from age 3- the lure of the sweets is strong in this one!). Only child so used to doing things solo!

I think rather than seeing it as a negative around your DD’s plans, I think it shows a wonderful amount of self awareness for a ND 6 year old. She’s identified that the whole thing is too overwhelming for her, chosen the bits she does want to participate in and what she can manage this year 🤷‍♀️

Hope they both have a lovely evening. Maybe plan something nice together in the run up (pumpkin picking/decorating?) you can all do together.

LuckySantangelo35 · 17/10/2023 08:14

It’s not a big deal op
sure both your kids will have a lovely night

ClairDeLaLune · 17/10/2023 08:11

Could you suggest to your DD that you all go walking round as a group and she doesn’t have to dress up, and just send DS to knock on doors? This is what we did for a couple of years as DS would never dress up or knock on doors. Then go home and do her activity all together?

I get you OP, it’s tough when one child doesn’t want to do “normal” child activities. But really, who defines normal? There’s so many social rules to abide by and when you think about them, many are just invented and ridiculous. You need to find your own normal as a family and to not care if it’s different from someone else’s.

millymog11 · 17/10/2023 07:58

Not read the whole thread.

Apart from Halloween which is the most ridiculous preposterous commercialised con out there (above christmas and all the others) you OP (yes you OP)are setting yourself up for two children who can hyper sense that mummy is feeling all their feelings on a moment by moment basis - when they are teenagers you might find yourself being played like only teenagers can.

Your child is 4. It will be a massive novelty to go out with your DH to knock on a few doors even if only for 30 minutes 45 minutes. He will be totally oblivious to the fact that he is not going with other children as it will be so excited to be out with his Dad until he realises which he will that there is something wrong because his mum looks so sad on his behalf!

come on! he is 4 years old. It is effin halloween. if you never mentioned it he might hardly even notice there are no other children with you and your DH when he goes out.

ToadOnTheHill · 17/10/2023 07:54

To give you some perspective, one child is knocking on doors for free sweets, lots of positive fuss about their costume and one is playing a game that they have made up and is excited about. Each getting to so exactly as they've asked and will receive 100% of an adults attention.

Each child is 100% happy.

And you feel sorry for them why? Because its bot what you imagined 2 kids would be? Kindly, OP, this is a you problem and you need to reflect on this so you can enjoy the children you have.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 17/10/2023 07:50

You are massively overthinking this.

rocknrollaa · 17/10/2023 07:48

It's fine OP. What do you think children with no siblings do?

TheaBrandt · 17/10/2023 07:46

God op you will need to toughen up if you think that’s sad!

Lorijune · 17/10/2023 07:45

It’s wonderful that you and dh understand and listen to what both children need. I can understand the feeling of sadness you have and not sure why others don’t get it?! You may find over the years that your two might not undertake activities together in the way you’d imagined/hoped. My eldest is off to Uni now and youngest is 4. The advice I’ve always given myself (and others if they ask for it) is to find acceptance with what is. Accept the children for who they are, accept yourself for your fears and anxiety, accept that some of your hopes/expectations won’t be met in your family. Accept the evening for what it is but also share (as you have done) your thoughts with others as there’s lots of kind people who will want to help in some way.

WandaWonder · 17/10/2023 07:33

Do you always find things to be dramatic about for no reason?

KilgoreTrouts · 17/10/2023 07:33

widowtwankywashroom · 16/10/2023 11:21

I think trick or treating is bloody awful.
Knocking on doors asking for treats.
You wouldn't do it any other night of the year.

There’s always one.

It’s like the people who get all crazed about toddler reins being about ‘having your child on a dog leash’.

SmileyClare · 17/10/2023 07:26

You can have a “fun spooky evening” as a family.

It’ll only take ten minutes to knock on a few doors with his dad. There’ll be all the local kids doing the same thing.

Hes 4 so hardly staying up all evening, it’s a school night for dd, it’ll be cold and probably raining out.

Lower your expectations 😂

Children generally enjoy the build up to halloween more than anything.

HAF1119 · 17/10/2023 07:16

Try to see it as an early experience to let them be different but happy. If DS is disappointed explain that it's totally fine for them to like and want to do different things and can both have fun - as things like this may come up again. Sometimes with ND his sister may not want to go over to a Santa, but encourage that it's totally fine for him to, they're just different. It's nice if he wants to be independent and do those things, and equally is okay for his sister to be more cautious.

I used to be 'made' to join in with things with my brother and it definately increased my personal anxiety - which just isn't worth it for things other than school etc

SmileyClare · 17/10/2023 07:13

This is so melodramatic.

You’ve built a fantasy in your head of what hallowe’en will look like for your family. Confused

Darkmode2 · 17/10/2023 06:56

Your 4 year old will feel nothing but excitement while he's out, he won't care that he's only with his dad

Tumbleweed101 · 17/10/2023 06:55

Your DD could use this year to 'practice' safe at home but be more confident to go out and do some neighbours houses next year.

Gerrataere · 17/10/2023 06:49

user1492757084 · 17/10/2023 04:06

Tell your daughter that her brother wants to go out Trick or Tricking but that she doesn't have to go and can play her games at home..
Don't make a big deal about it. Once your DD sees her brother come to no harm it might give her more confidence for next year when she might try joining him for a few local houses.

Idealy she will overcome her fear of normal interactions.
Your son has no fear which your DD should see as normal.
I would not show your alarm at him wanting to do something different.

Seriously? The daughter is ND, no amount of ‘showing her’ or expecting ‘normal’ (awful word in this context) social interaction will get her to overcome that. My eldest has a huge anxiety that comes with autism, he’s never been trick or treating. I wouldn’t dream of sitting in on Halloween night pointing out all the ‘normal kids doing normal things’, many ND kids are already hugely aware of how they don’t fit in.

@ApologiesandSanctomony I understand your sadness, I do. You’re allowed to recognise that some things that other families can do simply has to be done differently in your lives. It’s similar in my house, Christmas for example has to be very carefully planned so not to cause an overwhelming scenario (especially since one of my children still doesn’t ‘get’ the concept of the day at all, though he does love presents 😂). You’re doing the right thing, both your children will have the Halloween they want.

2Jays · 17/10/2023 06:40

We are in this situation too. It's fairly common for ND families and yes it is ok to feel sad.

Our DD (14) used to be part of a huge friend group with which we did loads of activities. Before we knew she was autistic (masking, compliant, huge meltdowns at home), we did all sorts of events. However around the age of 7 things started to go pear shaped at school and this started a long and traumatic journey to get a diagnosis and her needs met in education.

Her DD (10) was always included in activities but that obviously all changed when the oldest started to struggle. We lost our friend group because of all the stress and nearly lost our marriage and our minds. Our youngest managed to form a small friend group at school but has since become home educated (her request) and is more isolated than ever, despite my best efforts to find groups and activities.

Having an ND child in a family is hard. It changes the dynamic and limits the usual activities. We struggle to do anything together as a family. We don't go on holiday together and even simple trips are hard work. And yes it makes me feel sad that my youngest has had to live with the fall out from all of it. The damage caused by professionals, the gaslighting, the fight for every bit of help and understanding, it has all taken its toll.

So when you speak about just wanting to do a simple thing like trick or treating together, I really understand why that would make you sad.