Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sorry for my 4 year old

183 replies

ApologiesandSanctomony · 16/10/2023 10:36

With Halloween coming up, dc2 has been letting us know that he absolutely wants to go trick or treating. He loves dressing up, and has excitedly helped put indoor decorations up; it is becoming evident that he loves this time of year. The issue is he will be alone, with dh taking him around. I have tried to focus on doing fun things indoors, but he still wants to go. He is so little, and the thought of him standing at doors on his own, with dh hovering, upsets me.

DD who is 6 is ND, and under no circumstances wants to accompany him. She has made it clear that she wants to stay indoors. DD has said that she wants to play a game where she knocks on a door inside our house, and trick or treats me, then I'm to give her sweets. She doesn't want to dress up, but does wish to wear a Halloween themed top. I'm trying to make the evening fun for her with pizza with ds, and spooky treats. Trick or treaters knocking scare her, so I will be putting a bowl of sweets outside.

I feel so sorry for them both, ds being alone, and it is making it more upsetting to me by the indoor game dd wants to play. If they both were happy indoors having a spooky fun evening it would feel fine.

Has anybody experiencing a similar situation? I just feel abit sad for them both.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jewelspun · 26/10/2023 13:10

Dad spends time with his son doing what thousands of other parents do with their child when they go trick or treating.

What part of that is even remotely upsetting that would make anyone feel sad?

When my son was that age, some of the parents from his playgroup (approximately half a dozen who lived near each other) all got together and had one parent stay at home whilst the other went round to trick or treat.

We all met up at one point and then walked together with the children in a group to everyone's house. It worked out well and was just enough for the children and they were guaranteed sweets and cakes etc.

toadasoda · 26/10/2023 13:04

OP I think reading between the lines this has less to do with Halloween and more to do with the difficulties of having ND and NT siblings where you will have to make constant accommodations for one, sometimes to the detriment of the other. If so, I get it. I have twins, one is ND and there are many times where doing things together will not work. I go between feeling sorry for ND child who struggles with so many things to feeling sorry for NT child who I worry is being held back. If I'm wrong and you are literally only worried about Halloween evening then YABU, it's not big deal!!

miral · 26/10/2023 12:46

Why is it sad? They are both getting to do what suits them. Do you know any of your neighbours with kids of a similar age that your husband could join forces with? That’s what we did when our kids were small.

Yellownotblue · 18/10/2023 23:30

OP, I don’t know if this will help at all, but if DD was NT, you still wouldn’t be able to all go as a family : one parent would have to stay home to give sweets out!

I grew up in North America, Halloween was always a huge deal. I then emigrated to the U.K., and initially there was no TorT’ing at all in our neighbourhood, so we celebrated with American friends who lived in an expat enclave. But in recent years it has become hugely popular on our street, houses get decorated, and we get lots of kids going around, which is wonderful. Sadly my children are now teenagers and don’t want to do it anymore 🥺.

I bloody love Halloween, and the underlying spirit of it, which is a community celebration for children. Doing something nice for strangers; allowing children to indulge in “scary” stuff, which lots of children are instinctively attracted to, and is a way of conquering fear by microdosing it. I genuinely feel sorry for those who don’t understand this.

It sounds like both your DCs will have a lovely time and get an experience that is at the level they enjoy. Sounds absolutely ideal to me!

Gerrataere · 18/10/2023 22:55

VestaTilley · 18/10/2023 22:41

Sad about what? Hallowe’en isn’t even a big thing in our culture. We don’t do it at all in our family. Just let your DH take DS out and you look after DD. Maybe see if a new school friend will go out with their parents and your DH and DS.

It may not be part of your culture, but it is part of British history. Since you know, it’s where Halloween originated from. Evidently it is a ‘big’ part of our culture or at least in places outside of England. Autumn leading into winter has always had mixtures of thanksgiving, festivals and other events as has been for centuries. It’s part of our agriculture and history of ‘lighting up the dark nights’. Perhaps you’re not British/Celtic though and obviously it wouldn’t be much of a part of your culture…

VestaTilley · 18/10/2023 22:41

Sad about what? Hallowe’en isn’t even a big thing in our culture. We don’t do it at all in our family. Just let your DH take DS out and you look after DD. Maybe see if a new school friend will go out with their parents and your DH and DS.

GirlsAndPenguins · 18/10/2023 22:12

I didn’t really want to take my 2 year old trick or treating last year. I remember going as a child and people were not pleasant when you knocked on their doors. Not an experience I wanted for my child. At the time we had Merlin passes so paid for her to do the trick or treat town there. It was wonderful! She got dressed up, it was really spooky, knocked on lots of doors and got lots or Haribo! I would recommend if anyone is thinking about it.
Going to Butlins this year as it’s our 1/2 term and when I booked it was term time prices for some reason so a real bargain!
Ive not done this before but hoping she will still dress up and enjoy the Halloween activities as she loves Halloween and anything spooky 👻

AuntMarch · 18/10/2023 07:57

What is sad about one on one time with dad doing exactly what he wants?!

flustereddriver75 · 17/10/2023 19:11

The four year old will be completely fine to go with dad. Do you have any friends that he could go round with?
If not he'll be caught up in dressing up and getting sweets and won't really care.

As for your six year old, she sounds like she will be perfectly happy playing the game she's made up but I can understand a bit why it might sadden you that she doesn't want to do what others do.

However, maybe play the game and encourage her to open the door to a couple of trick or treaters. All children are different, it would be boring if they were all the same.

MeinKraft · 17/10/2023 18:07

Both of your children are getting to enjoy an activity they want to do and have 1-1 time with a parent. Sounds good to me.

YerArseInParsley · 17/10/2023 18:04

@ApologiesandSanctomony

I know what u mean. My 15yr old was always the kid alone when other people were getting invited to parties and going out with friends and their kids. It used to bother me thinking why is my kid always being left out but there's nothing u can do apart from just get on with it.

MumtoSENprincess · 17/10/2023 17:58

I have a ND child with learning disability. We don't go trick or treating but she loves all the children coming to the house. We put the pumpkin out and wait for the doorbell to ring, then she takes the tub of sweets out for them. Maybe your DD could do that part of Halloween?

I do get the 'sad' part, though - my DD will not go anywhere near Santa at Christmas and a lot of the fun things that other children enjoy just don't work for her. Yes, it's what she feels comfortable with, but when not wanting to do things comes from anxiety, that is sad.

Ffion21 · 17/10/2023 16:28

Don’t worry about it and just do two different things. One stays with daughter and one walks round with son.

it’s normal for parents to go round with the kids here so your son will be having the same experience as most when he goes round with his dad.

Magicmama92 · 17/10/2023 13:58

I take my daughter on her own since she's an only child and she's now five.
I'm a bit confused as to why your making this a huge deal.
Both children will be fine it's ok to go trick or treating with a parent.

LT1982 · 17/10/2023 12:31

LaMadameCholet · 17/10/2023 09:35

You are massively over thinking this. This is the problem with this ridiculous “making memories” culture, everything has to be fabulous and precious 🙄

Wow what a helpful, mind response- not.

A mum wanting to make sure both her kids enjoy something is hardly a "problem"

SmileyClare · 17/10/2023 10:18

jaysay · 17/10/2023 10:04

My 4 year old only child will be going out solo. He doesn't know any different and is perfectly happy about it.

This is usual protocol. Really no need for “gangs” of mums and children to go round together.

I find big groups trick or treating quite annoying- some of the parent groups are really loud, shouting orders at the dc from ten feet away to Watch the road! Just take a couple of sweets darling! Yelling over each other - and they block everyone’s way 😂

Your ds will meet lots of other dc and their parents when he goes round the block with his dad holding his hand (and torch) for him. Sounds just right for a 4 year old.

User2123 · 17/10/2023 10:09

Not read whole thread so sorry if it's been suggested, but if you didn't like the idea of him going out alone, are there any activities on over the school holidays/weekend that you could go to as a family? There's lots of Halloween themed parties/discos/soft play etc. around us where children are encouraged to dress up but don't have to. They play lots of games with other children and get sweets, could be a good compromise?

jaysay · 17/10/2023 10:04

My 4 year old only child will be going out solo. He doesn't know any different and is perfectly happy about it.

willowthecat · 17/10/2023 10:01

I think we all have a romantic image of crowds of kids running around together at Halloween but with smaller families and less cohesive communities there are fewer opportunities for this to happen. My older ds is disabled and can't go out my younger ds was either on his own ( me hovering in the background obv) or I would network like mad to get him involved with any local children going out at the same time - not easy either but all we can do - Good luck !

JaneFarrier · 17/10/2023 09:54

@ApologiesandSanctomony
Yes, we're in a similar situation and have been for some years. We also have a boy who loves going round the houses and a girl who finds the whole thing overwhelming. Both ND. Oddly the girl loves costuming and the boy tends to do the minimum (he knows a costume is expected but isn't really into it - he normally does ordinary clothes with a homemade mask.)

For the first few years both went, but daughter found it too scary and unpredictable (particularly creepy decorations and people opening the door in gruesome masks) and quite soon decided to bow out. It caused her some anxiety, and I'm glad we haven't pushed it. She also won't go to Hallowe'en parties at school etc. I was initially worries that she was missing out, but now I just let her set the pace. She knows her limits.

I take Son because my DH also finds it overwhelming, and it's actually turned into quite a nice time to do something with just him. He sometimes goes with a friend but often has more stamina than the friend does! Meanwhile Daughter stays home, watches a non-Hallowe'en film, and opens the door in costume if and when she feels like it.

I think you'll probably feel better about this once a pattern that suits them both has developed. They're still quite young and things do change.

LaMadameCholet · 17/10/2023 09:35

You are massively over thinking this. This is the problem with this ridiculous “making memories” culture, everything has to be fabulous and precious 🙄

NotYeti · 17/10/2023 09:24

We took DC4 trick or treating solo. We were in between schools too so all of his friends were in the old area, but it didn't matter. We just wandered around and it was so busy we just kind of joined a few groups (as in, kids queuing up to shout trick or treat and grab sweets) and everyone was happy and having a great time. I'd never gone trick or treating so didn't know what to expect, and I was a bit nervous going without any friends. But it was ace!

It was easier the following year when DC had settled in school and made a nice group of friends and I knew some mums too, so we got invited to a Halloween party followed by trick or treating in a group. Think we will be doing something similar this year. 😊

You sound like a lovely mum OP. I'm sure your kids have a great Halloween.

ChuffKnows · 17/10/2023 09:21

I've not read the whole thread so sorry if this has been covered already but does ds actually want to go out trick or treating or is it that he wants the sweets and fun? When mine were little or the weather was bad we would decorate, put spooky songs on and they would dress up and have their Halloween buckets ready. Every time trick or treaters knocked they would open the door to them and offer the sweets and then take a sweet for their own buckets once they'd gone. They really enjoyed this and still felt like they had been trick or treating too.

babyproblems · 17/10/2023 08:45

I’d see it as quality time together?? Maybe see if anyone from school or neighbours or social circle would like to join you? I’d get DH an outfit aswell and get him to properly join in!!! They could do a good double act if you are feeling inspired! Xx

Hoorahfordogs · 17/10/2023 08:45

I think you’re making an issue where there isn’t one.

I take DD alone and have done the last couple of years as the other DC are older and want to go with their friends. DD loves it - and yes I do tend to loiter at the end of a driveway when she goes up to the door!

Swipe left for the next trending thread