Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
Zebedee999 · 16/10/2023 12:38

Rousblouse · 16/10/2023 08:38

I saw that and I think it was a travesty holding a referendum like that if it didn’t have popular support. Imagine being an aboriginal waking up in Australia after that result. It is horrible. I live in Ireland and if we had a referendum on traveller’s rights we might get the same outcome for example and further alienate an already massively alienated section of our population.

This sort of thing needs to be done in the legislature not by popular vote.

Legislature's should be reflecting public opinion else why vote them in? I think there should be referendum on many more decisions taken by government... trust people rather than treat them as children.

smooththecat · 16/10/2023 12:38

InvisibleDuck · 16/10/2023 12:29

A referendum where the people on the losing side call those on the winning side names and dismiss them as Bad People instead of trying to understand their reasons for voting the way they did.

Familiar.

Oh do bore off, may I suggest Australia. Brexit is a giant shitshow and we are all living with the consequences. Stop banging your tiny little drum and own it.

TheSandgroper · 16/10/2023 12:36

We did it re the monarchy and we did it this time. We didn’t vote against the idea. We voted against what we were offered. I was desperate to vote yes but I wasn’t voting yes to that.

As we counted the votes, out of 1500, 6 were scribbled on/spoilt but only 11 were blank. The experienced vote counters were amazed at such a low number. The strength of opinion (in either direction) is not normally seen, apparently.

You may call us racist but most Australians really want to do the right thing. This referendum did not offer us that option. It was a complete schemozzle and the government can only blame itself.

Justanotherlurker · 16/10/2023 12:36

It's very easy to sit and think it must be racist, but with ballot initiatives, if the voters aren’t sure what the proposed change does, most will vote against the change.

Exactly what the voice advisory body would look like and how it would function were to be determined only once the concept had won approval.

Even more than the identity politics, this is the major political idiocy. Even if you are in favour of a vaguely defined "the voice", how can you be sure it is not turned into shit in the fine print by activists and bureaucrats? This way the Australian people had a divisive referendum over basically declarative gibberish. It was incredibly disrespectful towards the voter. Post-politics.

It's bizarre that a race based lobby group permanently fixed into the constitution was seen as the solution to politicians not adequately representing their constituents. The resultis having the same effect that other votes world wide have had, instead of introspection it's far easier to stick fingers in ears and denounce the result as being racist or from uneducated types.

And judging from state-level results, support was more or less inversely proportional to the percentage of native population living in the state.

To the surprise of absolutely noone with any critical thinking the baizuo are shocked.

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:36

You should have spent six minutes on Google because local voices are being established or already exist in two jurisdictions and Victoria is in the early stages of treaty negotiation.

Perhaps you consider yourself a stupid, racist colonial and who am I to argue with that? I am not, though, and nor are the people I associate with.

smooththecat · 16/10/2023 12:33

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:28

I'm shocked that the BBC referred to the block in Redfern as a "ghetto". Wow. Talk about racist.

I wouldn’t be too shocked, yesterday a BBC interviewer on the radio said (I think to a representative of another country in the region), Many in Israel want the Gaza Strip to be ‘cleared of people’. Just like that, so casual. Just a bit of ethnic cleansing for you with your breakfast. Imagine them saying that about a white population anywhere.

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 12:32

I have white nieces and nephews there and a mixed race niece (Islander) - all born and bred in Australia. They have very different experiences. No prizes for guessing which one can't get to work on the train in the morning without suffering racial abuse and being told to get back to her own country.

OP posts:
Dutch1e · 16/10/2023 12:30

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 09:14

Far be it from me to interrupt Mumsnet when it's in full "Australians are all stupid, racist colonials" mode but (a) the voice could have been legislated without a referendum, the government chose to try and place it within the constitution despite refusing to explain how it would work, (b) even placing it in the constitution didn't mean anything given that a future government could introduce legislation changing the voice to one bloke in Ulla Dulla if they had a mind to, (c) the yes campaign failed to engage with voters in working class areas or those with English as a second language and instead produced a top-down, corporation-heavy campaign that made people who were always going to vote yes feel good about themselves but didn't do anything elsewhere (d) there is a not insignificant Blak Sovereignty movement that doesn't want the voice, they want a treaty instead, (e) the no campaign was led by two indigenous politicians - whatever anyone thinks of Jacinta Price she has a skill for speaking plainly to the electorate, and (f) the yes campaign knew from very early on that the referendum was likely to fail but they brought the enabling legislating to parliament unchanged anyway and the government abandoned the idea of local and regional voices.

Now please do carry on explaining that your Aunt Beryl went to Sydney for three days in 1997 and was appalled at all the racism she saw and the terrible lack of nice civilised history like medieval castles.

I'm Australian and the country is, in fact, overwhelmingly made up of stupid racist colonialists.

Five minutes on Google makes it very clear that every Australiangovernment has disbanded the advisory boards that offer the opinion of Aboriginals & Torres Strait Islanders.

Lobby groups aren't new, and neither is the deliberate dismantling of anything remotely resembling an indigenous voice to Parliament.

All this referendum was asking is "hey, shall we enshrine the right for an advisory board to exist, in whatever form the Elders choose?"

The excuses you listed are just makeup to poorly hide the racism and deliberate ignorance.

We deserve the scorn.

InvisibleDuck · 16/10/2023 12:29

A referendum where the people on the losing side call those on the winning side names and dismiss them as Bad People instead of trying to understand their reasons for voting the way they did.

Familiar.

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:28

I'm shocked that the BBC referred to the block in Redfern as a "ghetto". Wow. Talk about racist.

FrodoBagginsToeHair · 16/10/2023 12:27

MerryMarigold · 16/10/2023 10:28

I have a view that Australia is more racist than the UK. My grandmother was Anglo Indian. As with racially mixed people there was a range of browner to lighter amongst her siblings. The 'whiter' ones were able to emigrate to Australia (2 out of 6) but my grandmother was at the browner end and rejected. It was nothing to do with qualifications. She was a qualified teacher and her sister had no qualifications. They seemed to value skin colour over education. I'm not sure if they told her the reason or if she guessed it but she was a lot darker.

Yes, it was a long time ago (the 1950s!) but it shows the UK were more progressive then, which is saying something, and I'm afraid it's left an impression on me regarding Australia so many years later.

Perfectly reasonable to judge a whole country by something that happened to someone else 70 years ago.

DiabolicalFinial · 16/10/2023 12:27

Simonjt · 16/10/2023 12:18

No, I’m not in the UK. In Aus we’re called it on the news, on sports shows, during matches, on the radio sports shows. Vile disgusting racism.

I have no idea what you watch or listen to, but I have not heard it broadcast on tv or radio. Nor have I heard it in sports - in reality, every code and sport is trying to stamp out any racism as unacceptable.

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 12:25

wandawaves · 16/10/2023 10:32

I was there 20 years ago and visited Sydney and Perth and did not see one indigenous person my whole time there.

Umm... ok? What's your point?
Also... what does an Indigenous Australian look like? Seems you're doing a bit of racist stereotyping there yourself.

Umm....ok.....my point was it must be difficult for the Indigenous people to get jobs and progress. They didn't seem to be represented in Sydney's CBD area, for instance working or shopping. Perhaps because too many of them had to live in places like this when I was there?

Sydney's Aboriginal ghetto to be bulldozed - BBC News

I wasn't discussing racial stereotyping in the first place, so don't understand your accusation? I'll go further then, I hardly saw anyone who wasn't white. Those few who weren't were Asian. It seemed much less multicultural to me than London was at the time.

BBC News

Sydney's Aboriginal ghetto to be bulldozed

A run-down housing estate in Sydney that has become a symbol of Aboriginal disadvantage is to be torn down in an effort to revitalise the area.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-pacific-11502471

OP posts:
Wonkasworld · 16/10/2023 12:25

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:20

Pleas provide evidence of that word being used in sports shows and on the news.

You will be waiting a while

Iwantcakeeveryday · 16/10/2023 12:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Why did you vote no?

Joan51 · 16/10/2023 12:21

The only time I’ve heard that term is from UK nationals. Otherwise never heard it used in Australia.
Maybe it’s a reflection of the radio and tv stations one follows.

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:20

Pleas provide evidence of that word being used in sports shows and on the news.

Simonjt · 16/10/2023 12:18

RichardsGear · 16/10/2023 08:56

Sorry to digress but what sort of TV programmes regularly feature the word p**i? Are you in the UK @Simonjt ?

No, I’m not in the UK. In Aus we’re called it on the news, on sports shows, during matches, on the radio sports shows. Vile disgusting racism.

CurlewKate · 16/10/2023 12:18

Yes- I thought it was a foregone conclusion too.😢

Joan51 · 16/10/2023 12:18

The only successful referenda have had bipartisan support. The conservative parties decided not to support the proposal; the proposal was doomed thereafter.
I don’t know anyone who voted no in the referendum. The electorate I live in voted yes and the State at the end of counting today also had just over a 50% yes vote.
The First Nations vote was also split into the yes and no camp.

Olivesmum78 · 16/10/2023 12:17

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:15

I’m curious to know what the posters who are decrying this vote as racist think of the Blak Sovereignty movement’s “progressive no” position. Obviously, you’ll all be very well informed on that, judging by the confidence with which you’ve given your views so far.

SerendipityJane · 16/10/2023 12:15

MyCircumference · 16/10/2023 09:59

i was also surprised and disappointed although i understand that it wasnt even binding, so the Voice may be listened to but not actioned.

The parallels with the non-binding Brexit vote simply will not go away will they ?

smooththecat · 16/10/2023 12:14

Lanoisette · 16/10/2023 08:45

There were many criticisms of the proposals. Including: they allowed one group access to the legislative process that no other group has; they distract from the real problems facing aboriginal people and give power to a metropolitan elite; they were very non-specific, with no indication of how the Voice would be appointed and how it would work.

Ooh Metropolitan Elites, that old chestnut.

Bluebellst · 16/10/2023 12:13

Isoqueen · 16/10/2023 12:10

When visiting Britain I am stunned by the racism there. How dare they call us Aussies racist - what a joke .We come from many, many different backgrounds here and ‘ white’ Australia is very much a thing of the past. We are one, but we are many and from all the lands on earth we come. The recent debacle sought to divide us and my First Nations friends all voted NO.

It isn’t just the British calling Aussies racist. It’s what the world is thinking right now going by my social media.