Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?

412 replies

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/australia-rejects-indigenous-referendum-in-setback-for-reconciliation/ar-AA1icZn2

OP posts:
Thread gallery
24
koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 13:05

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 13:00

Apologies, I missed including the BBC link. Here it is: https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-35296993

Thank you. That was really interesting. I can see in the 6 years since the "ghetto" article things had moved on and it's a word that shouldn't really be used now. I'll remember that going forwards in my own speech. Thanks!

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 16/10/2023 13:03

I do think it’s going to backfire on the opposition and their leader Dutton

Is it impacting the PM?

Ours walked out when the referendum went the other way, I doubt the same will happen but any political damage?

DoDoDoD · 16/10/2023 13:01

ALittleTeawithmilk · 16/10/2023 12:56

I’m Not reading any further or I’ll end up tearing my hair out in frustration.

The acknowledgement of First Nations Peoples as the First Australians could not be legislated. It’s a constitutional matter, a changing of the constitution. This demands a referendum. Australia is the only former British colony that does not acknowledge it’s First Peoples.

I’d like to say here that referendums in Australia do not have the same rules as referendums in the UK.

  1. legislating a Voice to Parliament - could be done. But the following govt, any following govt, could dismantle it if it wanted to. There would be nothing to stop dismantling it - which is exactly what we’ve seen happen at least 7 times now by successive governments. The voice needed to be entered into the constiution - (therefore necessitating a referendum) so it would always be there. Once it had got a yes vote, it would have gone to Parliament to be legislated; and been batted around by the two houses until a suitable form for it was agreed upon by both houses. Then, the form of the Voice could be changed by legislation, but the Voice itself, a non legislative body to parliament to advise government on matters pertaining to only Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People always had to exist. The, form itself could be changed. It would have no legislative power and could only advise on things pertaining to First Nations people.

Instead, we will go in as we have before, massive amounts of money spent trying to close the gap between living standards and life spans. eg A First Nations child, on average, will not live as long as the child she is sitting next to in school. I believe the life span gap is at least 8 years. At any rate, it’s too great and not getting smaller. This is terrible. Shameful. Heartbreaking.

I’d just like to add, As the votes come in we are seeing that the Aboriginal and Torres Strait islanders who live in the remote areas have voted overwhelmingly in favour of the Voice. This contradicts the ‘no’ campaign, which misinformed the country and said the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples did not want the Voice - At least Two opposition MPs were very vocal about this. (btw, the oppositions Shadow Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs resigned from his ministry because he did not agree with the way his own party was going. He’s a leading proponent of the yes campaign.

Now, very disturbingly, we have those two MPs, the ones who were very vocal about the First People not wanting the Voice saying that the voting system in these remote communities were not adhered to/interfered with (I think they are trying to say voters were coerced. They are casting doubt on the Australian Electorial Sustem. Who does that remind you of? It’s very Trump -Ian. And bullshit. Up until these figures started returning there was no questioning of our voting system by them. Btw, it’s an excellent system /never been questioned before.

This is the new world we’ve entered where lying is winning, and fuck truth and honesty.

It looks as though, wevare starting to see the Brexit Version of ‘buyers remorse’ - it’s been reported that a number of ‘no voters’ have posted on social media complaining of being lied to and regretting voting no. We shall see.

Please remember that many millions of Australians voted yes. They chose to believe what they were told by the First Nations Voice leaders - that more than 80% of First Nations People wanted the Voice:. This was also confirmed by numerous polls.. It’s looking like that was exactly correct.

Why did ‘no’ win? Partly Because of lies and misinformation - the media had not corrected during the campaign btw - although they have started writing and talking about it now - please note that Murdoch’s media controls about 70 percent of news media in Australia, and that he was not supporting constitutional acknowledgement nor the Voice.

Why else didn’t the referendum pass?

Also because there has not been a referendum passed in Aus that did not have bipartisan support of the two major parties. And at the beginning of all this, there was every indication that it would be bipartisan. It was the Opposition party that had, when in government, asked the First Nations people to design a form
of advisory body that became the Voice.

When the new govt was elected, this was one of the platforms on which they ran - a promise to hold this referendum. And things were looking pretty good. There was majority support for Yhe Voice until April this year. But you see it drop away from April on.

What happened in April? The opposition saw a political opportunity to increase their abysmal popularity numbers. The Leader of the Opposition, Peter Dutton’s popularity rating was in the 20 - 30 percent range. Extremely low. In April Dutton and his fellow MPs politicised the Voice and ceased any support for it, and started arguing against it. At first he said ‘no’ to both parts of the referendum question, but then, realising that Australians weren’t responding overly much to this, he changed tack a little and proposed that when in government he would hold a referendum to acknowledge First Nations People in the Constitution - (a referendum for the first part of the question). Many Australians were more happy with that, but also many were not, and wanted to see First Nations people get the non legislative Voice that had been requested by the former PM of the Previous government of which Peter Dutton had been a prominent member. Minister for Defence at one point. Minister for something else at another: He’s been a pollie or trying to be one, all his working life: He held important ministries.

Since April much misinformation and many lies went unchallenged by media, it was overwhelming. And on Saturday the majority of Australians voted no.

But many millions voted yes. We are divided.

To top this off Peter Dutton has already walked back his promise he made, for the last 5 or so months, to hold a referendum to acknowledge The First Nations People on the constitution when (if) he wins government. There will be now be no referendum should he win office.

This has divided the nation. I’ve seen nothing like it in Australia in my lifetime. I’m nearer 70 than 60. Historically, the WW1 years saw something that was perhaps as equally divisive. I’ve never lived through a time like this in Australia.

Take this away: if it had been a bipartisan agreement all along then it would have very likely have gotten through. And we had little reason, no reason really, to believe it wouldn’t be bipartisan when the process began about 5 years ago - I’m a bit hazy on that timing but it was many years, and a different government (the party that is now in opposition) . In April of this year it changed its mind / 180. I do think it’s going to backfire on the opposition and their leader Dutton, but the damage it’s caused? Where to begin?

Thanks for this detailed and informative post. Sounds like an absolute mess of a campaign, and a distressing outcome and aftermath.

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 13:00

ALittleTeawithmilk · 16/10/2023 12:56

I’m Not reading any further or I’ll end up tearing my hair out in frustration.

The acknowledgement of First Nations Peoples as the First Australians could not be legislated. It’s a constitutional matter, a changing of the constitution. This demands a referendum. Australia is the only former British colony that does not acknowledge it’s First Peoples.

I’d like to say here that referendums in Australia do not have the same rules as referendums in the UK.

  1. legislating a Voice to Parliament - could be done. But the following govt, any following govt, could dismantle it if it wanted to. There would be nothing to stop dismantling it - which is exactly what we’ve seen happen at least 7 times now by successive governments. The voice needed to be entered into the constiution - (therefore necessitating a referendum) so it would always be there. Once it had got a yes vote, it would have gone to Parliament to be legislated; and been batted around by the two houses until a suitable form for it was agreed upon by both houses. Then, the form of the Voice could be changed by legislation, but the Voice itself, a non legislative body to parliament to advise government on matters pertaining to only Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People always had to exist. The, form itself could be changed. It would have no legislative power and could only advise on things pertaining to First Nations people.

Instead, we will go in as we have before, massive amounts of money spent trying to close the gap between living standards and life spans. eg A First Nations child, on average, will not live as long as the child she is sitting next to in school. I believe the life span gap is at least 8 years. At any rate, it’s too great and not getting smaller. This is terrible. Shameful. Heartbreaking.

I’d just like to add, As the votes come in we are seeing that the Aboriginal and Torres Strait islanders who live in the remote areas have voted overwhelmingly in favour of the Voice. This contradicts the ‘no’ campaign, which misinformed the country and said the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples did not want the Voice - At least Two opposition MPs were very vocal about this. (btw, the oppositions Shadow Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs resigned from his ministry because he did not agree with the way his own party was going. He’s a leading proponent of the yes campaign.

Now, very disturbingly, we have those two MPs, the ones who were very vocal about the First People not wanting the Voice saying that the voting system in these remote communities were not adhered to/interfered with (I think they are trying to say voters were coerced. They are casting doubt on the Australian Electorial Sustem. Who does that remind you of? It’s very Trump -Ian. And bullshit. Up until these figures started returning there was no questioning of our voting system by them. Btw, it’s an excellent system /never been questioned before.

This is the new world we’ve entered where lying is winning, and fuck truth and honesty.

It looks as though, wevare starting to see the Brexit Version of ‘buyers remorse’ - it’s been reported that a number of ‘no voters’ have posted on social media complaining of being lied to and regretting voting no. We shall see.

Please remember that many millions of Australians voted yes. They chose to believe what they were told by the First Nations Voice leaders - that more than 80% of First Nations People wanted the Voice:. This was also confirmed by numerous polls.. It’s looking like that was exactly correct.

Why did ‘no’ win? Partly Because of lies and misinformation - the media had not corrected during the campaign btw - although they have started writing and talking about it now - please note that Murdoch’s media controls about 70 percent of news media in Australia, and that he was not supporting constitutional acknowledgement nor the Voice.

Why else didn’t the referendum pass?

Also because there has not been a referendum passed in Aus that did not have bipartisan support of the two major parties. And at the beginning of all this, there was every indication that it would be bipartisan. It was the Opposition party that had, when in government, asked the First Nations people to design a form
of advisory body that became the Voice.

When the new govt was elected, this was one of the platforms on which they ran - a promise to hold this referendum. And things were looking pretty good. There was majority support for Yhe Voice until April this year. But you see it drop away from April on.

What happened in April? The opposition saw a political opportunity to increase their abysmal popularity numbers. The Leader of the Opposition, Peter Dutton’s popularity rating was in the 20 - 30 percent range. Extremely low. In April Dutton and his fellow MPs politicised the Voice and ceased any support for it, and started arguing against it. At first he said ‘no’ to both parts of the referendum question, but then, realising that Australians weren’t responding overly much to this, he changed tack a little and proposed that when in government he would hold a referendum to acknowledge First Nations People in the Constitution - (a referendum for the first part of the question). Many Australians were more happy with that, but also many were not, and wanted to see First Nations people get the non legislative Voice that had been requested by the former PM of the Previous government of which Peter Dutton had been a prominent member. Minister for Defence at one point. Minister for something else at another: He’s been a pollie or trying to be one, all his working life: He held important ministries.

Since April much misinformation and many lies went unchallenged by media, it was overwhelming. And on Saturday the majority of Australians voted no.

But many millions voted yes. We are divided.

To top this off Peter Dutton has already walked back his promise he made, for the last 5 or so months, to hold a referendum to acknowledge The First Nations People on the constitution when (if) he wins government. There will be now be no referendum should he win office.

This has divided the nation. I’ve seen nothing like it in Australia in my lifetime. I’m nearer 70 than 60. Historically, the WW1 years saw something that was perhaps as equally divisive. I’ve never lived through a time like this in Australia.

Take this away: if it had been a bipartisan agreement all along then it would have very likely have gotten through. And we had little reason, no reason really, to believe it wouldn’t be bipartisan when the process began about 5 years ago - I’m a bit hazy on that timing but it was many years, and a different government (the party that is now in opposition) . In April of this year it changed its mind / 180. I do think it’s going to backfire on the opposition and their leader Dutton, but the damage it’s caused? Where to begin?

Thank you so much for this post.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 16/10/2023 12:58

Just reading the post but this is worth highlighting

It’s a constitutional matter, a changing of the constitution. This demands a referendum.

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 12:58

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:50

I know what Wikipedia says. I also know what the block looked like. I used to live a few streets away.

Here’s an article from the BBC (!) outlining why perjoratively describing a poor area where black people live as a “ghetto” - particularly by people who are not from that culture - has racist connotations.

I can't see the article to which you refer, but I shall read more about the word "ghetto". I didn't realise it was considered pejorative. Strange the BBC use it and then criticise use of it. Maybe the critical article came long after this report and things had changed, I don't know.

Whatever word is used, the area under discussion certainly isn't a place where anyone should have to live and I can imagine the future looks bleak for any child starting their lives there.

OP posts:
smooththecat · 16/10/2023 12:57

EasternStandard · 16/10/2023 12:44

Surely the pp can respond in kind

Your drum etc

Not really because they won, so I expect an end to their tiny drum.

ALittleTeawithmilk · 16/10/2023 12:56

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:40

This sort of thing needs to be done in the legislature not by popular vote.

Yes, I agree.

I’m Not reading any further or I’ll end up tearing my hair out in frustration.

The acknowledgement of First Nations Peoples as the First Australians could not be legislated. It’s a constitutional matter, a changing of the constitution. This demands a referendum. Australia is the only former British colony that does not acknowledge it’s First Peoples.

I’d like to say here that referendums in Australia do not have the same rules as referendums in the UK.

  1. legislating a Voice to Parliament - could be done. But the following govt, any following govt, could dismantle it if it wanted to. There would be nothing to stop dismantling it - which is exactly what we’ve seen happen at least 7 times now by successive governments. The voice needed to be entered into the constiution - (therefore necessitating a referendum) so it would always be there. Once it had got a yes vote, it would have gone to Parliament to be legislated; and been batted around by the two houses until a suitable form for it was agreed upon by both houses. Then, the form of the Voice could be changed by legislation, but the Voice itself, a non legislative body to parliament to advise government on matters pertaining to only Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People always had to exist. The, form itself could be changed. It would have no legislative power and could only advise on things pertaining to First Nations people.

Instead, we will go in as we have before, massive amounts of money spent trying to close the gap between living standards and life spans. eg A First Nations child, on average, will not live as long as the child she is sitting next to in school. I believe the life span gap is at least 8 years. At any rate, it’s too great and not getting smaller. This is terrible. Shameful. Heartbreaking.

I’d just like to add, As the votes come in we are seeing that the Aboriginal and Torres Strait islanders who live in the remote areas have voted overwhelmingly in favour of the Voice. This contradicts the ‘no’ campaign, which misinformed the country and said the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples did not want the Voice - At least Two opposition MPs were very vocal about this. (btw, the oppositions Shadow Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs resigned from his ministry because he did not agree with the way his own party was going. He’s a leading proponent of the yes campaign.

Now, very disturbingly, we have those two MPs, the ones who were very vocal about the First People not wanting the Voice saying that the voting system in these remote communities were not adhered to/interfered with (I think they are trying to say voters were coerced. They are casting doubt on the Australian Electorial Sustem. Who does that remind you of? It’s very Trump -Ian. And bullshit. Up until these figures started returning there was no questioning of our voting system by them. Btw, it’s an excellent system /never been questioned before.

This is the new world we’ve entered where lying is winning, and fuck truth and honesty.

It looks as though, wevare starting to see the Brexit Version of ‘buyers remorse’ - it’s been reported that a number of ‘no voters’ have posted on social media complaining of being lied to and regretting voting no. We shall see.

Please remember that many millions of Australians voted yes. They chose to believe what they were told by the First Nations Voice leaders - that more than 80% of First Nations People wanted the Voice:. This was also confirmed by numerous polls.. It’s looking like that was exactly correct.

Why did ‘no’ win? Partly Because of lies and misinformation - the media had not corrected during the campaign btw - although they have started writing and talking about it now - please note that Murdoch’s media controls about 70 percent of news media in Australia, and that he was not supporting constitutional acknowledgement nor the Voice.

Why else didn’t the referendum pass?

Also because there has not been a referendum passed in Aus that did not have bipartisan support of the two major parties. And at the beginning of all this, there was every indication that it would be bipartisan. It was the Opposition party that had, when in government, asked the First Nations people to design a form
of advisory body that became the Voice.

When the new govt was elected, this was one of the platforms on which they ran - a promise to hold this referendum. And things were looking pretty good. There was majority support for Yhe Voice until April this year. But you see it drop away from April on.

What happened in April? The opposition saw a political opportunity to increase their abysmal popularity numbers. The Leader of the Opposition, Peter Dutton’s popularity rating was in the 20 - 30 percent range. Extremely low. In April Dutton and his fellow MPs politicised the Voice and ceased any support for it, and started arguing against it. At first he said ‘no’ to both parts of the referendum question, but then, realising that Australians weren’t responding overly much to this, he changed tack a little and proposed that when in government he would hold a referendum to acknowledge First Nations People in the Constitution - (a referendum for the first part of the question). Many Australians were more happy with that, but also many were not, and wanted to see First Nations people get the non legislative Voice that had been requested by the former PM of the Previous government of which Peter Dutton had been a prominent member. Minister for Defence at one point. Minister for something else at another: He’s been a pollie or trying to be one, all his working life: He held important ministries.

Since April much misinformation and many lies went unchallenged by media, it was overwhelming. And on Saturday the majority of Australians voted no.

But many millions voted yes. We are divided.

To top this off Peter Dutton has already walked back his promise he made, for the last 5 or so months, to hold a referendum to acknowledge The First Nations People on the constitution when (if) he wins government. There will be now be no referendum should he win office.

This has divided the nation. I’ve seen nothing like it in Australia in my lifetime. I’m nearer 70 than 60. Historically, the WW1 years saw something that was perhaps as equally divisive. I’ve never lived through a time like this in Australia.

Take this away: if it had been a bipartisan agreement all along then it would have very likely have gotten through. And we had little reason, no reason really, to believe it wouldn’t be bipartisan when the process began about 5 years ago - I’m a bit hazy on that timing but it was many years, and a different government (the party that is now in opposition) . In April of this year it changed its mind / 180. I do think it’s going to backfire on the opposition and their leader Dutton, but the damage it’s caused? Where to begin?

Fifireee · 16/10/2023 12:55

This country voted for Brexit! I think we’re a pretty racist country.
The result of this vote is awful. I feel awful for all those who campaigned. It’s grim.
But when I lived in Australia the overt racism at times was quite shocking.

EasternStandard · 16/10/2023 12:53

SerendipityJane · 16/10/2023 12:47

Legislature's should be reflecting public opinion else why vote them in?

Even if public opinion is wrong ?

Example?

Zebedee999 · 16/10/2023 12:50

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 08:35

"The Voice to Parliament was proposed in the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a 2017 document crafted by Indigenous leaders that set out a roadmap for reconciliation with wider Australia.

Australia's Indigenous citizens, who make up 3.8% of the country's 26 million population, have inhabited the land for about 60,000 years but are not mentioned in the constitution and are, by most socio-economic measures, the most disadvantaged people in the country."

Australia rejects Indigenous referendum in setback for reconciliation (msn.com)

I have family out there. I just assumed that they would have voted YES. I hope they did. Perhaps I should ask them.

Everyone should get one vote - no more no less. Why should indigenous people, get more of a say than anyone else?

The minute some get more of a say than others in any society then that is divisive and will make matters worse.

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:50

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 12:42

A ghetto is a part of a city in which members of a minority group live, especially as a result of political, social, legal, environmental or economic pressure.

Ghetto - Wikipedia

"It is time for changes. This bit of land is like the Aboriginal graveyard. People come here to shoot up, to have drugs. In other words, they come here to die," said Mick Mundine, the head of the Aboriginal Housing Company, who has championed the redevelopment for more than a decade.

I have tried to upload a photo of the buildings. It is listed as a "sensitive image" so people would have to click on it if they want to view it.

I know what Wikipedia says. I also know what the block looked like. I used to live a few streets away.

Here’s an article from the BBC (!) outlining why perjoratively describing a poor area where black people live as a “ghetto” - particularly by people who are not from that culture - has racist connotations.

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 12:48

Claudie79 · 16/10/2023 12:45

Note that some indigenous leaders also voted no.

Yep, this is key. I have to say I’m not fully up on this news yet but I did read a little and read that the Northern Territory where most indigenous Australians live voted no more than anywhere else.

This is interesting and I shall follow it up. Thank you.

OP posts:
EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 16/10/2023 12:47

Rousblouse · 16/10/2023 08:38

I saw that and I think it was a travesty holding a referendum like that if it didn’t have popular support. Imagine being an aboriginal waking up in Australia after that result. It is horrible. I live in Ireland and if we had a referendum on traveller’s rights we might get the same outcome for example and further alienate an already massively alienated section of our population.

This sort of thing needs to be done in the legislature not by popular vote.

Not all Aboriginals wanted the referendum to pass. My first choice would have been to vote yes, but my friend and her whole family who are Aboriginal asked everyone they know to vote no. They want the government to use the mechanisms that are already in place and feel that this is just an empty gesture and won't address any of the actual issues effecting Aboriginal communities especially in the bush. I really didn't feel that this was an issue I should have a voice on, but before my friend spoke up I was 100% voting yea. My friend is directly effected by this and I trust her so I helped her families view be heard. It felt really wrong voting no, but after my friend had shared how her family felt about this it also felt wrong to vote yes.

SerendipityJane · 16/10/2023 12:47

Legislature's should be reflecting public opinion else why vote them in?

Even if public opinion is wrong ?

Claudie79 · 16/10/2023 12:45

Valeriekat · 16/10/2023 08:43

Apparently it was very thin on detail so no one really knew what it would entail. Note that some indigenous leaders also voted no.

Note that some indigenous leaders also voted no.

Yep, this is key. I have to say I’m not fully up on this news yet but I did read a little and read that the Northern Territory where most indigenous Australians live voted no more than anywhere else.

EasternStandard · 16/10/2023 12:44

smooththecat · 16/10/2023 12:38

Oh do bore off, may I suggest Australia. Brexit is a giant shitshow and we are all living with the consequences. Stop banging your tiny little drum and own it.

Surely the pp can respond in kind

Your drum etc

Zebedee999 · 16/10/2023 12:43

smooththecat · 16/10/2023 12:38

Oh do bore off, may I suggest Australia. Brexit is a giant shitshow and we are all living with the consequences. Stop banging your tiny little drum and own it.

Just out of interest the Tories took the UK into the EC in 1973, Labour held a referendum in 1975 to decide whether to stay in or leave, the result was to stay in. The Tories did a referendum in 2016, the result was to leave.

Like it or not that is democracy in action - giving the people the vote. There are dictatorships across the world where referendum would never be held. I'd like to see more of them personally!

Dutch1e · 16/10/2023 12:43

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:36

You should have spent six minutes on Google because local voices are being established or already exist in two jurisdictions and Victoria is in the early stages of treaty negotiation.

Perhaps you consider yourself a stupid, racist colonial and who am I to argue with that? I am not, though, and nor are the people I associate with.

But to answer your comment, it was sly and misleading to present those things as an either/or option. State-level treaty negotiations have always happened at the same time as federal advisory boards existing.

koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 12:43

It has posted anyway, I see!

OP posts:
koalaknickers · 16/10/2023 12:42

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:28

I'm shocked that the BBC referred to the block in Redfern as a "ghetto". Wow. Talk about racist.

A ghetto is a part of a city in which members of a minority group live, especially as a result of political, social, legal, environmental or economic pressure.

Ghetto - Wikipedia

"It is time for changes. This bit of land is like the Aboriginal graveyard. People come here to shoot up, to have drugs. In other words, they come here to die," said Mick Mundine, the head of the Aboriginal Housing Company, who has championed the redevelopment for more than a decade.

I have tried to upload a photo of the buildings. It is listed as a "sensitive image" so people would have to click on it if they want to view it.

To be shocked that Australia voted NO on this referendum?
OP posts:
DoDoDoD · 16/10/2023 12:40

LaBaDeeLaBaDa · 16/10/2023 10:08

I'm really disappointed at the result and definitely agree Australia has issues with racism, but polling showed a (pretty big) majority of people supported the idea of The Voice before the referendum campaign actually began (attached a screenshot of the graph below). That instinctive majority for "yes we should probably support this" went off a cliff, for all the reasons with the campaigns some pp have mentioned above. So I don't think it's right to attribute it just to straightforward racism - the instinct was to support, then it fell apart.

That's not to deny the racism that does exist, but handled differently this could have been a real moment for healing, and it has just made everything worse

This indicates a very poorly-run campaign. As we saw with Brexit, it's vital to be specific and detailed and to identify lies and exaggeration. In Ireland, there's an organisation (formerly the Referendum Commission, now the Electoral Commission) that is legislated for and handles all referenda, offering clarification and guidance, it came into being after a confusingly worded referendum. I think it would be worth other countries looking to it as a model.

I've Indigenous Australian friends (Torres Straits and Muruwari) and they're pretty devastated at the result.

BethDuttonsTwin · 16/10/2023 12:39

Good posts @BlinkyBulldozer

Refreshing.

Dutch1e · 16/10/2023 12:39

BlinkyBulldozer · 16/10/2023 12:36

You should have spent six minutes on Google because local voices are being established or already exist in two jurisdictions and Victoria is in the early stages of treaty negotiation.

Perhaps you consider yourself a stupid, racist colonial and who am I to argue with that? I am not, though, and nor are the people I associate with.

I think you're replying to me but weirdly the Reply button won't tag anyone. You have to click the 3-dot menu in the top right of the comment and click Quote or the person you're talking to won't always catch that you've said something.

Swipe left for the next trending thread